Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that Jude's ice cream have gone mostly vegan and are no longer gluten free?

566 replies

successstories · 30/04/2022 23:35

Royally pissed off. And shouldn't labelling be better regulated to ensure only products made with real milk and cream (aka dairy) are called 'ice cream'? Oat paste should be marketed as something else.

Being the '1st carbon negative ice cream company' will not make any difference if the product is no good or cannot be eaten due to allergens🙄

Who's advising these companies?

OP posts:
SoupDragon · 01/05/2022 11:17

PoseyFlump · 01/05/2022 11:12

So hoping that customers will not realise then, nice

With respect @successstories ALL food is vegan, you just also choose to eat non vegan food too. It's not a dirty word.

If ALL food is vegan how can you choose to eat non vegan food?

Of course all food is not vegan.

I don't want to eat fake dairy and I want it to be obvious what a product is. I wouldn't expect ice cream to not contain milk unless it was clearly labelled dairy free.

PoseyFlump · 01/05/2022 11:16

You don't have to call yourself a vegan to eat a carrot.

PoseyFlump · 01/05/2022 11:12

So hoping that customers will not realise then, nice

With respect @successstories ALL food is vegan, you just also choose to eat non vegan food too. It's not a dirty word.

NoSquirrels · 01/05/2022 11:12

And, whether you like it or not, this is the effect that these views have had on this particular company.

Their statements are all to do with reacting to climate change. Using more plant-based ingredients are part of their commitment to cut their carbon emissions - due to the climate emergency - and as cows/dairy are the biggest factor for them they’re exploring reducing their reliance on this as part of their sustainable business model.

It’s not some fad to please vegans.
The vegan products are in fact really a (happily marketable) by-product of their Climate Emergency work.

It’s shit for coeliacs. You have my sympathy there.

It’s shit they haven’t communicated their changes and they really should and you should really point that out to them.

But saying their company commitment to reduce impact on worldwide global warming is “a fad” or “a trend” or “a stupid decision” is pretty shit too, imo.

truhamboys · 01/05/2022 11:07

successstories · 01/05/2022 11:00

It's like omnivores stopped reading the moment they read the word vegan. I imagine this is why Jude's have changed their packaging

So hoping that customers will not realise then, nice

No, that's not the case. The information is still there and on the front of the packet - it's just that the customer goes "chocolate brownie ice cream, that sounds nice, oh it's vegan but I'll still have it" instead of "oh it's vegan... <stops reading>"

truhamboys · 01/05/2022 11:05

successstories · 01/05/2022 10:58

It's too much and too expensive for small businesses

They seemed to manage ok in the past

I'm not sure if the regulations changed and got tighter before I was in the industry, but certainly allergies are now taken more seriously and so businesses are less willing to take the risk.

No one wants to end up in a situation like Pret A Manger with Natasha Ednan-Laperouse (they had followed the law as it then stood, but had a shit storm of bad publicity) or worse Byron Burger and Owen Carey. Better to write "may contain" every allergen that ever enters your premises and lose a few sales than to inadvertently harm someone and be completely put through the ringer by the press and authorities as a result.

successstories · 01/05/2022 11:00

It's like omnivores stopped reading the moment they read the word vegan. I imagine this is why Jude's have changed their packaging

So hoping that customers will not realise then, nice

OP posts:
successstories · 01/05/2022 10:58

It's too much and too expensive for small businesses

They seemed to manage ok in the past

OP posts:
truhamboys · 01/05/2022 10:58

successstories · 01/05/2022 10:53

Can't say I've ever picked up the vegan version of something by mistake, they are usually clearly labelled

In the case of Jude's, you can only tell by a tiny green circle they've added saying it's plant based. The rest of the packaging has remained the same. It's very easy to get confused I would say

I once did some market research and found that "bread (vegan)" vastly outsold "vegan bread". It was the exact same product, just the ordering of the words changed.

It's like omnivores stopped reading the moment they read the word vegan. I imagine this is why Jude's have changed their packaging.

If you are reading the packaging closely enough to check for allergens then I'm sure you'll spot the word vegan during that process.

successstories · 01/05/2022 10:56

This is such a blatant attempt to be goady

I don't mean to be goady. I'm just trying to point out the real impact that these trends (or philosophies, by well meaning individuals in many cases) can have in people's lives. There are tangible downsides too which some fail to see

OP posts:
Innocenta · 01/05/2022 10:54

sickofthisnonsense · 01/05/2022 10:41

Vegan is everywhere. What it means is that it's harder to find gluten and dairy free foods that used to be widely available.
Most vegan foods isn't actually safe for dairy allergies- read the label they all say 'may contain'.

@sickofthisnonsense They don't all say 'May contain'. That's just totally inaccurate.

successstories · 01/05/2022 10:53

Can't say I've ever picked up the vegan version of something by mistake, they are usually clearly labelled

In the case of Jude's, you can only tell by a tiny green circle they've added saying it's plant based. The rest of the packaging has remained the same. It's very easy to get confused I would say

OP posts:
Innocenta · 01/05/2022 10:52

successstories · 01/05/2022 10:45

It's not a religion in the sense that no deity is involved, but if it helps you to understand how ethics vegans think and feel, that is probably the best comparison to use

Well, with due respect, I would not subscribe to a religion or ethical belief that results in dogs having treats available when out and about but human coeliacs going without. It doesn't sit right with me. And, whether you like it or not, this is the effect that these views have had on this particular company.

This is such a blatant attempt to be goady that I don't know how you expect any vegan to respond. You are not the only person with medical needs.

successstories · 01/05/2022 10:45

It's not a religion in the sense that no deity is involved, but if it helps you to understand how ethics vegans think and feel, that is probably the best comparison to use

Well, with due respect, I would not subscribe to a religion or ethical belief that results in dogs having treats available when out and about but human coeliacs going without. It doesn't sit right with me. And, whether you like it or not, this is the effect that these views have had on this particular company.

OP posts:
Knifer · 01/05/2022 10:41

PoseyFlump · 01/05/2022 10:36

@Knifer I know people who claim they can't eat gluten when that was a 'trend' but I wouldn't dream of being so rude to them.

Meat and dairy do make vegans ill when their bodies haven't had it for so long. Personally I think everybody would be healthier for giving up meat and dairy in the same way as alcohol and white sugar. It's a major cause of inflammation in the body so it's funny that it is being dismissed on medical grounds when it can solve many problems people aren't even aware of until they give it up, dairy in particular.

Ah, see, I would indeed dream of calling them out on it. Choices and necessity are not in the same camp. When I have been out with people who made a song and dance about needing gluten free or vegan food in a restaurant but then went and got a cheeseburger from McDonald's or a kebab from a van "as a treat" I absolutely have called them out on it. On the basis that you can't dress up a choice like a medical need (GF) and you can't be so principled and so offended that others still eat animal products only when you feel like it (Ve).

I have no problem with vegan foods, I have to eat a lot of them so that my medical conditions aren't exacerbated. I have a problem with foods that meet a medical need being replaced by foods that cater to a choice. There's a market for both.

truhamboys · 01/05/2022 10:41

I wonder how many people know all the hoops you have to jump through to call something gluten free. It goes substantially beyond just not containing gluten - we're talking lab analysis and regular swabbing of surfaces. It's too much and too expensive for small businesses (though I strongly suspect many cafés and suchlike aren't sticking to the testing required).

The allowable level of cross contamination is 20ppm which is equivalent to a pin prick on a sheet of A5 paper. There's hell to pay if you get it wrong. Unless you're specifically targeting the gluten-free market, or are a huge business and the costs are relatively insignificant, I totally get why businesses label things as may contain gluten (or nuts, or milk) just to cover their arses.

sickofthisnonsense · 01/05/2022 10:41

Vegan is everywhere. What it means is that it's harder to find gluten and dairy free foods that used to be widely available.
Most vegan foods isn't actually safe for dairy allergies- read the label they all say 'may contain'.

PoseyFlump · 01/05/2022 10:36

@Knifer I know people who claim they can't eat gluten when that was a 'trend' but I wouldn't dream of being so rude to them.

Meat and dairy do make vegans ill when their bodies haven't had it for so long. Personally I think everybody would be healthier for giving up meat and dairy in the same way as alcohol and white sugar. It's a major cause of inflammation in the body so it's funny that it is being dismissed on medical grounds when it can solve many problems people aren't even aware of until they give it up, dairy in particular.

Knifer · 01/05/2022 10:36

Innocenta · 01/05/2022 10:30

@Knifer You don't have some kind of exclusive rights to medical dietary issues.

I am 100% sure I covered that in my first sentence by clarifying the difference between choice and dietary need.

But please, continue in the exhausting vegan stereotype. I'm sure you're not confirming any biases here.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 01/05/2022 10:33

NoSquirrels · 01/05/2022 09:19

I wasn’t referring to their focus groups.

It is not a stupid decision on the part of any company to react to the Climate Emergency.

This is entirely separate to the issue of whether they should continue to make gluten-free products.

If they can’t continue to be gluten-free, because of the changes to their manufacturing required to react to the climate emergency, they should be upfront in explaining this to their customers.

It is a stupid decision because it increases the demand for non vegan ice cream because the Celiacs don't have the ability to choose the vegan ones anymore. And it discriminates against Celiacs who aren't able to have dairy ice cream either.

By the way, their vegan ice cream is still on the Tesco website being sold as gluten free. That'll be fun when somebody finds out they've just been glutened. Much like the M&S gluten free bread that wasn't a couple of months ago.

LittleMissMoggy · 01/05/2022 10:33

Argh apologies for the typos

LittleMissMoggy · 01/05/2022 10:32

I appreciate that removing things like gluten free options is very frustrating for those with medical needs. As a vegetarian I get frustrated when gelatin is added to products making them unsuitable for me.

However.... The criticism if using words like milk and burgers for vegan she vegetarian foods does make my eyes roll...🙄I've never accidently bought the wrong product. It wouldn't harm people to actually make what they are putting into their bodies by looking at the packaging properly.

Innocenta · 01/05/2022 10:30

@Knifer You don't have some kind of exclusive rights to medical dietary issues.

Innocenta · 01/05/2022 10:29

@Knifer lol, as I've said like five times in the thread, vegans are not magically without medical issues. I myself have three serious GI medical diagnoses which affect my diet; two allergy related 'umbrella' conditions which cause a lot of complex symptoms and are very difficult and stressful to manage; and multiple 'normal' allergies too. I am prescribed epipens to carry at all times. I am also in longterm recovery from past anorexia nervosa.

But oh no. Everything about my food is so easy.

1940s · 01/05/2022 10:27

There's more egg and milk allergies than gluten so more people are winning with the trend shifting.