Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I’m in the wrong job

55 replies

Sarah891 · 01/05/2022 10:48

So, I have been doing the same job for about 5 years. I recently mentioned promotion to my manager and he gave me a project to do, he asked me to look at the data base and ask other team members to get involved to see how we could improve it, which I think is fine, however, my DH said he would have already discovered the issues and corrected them before being approached by manager (hence why he has done so well) I’m really not very business minded and feel like going for promotion is a mistake?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Sciurus83 · 01/05/2022 17:08

I can guarantee that he is not well liked, he's just too arrogant to realise people find him a pompous arse

Graphista · 01/05/2022 16:53

I agree that acting on your own initiative and being proactive are key requirements in more senior staff.

But your dh sounds an arrogant twat who didn't express this well! Nobody never makes mistakes! We all do we're bloody human!

Jobs where I've been there long enough for promotion aspects (ex was military as was dad so I've moved around a lot due to them) I also went to the "boss" with ideas for improvements.

This has been from minor suggestions like to stock more vegetarian items in a small supermarket as there were very little and we the shop floor staff were frequently being asked for certain products which we didn't stock. As I'm veggie myself manager initially thought it was a personal thing so with his permission me and the other shop floor staff kept a simple record in notepads of how often we were asked for certain of these products over a month and present that to him and he was surprised to learn how often it happened, he got the stock in one month on a sort of trial basis and we sold out in a week! He then agreed to stock more and it was very successful not only in terms of selling these particular products but in attracting higher footfall/custom generally.

To overhauling a database used by the entire uk military that was a pain in the backside to use as it was! I suggested it, IT dept was brought in for that side but I was able to communicate to them what the issues were that users were having plus there were a number of glitches that they were unaware of but were simple to fix. Result the database was much easier to use and this reduced pressure on another linked dept who were only really supposed to deal with certain aspects of the info mainly emergency based where previously they were dealing with a lot of frustrated and confused day to day users of it.

I have to say I think you need to really work on your confidence and assertiveness too (possibly your husbands fault!)

Look into taking an assertiveness class - maybe you could even suggest your employers run a workshop for all staff on this? If they deal with clients/customers these are fantastic for teaching how to deal with complaints etc

A manager should be able to confidently discuss pretty much anything with colleagues and certainly subordinates.

If you aren't confident/comfortable discussing improvements to a database how would you cope holding interviews and hiring people or even harder handling disciplinary action or firing someone? Cos let me tell you that stuff is tough!

Consider do you really want a promotion or is it just more pay/you think you're supposed to?

redskyatnight · 01/05/2022 16:15

Sarah891 · 01/05/2022 15:16

He seems really well liked which is what I find odd?

he might well be an specialist in an area that most people know nothing about, so people tend to accept what he says as gospel. I work with a few of those. They are mostly right and what they say is mostly good advice, and when they are not right and giving bad advice, they say it so confidently that people still believe them. They are 90% really good employees; but a bit of humility would make them 100% good.

SinaraSmith · 01/05/2022 15:58

Sarah891 · 01/05/2022 15:16

He seems really well liked which is what I find odd?

Do you work with him? If you do, do people know you are his wife?

chances are, you have no clue what people really think of him.

Do you really believe he never makes a mistake? Has he never made a mistake at home? At all? Ever.

If you think that, then he has brain washed you too. Are you actually happy with this man who believes it’s impossible for him to get something wrong?

Hexen · 01/05/2022 15:41

Sarah891 · 01/05/2022 15:16

He seems really well liked which is what I find odd?

Well, two points to consider…

is it him telling you he is well liked? (And even if you have met some of his colleagues in person, they are hardly going to let on their true feelings in front of his wife)

second… I quite like my ‘Bob‘. He is just a PITA to manage.

Sarah891 · 01/05/2022 15:16

He seems really well liked which is what I find odd?

OP posts:
trilbydoll · 01/05/2022 14:59

Every workplace is different though. I'd be horrified if someone decided unilaterally to change something without first checking if other depts use it, if other people in our dept use it for a variety of purposes, and why it was created in the first place. Your DH sounds like an absolute nightmare and I bet he gets promoted to make him someone else's problem!

Hexen · 01/05/2022 14:43

Sarah891 · 01/05/2022 13:58

He says he never makes mistakes, he is never wrong and knows what is required. He said there is a reason why everybody comes to him for answers and not the other way round. He said there is factual evidence that he is never wrong

JFC. I manage one of these. He’s a fucking nightmare.

and yep, decided of his own bat that something ‘needed changing‘ and so, yep. Just changed it.

except he changed it in a way that made life easy for him…. Not the 20 other people who use the system in different ways. Because he was too fucking arrogant to ask. And too fucking arrogant to listen.

even now, he still thinks he’s done an amazing job…. Because he literally cannot compute otherwise. And ‘Bob‘ if that’s you… yeah it wasn’t a promotion, it’s an interdepartmental Game of hot potato to pass you on to another team before you fuck something else up.

Bumply · 01/05/2022 14:34

I've got a colleague who is making a name for fixing little things that have been broken that no one else had the time to address.
My work is more juggling several things at once and he would hate that.
We just work to our strengths.
I've been talking about promotion with my team lead and we've gone through the criteria and found several things I'm already working on higher level now, and we've come up with a list of other tasks I can do this year to demonstrate I'm ready for the promotion.
Other team members have similar tasks and it will be mentioned during team meetings so if I was approached about project x by person y I'll know what it is I'm helping with and vice versa.

Oh, and fixing things you see are broken is only useful if a) you've already completed the work you're supposed to be doing and b) communicate with others as to the best solution otherwise you might be wasting your time on something less important or not fixing it the way the majority need/want

cornflakedreams · 01/05/2022 14:33

Sarah891 · 01/05/2022 13:58

He says he never makes mistakes, he is never wrong and knows what is required. He said there is a reason why everybody comes to him for answers and not the other way round. He said there is factual evidence that he is never wrong

Either he is delusional or he is a bully. I know what my money's on.

No wonder your confidence is in the basement. People who love you build you up, they don't knock you down. So that's one mistake he's made, isn't it?

Your manager has confidence in you to do this or they wouldn't have suggested it. Your husband should learn from them and try encouraging you for a change.

If someone at work asked me for input into how a process or system could be improved, I would be pleased that a) things were going to be improved and b) that I was being valued and listened to.

You really don't know what other people will be thinking. You are not a mind reader. It's your husband's bullying voice in your head telling you they'll react negatively.

I'm sorry your husband is a bully.

ldontWanna · 01/05/2022 14:32

Sarah891 · 01/05/2022 13:58

He says he never makes mistakes, he is never wrong and knows what is required. He said there is a reason why everybody comes to him for answers and not the other way round. He said there is factual evidence that he is never wrong

Well he is wrong about that isn't he? He's not God or some kind of omniscient being. He's just a bog standard human, by definition it's impossible for him to never be wrong about anything.

Sarah891 · 01/05/2022 14:31

Thanks Ladies, yea your right. I CAN do this

OP posts:
Wallywobbles · 01/05/2022 14:24

Why is your DH god? Just stop asking his opinion and follow the excellent advice you've been given by the highly competent women here. Particularly that of @OnceUponAThread.

Honestly give yourself a break and stop asking your DH for career advice.

Canhearthemice · 01/05/2022 14:21

There is a Bertrand Russell quote something like this

'The problem with this world is that fools are always so certain of themselves and wise people so full of doubts'

I do think there is a lot of truth in this, coupled with the phenomena that mediocre men will oversell themselves and women will under sell themselves despite having all the right credentials.

Do NOT allow your husband to make you doubt your ability. YOU CAN do this.

When talking to the people, can you not explain that management has asked you to seek a wider opinion.

SinaraSmith · 01/05/2022 14:05

Sarah891 · 01/05/2022 13:58

He says he never makes mistakes, he is never wrong and knows what is required. He said there is a reason why everybody comes to him for answers and not the other way round. He said there is factual evidence that he is never wrong

But you can’t dispute that, can you ?

I could tell do I am never m, ever wrong. Doesn’t make it true.

Is he ever wrong at home?

and as I said before, if he was so great he would know the process is wrong. So when he says he is only wrong when the process is, he is taking bullshit.

I would bet my years salary, he colleagues do not agree. And he often makes things worse for them. He knows what he requires. Not whatever one else does. He is a self important, delusional twat. and he is making you feel like shit so he can tell you how much better than you he is.

the task is to collaborate. If you followed his plan and did it yourself, you would fail the task. No matter how good the work was at the end.

Sarah891 · 01/05/2022 13:58

He says he never makes mistakes, he is never wrong and knows what is required. He said there is a reason why everybody comes to him for answers and not the other way round. He said there is factual evidence that he is never wrong

OP posts:
Thingsdogetbetter · 01/05/2022 13:51

SwedishEdith · 01/05/2022 12:52

I work with someone like your husband. He's always taking over things and "fixing" them, only consulting when they're nearly finished. They're full of mistakes but he brings them up all the time because he's using them as evidence of how "good" he is. He doesn't take challenge well.

Ditto. Then we have to fix his fuckups while rolling ours eyes at his self promotion and inability to ask anyone's opinion - especially those with more expertise than him. Total knobhead whose fixes make 10 times more work for everyone else.

AlisonDonut · 01/05/2022 13:15

ask other team members to get involved to see how we could improve it

I wouldn't be ringing round people to ask I'd book a teams call or a meeting to gauge group opinion. What does he feel is wrong with it? What changes do you actually think can be made? What is he trying to achieve with this?

OnceUponAThread · 01/05/2022 12:57

Your husband sounds deeply unpleasant and like he's undermined your confidence at the the worst possible time. Bin him Ignore him.

In terms of the task, you are WAY overthinking it.

Step one: make a list of colleagues to speak to. This should be people who use the database in a variety of ways for different tasks. (People who input, people who extract, people who present based on it. Etc). Make sure that it's broad as different departments and levels will have separate issues with the system as is.

Step two: either by email, call or F2F, open lines of communication with these people. Given how you are feeling awkward, I'd frame this in the context of the specific task you've been set. E.g.

Hi Sharon, Bob has asked me to compile a list of issues with the database system and look for improvements that we'd all like to see. At this stage I'm gathering insights from people who use it. Can you let me know any challenges it's creating for you, or any new features / changes you'd love to see implemented by XX date.

Step three: create a list. Gather up all the challenges identified across all colleagues. Group them by theme. Identify where solutions have been suggested. Or where you have ideas for what could solve the problems. Including potential add ons or features that could save time / improve processes etc.

Step four: circulate the list. Hi everyone, thanks for your input so far. I've pulled together all the top issued identified and the possible solutions. Let me know if you have any feedback / extra requests before I present it back up to Bob.

Step five: organise a sit down with Bob. Walk him through the findings. The major issues and top priorities. Suggest an action plan for improvement based on what you've learnt. Including what to tackle first and the ideal impact of each change. Credit all people involved.

Bish, bash, bosh. Job done.

redskyatnight · 01/05/2022 12:55

Sarah891 · 01/05/2022 12:38

It’s not that I feel uncomfortable as such, it’s more me knowing what they will be thinking when I’m talking to them?

Why do you need to know what they are thinking?

You frame this as "I'm looking for ways to improve the database and would like your input". If you feel it's too odd for you just to go in and say that you could instead say "Manager has asked me to look for ways ..." The first option makes you sound more like a senior person and personally what I would use. Part of how people perceive you is how you present yourself.

Being a manager means not everyone will like you; not everyone will appreciate what you are doing and not everyone will agree with you. If you're uncomfortable with that, then maybe it is the wrong job.

SwedishEdith · 01/05/2022 12:52

I work with someone like your husband. He's always taking over things and "fixing" them, only consulting when they're nearly finished. They're full of mistakes but he brings them up all the time because he's using them as evidence of how "good" he is. He doesn't take challenge well.

ldontWanna · 01/05/2022 12:50

Sarah891 · 01/05/2022 12:38

It’s not that I feel uncomfortable as such, it’s more me knowing what they will be thinking when I’m talking to them?

How much of this self consciousness has been drummed into you by your "I know it all" husband. I mean you haven't even started yet and he's already telling you you failed and all the ways you're doing it wrong.

Clarinet1 · 01/05/2022 12:49

Don’t frame your enquiries as “I don’t know what to do” more as “Here is a chance to have your say”. After all, the people you are talking to are just as much part of and users of the system as you are. It
is amazing how often everyone thinks something is wrong but nobody bothers to make a suggestion or takensteps to put it right.
Oh and I’m afraid your DH sounds totally up himself.

SwedishEdith · 01/05/2022 12:48

I can't work out what you're worried about - is it leading groups of people? Your husband's fixes to the database may not be all of the things that needed changing. And if he just made changes and didn't tell anyone, there are knock-on effects there. Do you know who needs to help you? Set up a teams call, say this database isn't quite right, I've some ideas on what needs fixing but I'd like to hear from the rest of you as well so we capture everything. Then it's more conversational and feels less intimidating than a big formal project.

TruthHertz · 01/05/2022 12:47

Don't overthink it, OP. Just ensure you know why you're calling them and what you want to gain. Keep it focused on the task in hand.