I just watched the testimony of the first slap and I don't think she's putting it on. I remember the first time my ex really lost his temper at me. He was never physically violent but he would yell and rage and accuse me of all sorts of bad things and then blame me for him getting upset 'because he loved me'.
I totally recognise that sense of shock and freezing in confusion, not knowing what to do when someone you love and you believe loves you does something you never expected. I'd had arguments with boyfriends in the past but never before had someone just lose it at me for what seemed like no real reason. Your mind is spinning, trying to figure out what the hell is going on. That detail about looking at the dirty carpet really rings true to me. I remember staring down at the chair I was sitting on and noticing the way it was soldered together. It's like your brain is trying to cling onto a real-life, firm detail that will help you find your mental footing again because what's going on emotionally and psychologically is all over the place.
Amber was 26 when she started dating Johnny. She'd been in a 5-year relationship prior to that. Her ex supports her and says there wasn't actually any violence in their relationship. There was a massive power imbalance at the start of Amber and Johnny's relationship, he was twice her age and a superstar whereas she was barely known. Compared to him, she was relatively inexperienced in relationships. Sometimes the way the more experienced person behaves 'resets' the tone for a relationship.
In that first fight, I begged my ex (who was also a fair bit older than me) to stop shouting at me and that nobody had ever yelled at me like that before. That just made him angrier. He said he didn't believe me and that expressing anger was normal and healthy and I had led a weird, sheltered life. He said my parents must have been overprotective and not prepared me very well for dealing with normal relationship conflict and expressing emotions if I'd never heard them yelling at each other. The stupid thing is that at the time, it made a twisted sense. I loved him and wanted to believe that he was right. Over time, I often ended up yelling at him in fights to 'give as good as I got', but I always felt awful afterwards. I can totally believe that if Johnny introduced physical violence to the relationship, Amber adopted it as a normal pattern of behaviour. It doesn't make it right or healthy, but abusive relationships often end up with toxic dynamics. There's always a primary abuser though, and given the absolutely vile way Johnny writes about women in his messages, it seems evident to me that he has an abuser mindset.