Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are people in care homes constantly treated like this?

136 replies

Mooooooooooooo · 01/05/2022 07:57

If i were to whistleblow, I'd be doing it for every single care home.
Residents are constantly referred to as 'cute'. Why? They wouldn't be referred to in that way if they weren't elderly I bet.
Having their heads patted by carers.
Talk of 'favourites'.
We do have some absolutely lovely, endearing and sweet residents but still, they don't deserve to be patronised.
Talking about them in front of them thinking because they have dementia, they won't understand.
A nurse told me that a lady with dementia needs a wash because she 'stinks' even though she was right in front of me.
I know we have some residents who are very hard of hearing so you do have to shout, but sometimes there's a very bossy/rude tone from carers.
It's the case in many homes I've seen

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 01/05/2022 20:14

@Norush4 you’re just embarrassed you failed to read my post properly and jumped on some unsuspecting person in error. Yes if it comes down to my mothers care or someone else’s feelings I will advocate for my mother every day of the week and twice on Sunday

I hope for you that you have someone willing to do the same if/when you find yourself needing an advocate.

TabbyMcTatBuskersCat · 01/05/2022 20:10

Not in the care homes I've worked in. Disgusting behaviour and disrespectful language. I'd be whistleblowing if I heard that.

JollyWilloughby · 01/05/2022 20:05

@Cleothecat75

I would argue that safeguarding concerns in childhood settings are taken far more seriously and acted upon more so than in elderly care home settings. Unfortunately you can’t compare the two. Many, many people whistle blow to no avail.

Norush4 · 01/05/2022 20:04

@saltinesandcoffeecups you sound delightful you better steady on you don't end up in one of these type of establishments one day... hope that you do get someone who does "give a shit". You rude individual.

Please don't continue this repetition either.

Cleothecat75 · 01/05/2022 20:02

If i were to whistleblow, I'd be doing it for every single care home
why are you not whistle blowing On every care home if care is that bad? Just because it is happening in ‘every single care home’ you visit does not mean it’s right. Surely you cover safeguarding in your training? Every time something happens that is wrong or unkind or abusive, surely you report it? How do you think things changeIf no one is ever pulled up on this kind of thing?

I used to work in childcare and have reported settings I worked for, for safeguarding reasons and also other settings where I witnessed bad practice. It’s the right thing to do.

So, I’m not quite sure what your Aibu is? Yes YABU for not reporting and YANBU for thinking it’s wrong to treat dementia patients like this.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 01/05/2022 19:59

Norush4 · 01/05/2022 17:28

Who are you speaking to in such a jumped up tone? You never stated it was a video call... the way you said it was as though you wanted to film the staff.

Many people would not want to be filmed whilst working and just so I am clear I do not begrudge a video call... the world has moved along and hospitals have Ipads.

For you and others who are not familiar with Alexa. You have 2 options, you can video call where the other party has to accept your call. And there is the drop in feature where you can pre clear contacts to connect with video automatically.

The drop in feature plays a sound and then connects video after a pause. The device also allows for do not disturb so a trusted contact can not drop in until that is turned off.

The way I said it did not indicate that I wanted to film staff. You read that into my statement (have no idea how you came to that conclusion). Although quite honestly I don’t give a shit if staff want to be filmed or not. My concern was my mother’s care and not the staff’s feelings.

All that being said it was a great facility with wonderful staff, which was confirmed by my mother after she regained her cognitive ability following radiation treatment on her brain. Thankfully she’s home now where she will stay until she passes, but they helped her last few years be good ones.

NellesVilla · 01/05/2022 19:56

So, there are good carers, bad carers and those that prop up the middle.

How do we attract decent carers to the industry? My company have tried: decent wages and pay progression; incentives such as welcome bonuses; advanced training, but we’ll never have enough carers, let alone the really good ones we’d like to retain.

I myself undertook a care job in the past (domiciliary and live-in work), but it was not for me. I did the best I could: I was patient, considerate and cheerful, but found it to be hard work and realised I was quite squeamish at times. These parts of the job will never attract some people, I’m afraid.

The future is a concern.

Randomname85 · 01/05/2022 19:55

SO MANY TYPOS.

Randomname85 · 01/05/2022 19:54

The care gone my grandmother is in currently is amazing and the residents aren’t treated like this at all. The home she was in previously was so patronising- I used to cringe when they’d shout in her face - she is hard of hearing but it’s hard to watch. The also make her make a card like a 3 year old sight stickers all over it it was so cringeworthy - she is full capacity just very frail. I wouldn’t say they don’t care but the did constantly forget to charge her hearing aids, and on a few occasions forgot to give her medication and change her pad (‘nappy’).

Norush4 · 01/05/2022 19:53

I didn't miss anything I merely asked if you were filming and you said no. That is sufficient no need for your uppity teenage tone... "So and ummm"

saltinesandcoffeecups · 01/05/2022 19:50

Norush4 · 01/05/2022 16:56

So you was filming? Is this allowed?

Not filming no, but video was on when I dropped in. You missed the part where I asked and the facility encouraged it? So umm considering they said yes when asked and plugged it in because they were closed to visitors, yes allowed.

NellesVilla · 01/05/2022 19:49

I hope it goes well, seeing as you've been ignored already once on this thread - which pretty much sums up how carers are treated - ignored unless it's to be slagged off.

True

Norush4 · 01/05/2022 19:46

It's not just the carers at fault it's the relatives. I think it's an old school rule before my time.. night staff would dress residents half a sleep and then put them back in bed because day time staff cannot possibly wash and dress 8 people and take them to the main hall for breakfast and assist with feeding on top of. It's relatives who demand that their family member is dressed by a certain time. Perhaps the resident doesn't want to get dressed?

Maverickess · 01/05/2022 19:35

vodkaredbullgirl · 01/05/2022 19:11

Time for me to do a 12 hr night shift. To give my best to the residents we look after.

I hope it goes well, seeing as you've been ignored already once on this thread - which pretty much sums up how carers are treated - ignored unless it's to be slagged off.

I honestly cannot believe that with all the very public problems facing social care, the very real issues that people are facing, the absolute shit show that social care is, that this is being considered such a problem. It's a symptom of a much wider problem, and a minor one at that.

Everyone wants those delivering care to care, want their relatives treated well, want their carers to treat them like their own family - yet when they do they're accused of being abusive and patronising people.
I get the theory behind it, but a blanket ban and insisting that no one do it is in no way person centred - what about what the person being cared for wants? What if it makes them feel included, valued, that they mean something to someone other than just a job to do? Nope, you will have what someone else has decided is appropriate for your dignity to be respected and that is that!

MardyOldGoth · 01/05/2022 19:26

I worked in a care home around 20 years ago. We called an ambulance for a woman with breathing difficulties and paramedics were debating about whether she needed to be taken to hospital. In front of her, one said 'If she's going to cark it anyway, she's probably better staying here.' Couldn't believe what I was hearing!

I agree with a PP about carers though. There's an old saying about what you get if you pay peanuts. The entire system needs an overhaul - training, qualifications, pay and working conditions, the lot!

Adamsauntagain · 01/05/2022 19:19

Saying everything is terrible isn't bringing issues into the light - it's just saying everything is terrible. It's scaremongering. Of course there are issues, I just said that. Everybody knows that. That's why this thread started in the first place. Of course we need to know - there has been a fair bit in the news about that already, that's why most people don't want themselves or their relatives to be in care or nursing homes. But there is good care there too. Any decent book should discuss good practice alongside safeguarding concerns. A light should be shone on all of it.

ts all well and good you saying it “shouldn’t” be privatised but that’s not the reality is it? Particularly for homes with private owners of which there are many.

Yes, and it shouldn't be that way. There is nothing wrong with me saying it, it's not an unusual viewpoint - it was a response to the comments around structural issues.

JollyWilloughby · 01/05/2022 19:12

@Adamsauntagain

I didn’t say she was the only passionate person working in social care. Neither did I say it was a secret. Anyone can write a book about their experiences. It’s not exclusive, like I said she’s collaborating with many other home managers. No, you don’t need to be a manager to be passionate but working at that level (and on the ground) does give you a wide ranging level of expertise on current issues within care homes. There’s nothing arrogant about that. That’s just a fact.

it’s a shame you think it’s scare mongering. It’s attitudes like that that don’t really help bring these issues more into light. Keeping an eye on your relatives is obviously a very sensible thing to do. Unfortunately not everyone has that watchful eye.

its all well and good you saying it “shouldn’t” be privatised but that’s not the reality is it? Particularly for homes with private owners of which there are many.

vodkaredbullgirl · 01/05/2022 19:11

Time for me to do a 12 hr night shift. To give my best to the residents we look after.

roadsweep · 01/05/2022 19:04

Confusion101 · 01/05/2022 08:05

I wouldn't consider cute a disrespectful word. I have heard it used to describe people of all age groups and it's always been used positively?

My 86 year old grandfather would absolutely hate being referred to as cute. As a Coronel in the British army and high ranking officer for the Saudi national Guard, it would be an insult.

Babies are cute, not fully grown adults.

Adamsauntagain · 01/05/2022 19:01

The social care sector should not be privatised - it absolutely shouldn't.
Yes, huge structural issues.
That said, there are some good nursing homes with caring staff despite that and some companies are way better than others . @JollyWilloughby you are scare mongering - you and your mum's experiences are not the be all and end all. Your mum's not the only passionate person working in adult social care/nursing homes and that passion isn't exclusive to those in managerial or nursing positions. You are very proud of her and that is nice. but your knowledge isn't secret and you sound a little arrogant talking about people living in ignorance - we know, that's why people are so wary of their relatives needing to go into care and why it is so incredibly stressful and why people keep an almost constant eye out.

Norush4 · 01/05/2022 18:49

@Adamsauntagain thank you. I don't mind someone sharing their horror stories. However I find some people don't address the root cause why is staffing so poor? Why did nobody bother to turn up for their shift? Why is the company having to rely on agency and payout excess money?

Why isn't training pushed to higher levels for the residents complex needs? I don't rember having refresher training which is very odd because a lot of other health settings you do or it's available.

JollyWilloughby · 01/05/2022 18:47

@Norush4

Yes many nurses will not roll their sleeves up. My mum always did. Always worked on the ground too but she is retired now, and writing her book. She was so passionate.

There have been other home managers who have been able to give their opinion in certain chapters of the book too.

JollyWilloughby · 01/05/2022 18:44

It’s not necessarily a management issue, it can be an owner issue. There are wider, structural issues here at play. Some owners restrict the use of pads for example to save money, doesn’t matter how kind the home manager is, they will not be able to over ride that.

Even after informing CQC it is often all brushed under the carpet.

Norush4 · 01/05/2022 18:44

@JollyWilloughby absolutely where I worked was fabulous but I have heard horror stories like what you say you have experienced. It was a very wealthy Jewish care home. We had chefs and a team of house keepers... and we had laundry staff also. I thank my lucky stars we had the additional roles to help us although it was a huge place so it was needed. The actual carers were still thin on the ground. You get the odd couple of good nurses that will assist and help out but most will deliberately sit in the office and drag their medicine round all morning.

Adamsauntagain · 01/05/2022 18:40

I've been on this thread three times and then I delete my account because it's too aggravating and then I find myself back on here again because some things you just can't let go. Right @Norush4 I have looked after an elderly relative but his needs were too great for me to continue to do so and that is why they are in a nursing home. I have defended carers, nursing homes and calling people love on this thread (because Jesus, it doesn't matter and I also understand the theory around it) BUT there sometimes there are safeguarding issues in care and nursing homes and sometimes there are poor carers sometimes giving poor care and that's a fact that I'm sure you would acknowlege yourself. I entered into my relative needing a nursing home so stressed and terrified for them because I'd read about bad carers and care homes but the truth is there are some outstanding carers and nurses out there and some really caring nursing homes and care homes. There are also some average carers who are there for the money (the very underpaid for the job money) and do what they need to do and get out - they aren't abusive, they're just giving the bare minimum - clean, care, feed and leave but that is different from people who are abusive and neglectful. It seems if the norm and the culture of the place is to give good kind care and the people working there take a pride in doing that the potentially bad carers are the minority and they're monitored by their colleagues as much as anybody else.
I'm pleased that my relative is somewhere that thus far, has a caring ethos, where the majority of the carers and good and caring and some are outstandingly good at, what is a difficult job, emotionally and practically. There are some good, kind nurses and cleaners there too and the chefs are very good at giving people what they want to eat and trying to make allowances around medical needs versus dietary preferences. I keep a constant eye out - as much as I can - because I know things can change and places can go downhill but I really hope it doesn't. A lot of it is, as someone said above, to do with management too. It's a place with a nice heart and also, some fun but it goes through phases of being short staffed and that is very hard for the staff. The agency carers aren't well thought of - possibly because they get paid more for the same work (not their fault I know) and on one occasion I heard about, don't always turn up.
So, thank you good caring carers you are VERY highly thought of. Please read the comments on this thread that say this and similar and not the other ones. I really am deleting my account now and not coming back - because it's all a bit bad for my blood pressure, but just to say again, thank you.