Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that women’s rape crisis therapy should NOT be mixed-sex?

240 replies

IamSarah · 01/05/2022 10:02

Women’s rape crisis therapy in Sussex is currently mixed-sex. The women's groups are open to anyone, male or female, who identify as a woman.

My women’s therapy group was attended by a male who presented outwardly as male.

I am making a legal challenge to the Sussex Rape Crisis centre claiming that women who have been raped or sexually abused should have the option of single-sex female only therapy IF they want it.

This would be in addition to the existing mixed-sex options.

If you are thinking YANBU then please visit my Twitter page which has more information on how you can help women like me secure female only therapy:

twitter.com/sarahsurviving

If you are thinking YABU please let me know how you would explain this to your daughter, mother or sister if she’d been raped?

OP posts:
Whatsmyname100 · 01/05/2022 19:35

DontPickTheFlowers · 01/05/2022 11:16

I’m not sure where I stand on this. Where would the support be for men who have been raped? I seriously doubt anyone would go to such a group for kicks. They need help too.

Oh boo. Then they can attend a men only group.

Whatsmyname100 · 01/05/2022 19:33

FromOurHatsToOurFeet · 01/05/2022 10:23

It's ridiculous that anyone thinks it's acceptable. Their claim that transwomen "add value" to the women's groups is just bizarre - surely most women in the group, having been raped by penis, would rather not have the "added value" of a one in the room.

This. It's disgraceful that a woman who has been through so much trauma has to now endure her therapy with a man present.

Roseglen84 · 01/05/2022 19:27

SmiledWtherisingsun · 01/05/2022 16:35

Why can't we just have trans groups, women's groups & men's groups???

Women have been suggesting third spaces as a solution for some time now, and are branded bigoted and hateful for even doing so. These men want to be in women's spaces, that's where they get their validation.

And I believe for some men, the fact that their presence makes women uncomfortable is part of the appeal.

MrsDanversBroom · 01/05/2022 19:23

IamSarah · 01/05/2022 14:05

It is entirely unbelievable this is allowed to take place, and that some people try to justify this. Just think about it - women are FORCED to share the horrific details of their rape in front of males, or not have any group therapy provision. In what world is that acceptable?

It was unacceptable.

I was was asked directly to speak about my abuse and felt manipulated into talking about my sexual violence in front of a male to 'be kind' despite every instinct telling me not to.

It felt familiar - putting aside my own feelings and boundaries to please a male. That's exactly what sexual abuse is. The irony wasn't lost on me.

I’m so sorry, this is exactly why we need single sex spaces. I’ve donated.

YouSetTheTone · 01/05/2022 18:51

And the pp who did not think that men could possibly go to a women-only counselling session for nefarious reasons is indeed naive.

If you accept that men will sexually abuse, assault, and violently rape women (hence the need for such counselling sessions) how can you not accept that some men might exploit the potential access to those spaces? Not all assault is physical. Some men will do anything they can to penetrate women’s spaces and boundaries. There is no way to distinguish between these men and Hayley Cropper. So all men are excluded regardless of how they ‘identify’. This isn’t hard to understand, so I don’t understand why so many people have enabled this absolute plundering of the right for women to spaces that provide them with dignity, privacy and safety.

YouSetTheTone · 01/05/2022 18:43

Supersee · 01/05/2022 17:34

Didn't the head of the Edinburgh Rape
Crisis Centre (who is a transwoman aka a biological male) say that women need to 'reframe their trauma' and that they are transphobic if they request a counsellor of the sex of their choosing (a woman).

I can't believe we are living in these times. It makes me want to weep.

Sarah I salute you.

Yes, you’re right, he did. This CEO also got very angry when the Scottish government did not agree with him that women should not have the right to request a female medical examiner after being raped.
That’s right - his feelings are that women are not entitled to request that the person examining their genitals for forensic evidence after a rape is female. He believes that women should accept a second violation (if they do not want the examiner to be a man) because the feelings of men identifying as women are more important than the feelings of women.
This man is now the CEO of Edinburgh Rape Crisis Centre even though the advert for the post specifically said it was for women.

This man has no respect for women’s boundaries, and it seems that the Brighton Rape Centre at the centre of op’s case shares his sentiments.

Well women are fighting back. Thank you again Sarah!

Notanotherwindow · 01/05/2022 17:53

I'd also like to add that I see a male therapist. I trust him more than anyone and he is absolutely the best choice I could have possibly made. But seeing him was MY choice.

I had the option of male or female but having narrowed down my shortlist there was something I liked about him, even from just a profile picture he looked kind and having met him, I could tell instantly that he isn't anything like my abuser. Literally polar opposites.

But I picked him.

Joining a group for therapy is hard, there is already limited choice in that you can't control who the other members are but their sex is the one thing you should have a say in. You should have the option not to have men in your safe space where you are most vulnerable. Surely this is a basic right?

Notanotherwindow · 01/05/2022 17:38

Men have a right to support too after being raped. This could be either mixed sex or single sex (men only) and both these options exist, at least in my area. I really don't see any reason that biological males need to be in a women's single sex group, regardless of what they identify as.

If you identify as a woman and think its acceptable for you and your fully functioning penis to be in a group with biological women then you presumably have no problem with other transwomen being in a group with you, penis or no. Therefore there is no reason why you can't join a mixed sex therapy group.

Men have 2 options already. Mixed or male only.

It is unacceptable for women to have only one option. There should be a single sex and mixed sex option for both sexes, and gender, as they keep reminding us, is fluid and therefore irrelevant.

Pinklimey · 01/05/2022 17:35

Pledged.

Supersee · 01/05/2022 17:34

YouSetTheTone · 01/05/2022 16:37

As Helen Joyce pointed out yesterday, if you’re telling women to reframe their boundaries [in respect of men in women-only counselling sessions] you’re one step away from telling women to reframe their rape as consensual. Either women are entitled to set their own boundaries, or they’re not.

It seems like in the U.K. in 2022 women are not, in fact, entitled to set their own boundaries.

I have donated to your cause op and thank you so much for taking up this crucial legal challenge.

Didn't the head of the Edinburgh Rape
Crisis Centre (who is a transwoman aka a biological male) say that women need to 'reframe their trauma' and that they are transphobic if they request a counsellor of the sex of their choosing (a woman).

I can't believe we are living in these times. It makes me want to weep.

Sarah I salute you.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 01/05/2022 17:22

YABU if you are suing a particular centre who don't believe there is that need to force them to provide that service. Put the money into setting up a new one

It was women who set up these rape crisis centres in the first place ffs.
Why the fuck should they be the ones to have to start again. Besides, any new female only centres would be targeted incessantly by TRA's who demand men with lady feeling be allowed in.

These men don't want trans spaces or mixed sex spaces. They want access to female only spaces because mixed sex doesn't provide validation or anything else they want.

And what happens when these men can't access female only spaces? They try to destroy them, because if they can't have access to them, women aren't allowed to have them.

I seriously doubt anyone would go to such a group for kicks

You are seriously naive.

IamSarah · 01/05/2022 16:51

As Helen Joyce pointed out yesterday, if you’re telling women to reframe their boundaries [in respect of men in women-only counselling sessions] you’re one step away from telling women to reframe their rape as consensual. Either women are entitled to set their own boundaries, or they’re not

This x 100

A lot of female survivors (myself included) have grown up with no idea how to say no or set boundaries. It's all part of the abuse.

A rape crisis service actively encouraging women to ignore their instincts and boundaries is so, so wrong.

A RC centre assuming women have the strength and courage to voice their concerns if something feels off comes from a shocking place of privilege. It's not at all trauma informed.

OP posts:
YouSetTheTone · 01/05/2022 16:37

As Helen Joyce pointed out yesterday, if you’re telling women to reframe their boundaries [in respect of men in women-only counselling sessions] you’re one step away from telling women to reframe their rape as consensual. Either women are entitled to set their own boundaries, or they’re not.

It seems like in the U.K. in 2022 women are not, in fact, entitled to set their own boundaries.

I have donated to your cause op and thank you so much for taking up this crucial legal challenge.

SmiledWtherisingsun · 01/05/2022 16:35

Why can't we just have trans groups, women's groups & men's groups???

SmiledWtherisingsun · 01/05/2022 16:34

DontPickTheFlowers · 01/05/2022 11:16

I’m not sure where I stand on this. Where would the support be for men who have been raped? I seriously doubt anyone would go to such a group for kicks. They need help too.

At a men's group! Ffs. 🙈

SmiledWtherisingsun · 01/05/2022 16:34

Shared x

Pember · 01/05/2022 16:24

YANBU, of course! Thank you for fighting this after everything you’ve already fought Star

Pixiedust1234 · 01/05/2022 16:20

I wish I could donate but can only wish you plenty of luck for the times ahead. You rock, thank you Flowers

Newmum738 · 01/05/2022 16:19

YANBU

TooBigForMyBoots · 01/05/2022 16:18

YANBU @IamSarah.💐

Theeyeballsinthefuckingsky · 01/05/2022 16:04

YADNBU Sarah you amazing woman

and as for the “ooooh why don’t you set to your own single sex service if you think need one so much” crowd. Women did that!! We already fucking did that! Where do you think rape crisis services came from in the first place??

TRA agenda is very clear, no women single sex spaces ever anywhere for any reason! If a new single sex service was set up for women they’d be all over it straight away, demanding TW be let in, threatening & intimidating trustees, staff, funders & local cllrs. As far as they are concerned there is no justification for ever keeping them out of woman’s spaces

C8H10N4O2 · 01/05/2022 15:30

CrowUpNorth · 01/05/2022 14:08

YANBU to want there to be a service that provides a woman only service that also excludes trans women where not doing so excludes people. The law permits that. YABU if you are suing a particular centre who don't believe there is that need to force them to provide that service. Put the money into setting up a new one, not bankrupting a service that isn't ideal and clearly excludes some women so there isn't anservice at all

There isn't a service for women if it isn't single sex.

The frustrating thing about gender activists removing single sex provision is that it doesn't even help trans women whose pattern of experience and injury is different and needs specialist care.

I know of at least one rape crisis centre set up and established by women, which has added single sex male services, mixed services and specialist services for trans and non binary clients and still the gender activists want the single sex female provision shut down. They are notably quieter on the single sex male provision.

Don't kid yourself this is about equality, its about removing sex specific spaces from women even where the justification is overwhelming. I'm sick of victims of male abuse and violence being told to "reframe their trauma" to accommodate the desire of some men to be rape counselors and here first hand accounts from rape and abuse victims.

Any properly qualified (and motivated) counselor will tell you that the service only works if the client feels safe with the counselor and that the priority is the client needs, even if that means changing counselor. More to the point, trans women and men I know from pre the GRA are not wanting this, its entirely ideological.

StellaAndCrow · 01/05/2022 15:16

skybluee · 01/05/2022 14:39

I wouldn't be able to go to one of those groups. And crucially I wouldn't be able to explain why or say why. So I would just disappear and not go back. I wonder how many people are in that situation, uncounted, unknown. There's no way of telling. You would just be excluded from the service.

Speaking of non single sex provision. I was in an eating disorders unit. It was for adults but also catered for those who were 16-17. Usually it was all women but on some occasions there were men patients. One of them slept with one of the women patients who was in the 16-17 bracket. I know it's technically legal but I don't think it's OK. One of the guys used to piss in the sink in the laundry room when the other toilets were locked. No girls did this. It does introduce issues.

More than that though, I had an issue with there being male bank staff. These men you didn't know, they would turn up, often they would be very tall, 6 foot 6, often didn't speak very good English, they would be sitting outside of your room while you were meant to sleep, or on occasion sitting within arm's length, you're in bed, in your pyjamas. I have never been in pyjamas in front of a man before (outside of when I was a child). Or slept in bed with a man in the room. I was so so uncomfortable with it and when I raised it I was treated like I was unreasonable and the head of the place got angry that I was criticising 'his staff' (I think he said how dare you say that about 'my staff'). He had never met these people as far as I'm aware. One of them told me he was only there because his mum worked on staff allocation for bank staff and 'ot him the job' and that he was a 'bad boy' (he literally said that). When my friend came to visit he made her feel massively uncomfortable standing outside of the visiting room directly opposite and she said he was just staring at her. Men don't understand how intimidating it is. I am not comfortable AT ALL being in my pyjamas in front of men. It makes me feel sick and vulnerable and I hate it. Often I would have to pretend to be asleep. I have never, ever slept as badly in my life as I did in there. It was months of terrible sleep which I think massively impacted my behaviour. I felt like a different person (not in a good way). I just wanted to be able to sleep and when I came home the first thing I did is try to go to sleep even though it was the day. I was really grateful for the help I received there, massively so, but the male bank staff was a big issue and I felt unsafe a lot of the time (not in the day and not when I was dressed).

Sorry I went off on a tangent. I think my point is that people are vulnerable in these groups. Well, my point is that single sex spaces need protecting.

Thank you for sharing this skybluee - people should know what it is like for women. I'm so sorry that you had this experience, it sounds awful, and to have your views dismissed like that is just horrendous.

SexyLittleNosferatu · 01/05/2022 15:02

You didn't go off on a tangnet skybluee. You make some really valid points.

LK1972 · 01/05/2022 15:01

CrowUpNorth · 01/05/2022 14:08

YANBU to want there to be a service that provides a woman only service that also excludes trans women where not doing so excludes people. The law permits that. YABU if you are suing a particular centre who don't believe there is that need to force them to provide that service. Put the money into setting up a new one, not bankrupting a service that isn't ideal and clearly excludes some women so there isn't anservice at all

Rape Crisis makes this point very clearly.

'Research conducted by the Women’s Resource Centre found that women who had used women-only services greatly valued this support. An independent poll of 1,000 women across the UK found that 97% of those interviewed thought a female rape victim should have the choice of accessing a women-only support service.'

rapecrisis.org.uk/about-us/why-women-girls/#!

'Of sexual offences recorded by the police in the year ending March 2020, the victim was female in 84% of cases' (www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/crimeandjustice/articles/sexualoffencesvictimcharacteristicsenglandandwales/march2020)

You and Brighton's Rape Survivors Network - we don't think there's any need for women-only service.

So those 97% of women who think women should have access to women-only services (btw, wtf is wrong with the other 3%?) can just set up these services, again?
Because women have had to set up services for abused and raped women once already, that was the achievement of the second wave feminists, you're suggesting that now they've been taken over by men we should just roll over and accept it? Really?

These services are now government funded. Women are also tax payers, and voters, and deserve a fair treatment from government supported charities.

This charity insists that males 'add value' to women's rape counselling groups. Could you perhaps explain to us what that value is?