Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think being a SAHM/housewife is not the same as someone claiming benefits?

1002 replies

Jajana · 01/05/2022 08:00

Was chatting to my sister and was talking about how my MIL is a housewife (sorry not sure if that’s the correct term). She said that being a SAHM/housewife is no different to someone claiming benefits and would rather claim benefits than rely on someone for an income!

Bearing in mind, FIL runs a very successful business and all of the money MIL receives is from private funds - not through the state.

Am i being reasonable to think being a SAHM/housewife isn’t the same as claiming benefits?

OP posts:
greenteafiend · 01/05/2022 12:23

This is a little different to being left high and dry when he fucks off with something younger, perkier and tighter (see the relationships board for examples) - or even if he becomes ill or dies.

Yup. Twitter is full of right-wing men who express disgust and repulsion at the fact that women age, yet also demand that women become homemakers. The reality is that a big reason why women usually hang on to their careers is because we're painfully aware of the tendency of some men to trade in or cheat on wives who are aging. Ageism is a thing in the workplace too, but seniority and experience gives you some protection. A SAHM has no such protection.

Whereverilaymycat · 01/05/2022 12:23

I just think your sister is being unkind.

Basically saying your MIL is somehow wrong because she's just like these other people who are also wrong.

Doesn't really show a great deal of understanding of how benefits work, or the broad range of reasons someone may be a stay at home parent.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 01/05/2022 12:21

To add men agree to the SAHW it is easiest for them otherwise they'd have to share the daily tasks after working all day.

It rarely benefits the woman.

Underhisi · 01/05/2022 12:20

I'm a sahm and claim benefits because I am also my child's carer. Ideally we would both be sahm parents and carers because he needs a minimum of 2:1 care. Childcare isn't a possibility because it doesn't exist in our situation where occasional specialist residential respite is the only respite we can get.

Topgub · 01/05/2022 12:18

@pinklavenders

How does providing a service for your family benefit society?

EmeraldShamrock1 · 01/05/2022 12:18

It's no wonder so many men are incapable when they're accustomed to their personal needs being taken care of by their wife.

Many have a non sexual work wife massaging their ego, reminding them of the days plan.

From DM to DW any independent years before the transition when they managed to look after their admin or iron clothes, even vacuuming is forgotten.

If reincarnation exists I definitely want to come back as a man.

Topgub · 01/05/2022 12:17

If I truly thought that being a sahp was so fulfilling and of such a benefit I'd be expecting my male oh to value it as much as me.

I wouldnt be ok with him not valuing it and working instead

pinklavenders · 01/05/2022 12:15

So a 'job' is only a job if it's performed outside the home in return for a salary?

Waxonwaxoff0 · 01/05/2022 12:14

pinklavenders · 01/05/2022 12:13

Cleaning your own house and looking after children you chose to have is not, and never will be, a job. It's just part of life.

And?

Both activities are contributing to society - in one case you're offering your services to an outside employer, in the other you're offering your services within your family.

Why is the latter less valuable?

I didn't say it wasn't valuable. I said it's not a job.

pinklavenders · 01/05/2022 12:13

Cleaning your own house and looking after children you chose to have is not, and never will be, a job. It's just part of life.

And?

Both activities are contributing to society - in one case you're offering your services to an outside employer, in the other you're offering your services within your family.

Why is the latter less valuable?

Topgub · 01/05/2022 12:09

@pinklavenders

You can look after a family and work.

Women are restricted in getting a good eduction and good career because of sexist beliefs like they are better suited to finding fulfillment from not working.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 01/05/2022 12:09

I hope the director of every company you’ve ever workedd for has been a woman then!

I have never worked for private enterprise. Like all workers, though, I have skills and a CV as well as references. I've changed jobs (never been sacked) and each time like other workers, of both sexes, I have applied for new ones. That's what workers do.

This is a little different to being left high and dry when he fucks off with something younger, perkier and tighter (see the relationships board for examples) - or even if he becomes ill or dies.

Far, far too risky - as the wise woman who spoke with experience told me.

TeaBug · 01/05/2022 12:08

There are many, many people (mostly women) trapped in caring roles

The worst part of it is being invisible to society at large. Well maybe not the worst part but the most frustrating.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 01/05/2022 12:07

Cleaning your own house and looking after children you chose to have is not, and never will be, a job. It's just part of life. The reason you pay other people to do it is because they're cleaning YOUR house and looking after YOUR kids. They're not obligated to do it the way you are obligated to.

pinklavenders · 01/05/2022 12:05

Youre coming dangerously close to saying women are designed to look after kids and men are designed to make money.

Every woman (and man) should be free to choose how she wants to live her life! Women need a good education and the opportunity for a great career!

But many women find looking after a family a very fulfilling job.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 01/05/2022 12:01

Fizbosshoes · 01/05/2022 11:46

I remember reading in another thread someone insisting if both parents were working, a cleaner was a necessity rather than a luxury.

Nearly everyone I know (working and SAHMs) has a cleaner where I live (out of all my friends, I can think of one other who doesn't have a cleaner) but that still (imo) doesn't make it an essential like rent or mortgage, gas/electricity, food, water etc!

Probably depends on what type of area you live in. I live in a very working class area, a lot of us including myself work in the local factories or the airport, manufacturing is a big industry here. No one I know could justify the cost of a cleaner when you can just do it yourself especially with the cost of living nowadays.

Louise0701 · 01/05/2022 12:01

@YetAnotherSpartacus I hope the director of every company you’ve ever workedd for has been a woman then!

greenteafiend · 01/05/2022 11:56

But how is it that it’s ok to pay for a housekeeper in this way but if a mum (or dad) chooses to do this job, they’re seen as essentially unemployed? Seems wrong.

For me, it is not the nature of work that is done, but the question of whether one is financial dependent on a spouse or an employer.

It's personally risker to be completely financially dependent on a spouse, because one lacks bargaining power.

With an abusive employer, you can leave, threaten to leave, or shop around for the best (or "least bad") working situation, and you can also increase your bargaining power by improving and learning new skills and experience which can potentially make you a more attractive employee.

You can't do this with an abusive spouse if you are a SAHM; you can't be like "I don't like my breadwinning husband because he treats me like shit, so I'm going to look around for another breadwinning husband to support me instead." Men rarely want to support other men's genetic offspring, so you are basically tied to the one you've got. As you get older and acquire children, you become ever-less attractive to other men as a wife, so the odds of finding a man willing to become your new breadwinner and support you and your kids (to him, these would be stepkids) in the style you are accustomed to will get lower with each year. So if you have little employment history you are in a financially vulnerable position.

A housekeeper does not have this issue; (s)he can leave and find another position if (s)he is poorly treated.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 01/05/2022 11:54

I could never, ever rely on a man for money. It's too risky. As a woman once said to me (voice of bitter experience) "you are one man from the state".

AlexaShutUp · 01/05/2022 11:52

Why are people bringing breastfeeding into it? I bf dd until she was nearly 3, it didn't stop me from working. Confused

AlexaShutUp · 01/05/2022 11:51

I think it's probably true to say that the SAHP facilitates the WOHP's career where both partners are lower earners, as they would struggle to afford childcare even with both partners working. In that scenario, there really isn't much choice as to whether one parent becomes a SAHP, unless both are able to work PT or do opposite hours around each other's shifts etc.

However, I don't think it's true that people with really successful careers need a SAHP at home in order to facilitate that career. I think that has been amply disproven by the sheer number of very successful people in different fields who have managed to rise to the top without having had that support. Of course, having a SAHP might make life easier in many ways, but it certainly isn't a requirement.

Topgub · 01/05/2022 11:47

@pinklavenders

Very few women breastfeed for very long. I highly doubt it has that much of an impact.

Youre coming dangerously close to saying women are designed to look after kids and men are designed to make money.

Fizbosshoes · 01/05/2022 11:46

I remember reading in another thread someone insisting if both parents were working, a cleaner was a necessity rather than a luxury.

Nearly everyone I know (working and SAHMs) has a cleaner where I live (out of all my friends, I can think of one other who doesn't have a cleaner) but that still (imo) doesn't make it an essential like rent or mortgage, gas/electricity, food, water etc!

Gwenhwyfar · 01/05/2022 11:45

I have a job so I reply on my employer for money. Same as a housewife relies on her husband I suppose.

JacquelineCarlyle · 01/05/2022 11:45

Iwantmyoldnameback · 01/05/2022 08:04

Many housewives/SAHM do contribute to the overall family income by enabling others to work to their full potential. It's a partnership, your sister is wrong.

This - I can't believe anyone sees it any other way.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.