Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that women’s rape crisis therapy should NOT be mixed-sex?

240 replies

IamSarah · 01/05/2022 10:02

Women’s rape crisis therapy in Sussex is currently mixed-sex. The women's groups are open to anyone, male or female, who identify as a woman.

My women’s therapy group was attended by a male who presented outwardly as male.

I am making a legal challenge to the Sussex Rape Crisis centre claiming that women who have been raped or sexually abused should have the option of single-sex female only therapy IF they want it.

This would be in addition to the existing mixed-sex options.

If you are thinking YANBU then please visit my Twitter page which has more information on how you can help women like me secure female only therapy:

twitter.com/sarahsurviving

If you are thinking YABU please let me know how you would explain this to your daughter, mother or sister if she’d been raped?

OP posts:
jeaux90 · 03/05/2022 06:59

I contributed to the crowdfunding, been following you since this kicked off.

I hope you kick their arses.

IamSarah · 03/05/2022 06:39

Is it possible though? By that, I mean funding.

The RCC has a large amount of restricted funds specifically to support female survivors. None of their funding conditions state they need to support men or transgender survivors - it is an ideological choice.

Do the RCC have enough to offer men only, women only and mixed groups

Yes and they were planning to run a number of closed peer support groups (meaning the same people attend every time) so I suggested just one of these groups could be for women born female and this could be arranged discreetly.

I presume that they run off charitable donations and/or Govt. funding.

Yes - and women pay council tax too and deserve to have our needs met too.

If you are successful but RCC do not have enough money to offer every woman single sex therapy, what would happen?

I have been very clear I am not in this for the money and will donate any compensation to a VAWG charity. I would even donate back to the centre on the condition they run a single sex group if this is what the judge rules.

OP posts:
RobertaFirmino · 03/05/2022 01:47

women who have been raped or sexually abused should have the option of single-sex female only therapy IF they want it

How could anyone disagree with this? Is it possible though? By that, I mean funding. Do the RCC have enough to offer men only, women only and mixed groups? I presume that they run off charitable donations and/or Govt. funding. If you are successful but RCC do not have enough money to offer every woman single sex therapy, what would happen?

Ellie56 · 03/05/2022 00:05

Dear God how did we get here?

Male bodied people (aka transwomen aka men) allowed in women's and girls' toilets and changing rooms, male bodied people convicted of sex offences against women allowed into women's prisons where they predictably committed more sex offences against women, male bodied athletes being allowed to compete in and unsurprisingly win in women's sports, and a Rape Crisis Centre headed by a male bodied person.

I sometimes think I am living in a parallel universe.

Supersee · 02/05/2022 19:28

ScrollingLeaves · 02/05/2022 19:16

DontPickTheFlowers · 01/05/2022 11:16
I’m not sure where I stand on this. Where would the support be for men who have been raped? I seriously doubt anyone would go to such a group for kicks. They need help too.

There are groups for men who have been raped.

There was a poster here, maybe before Christmas whom others may remember. She was attending a rape crisis centre where trans women could attend group meetings for men, a meeting for trans women, or a women’s meeting. 3 choices.

Thereby leaving raped women no choice but a group potentially mixed with a male/males.

And think of the Rape crisis centre for women in Edinburgh actually run by a male dressed as a woman.

I think the poster you are referring to is the OP.

ScrollingLeaves · 02/05/2022 19:18

Y are definitely NOT BU

ScrollingLeaves · 02/05/2022 19:16

DontPickTheFlowers · 01/05/2022 11:16
I’m not sure where I stand on this. Where would the support be for men who have been raped? I seriously doubt anyone would go to such a group for kicks. They need help too.

There are groups for men who have been raped.

There was a poster here, maybe before Christmas whom others may remember. She was attending a rape crisis centre where trans women could attend group meetings for men, a meeting for trans women, or a women’s meeting. 3 choices.

Thereby leaving raped women no choice but a group potentially mixed with a male/males.

And think of the Rape crisis centre for women in Edinburgh actually run by a male dressed as a woman.

YouSetTheTone · 02/05/2022 19:09

Momiette · 02/05/2022 18:21

They get raped by other men....

You mean men get raped by men?

Yes they do, and these victims have access to men-only sessions and mixed sex sessions. Why should they have access to women-only sessions too?

Momiette · 02/05/2022 18:21

They get raped by other men....

montysma1 · 01/05/2022 22:37

They have made a trans "woman" the head of Rape Crisis Scotland despite it being a protected women only post.

This person has said that women who have been raped and wish only to speak with other women must "reframe their trauma" or they are bigots.
So there you have it.

LK1972 · 01/05/2022 22:13

Crumbler · 01/05/2022 20:31

YABU to expect 'rape centre' to be inherently exclusive for women. But YANBU in demanding women only rape centres.

There are men only, LGBT and 'women only' group that is in fact mixed sex. There is NO provision for actually women only!

RogersOrganismicProcess · 01/05/2022 21:18

Best of luck Sarah, I struggle to talk about my experiences even in front of other women survivors. Not a chance I’d manage with penis in the room.
Thank you for making your stand.

GertrudeKerfuffle · 01/05/2022 21:17

Thank you @IamSarah for standing up and saying no for all of us. After everything you've been through, it can't have been an easy decision to fight this, but I'm so glad you are Flowers

I had a thought about the 'value' including trans women provides - they probably mean they get an all-important shiny gold star from Stonewall Confused

Pompomdogbowl · 01/05/2022 21:02

Also I’ve donated, good luck

Pompomdogbowl · 01/05/2022 21:02

Having worked in a single sex service with women who have experienced sexual assault and DV I can say YANBU x1000.
Women need single sex spaces, especially free from a penis. I do think men need support as do trans people, but this should never be at the cost of women. How rape crisis can hold their head high when they are potentially re-traumatising women.

keeptalkinghappytalk · 01/05/2022 20:57

So touched by Gradmom… says it all..

massive support to you Sarah… I’ve donated x

Gradmom · 01/05/2022 20:50

I am autistic and would not have attended the DV counselling service and group that I was offered had there been men present. That counselling re-framed my logical awareness of what DV abuse and sexual grooming and good boundaries look like and has kept me safe ever since.

Speaking of boundaries...Mine are very much clearer now and penis within a sexual abuse setting for natal sexed women definitely would not be something I just felt I had to be kind about and accept without offering extreme resistance as an act of self care.

As a previously groomed and abused autistic girl within a young persons care institution I was subject to abuse by male residential social workers aged 14.

I was 'found' by Operation Hydrant aged 45. People were taken to court in their late 70's

This early life experience set me up for more abuse of trust when what I needed within institution and workplace were VERY CLEAR boundaries and clear cut safeguarding to protect me. Same from my counselling service.

I am still not comfy with random men in the healing/care/safe spaces of women on the basis of it's 'kind to be trusting'. I am 50 now and I know how damaging it is to DV/SA victims to allow them to be put at any risk of further harm.

A support worker recently suggested that as an autistic woman I might consider self care an act of political warfare. She has it right. It is precisely that for us.

YANBU.

Waitwhat23 · 01/05/2022 20:43

YABU to expect 'rape centre' to be inherently exclusive for women.

She's not. The service she refers to has a women's group (in reality mixed sex), a men's group and a group for trans or non binary people. What it does not have is a single sex female group and refuses to provide such a service despite being able to do so using the single sex exemptions in the EQA2010.

The only group without access to the support they need is women who require a single sex service.

And Sarah isn't asking for this service instead of the other groups but in addition to.

Crumbler · 01/05/2022 20:31

YABU to expect 'rape centre' to be inherently exclusive for women. But YANBU in demanding women only rape centres.

RishiRich · 01/05/2022 20:11

YANBU. Women need spaces away from men. Vulnerable women do not access rape crisis therapy to prop up a man's delusions about himself.

pentagone · 01/05/2022 20:10

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

I absolutely do question the motives of males accessing women only services, especially where trans specific services exist, as in the case of the male at The group Sarah was in.

there are men who get sexually aroused by women being violated, there are men who enjoy intimidating women, and having power and control. Why on earth would we expect these men to stay away from services like these when they can access with impunity? And at the very least, the male at Sarah’s group was so oblivious as to the effect his presence may have on women sexual abuse survivors, that one has to suspect that any contribution they would have made would not have been helpful. The whole point of groups like this is that you are with people who ‘get it’ and that individual clearly did not ‘get’ what it’s like for women.

pentagone · 01/05/2022 19:59

IamSarah · 01/05/2022 16:51

As Helen Joyce pointed out yesterday, if you’re telling women to reframe their boundaries [in respect of men in women-only counselling sessions] you’re one step away from telling women to reframe their rape as consensual. Either women are entitled to set their own boundaries, or they’re not

This x 100

A lot of female survivors (myself included) have grown up with no idea how to say no or set boundaries. It's all part of the abuse.

A rape crisis service actively encouraging women to ignore their instincts and boundaries is so, so wrong.

A RC centre assuming women have the strength and courage to voice their concerns if something feels off comes from a shocking place of privilege. It's not at all trauma informed.

This is extremely well put.

This x 1000

HotDogKetchup · 01/05/2022 19:57

Having used the service I was about to say YABU - but that was 1-2-1 counselling. I can’t imagine a mixed sex group setting. Thank you for fighting this.

IamSarah · 01/05/2022 19:55

No one is questioning the intentions of the trans people joining the womens group.

I think it's okay and healthy to question the motives of a male joining women's rape crisis meetings.

Abuse and take survivors have been lied to and manipulated by men. Expecting them to trust any man who claims to be a woman is a very big ask.

OP posts:
ChairCareOh · 01/05/2022 19:43

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request