Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you think of this situation and who's being unreasonable?

205 replies

HillProp · 30/04/2022 19:52

John is married to Lisa who he shares DC with. He also shares DC with Kate (so Lisa's DSC). Lisa works part time (although not massively part time to be fair!) due to young DC so tends to take on more childcare for all of the children than John.

Whenever there is an argument between John and Lisa, one of Lisa's responses is that John do X Y or Z for his own kids from now on. For example: 'You can cook for your own kid from now on' meaning her DSC. She will say this even if DSC are there.

Lisa's DSC have told their Mum, Kate, about this who has now told John she's annoyed about this and thinks it's cruel of Lisa. DSC generally like Lisa and they get on well typically.

Lisa feels like John leaves a lot of his children's care to her and this is her retaliation when things blow up between them although it isn't always actually anything to do with the DC but this is her way of 'getting to him', by refusing to do anything for his older DC.

Who's unreasonable?

Lisa for using DSCs care as a means to punish John?

Or Kate for having a go at John about this comment?

Or options 3.. John for putting too much onto Lisa in relation to his older DC?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ddl1 · 09/06/2022 18:02

On reflection: I think that if Lisa set out at the beginning what she is and isn't prepared to do, then she is not U to stick to it. On the other hand, if she withdraws previously agreed help to the children in order to punish John, then it is U; the children shouldn't be used as pawns. And John is of course U not to do more for his children,

ExMachinaDeus · 03/05/2022 20:10

If Lisa were Keith, and Kate’s new partner, no one would be expecting her to do all the childcare. Not Kate. Not John. Not Keith.

This. Both John & Kate assume Lisa will do the childcare. Because they assumer her time isn't so important as theirs.

stopwaitingforpermissiontobeyou · 03/05/2022 17:49

funinthesun19 · 03/05/2022 15:09

It’s blindingly obvious where Kate is at fault.

She’s contributing to Lisa’s already overloaded mental health by using her as childcare when Lisa is already in a tough situation. It just shouldn’t be happening. Then when you add her latest response to Lisa, all of it together just shows her complete lack of empathy, respect and understanding of Lisa’s position.
I get she’s thinking about her children, but she also needs to understand that another woman shouldn’t be run in to the ground to keep her satisfied.

I really don't think that is a big deal. Co parenting is tough and she took on a man with children (and before anyone jumps down my neck , I'd say the same sexes reversed).

The fact Kate doesn't have a partner isn't here or there. Perhaps a discussion needs to be had but I'm not sure why we are ignoring Lisa's dreadful comment.

funinthesun19 · 03/05/2022 15:45

Same. I’m not siding with Lisa just because she’s a woman.
I’m also not against John just because he’s a man. If the sexes were reversed I’d be saying exactly the same.

But there is absolutely no denying that the overwhelming majority of these bad situations are caused by men/fathers, so usually this is where a woman is suffering.

I do have empathy for Kate too. Dealing with an ex like John to co parent with is hard work. And with that in mind surely she knows what he is like with Lisa too.

SoggyPaper · 03/05/2022 15:35

Sofielou · 03/05/2022 15:26

why are we automatically siding with Lisa because shes a woman?

I'm not siding with Lisa because she's a woman; I'm siding with her because she's the only one looking after kids who aren't hers and being taken advantage of! I'd say the same whatever her sex - it has nothing to do with it.

If Lisa were Keith, and Kate’s new partner, no one would be expecting her to do all the childcare. Not Kate. Not John. Not Keith.

He’d be unlikely to be telling Kate to feed her own kids because it’s statistically highly likely that she would have been doing it anyway.

I doubt John would be phoning Keith up to ask for childcare either.

billy1966 · 03/05/2022 15:33

John is a waster.
Kate got rid of him and shouldn't be imposing on Lisa.

Lisa is a fool to have married such a waster.

Lisa should not be saying things like that in front of the SC, that is SO wrong.

Lisa should unilaterally stop ALL childcare for SC, and should focus on her own children and dump John's ass asap.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 03/05/2022 15:32

Unless you tell us which one is your sister, we won't know how you've skewed this and can't give useful answers.

Sofielou · 03/05/2022 15:26

why are we automatically siding with Lisa because shes a woman?

I'm not siding with Lisa because she's a woman; I'm siding with her because she's the only one looking after kids who aren't hers and being taken advantage of! I'd say the same whatever her sex - it has nothing to do with it.

Squillerman · 03/05/2022 15:12

Lisa shouldn’t be making comments like that in front of the children, she’ll make them resent her when they grow up. John should be doing more for his children than he currently is. Kate isn’t BU to be annoyed at Lisa’s remarks.

funinthesun19 · 03/05/2022 15:09

stopwaitingforpermissiontobeyou · 02/05/2022 21:30

This is nonsense.

How on earth is this Kate's fault?

It’s blindingly obvious where Kate is at fault.

She’s contributing to Lisa’s already overloaded mental health by using her as childcare when Lisa is already in a tough situation. It just shouldn’t be happening. Then when you add her latest response to Lisa, all of it together just shows her complete lack of empathy, respect and understanding of Lisa’s position.
I get she’s thinking about her children, but she also needs to understand that another woman shouldn’t be run in to the ground to keep her satisfied.

HotDogKetchup · 03/05/2022 10:03

stopwaitingforpermissiontobeyou · 02/05/2022 21:30

This is nonsense.

How on earth is this Kate's fault?

Because Kate recognises Lisa has too much on her plate but is still happy to take advantage of her for her own means.

stopwaitingforpermissiontobeyou · 02/05/2022 22:50

TimBoothseyes · 02/05/2022 08:16

Did you miss this bit of the OP

Lisa's DSC have told their Mum, Kate, about this who has now told John she's annoyed about this and thinks it's cruel of Lisa.

Asking for help, yet calling the person helping "cruel" is the actions of a CF.

Nonsense.

Lisa was cruel about the kids. that was a nasty thing to say. Whether Kate has 'asked' for help is irrelevant.

stopwaitingforpermissiontobeyou · 02/05/2022 22:49

Sofielou · 01/05/2022 17:59

Woman in asking another woman for help shocker.

I didn't get much of a sense of "asking". The word used was "relies on". In other words, takes the fucking piss and expects her to help out, rather than asks.

Says who? We still have no idea who OP is.

how many times do we read threads about the ex being a 'psycho' and she isnt? why are we automatically siding with Lisa because shes a woman?

stopwaitingforpermissiontobeyou · 02/05/2022 21:30

funinthesun19 · 01/05/2022 17:29

Or taking advantage of another woman and contributing to her already overloaded mental health.

Yep! Exactly that.

This is nonsense.

How on earth is this Kate's fault?

TimBoothseyes · 02/05/2022 08:16

stopwaitingforpermissiontobeyou · 01/05/2022 16:42

Woman in asking another woman for help shocker.

Did you miss this bit of the OP

Lisa's DSC have told their Mum, Kate, about this who has now told John she's annoyed about this and thinks it's cruel of Lisa.

Asking for help, yet calling the person helping "cruel" is the actions of a CF.

Sofielou · 01/05/2022 17:59

Woman in asking another woman for help shocker.

I didn't get much of a sense of "asking". The word used was "relies on". In other words, takes the fucking piss and expects her to help out, rather than asks.

lunar1 · 01/05/2022 17:43

Just another case of the children baring the brunt of shitty adult behaviour all round really.

If Lisa wants do do less-and she should, she needs to be a grownup and tell her husband and not make the children feel like unwanted garbage.

John needs to parent his children himself and cut his hours if needed. He needs to stop relying on Lisa and making his children feel like shit in a game of pass the bomb.

Kate needs to only communicate with the other parent of her children and not rely on Lisa!

Lisa is bringing taken advantage of, but loses all respect for saying deliberately hurtful things in front of the children.

DisforDarkChocolate · 01/05/2022 17:33

Option 3, the other two options would be minimised if John pulled his finger out.

Poor bloody kids.

funinthesun19 · 01/05/2022 17:29

Or taking advantage of another woman and contributing to her already overloaded mental health.

Yep! Exactly that.

funinthesun19 · 01/05/2022 17:27

stopwaitingforpermissiontobeyou · 01/05/2022 16:42

Woman in asking another woman for help shocker.

I’d say in these circumstances it is pretty shocking. Kate probably knows what her ex is like and knows what things will be like for Lisa, and yet she herself still relies on Lisa. And given her latest reaction to Lisa being at the end of her tether, I hope she doesn’t ask for help from her in future.

HotDogKetchup · 01/05/2022 17:23

stopwaitingforpermissiontobeyou · 01/05/2022 16:42

Woman in asking another woman for help shocker.

Or taking advantage of another woman and contributing to her already overloaded mental health.

SeasonFinale · 01/05/2022 17:22

The DSC are also unreasonable for reporting back to their Mum conversations that are happening at Dad's! Grin

All of them!

aSofaNearYou · 01/05/2022 16:58

Perhaps saying Kate relies on her too is unfair. She has actually told John in the past he leaves too much to Lisa in regards to their children. But then if John can't do something like an extra day for DC etc.. for whatever reason, she will ask Lisa as she knows she is sometimes at home anyway.

That is still her expecting too much of her, though. She agrees that John does this and then contributes to it.

stopwaitingforpermissiontobeyou · 01/05/2022 16:42

funinthesun19 · 01/05/2022 14:30

Kate doesn't have a partner so does sometimes rely on Lisa as well.

Wow. She has a nerve.

Woman in asking another woman for help shocker.

HillProp · 01/05/2022 15:39

John doesn't make enough effort imo, he seems to think because Lisa does most of the care for their children that she should do it for his as well and not differentiate between them whereas Lisa sees her DSC as what should be John's responsibility and she's helping him with that. Imo he leaves too much of the care for ALL the DC on Lisa's shoulders using his full time working as an excuse to do wo. Lisa doesn't seem to mind as much doing the majority care for her own DC but that doesn't really extend to her stepDC and she does appear to be getting resentful of that side of things.

Perhaps saying Kate relies on her too is unfair. She has actually told John in the past he leaves too much to Lisa in regards to their children. But then if John can't do something like an extra day for DC etc.. for whatever reason, she will ask Lisa as she knows she is sometimes at home anyway.

OP posts: