Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are people in care homes constantly treated like this?

136 replies

Mooooooooooooo · 01/05/2022 07:57

If i were to whistleblow, I'd be doing it for every single care home.
Residents are constantly referred to as 'cute'. Why? They wouldn't be referred to in that way if they weren't elderly I bet.
Having their heads patted by carers.
Talk of 'favourites'.
We do have some absolutely lovely, endearing and sweet residents but still, they don't deserve to be patronised.
Talking about them in front of them thinking because they have dementia, they won't understand.
A nurse told me that a lady with dementia needs a wash because she 'stinks' even though she was right in front of me.
I know we have some residents who are very hard of hearing so you do have to shout, but sometimes there's a very bossy/rude tone from carers.
It's the case in many homes I've seen

OP posts:
LightningAndRainbows · 01/05/2022 15:25

NellesVilla · 01/05/2022 13:11

And fwiw, I work in admin in the care industry currently, and I call PWS (people we support), “babes”, and I’m not stopping now! Sorry, not sorry.
Got that off my chest now!

You do what? You should stop that. Address them as a person of equal standing who deserves your respect. Not a mate down the pub.

NellesVilla · 01/05/2022 15:00

This practice is regarded as patronising, sexist and ageist and not client centered. It is also unprofessional. People of all ages should be spoken to using whichever form of address they prefer. This has been known about for many years now and there is no excuse to keep doing it. If CQC hear you doing it they would come down very heavily on you and certainly recommend training to ensure clients are spoken to in a respectful manner.

Erm, what???! Calling someone “babes”??? I think you’ll find CQC have more pressing issues, babes! I couldn’t give a shiny crap what they think about this. DFOD!!!!

Mooooooooooooo · 01/05/2022 14:59

If you read my post I have never once mentioned terms of endearment or said i had whistleblown

OP posts:
WhoWants2Know · 01/05/2022 14:55

I can't get myself worked up over people using terms of endearment while supporting others, any more than I would have been upset about nurses and porters calling me "my lovely" and "darling" last time I needed to be in hospital.

Does it not occur to you that those terms fall within people's natural speech patterns? Or that carers build mutually rewarding and affectionate relationships with the people they look after, every day for years at a time?

Did you actually ask any of the service users whether they mind being referred to in this way before you decided to whistleblow on all these care homes?

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 01/05/2022 13:48

NellesVilla · 01/05/2022 13:11

And fwiw, I work in admin in the care industry currently, and I call PWS (people we support), “babes”, and I’m not stopping now! Sorry, not sorry.
Got that off my chest now!

This practice is regarded as patronising, sexist and ageist and not client centered. It is also unprofessional. People of all ages should be spoken to using whichever form of address they prefer. This has been known about for many years now and there is no excuse to keep doing it. If CQC hear you doing it they would come down very heavily on you and certainly recommend training to ensure clients are spoken to in a respectful manner.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 01/05/2022 13:37

JollyWilloughby · 01/05/2022 12:44

And don’t even get me started on the “game face”

when family walk through the door and everyone turns into Mary Poppins….. it’s not the reality

they’re bloody awful god forsaken places, and I wish I never stepped foot in them so I could live the life of ignorance like everyone else.

makes me shudder at the thought of going in one

This is not universal. My mum lives in a care home and has capacity, so she reports back everything she sees that she doesn't approve of, and there's very little. Having to wait for things when they are short staffed, irritation with some other residents, an agency member of staff turning her light on in the middle of the night, and outrage about a lift issue - mainly in the context of the poor staff being run ragged. The agency staff was given short shrift by the manager.

They have weekly residents' meetings with the senior staff, and feedback is listened to. I've been there frequently, moving around the home between the communal areas and mum's room, and often witness the care of others which is respectful and affectionate. There's lots of smiles and laughter (from the residents). I'm sure my mum calls some of the staff "my dear" - it would be surprising if she didn't.

Yes, it's not what we'd choose with infinite resources, but there really is no other option. And I'm very grateful to the staff for their limitless kindness. I do agree though that it's the management who set the tone. Perhaps it being a not-for-profit helps with that.

Hardbackwriter · 01/05/2022 13:36

As a society, we don't know what to do with our huge and growing population of very elderly people and people living with dementia for long periods. No previous generation has had this issue on this scale, which is why none of the previous solutions work. People know that care homes are a suboptimal solution, which is why almost everyone says they don't want to go into one themselves. But the other solution is to accept that other people (realistically: women) have to give over decades of their lives to providing constant care - and that still often won't result in high quality, or even safe, care. It's crap and hard and awful but it's not the OP's fault and not talking about it won't make the problem go away and it won't get us any closer to better solutions.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 01/05/2022 13:29

I’ll say this again. If you think you will be in a position to be responsible for elderly people get them and yourself an Alexa with video now, before they go into a care home. Get them used to using it before there is any mental decline.

my mother was placed in a transitional rehab/care home last summer and it was invaluable for me to be able to ‘drop in’ with video. It was also reassuring that the staff encouraged it. It told me that they weren’t worried about unannounced visits.

this was especially true since I live 6 hours away and she was in during COVID lockdowns.

NellesVilla · 01/05/2022 13:11

And fwiw, I work in admin in the care industry currently, and I call PWS (people we support), “babes”, and I’m not stopping now! Sorry, not sorry.
Got that off my chest now!

Hardbackwriter · 01/05/2022 13:09

lollipoprainbow · 01/05/2022 12:57

@JollyWilloughby I'm sure your comments are really helpful for relatives broken hearted about having to put their loved ones into care homes when there is no other option.

I have so much sympathy for you and how it must feel to read this, but if that is her factual experience what do you expect her to do? Never tell anyone in case it upsets them? I can see why she wants to tell people of her awful experience and why she might think people will want to know even though it might leave them feeling conflicted.

NellesVilla · 01/05/2022 13:07

Personally, I get fed up of people insulting the care industry all the time (staff), when they themselves would never work in it.

For those of you that are so outraged, what are you going to do about it? Are you going to enter the industry and show the rest of them no-good, heartless, uneducated scum how it’s done? You try wiping arses each day, hurting your back and having bodily fluids squirted into your eye and being chatty, smiley and energetic throughout each grueling, underpaid shift!!

Fwiw, some carers are bloody excellent, not all, but some. I’ve worked in many and some homes/clients are incredibly fortunate to have some of these hard-working, devoted, dedicated men and women.

zafferana · 01/05/2022 13:04

I can well imagine that the behaviour your list is the tip of the iceberg. I can't stand the patronising tone that is used by many HCPs and care workers, calling older women 'my love', and my personal favourite 'aw bless' to every single fucking thing that anyone says in relation to an older person. Older people are just people, the same as us, and I really, really wish that patronising words and phrases were banned when speaking to them. It grates so much with me and I'm only middle aged. I'd honestly rather kill myself than have to listen to that shit all day every day.

As for saying, in someone's hearing, that they stink - that is appalling and should be reported.

lollipoprainbow · 01/05/2022 13:04

@NellesVilla 'stench of urine'

NellesVilla · 01/05/2022 13:02

@lollipoprainbow ?????!

lollipoprainbow · 01/05/2022 13:01

@NellesVilla what a horrible sweeping statement to make.

NellesVilla · 01/05/2022 12:59

I used to teach ESOL to new carers in care homes. Most of them were lovely people from India and the Philippines who couldn’t do more for their clients. They were v sweet and eager to learn colloquial English to be able to communicate with the people they cared for.

However, the stench of urine put me off and one reason why I couldn’t work in one. I have been a carer to people in their own homes before and so much easier to keep on top of interesting smells and the general cleanliness of the client and building!

lollipoprainbow · 01/05/2022 12:57

@JollyWilloughby I'm sure your comments are really helpful for relatives broken hearted about having to put their loved ones into care homes when there is no other option.

MissyB1 · 01/05/2022 12:53

Stupid scaremongering thread title - please get it changed.

JollyWilloughby · 01/05/2022 12:44

And don’t even get me started on the “game face”

when family walk through the door and everyone turns into Mary Poppins….. it’s not the reality

they’re bloody awful god forsaken places, and I wish I never stepped foot in them so I could live the life of ignorance like everyone else.

makes me shudder at the thought of going in one

JollyWilloughby · 01/05/2022 12:41

Carer rather

JollyWilloughby · 01/05/2022 12:41

ive worked in the sector as a career, my mother has managed an awful lot of care homes as a nurse and most need to be whistle blowed on.

The large majority fail to provide adequate care because of a lack of funding, lack of training, lack of career progression and profit makers from home owners who couldn’t give a shiny shite about the care of the residents and are more concerned with the money they pay.

Onlyforcake · 01/05/2022 12:38

Across the board, care staff are too low in number so are pushed for time, undertrained without enough oversight. Probably because that patronising attitude towards the elderly is very embedded in society, so care is a very low paid, low status job.

People literally say 'couldn't you do x/yz instead' when they hear I work in care. My work is a privilege, but so few in the field see it that way. Its heartbreaking

MatildaTheCat · 01/05/2022 12:35

I understand your point and have unfortunately got more experience in this field than I want. Be aware that ‘changing homes’ isn’t an option for some people. My DF was only accepted by one home due to his needs (not aggressive) and I hated it with a passion. The staff were not good in the main and there was nothing we could do about it.

FIL is in a beautiful place where the staff are exceptional. It’s complicated.

Ownedbymycats · 01/05/2022 12:26

I've a young relative in a nursing home, not the most appropriate place for her but there's no choice really. We've found the home generally very satisfactory but we challenge any issues we see and try and do it in a positive way. The home constantly ask for dry shampoo and don't brush it out properly when they use it. We also notice they shower her far less frequently when she has dry shampoo so we rarely supply it. Because she's quite young but is seen as lacking capacity to make decisions we need to give permission to allow her to be photographed. The home are very keen to put craft activities etc on FB and constantly ask permission which we always refuse.
The staff are generally really well meaning but like most things in life it's all about communication.

lljkk · 01/05/2022 11:07

Only on MN would being called 'cute', 'pet', 'petal' : be deemed abusive language.

Interesting that OP used words like "lovely" "endearing" "sweet" to describe residents. Why are those words not being deemed abusive ("condescending", "patronising") language, too?

I routinely tell adult DS that he stinks. If that's what it takes to coax him into a shower.... I might say it in front of other members of our household. He's not got SN or MH issues. He's just not bothered, which I vastly prefer to the anxiety fest that most MNers seem to live in. It's factual, not shameful.

tbh, people talk about small children in front of them with great explicitness when the kids can't understand or mind. If anything, it's much more respectful to have those conversations in front of resident but with colleagues or their F&F than to talk about the residents behind their backs. Isn't talking about someone behind their backs one of the big things that most people hugely resent?

Don't think I can agree with single one of OP's concerns.