Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are people in care homes constantly treated like this?

136 replies

Mooooooooooooo · 01/05/2022 07:57

If i were to whistleblow, I'd be doing it for every single care home.
Residents are constantly referred to as 'cute'. Why? They wouldn't be referred to in that way if they weren't elderly I bet.
Having their heads patted by carers.
Talk of 'favourites'.
We do have some absolutely lovely, endearing and sweet residents but still, they don't deserve to be patronised.
Talking about them in front of them thinking because they have dementia, they won't understand.
A nurse told me that a lady with dementia needs a wash because she 'stinks' even though she was right in front of me.
I know we have some residents who are very hard of hearing so you do have to shout, but sometimes there's a very bossy/rude tone from carers.
It's the case in many homes I've seen

OP posts:
PintOfCoffeePlease · 01/05/2022 10:59

That is not behaviour I would accept in any care home I’ve worked in. I have challenged it on the spot and taken it higher when the staff member is combative or unreceptive, or when there is an organisational issue rather than any one individual. Please consider doing the same.

For balance, the vast majority of people I’ve worked with in care contexts are warm, caring and doing their absolute best in a tough job. Those who are deliberately cruel are rare. Those who are trying and get it wrong are more common, but generally open to learning and doing better.

itstaxing · 01/05/2022 10:55

Not all Carers are like this but the system is totally broken. People working minimum wage in a stressful busy environment with too much to do and insufficient training and no hope for progression. It brings out the worst in people. Medical staff in elderly care hospitals aren't much better in my opinion - just watched more.

lollipoprainbow · 01/05/2022 10:48

Not in my mum's care home it's wonderful.

Mooooooooooooo · 01/05/2022 10:46

Glad to hear there are some lovely ones too

OP posts:
TokyoTen · 01/05/2022 10:42

Not all care homes.are.the same! My mum is in a lovely one and she loves it there. The staff are absolutely lovely and respectful too.

Gazelda · 01/05/2022 10:08

For balance, I know a lot of people who are living in care homes. I see them treated with respect, dignity and as individuals. I see them receiving person centred care. Their hobbies and interests are supported. Their personal care treated as priority. Their social needs met. Their family and loved ones kept informed. Their surroundings looked after and made personalised where possible. Relationships with staff are positive and regularly reviewed. Clear whistleblowing and complaints procedures are in place with easy to follow and confidential opportunities to report.

Not all care homes are unpleasant. Not all care staff are unfeeling. Care homes can be a very positive experience, filled with laughter, compassion, comfort and respect.

mycatisannoying · 01/05/2022 10:06

A friend of a friend is a complete narcissist, and was working as a while as a carer. During lockdown, she took her family (partner and two sons) into the home of a vulnerable lady with dementia. This is because she was expecting a phone call during her visit, and thought that they could look after her (they were complete strangers to her) while she took the call.
I reported it. I just couldn't believe that she would be so selfish as to risk the woman's health.
She wasn't even fired.
You pay peanuts, you get monkeys (in some cases, by no means all).

Sally090807 · 01/05/2022 09:53

When my mum was in a care home at a relatively young age but with mild dementia one of the staff came in the room and I asked how mum was doing. She said “she’s not too good”, she then pulled the bedsheets away from her feet and said “ her feet and legs will change colour when she’s near the end, she’s not quite there yet”. I just couldn’t believe that a member of staff would say that in front of my mum. 😢

watcherintherye · 01/05/2022 09:42

Ferngreen · 01/05/2022 08:00

Not like that in the care home I visit. Carers are kind and chatty with the residents.

Of course they are, when there are visitors around!

LightningAndRainbows · 01/05/2022 09:40

Ah ok. Then maybe report all the shit ones and just go to the nice ones?

toomuchlaundry · 01/05/2022 09:39

In your first line you said you would have to whistleblow for all homes @Mooooooooooooo How did you think people would interpret that?

Mooooooooooooo · 01/05/2022 09:33

I didn't think it would be taken so literally but maybe i should have been clearer.

OP posts:
LightningAndRainbows · 01/05/2022 09:31

Mooooooooooooo · 01/05/2022 08:58

Yes definitely not all homes, been to one really nice one

Then why did you imply it was all homes? And constantly?

Mooooooooooooo · 01/05/2022 09:31

Quite obvious I'm not saying every single home in existence bar one single one. The past couple of weeks I've been to a lovely one but some were like above

OP posts:
Mooooooooooooo · 01/05/2022 09:30

Itwillbeok1 · 01/05/2022 09:19

This is the most irresponsible AIBU. I am only on mumsnet for the elderly parents thread - because I found it helpful. I've never posted before but I have to answer this to tell anybody who has parents that are needing care to not worry and think it is all homes - it isn't. I've been where you are and there are good places. Of course, there are bad places and it's a constant process of assessment - you keep an eye out for your relative etc as much as you can, continuously , but please, please, don't think everywhere is awful. The whole thing is hard enough to navigate without starting out expecting abuse and neglect at every turn.
To the OP - Do you not think that a number of people reading this board have parents that are in nursing homes because their needs are so great they can't be cared for any other way? How dare you start flexing and showing off and adding to their stress by saying it's all homes and then contradict yourself further down by saying 'Yes definitely not all homes, been to one really nice one.'
I'm guessing you are agency staff ? So, do your job and whistleblow for every single care home and not in an anonymous sneaky google review way - be upfront and report to social care, CQC, local newspaper - the works.

There are some care and nursing homes with safeguarding concerns and these are the stories that often, but not always, end up in the news - and it's appalling and worrying and horrible but there are plenty that are good.

There are huge worries with social care - it's stressful as all hell to navigate, care should never have been taken off the NHS and passed to social care, care should NEVER have been privatised and that goes for children's homes, learning difficulties etc.
Of course there are bad places but that is not the norm. Shame on you OP, shame on you.

Ermm...wow? Huge huge overreaction

OP posts:
BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 01/05/2022 09:27

This is unacceptable practice these days and CQC would come down hard on these things if they identified them. The staff - including the nurses - need training in dignity and respect. It is a hard job, but it's not difficult to use someone's name as opposed to 'dear' or 'petal'. Saying someone stinks right in front of them is unprofessional and totally unacceptable as well. The staff often forget themselves in these places. The manager and senior members of staff set the tone and culture, so they need to address these problems.

Itwillbeok1 · 01/05/2022 09:19

This is the most irresponsible AIBU. I am only on mumsnet for the elderly parents thread - because I found it helpful. I've never posted before but I have to answer this to tell anybody who has parents that are needing care to not worry and think it is all homes - it isn't. I've been where you are and there are good places. Of course, there are bad places and it's a constant process of assessment - you keep an eye out for your relative etc as much as you can, continuously , but please, please, don't think everywhere is awful. The whole thing is hard enough to navigate without starting out expecting abuse and neglect at every turn.
To the OP - Do you not think that a number of people reading this board have parents that are in nursing homes because their needs are so great they can't be cared for any other way? How dare you start flexing and showing off and adding to their stress by saying it's all homes and then contradict yourself further down by saying 'Yes definitely not all homes, been to one really nice one.'
I'm guessing you are agency staff ? So, do your job and whistleblow for every single care home and not in an anonymous sneaky google review way - be upfront and report to social care, CQC, local newspaper - the works.

There are some care and nursing homes with safeguarding concerns and these are the stories that often, but not always, end up in the news - and it's appalling and worrying and horrible but there are plenty that are good.

There are huge worries with social care - it's stressful as all hell to navigate, care should never have been taken off the NHS and passed to social care, care should NEVER have been privatised and that goes for children's homes, learning difficulties etc.
Of course there are bad places but that is not the norm. Shame on you OP, shame on you.

Idiotintraining · 01/05/2022 09:15

I am in two minds about this. Firstly some residents have been denied visitors for a long time and I think sometimes it might seem harsh but isn't meant to be there just engaging with the resident who might now have some one come to see them for a while to try and make them happy.

It does sound degrading but it makes conversation with a client and if they have someone to talk to its better then nothing

Moaningturtle1 · 01/05/2022 09:06

I work in a care home for adults (16-64) with severe disabilities. I talk to them in the same way I talk to everyone, which means sometimes the odd “ok sweetheart” or “morning chuck” comes out I have to admit. It’s a home environment and I suppose I act more like a member of a household than a visiting professional. I don’t think the clients mind, in fact I know they love me. It’s a hard job and a hard life for those I look after, most of us are just trying to make the day brighter.

Mooooooooooooo · 01/05/2022 08:58

Yes definitely not all homes, been to one really nice one

OP posts:
vodkaredbullgirl · 01/05/2022 08:55

Not all care homes are like that, well definitely not in the care home I work in. Residents are treated with respect and dignity. No love or dear where I work.

ChocolateDeficitDisorder · 01/05/2022 08:50

When care you create a care standards vs profit situation, profit will always win.

UmbilicusProfundus · 01/05/2022 08:46

Yes @Confusion101 people may say it with positive intent, but it is actually really patronising/ infantilising in this context.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 01/05/2022 08:45

LightningAndRainbows · 01/05/2022 08:18

Are these staff like this from the get go? If not what is it that happens that makes them like this?

I suspect there are lots of reasons.

It's generally a poorly paid job with no experience needed, so almost anyone (however poorly suited they are) can apply and become a carer.

Care homes are desperate for staff - any staff - so would rather have anyone than no-one.

The working conditions are generally pretty awful - long hours, not enough breaks, lack of training, poor pay, lots of overtime - it's easy to become jaded and burnt out in a job like that.

Of course none of that is an excuse to treat people badly or to be abusive but I can see why care homes generally end up being staffed by people who don't really appear to care.

It's certainly not a job just anyone can do - I certainly couldn't do it!

veronicagoldberg · 01/05/2022 08:36

Caring can be a pretty unpleasant job for rubbish pay, so it's probably easy to become jaded and end up mistreating residents. Maybe if the work was valued more and the pay higher, it would attract more caring people.