Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are people in care homes constantly treated like this?

136 replies

Mooooooooooooo · 01/05/2022 07:57

If i were to whistleblow, I'd be doing it for every single care home.
Residents are constantly referred to as 'cute'. Why? They wouldn't be referred to in that way if they weren't elderly I bet.
Having their heads patted by carers.
Talk of 'favourites'.
We do have some absolutely lovely, endearing and sweet residents but still, they don't deserve to be patronised.
Talking about them in front of them thinking because they have dementia, they won't understand.
A nurse told me that a lady with dementia needs a wash because she 'stinks' even though she was right in front of me.
I know we have some residents who are very hard of hearing so you do have to shout, but sometimes there's a very bossy/rude tone from carers.
It's the case in many homes I've seen

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TravellingSpoon · 03/05/2022 09:24

Well this is a great motivator having come off a very tiring nightshift, my third in a row.

As with all jobs, you get some good and some not so good carers, but to tar everyone with the same brush is unfair.

Those of you who have a problem with terms of endearment, I wonder how you would balance it? You are asking people to be caring and to care for people as they would thier own family members (which is the no1 thing people say when looking around our home), but not too much in case its patronising. In the area I work in, its commonplace to call people 'duck', everyone says it. Our residents, the staff to each other etc. If thi is the worst thing that happens I cant get worked up over it.

As someone said upthread, no-one ever talks about carers unless its to bash us, yet they wouldnt do the job themselves.

JollyWilloughby · 02/05/2022 08:51

@Everydayisabadhairday

Agreed. People whistle blow all the time, it’s very common place.

Problem is the likelihood of anything actually being done is incredibly slim.

Maverickess · 02/05/2022 08:50

Everydayisabadhairday · 02/05/2022 08:36

You have a moral duty to those people to whistleblow each and every time you see something that's wrong. If you're seeing mistreatment and not reporting it then you're just as bad.

And that leads right back to the problem imo, that caring for elderly, disabled and vulnerable people is not valued.
Because when you whistleblow as a carer you are ignored because you are unskilled, uneducated and can't do any better.
I know, I've done it 3 times - the differences that it achieved? I chose to get out.

Everydayisabadhairday · 02/05/2022 08:44

Then that's what should be done.

JollyWilloughby · 02/05/2022 08:43

@Everydayisabadhairday

That is why people who feel that “moral duty” simply cannot work in care and have to leave the sector. OP sounds like one of these people, hence I would be suprised if she continues to work in the sector.

You would be whistle blowing on most homes.

Everydayisabadhairday · 02/05/2022 08:36

You have a moral duty to those people to whistleblow each and every time you see something that's wrong. If you're seeing mistreatment and not reporting it then you're just as bad.

JollyWilloughby · 02/05/2022 08:28

@Maverickess

Totally agree with everything you’ve just said.

Maverickess · 02/05/2022 07:58

I see camera's as a positive thing to be honest, they've backed me up on more than one occasion where something has happened and the automatic response has been that the carers did something wrong - and there's actual evidence that they didn't, that the event happened because of the symptoms of a person's illness, not because the staff can't be arsed, because of another residents behaviour that have needs above the resources provided, because of the fact that the members of staff on duty were all busy with other residents and so no, room 5 wasn't left for hours asking for the toilet, there weren't enough people to take them when they asked and they unfortunately, needed to wait, and unfortunately, carers cannot defy the laws of physics and be in two places at once. Or they were offered food, different choices, encouraged, assisted and they still chose not to eat because they didn't want to. That a carer sat with someone for 30 minutes trying to persuade them to take their medication and had it swiped out of their hands or thrown at them - and this was reported and recorded on multiple occasions, so it isn't a case of people left in pain because it's easier for the staff - while everyone else's medication is then delayed by that half an hour.

Let's face it, the phrase 'easier for the staff' is used very often, but if you really think about it it's more about what's realistically achievable with the resources present, and is actually 'it's cheaper for the provider'.
The standards can be the highest ever thought of, but they are absolutely meaningless if there's no investment in meeting them, without the resources they're not going to be met. And shouting at the carers isn't going to change that, it's been going on for decades and things are getting worse instead of better.
Of course there are good homes and good carers, as well as bad, but the bar is set by those at the top, not those at the bottom, if the bar is set at maximising profit then that's what will happen, despite the best efforts of the best carers in the world.

JollyWilloughby · 01/05/2022 22:43

The 15 hour shifts which are the norm in some homes are an absolute killer. 7am - 10pm. Emotionally draining work AND physically hard work.

15 hours and sometimes you’re so busy you work through your break.

Now I class myself as a kind and patient person but who…. who on this earth can provide a good standard of care when you’re in your 14th hour and you’re on your third consecutive 15 hour shift?

I mean maybe mother Theresa could manage it but the average person? Not a bloody chance. Modern day slave labour. I went in on a 22 hour contract but was begged to do overtime and nothing is ever enough.

Also, people just don’t want to do the job. It can be unpleasant dealing with a LOT of urine and feaces day in day out (and multiple times a day). Coupled with feeding and most people just want out, it’s incredibly strenuous on the back too.

ApplesAndChalk · 01/05/2022 22:38

LightningAndRainbows · 01/05/2022 08:18

Are these staff like this from the get go? If not what is it that happens that makes them like this?

I think it's a combination:

Low Pay and very low valued work.
Low staffing and poor supervision and training.
Complex high needs of service users, with no increase in staffing to account for this.
Compassion Fatigue, to a degree.

Thats not to say that all care homes or carers are awful, of course not.

XelaM · 01/05/2022 22:14

My grandma used to talk about my grandpa right in front of him claiming "He's hard of hearing anyway" 😄It used to make us laugh. She adored him

saltinesandcoffeecups · 01/05/2022 22:04

I’ll never be wrong about caring advocating for my loved one. What an odd thing to think, that it’s wrong. Fortunately she was in a place with great people who valued input and help from family members.

You have a peachy night too … hope you have someone more willing than yourself to advocate for you (despite what the carers think) when the time comes.

NellesVilla · 01/05/2022 21:46

@saltinesandcoffeecups ?????- I’m not getting wound up, sweets. Just admit you’re wrong and are speaking a load of shite. Don’t get yourself all upset now!
Goodnight, all!

saltinesandcoffeecups · 01/05/2022 21:41

@NellesVilla not twisting any words hun, in fact quote in directly. If you are getting wound up, that’s on you. Might I suggest some self reflection on your attitude towards family members, you might just find that family is part of the care team for the most important party in the equation.

NellesVilla · 01/05/2022 21:32

@saltinesandcoffeecups , you are an expert at twisting words, aren’t you? Be a love, and how about you piss off, or at least stop speaking out of your arse and winding up care staff?

You're like a dog with a bone- get a life, babes!

saltinesandcoffeecups · 01/05/2022 21:26

NellesVilla · 01/05/2022 20:45

Although quite honestly I don’t give a shit if staff want to be filmed or not. My concern was my mother’s care and not the staff’s feelings.

Geez, you’re a real peach, aren’t you, @saltinesandcoffeecups? I bet the care staff thought you were a right pita. We had a name for family members
like you when I worked in care, one which I won’t repeat here. Honestly, most good carers love caring for people, but even those with the patience of a saint, detest annoying or interfering family members, many of whom speak out their arses, do not know what they are talking about and just make the carers’ lives more difficult.

So you missed the part about me asking the staff about the Alexa and them encouraging it? Or the fact that I said they were great and provided great care? Why would care staff not want to be observed? It’s a big red flag if they object.

if it came down to your parent’s care or hurting the feelings of a staff member, would you sit back and not advocate for your parent? If you say yes, I’m going to call bullshit or weep for your parents.

but nice to know what you think of family members looking out for their loved ones. I would have gladly be annoying or interfere if I didn’t think she was getting the care she needed and deserved…It’s a little telling that you feel this way…

What is interfering to you? Is it when a Nurse signs someone up for hospice without ever seeing them, talking to the family, or talking to her doctors? Should I have not interfered and just let them not do any rehab with my mother? I should have just given up like this ‘carer’ did? Do piss off and maybe listen to the family of those in your care. You might just find out they know more about them than you do.

JollyWilloughby · 01/05/2022 21:11

@SquirrelG

Probably the same as reporting to authorities.

Nothing.

SquirrelG · 01/05/2022 21:01

YABU to say that all care homes are like this. If you have concerns then take them up with the appropriate authorities - what you do think having a rant of MN is going to achieve?

NellesVilla · 01/05/2022 20:45

Although quite honestly I don’t give a shit if staff want to be filmed or not. My concern was my mother’s care and not the staff’s feelings.

Geez, you’re a real peach, aren’t you, @saltinesandcoffeecups? I bet the care staff thought you were a right pita. We had a name for family members
like you when I worked in care, one which I won’t repeat here. Honestly, most good carers love caring for people, but even those with the patience of a saint, detest annoying or interfering family members, many of whom speak out their arses, do not know what they are talking about and just make the carers’ lives more difficult.

JollyWilloughby · 01/05/2022 20:39

@GregoryFluff

Not always in our LA

@Maverickess

Funny that. Totally what happens though.

@Shiningstarr

Agreed. Game face/chat is a real thing.

Shiningstarr · 01/05/2022 20:32

Ferngreen · 01/05/2022 08:00

Not like that in the care home I visit. Carers are kind and chatty with the residents.

Well of course it would seem like that to a visitor. They will be different when there is a visitor there.

Maverickess · 01/05/2022 20:25

JollyWilloughby · 01/05/2022 20:15

What happens when you whistle blow and nothing gets done? Myself and several colleagues whist blew on one particular home and….. nothing happened.

Yup, been there, and because I went through the proper channels (management then providers then CQC) I was suddenly underperforming and managed out.
Funny that.

Gagaandgag · 01/05/2022 20:17

TheVolturi · 01/05/2022 16:02

I've worked in loads of care homes and I've got to say it put the fear into me. I'd rather die alone than go into a care home I really would. The majority treat the residents like nothing, wheeling them about, getting them up because its time to get up, shoving them to bed because it's time for bed, usually against the clock because there are so many more residents to do the same with and so few staff. Aside from the fact that practically anyone can get a job as a care assistant, which is scary because in my opinion you have to be a certain sort of person to do the job well. The whole of the elderly care system needs to be taken over by NHS, pay rises, more thorough recruitment, and better standard of care across the board.

Sad to say that, even though I only worked in two homes personally I agree with this from my experience.

I once got into trouble with a manager when I tried to brush a residents hair. An older carer who had been there for many years told the manager I wasn’t ‘pulling my weight’ - what!? giving the poor old resident 5 min of self care? The rest of the time I was running around crazy multi tasking? It was an obscene allegation and really opened my eyes to how some homes work.

She actually grabbed the brush out of my hand and shouted “get to bed!” to the resident. I was the one who got in trouble?!

I think that unfortunately wherever there are vulnerable people there will always be people who sadly take advantage for various reasons.

Also the PP who spoke of the Mary poppins effect - yes very true of the homes I was in! All smiles and total respect when relatives were around - everyone was suddenly best friends and rushing to buzzers.

However, I have met some genuinely caring and respectful carers also. Of course there will be homes who are doing ‘better’ I don’t think OP is denying this.
But after my experience I agree with PP who had the Alexa video installed - if you can afford to do this as a relative/ any other video capacity - I would!

GregoryFluff · 01/05/2022 20:17

JollyWilloughby · 01/05/2022 18:44

It’s not necessarily a management issue, it can be an owner issue. There are wider, structural issues here at play. Some owners restrict the use of pads for example to save money, doesn’t matter how kind the home manager is, they will not be able to over ride that.

Even after informing CQC it is often all brushed under the carpet.

Pads are not provided by the care home, patient is assessed and allocated and provided via continence services

JollyWilloughby · 01/05/2022 20:15

What happens when you whistle blow and nothing gets done? Myself and several colleagues whist blew on one particular home and….. nothing happened.