Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that Jude's ice cream have gone mostly vegan and are no longer gluten free?

566 replies

successstories · 30/04/2022 23:35

Royally pissed off. And shouldn't labelling be better regulated to ensure only products made with real milk and cream (aka dairy) are called 'ice cream'? Oat paste should be marketed as something else.

Being the '1st carbon negative ice cream company' will not make any difference if the product is no good or cannot be eaten due to allergens🙄

Who's advising these companies?

OP posts:
OhLordyWhatNow · 02/05/2022 13:00

Yes, it was a hypothetical question. It's always about profit.

WeCouldBeSpearows · 02/05/2022 12:57

I'd happily see a smaller range of non GF foods to make way for more GF and vegan options but retailers don't appear keen, the question is why?

Because they know what the demand for GF, non-GF and vegan food is, and stock their shelves accordingly. They want to maximise the profits they can make using the space they have available.

OhLordyWhatNow · 02/05/2022 12:47

@LadyMonicaBaddingham

"OhLordyWhatNow
*Oh and coeliacs disease is not an allergy."
No, but it's a serious medical condition nonetheless.

Unlike veganism, which for the overwhelming majority of vegans is a CHOICE*

Not quite sure why you're having a pop at me. I'm well aware that Coeliacs is an autoimmune condition and all its consequences.

I'm concerned about the diminishing supply of GF options to make way for vegan options on the shelves. I don't believe this is the fault of vegans, it's the fault of the retailers and in this case kiosk and coffee shop owners.

There is room for both GF and vegan and more should be done to accommodate this rather than what is currently happening.

I'd happily see a smaller range of non GF foods to make way for more GF and vegan options but retailers don't appear keen, the question is why?

Innocenta · 02/05/2022 11:48

@NewPapaGuinea But the reality is that language does change. You don't have to like that! But it's a property of English. If I was offering ice cream, at my place, to an omni guest, I might qualify it by saying 'vegan' if I didn't know their dietary needs already. To ensure they knew it wouldn't be 'typical' dairy ice cream. Most of my omni friends eat plant based a lot, though, and I wouldn't necessarily mention it. Maybe, maybe not. I do normally ask about any changes to dietary needs if we are feeding anyone, so new restrictions would come up at that point.

In my own family where three of us only eat vegan ice cream, I don't call it 'vegan ice cream' because the qualification is redundant. Why would I say 'vegan ice cream' to my partner, when she's also vegan? I just say 'ice cream'. We both know it's vegan.

When we first started finding vegan ice cream products, we focused more on being excited at their veganness. Now it's become more normal and we are more likely to just refer to 'ice cream' in day to day life. Over time, more vegans will likely feel similarly and will just say 'ice cream' (meaning vegan ice cream with no dairy).

That's how language usage works.

Innocenta · 02/05/2022 11:42

@LadyMonicaBaddingham It isn't an either/or. There's no need to create some weird competition. Vegans can have as many, and as serious, medical dietary needs as people with coeliac disease. The goal should be to accommodate everyone while causing the least harm.

Innocenta · 02/05/2022 11:40

@Dinoclaw I'm not trying to deflect from giving suggestions of food. It's a lot of work to go over someone's full diet and all their needs with them, so I'm not planning to do it with someone who has explicitly said they have no intention of even trying to eat plant based. How is that a deflection? I've been 100% open about it.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 02/05/2022 11:35

OhLordyWhatNow · 01/05/2022 01:53

Oh and coeliacs disease is not an allergy.

No, but it's a serious medical condition nonetheless.

Unlike veganism, which for the overwhelming majority of vegans is a CHOICE

Dinoclaw · 02/05/2022 11:32

Innocenta · 02/05/2022 11:23

@Dinoclaw I don't have 'multiple intolerances', lol. I have life threatening allergies. I've gone into anaphylaxis; I carry epipens. I have serious gastrointestinal conditions that I'm under multiple tertiary care consultants for. Multiple hospitalisations, etc.

Your assumption that anyone who does manage to be vegan just has some minor intolerances is... very, very wrong.

I didn't make that assumption, I have intolerances and was talking about myself and didn't mention allergies. I also said previously I have a lot of respect for people who are vegan despite already having limited diets, so not sure why you're being defensive and quite frankly an ass about it. Seems you're one of those who give vegans a bad name by being preachy. Of course probably to deflect from actually giving any suggestions of foods!

NewPapaGuinea · 02/05/2022 11:28

Innocenta · 02/05/2022 11:25

Beanburger.

Falafel burger.

Chickpea burger.

Lentil burger.

Tofu burger.

Nut burger.

Seitan burger.

Etc. (Before random people start complaining that they couldn't eat these - I can't eat most of them anymore either. thanks, body!)

So not just “burger” then. When I said you can’t call dairy free ice cream “ice cream” and you need to qualify it with “dairy free” (or similar) you argued against it and said language changes.

NewPapaGuinea · 02/05/2022 11:27

WeCouldBeSpearows · 02/05/2022 11:20

Have you seen any vegan ice cream that hasn't had, in obvious writing on the front, the words 'vegan' or 'non-dairy' or 'plant-based' or similar, to make it clear?

Because I haven't.

That’s exactly my point. You can’t juat label vegan/dairy free ice cream as just ice cream without the qualifying words. A previous poster was arguing against this.

Innocenta · 02/05/2022 11:25

NewPapaGuinea · 02/05/2022 11:18

How did you know it was a vegan burger?

Beanburger.

Falafel burger.

Chickpea burger.

Lentil burger.

Tofu burger.

Nut burger.

Seitan burger.

Etc. (Before random people start complaining that they couldn't eat these - I can't eat most of them anymore either. thanks, body!)

Innocenta · 02/05/2022 11:23

@Dinoclaw I don't have 'multiple intolerances', lol. I have life threatening allergies. I've gone into anaphylaxis; I carry epipens. I have serious gastrointestinal conditions that I'm under multiple tertiary care consultants for. Multiple hospitalisations, etc.

Your assumption that anyone who does manage to be vegan just has some minor intolerances is... very, very wrong.

WeCouldBeSpearows · 02/05/2022 11:20

NewPapaGuinea · 02/05/2022 11:14

Would you be happy to eat a “burger” that was actually a vegan burger but not named as such?

When you have an ice cream, the expectation is it’s dairy. Blurring the lines helps no one.

Have you seen any vegan ice cream that hasn't had, in obvious writing on the front, the words 'vegan' or 'non-dairy' or 'plant-based' or similar, to make it clear?

Because I haven't.

Dinoclaw · 02/05/2022 11:19

Innocenta · 02/05/2022 11:15

@Dinoclaw If you actually had any interest in plant-based eating I'd happily try to help you figure it out, but since you've clearly decided you're not interested, I'm not sure why you're asking! As with anyone who has restrictions, it would depend on what your problems are, why, what you can tolerate, and umpteen other factors.

I have looked into it extensively, and unless I substituted real food with multivitamins and forced calories in through meal substitutes I wouldn't be able to have a balanced diet. Im not saying people can't with multiple intolerances and much respect for them- but seen as though the main foods are out of bounds then not sure what these mysterious foods are. I don't eat any dairy.

NewPapaGuinea · 02/05/2022 11:18

How did you know it was a vegan burger?

Innocenta · 02/05/2022 11:17

NewPapaGuinea · 02/05/2022 11:14

Would you be happy to eat a “burger” that was actually a vegan burger but not named as such?

When you have an ice cream, the expectation is it’s dairy. Blurring the lines helps no one.

...yes. I've eaten loads of burgers not labelled as 'vegan burgers', going back to literally the age of about five.

Innocenta · 02/05/2022 11:15

@Dinoclaw If you actually had any interest in plant-based eating I'd happily try to help you figure it out, but since you've clearly decided you're not interested, I'm not sure why you're asking! As with anyone who has restrictions, it would depend on what your problems are, why, what you can tolerate, and umpteen other factors.

NewPapaGuinea · 02/05/2022 11:14

Would you be happy to eat a “burger” that was actually a vegan burger but not named as such?

When you have an ice cream, the expectation is it’s dairy. Blurring the lines helps no one.

WeCouldBeSpearows · 02/05/2022 11:12

I'm sure most vegans don't appreciate the forced combination either

They probably like it even less than you do.

I would much rather have vegan alternative to ice cream than a gluten-free alternative to the cone. Vegan ice cream is generally very good (although I haven't tried a vegan Cornetto).

I do feel for people with coeliac disease, as gluten free versions of most things that ordinarily contain gluten are often adequate at best, and are so much more expensive. And grabbing a quick sandwich for lunch must be difficult - I've certainly not seen them, but there are usually at least two vegan options.

Dinoclaw · 02/05/2022 11:11

Innocenta · 02/05/2022 11:06

@Dinoclaw and @PinkSparklyPussyCat Frankly I think it's a bit of a defeatist and avoidant attitude. Both of you have only mentioned a small number of vegan foods, and there are many, many others. I am speaking as someone who is vegan while dealing with multiple serious gastrointestinal conditions and allergies myself, so by no means an ignorant healthy person. I know that people with medical restrictions can be vegan.

I'm sure many do, yes. Personally I don't care if its selfish I don't want to live off of a very very restricted diet (more so than it is already) or be shitting through the eye of the storm every 5 minutes and in agony. I am intrigued though, I can't tolerate any pulses, a fair amount of grains, a range of fruit and veg or soya- my diet really is basically bland, boring and basic. What wonderful foods should I be having that will provide me with sufficient calories and nutrition?

Innocenta · 02/05/2022 11:10

NewPapaGuinea · 02/05/2022 10:55

As for vegan ice cream being called ice cream - are you also annoyed at the lack of mince in mince pies, or the lack of butter in peanut butter? It's a clear name and everyone instantly has a decent idea of what they're getting

If you could get mince pies with mince and peanut butter with butter then I get your point. However, you can’t so the analogy doesn’t work. Ice cream without a typical ingredient isn’t ice cream. Should be named Dairy-free ice cream or similar.

...But it is ice cream. The meanings of words change and expand with time: that's how the English language works, and always has worked.

Innocenta · 02/05/2022 11:06

@Dinoclaw and @PinkSparklyPussyCat Frankly I think it's a bit of a defeatist and avoidant attitude. Both of you have only mentioned a small number of vegan foods, and there are many, many others. I am speaking as someone who is vegan while dealing with multiple serious gastrointestinal conditions and allergies myself, so by no means an ignorant healthy person. I know that people with medical restrictions can be vegan.

NewPapaGuinea · 02/05/2022 10:55

As for vegan ice cream being called ice cream - are you also annoyed at the lack of mince in mince pies, or the lack of butter in peanut butter? It's a clear name and everyone instantly has a decent idea of what they're getting

If you could get mince pies with mince and peanut butter with butter then I get your point. However, you can’t so the analogy doesn’t work. Ice cream without a typical ingredient isn’t ice cream. Should be named Dairy-free ice cream or similar.

SunaksNutsack · 02/05/2022 10:48

I make my own ice cream at home and it doesn’t contain any gluten unless it’s got cookie dough or similar gluten containing ingredients added to it. Thinking therefore it might be a commercial issue?

Does the maker have to pay extra for certified gluten free ingredients, then to get the gluten levels checked in the finished products? Then the cost might be prohibitive if there are not enough customers still willing to pay a premium. I hoped that the increased GF options that arose when GF was fashionable would stick around for people who really need them, but it sounds as though that isn’t the case.

The company have probably found that the vegan range sells well but they need a reasonable selection of vegan flavors to keep customers interested in the products. And they can’t be specialists in everything so have chosen to change their focus.

I would look for other options or consider getting an ice cream maker. I got mine from John Lewis. An investment but the ice cream you can make with it is sublime and not expensive.

Dinoclaw · 02/05/2022 10:42

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 02/05/2022 10:38

Good for them, I don't want to feel permanently ill. I would imagine no beans, lentils, chickpeas, limited veg and hardly any fruit would make a vegan diet a bit tricky. As I said I'm not prepared to make myself ill while I try and find out what I can and can't eat.

As well as thatI'm not giving up proper ice cream and cheese for anyone!

I am the same, I would like to be vegan for ethical reasons but my digestive issues mean lots of the staples like pulses, veg, and most fruits would absolutely destroy me! Like you I just try and make better choices about where I buy stuff, I know it doesn't mitigate everything but I do think everyone doing what they can/want to is probably more impactful overall than everyone aiming to give up everything as most then wouldn't bother trying.