Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL names her cat after our son

261 replies

JKT007 · 01/05/2022 02:05

Am I being unreasonable thinking it's very odd that my MIL named her kitten the same name as our son, her grandson?

OP posts:
Hepzibar · 02/05/2022 20:29

LimoncelloMadness · 02/05/2022 20:11

Baffled by all the many posts trying to justify this and pretend it's reasonable. Let's face it, it's really fucking weird!

Agree.
Utterly bizarre to name an animal after your only grandchild, or any grandchild.
What on earth is she thinking.

Rosiebean17 · 02/05/2022 20:26

My ex MIL named her new kitten the same name as a dog we'd owned. Thing was, the dog had to be rehomed and we were devastated and less than a month later she called said kitten the same name.
Same MIL used to also call up and cry if ex DH said we had plans together too at the time of said plans. She still sends me odd text messages several years since divorce which is another story 😆
That said, it gives me my creepy ex MIL vibes so for that reason I've voted as not unreasonable.

ddl1 · 02/05/2022 20:23

It somewhat depends on the name. If it's a common name (Sam, Jack, Oliver) or one with some association with cats (Felix) it might be coincidence. In any case, I wouldn't worry; if she's a cat-lover this might be a compliment.

Rottweilermummy · 02/05/2022 20:23

Yanbu
Mils have weird habits to test us sometimes , I do have good relationship with mine BTW,
I thought this might make you feel a bit better, my new DH , bought a puppy when we were first dating and wanted to call it same name as me!! Needless to say I chose a better name lol

SuzyQ12 · 02/05/2022 20:22

I'd take this as a compliment, if anything. Wouldn't bother me at all.

Diverseopinions · 02/05/2022 20:20

YorkshireRog It doesn't harm the child, for sure, so no big deal, but it is weird that all the associations connected with the name of her dear grandson can be invested in a cat.

Usually, we like to have one name only among our children....the first name ( not so much middle name ) is special and becomes imbued with a sense of their special personality. How could someone think to do this....

If nothing else, it's a fascinating conundrum for amateur psychologists. ...what can it be all about? What is she thinking of? My sister called her cat by the name of my cat, and I thought that that was odd and unimaginative, but this is something else, and I can't believe a real psychologist wouldn't find it fascinating.

But the best thing about this is nothing to do with the oddness, but rather OP's kind and wonderful response that her MIL is much loved and she would never embarrass her. What a thoughtful, generous lady.

a1poshpaws · 02/05/2022 20:15

I think it's a high compliment. But then I rate cats far more highly than kids.

Seriously, I've had dogs, horses, pigs, chickens, sheep and cats with human names all my life - think Jack, Jane; Becky; Rosie; Bess; Jed; Harry; Elsie and so on. And my own name is apparently a very popular one amongst Golden Retrievers.

Don't sweat the small things.

LimoncelloMadness · 02/05/2022 20:11

Baffled by all the many posts trying to justify this and pretend it's reasonable. Let's face it, it's really fucking weird!

edenhills · 02/05/2022 20:10

My mum did this! She gave her new cat my name shortly after I had my first child. It was all very odd. She made a big deal about it like she wanted me to make a fuss but I just ignored it. The cat sadly died after about a year which is something your mil might want to think about as my mum felt even sadder burying a cat with her child's name.

CleansUpButWouldPreferNotTo · 02/05/2022 20:01

That is a bit weird - I'd give DS a nickname, and see if the kitten acquires the same nickname - if it does, then call MIL out about it.

Mothership4two · 02/05/2022 19:57

Voted YANBU but it is kind of funny

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 02/05/2022 19:56

How does your son, Tiddles, think of the situation?

Pugdogmom · 02/05/2022 19:50

Personally I think it's funny 😄. Saying that, I met a lady who got really upset with me as I have a dog with the same name as her husband. I had the dog before I met her.😅

Missingpop · 02/05/2022 19:48

I’m sorry but this has made me laugh.
Maybe she’s done it so shes doesn’t forget his name; she might have realised she’s getting forgetful & this is her way of hiding it from the family; especially if she’s a proud woman, admitting your forgetting names; places; dob; is very frightening for some people; don’t judge her to harshly ask her gently to find out what’s going on, then help her if she needs it she will appreciate your understanding so much & if your son questions why has Nannie named her kitten the same as him, just say because your both so cute & gorgeous x

Prestel · 02/05/2022 19:48

Wow! Opinions are really split on this.

I voted YANBU. My DD became good friends with a girl who had the same name as our cat and contrary to all those above who insist it's not a problem, it did cause confusion on occasion, which you just put up with or have a laugh about when it's a coincidence but it's really quite odd and annoying for your MiL to do it on purpose, imo.

whynotwhatknot · 02/05/2022 19:37

Yeah its odd her only grandchild and she decides the name of her cat will be the same

is it indiana

Newbie20 · 02/05/2022 19:34

@JKT007 I think it is a little odd but it is just a name. Could you ask her how she came about choosing the name or something like that? Maybe she didn't think about it when picking a name or maybe she just really likes the name. Maybe she has always liked the name and told herself that she would use it when she got a pet but your son was born and named the same name before she ended up getting the pet but she still wanted to use it. Maybe it was the name that fitted the cat or the only name that the cat actually responded to. It could end up being quite a sweet sentiment especially if your MIL is very close to your son as he and the pet will probably form a lovely bond together. As long as she doesn't start trying to call your son a different name then just try to roll with it if you can. But without asking her about the name you will never know the reasoning behind it. As long as you have a decent relationship with her then asking shouldn't cause any problems

Phphion · 02/05/2022 19:32

My dad named both one of his sons and one of his dogs after himself.

He would never describe himself as imaginative.

Definitelyrandom · 02/05/2022 19:31

I named my elder son after a gerbil. TBF it was actually a family name as well.

100problems · 02/05/2022 19:24

If I had a dachshund I would name her Daphne. I have an auntie called Daphne.

Look on the bright side, she bought a cute pet and named it the same as her cute grandson.

Would've been a lot worse if she'd got, say a tarantula, and called it your name.

I will drink gin at inappropriate times from china tea cups when I am old. And encourage Daphne to look angelic but nip those I disdain.

HarrietSchulenberg · 02/05/2022 19:20

It is a bit weird but I named DS2 after my grandad, who happened to have the same name as my childhood cat. Grandad's name was always shortened but cat and DS2 always use the long version.
MIL took in a stray just after DS1 was born and named it the same as DS1.
I guess none of my family are too thoughtful about names!

RhymesWithBouquet · 02/05/2022 19:14

Pretty please, get a female dog, preferably a really derpy looking Boxer, and name it after MIL 😈

Sarbears28 · 02/05/2022 19:13

One of my DC has the same name as FIL's dog. It doesnt bother us and our DC loves sharing their name with 'granda's dog'.

LondonQueen · 02/05/2022 19:11

RobertaFirmino · 01/05/2022 02:11

Maybe she'd been looking for a kitten for yonks and had his name already picked out. Then you come along and not only steal her son from her but also her KITTEN NAME! MIL took to AIBU, what with it being such a supportive, encouraging community and was advised that nobody owns a name.

Haha I can imagine this, evil DIL has stolen my son and kitten name!

OuchitHurtstoomuch · 02/05/2022 19:10

I named one of my kids after my aunties cat and one of my other kids is named after the neighbours dog.