Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that Jude's ice cream have gone mostly vegan and are no longer gluten free?

566 replies

successstories · 30/04/2022 23:35

Royally pissed off. And shouldn't labelling be better regulated to ensure only products made with real milk and cream (aka dairy) are called 'ice cream'? Oat paste should be marketed as something else.

Being the '1st carbon negative ice cream company' will not make any difference if the product is no good or cannot be eaten due to allergens🙄

Who's advising these companies?

OP posts:
PoseyFlump · 01/05/2022 19:17

@beautifulworldwhereareyou I think the majority of people see it the way you do.

Lily452 · 01/05/2022 19:16

Innocenta · 01/05/2022 07:41

@Lily452 You should keep looking! Increasingly there are vegan products made in fully vegan factories which would be safe.

I’ll have to take your word for it because I have not encountered a single “vegan” product that did not also list cross contact for milk or eggs. Perhaps there are some out there but this ice cream isn’t one of them, apparently.

successstories · 01/05/2022 19:14

If we can get to the stage where we can cater to medical issues, food tastes good and is nutritious, whilst minimising our hurt to animals and the planet, why would that not be a good thing?

We are not there yet, and the jury is out on whether this will ever be achieved. Why start withdrawing options and foods now as if human lives didn't matter?

FWIW, your ideal most likely involves pumping some man-made concoctions full of artificially produced supplements. Many people due to various reasons cannot absorb them properly, what's your solution then? Let those people starve as animals are obviously more important?

OP posts:
beautifulworldwhereareyou · 01/05/2022 19:13

successstories · 01/05/2022 19:02

Also, just to clarify - is the deal that it now says it’s made in a factory which also handles gluten? because I would eat that, and so would my mum who is also coeliac and hasn’t eaten gluten in 25 years

I'm not a medical professional, but the consensus is that only if it's labelled as 'gluten free' or within the list held by Coeliac UK you can be sure that it's safe to eat

Usually they add a disclaimer saying that it's been made in a factory that also handles gluten because they cannot guarantee that it hasn't been cross contaminated

Fair enough, I guess it’s one of those things where realistically the risk of cross contamination is very low so probably not worth getting angry over. If it actively contained wheat I’d get it. But again, maybe I’m just being blasé about it - although I literally check everything and never eat anything I’m not sure of, I just personally think in this situation odds are it’s ok

PoseyFlump · 01/05/2022 19:13

Yes, this is utter madness

I wouldn't expect you to understand why someone would prioritise the planet and animals over your ice cream emotional breakdown.

LoveInSlowMotion · 01/05/2022 19:12

successstories · 01/05/2022 19:05

I imagine it would shock some posters on here when I say that I'd still eat vegan even if it was detrimental to my own health

Yes, this is utter madness

I don’t think it’s madness. To me, eating animal products is madness. Morally, I have no right to end an animals life because physically I am capable.

If my partner was told he could be healthier by eating dog meat, he wouldn’t do it. I doubt many people would. To me, cows, pigs, chicken, they’re no different.

successstories · 01/05/2022 19:05

I imagine it would shock some posters on here when I say that I'd still eat vegan even if it was detrimental to my own health

Yes, this is utter madness

OP posts:
successstories · 01/05/2022 19:02

Also, just to clarify - is the deal that it now says it’s made in a factory which also handles gluten? because I would eat that, and so would my mum who is also coeliac and hasn’t eaten gluten in 25 years

I'm not a medical professional, but the consensus is that only if it's labelled as 'gluten free' or within the list held by Coeliac UK you can be sure that it's safe to eat

Usually they add a disclaimer saying that it's been made in a factory that also handles gluten because they cannot guarantee that it hasn't been cross contaminated

OP posts:
PoseyFlump · 01/05/2022 19:01

@LoveInSlowMotion I think the answer to that is because people think their taste buds are more important.

I imagine it would shock some posters on here when I say that I'd still eat vegan even if it was detrimental to my own health. But then I don't rate humans that highly.

As it turned out, going vegan put an end to a long term health condition I had that I thought 'was just the way I am' so win, win.

LoveInSlowMotion · 01/05/2022 18:53

successstories · 01/05/2022 18:34

My ideal would be for all food to be plant based and all medical conditions and allergies to be available within those plant based foods

Exactly, it's your ideal and your opinion (probably shared by most vegans and most likely pushing companies to make unwise decisions).

To save the planet and be kind to animals, we have to try to achieve plant based eating

Most people don't want to achieve 'plant based eating'. You (and other posters in these types of threads) seem to be saying 'we' a lot, as if everyone agreed with this philosophy. Who is 'we'? Most people clearly don't want to eat only plants as they don't think they provide enough nutrition (medical conditions or not) or they simply don't want to.

Why would anyone want to kill/exploit animals if we don’t have to? 🤷🏻‍♀️ My partner eats meat, he loves animals and would like to eat plant based full time. However, he freely admits that for him, eating fully plant based is too hard and not convenient enough....yet ! I hear this a lot from people whilst campaigning.

If we can get to the stage where we can cater to medical issues, food tastes good and is nutritious, whilst minimising our hurt to animals and the planet, why would that not be a good thing? Why would we continue to think that we have the right to hurt animals? Because we want ice cream made with cows milk???....that just doesn’t justify it to me and to an increasing number of people are starting to think the same.

beautifulworldwhereareyou · 01/05/2022 18:50

Also, just to clarify - is the deal that it now says it’s made in a factory which also handles gluten?

because I would eat that, and so would my mum who is also coeliac and hasn’t eaten gluten in 25 years. I was only diagnosed less than a year ago so I would appreciate if I was being a bit naive about it but we both eat things like Cadbury’s which say “may contain wheat” and we’re both always fine. Of course, while it might not produce outward symptoms you never know if it’s doing internal damage etc etc and I wouldn’t expect another coeliac to do the same.

however, of all the things I find I can’t eat, I’ve cream isn’t one of them. I feel like there’s loads of gluten free dairy ice cream?!

being coeliac is shit, and it’s annoying when people are like “meat also gives you cancer!!” obviously I’m vegan, I don’t eat animal products so it’s not even like I disagree but it just rubs me up the wrong way when being coeliac is an actual condition that you can’t choose and that can make you severely ill long term if you don’t know you have it.

StaunchMomma · 01/05/2022 18:49

It's so frustrating being gluten free at the moment. Our ranges get smaller and smaller as the vegan trend grows.

Nothing against vegans, I used to be one years ago, but it IS a choice, whereas being GF isn't for the vast majority of us.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 01/05/2022 18:45

My ideal would be for all food to be plant based and all medical conditions and allergies to be available within those plant based foods

Your ideal might be but having a stomach that doesn't tolerate beans, lentils, mushrooms, too many veg and hardly any fruit I'll crack on with eating meat thank you. I don't fancy constant pain and upset stomachs or living on potatoes for the rest of my days.

PoseyFlump · 01/05/2022 18:41

You could turn your argument @successstories on it's head. For years us vegans who don't have a problem with gluten have had to put up with 'free from' food that ticks all the boxes, GF, nut free, dairy free, taste free....

PoseyFlump · 01/05/2022 18:38

probably shared by most vegans and most likely pushing companies to make unwise decisions

Sorry but you're just getting silly now.

successstories · 01/05/2022 18:34

My ideal would be for all food to be plant based and all medical conditions and allergies to be available within those plant based foods

Exactly, it's your ideal and your opinion (probably shared by most vegans and most likely pushing companies to make unwise decisions).

To save the planet and be kind to animals, we have to try to achieve plant based eating

Most people don't want to achieve 'plant based eating'. You (and other posters in these types of threads) seem to be saying 'we' a lot, as if everyone agreed with this philosophy. Who is 'we'? Most people clearly don't want to eat only plants as they don't think they provide enough nutrition (medical conditions or not) or they simply don't want to.

OP posts:
beautifulworldwhereareyou · 01/05/2022 18:33

As a vegan who is also coeliac, I’m not sure which side of the argument I’m on here

LoveInSlowMotion · 01/05/2022 18:32

PoseyFlump · 01/05/2022 18:20

@successstories I'm beginning to think you did actually intend your thread to be a vegan bash. Either that or you are becoming way too emotional over ice cream.

I hope that wasn’t the case but there have been a lot of vegan bashing threads on here. One got deleted not long ago. I hope it’s just a case of OP being fed up that her favourite ice cream is no longer available to her. My friend is celiac and my daughter has an allergy so I know it can be disappointing when one of your safe foods is no longer ok and I understand the difficulty of living on a medically restricted diet. I don’t see any need for blaming vegans or trying to make a them versus us thing.

catsonahottinroof · 01/05/2022 18:29

I've never eaten their products and am not a vegan, but inclined to say yanbu if they started off doing dairy ice cream. It's up to them of course, and they will know if there is a big enough gap in the vegan market for them to specialise in this (I've noticed Ben and Jerry's now do quite a lot of vegan). But, the main draw of ice cream is to use real dairy cream, and I thought Jude's used this in their marketing.
It used to annoy me when looking for gluten free products that a lot of companies made their products both gluten free and dairy free, so the worst of everything in many cases eg gluten free pizza with vegan 'cheese' on top.

PoseyFlump · 01/05/2022 18:25

What @LoveInSlowMotion said 👏🏻

LoveInSlowMotion · 01/05/2022 18:22

successstories · 01/05/2022 18:01

But many meat eaters, that are not celiacs will buy the vegan burger

Most meat eaters will choose a beef burger over a vegan one if both options were available actually

Actually, we are seeing that people are eating less meat, even if they eat meat. People that eat meat are choosing vegetarian and vegan options for both health and ethical reasons sometimes. As well as obviously the number of people becoming vegan/vegetarian is increasing.

Humans in most areas have evolved eating meat (and dairy). Are you suggesting vegans don't get cancer or inflammation?

Studies show vegetarians and vegans have lower cancer rates.

Well, in this example it does appear to be one or the other

I don’t think it needs to be an argument between vegans and celiacs. This constant need for division is unhelpful. As a vegan, I don’t want you to struggle to find foods. My ideal would be for all food to be plant based and all medical conditions and allergies to be available within those plant based foods. To save the planet and be kind to animals, we have to try to achieve plant based eating. And we of course must make sure that everyone can eat healthily and safely within that. No hatred required, we can respect people, animals and the planet.

Innocenta · 01/05/2022 18:21

successstories · 01/05/2022 18:05

Sorry but that's debatable considering what we know about the links to cancer and inflammation from eating dairy and meat

Humans in most areas have evolved eating meat (and dairy). Are you suggesting vegans don't get cancer or inflammation?

Look it up. No one is guaranteed; anyone can get cancer. But veganism stacks the deck in your favour.

Innocenta · 01/05/2022 18:20

successstories · 01/05/2022 17:59

Literalism about food is just silly

Correct labelling is now called 'literalism'? Blimey!

So do you normally complain about peanut 'butter'? Spotted dick?

PoseyFlump · 01/05/2022 18:20

@successstories I'm beginning to think you did actually intend your thread to be a vegan bash. Either that or you are becoming way too emotional over ice cream.

Innocenta · 01/05/2022 18:19

@NeverDropYourMooncup If he can squish meat mince, he can squish beans.