Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Part 2 -AIBU to wonder why so many people assume Johnny Depp is the good guy and Amber Heard is the villain

1004 replies

StormzyinaTCup · 30/04/2022 19:14

Just thought I would start a follow on thread for anyone interested in the trial. I have kept it in AIBU so that it is easier for previous posters from Part 1 to find.
We are halfway through and have heard JD's testimony so next week we will hear from AH.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
mummyrocks1 · 05/05/2022 19:22

Yep. I have written that in my post. That is the strange thing. If he did all of this where Is the physical evidence? You would be black and blue by what she is describing. No visits to the doctor, only one call to the police.

Her doctor did say she saw her with a split lip.

Her therapist seems to think her word, her texts to her family and friends and her pictures of bruises are enough. I can't understand why JD lawyers didn't question this evidence more when previously they would object to any tiny thing.

But you do have audio recordings of him saying he did headbutt her and talking about bloodbaths. Her saying her away from me, taking about him hitting her against a wall and one where he says he cut his own finger off. One saying it's not ok for her to scream but it's ok for him to push her.

My opinion keeps changing as the whole thing is bizarre. I think AH will win though. JD didn't come across well to the jury.

Rinoachicken · 05/05/2022 19:07

mummyrocks1 · 05/05/2022 18:52

I think you need to watch more. There are multiple times she is accusing him of physical and sexual violence. She is basically saying he beat her regularly as a matter of course. Particularly bad instances were in Hicksville, Bahamas and Australia and on the aeroplane.

Yes, she has testified that she was beaten on an almost daily basis, usually in the face, while he was wearing rings, splitting her lips, breaking noses and ribs, she testifies he would punch her in the face repeatedly - and yet - we have seen no evidence of this at all - no medical evidence, no witnesses who saw it happen (even though she has said there were often other people around when it happened), no-one who can testify to seeing injuries. She was a very photographed woman at that time. Are you honestly telling me that a woman who is severely beaten, and in the face, on an almost continuous basis would NOT have been caught out by paparazzi at least once? Not one bruise ever? Even on dates when she appears in public within 24hrs of alleged beatings??

im sorry but it just doesn’t make sense to me

Midlifemusings · 05/05/2022 19:02

In many of the recordings people are saying as evidence because of statements he used after the fact, he isn't specific in what he is atoning or apologizing or opining about. He talks in a manner that lends itself to being vague in nature.

He used the word monster in texts to Elton John before Amber was even in the picture to refer to the hold alcohol had on him. He calls her cunt jokingly in text exchanges where they are joking with each other and he uses very poetic phrases like bloodbath without specific meaning. My personal patience with his way of speaking would last about 3 minutes but she went on and on about their shared love or prose and poetry and literary genres and that seemed to attract her.

Boulshired · 05/05/2022 18:52

The size imbalance can be used against the man, my mother would attack my father in the safe knowledge he would never hit her back till the point my father would punch the wall or door. Then tell anyone who would listen how abused by him she was. Even us (her children) who had the joy of watching it every Wednesday, Friday and Saturday like clockwork. Amber herself uses the size argument, in that she not capable of knocking him out.

mummyrocks1 · 05/05/2022 18:52

starrynight21 · 01/05/2022 00:05

Her accusation about being beaten seems to come down to one event - a day when she says he threw a phone at her face causing swelling / bruising. So far I've seen many people who were there that day, ie police, security, neighbour, doorman, driver, all saw her close up and saw no evidence of any damage . The police were there to assess for any DV and they saw nothing , despite her face being flushed from crying - they are actually trained to see any injuries and they reported "no injury" and " caller didn't want to talk to us" . I'd have thought that if you'd been injured by your husband and you called the police , you'd at least talk to them.

There are also several audio recordings where she is saying that she has hit him, and accusing him of running away, hiding from her etc. She threw a bottle at him and it took the end of his finger off.

I haven't heard any evidence where he is the perpetrator of any violence against her .

She told a TV interviewer that she had donated all her divorce settlement to charity - but she was lying, she paid one installment and has never paid them another cent. This pattern of lying makes her look like someone who cannot be trusted to tell the truth.

I think you need to watch more. There are multiple times she is accusing him of physical and sexual violence. She is basically saying he beat her regularly as a matter of course. Particularly bad instances were in Hicksville, Bahamas and Australia and on the aeroplane.

mummyrocks1 · 05/05/2022 18:47

BonnesVacances · 30/04/2022 21:59

I've followed both trials closely. I've not seen any evidence yet that JD has been physically abusive.

That said, I do think he was emotionally withdrawn. There's evidence that when AH was upset with him and wanted to talk, he didn't engage and walked away. Even when she was upset about him being late for her birthday party, he said he just read his magazine instead of talking to her.

It may be a coping mechanism though as she has histrionic personality disorder so he was probably totally done with it all by then. But in her mind, he was being emotionally abusive by walking away and not listening to her.

If you listen to longer versions of the audiotapes released there is. It seems JDs lawyers were rather selective in which bits they had heard. I heard him say he head butted her, another of her saying get away from me, another of him burning her with a cigarette and another of him talking about the blood bath on the island. Others of her saying he hit her and he does not deny it. Does that count as admitting? If someone accused me of that I would make Damn sure I denied it.

The psychologist for AH was pretty damning for JD. If to be believed it conveniently allows AH to have gaps in memory and confusion over the events.

After today I don't think it looks good for JD. I think AH will win. She was really selling it on the witness stand. She is very believable I think.

But it did seem scripted. No thinking about her words and answering off the cuff, no tears when she was meant to be distressed. What she was saying and the order she was saying was too in line with her solicitors questions, all in the same order of what she was going to ask.

Also- if you have been beaten up like she says you have bruises. How did no one see any bruises! It doesn't make sense. Unless all those people are lying.

It's all bizarre

CorsicaDreaming · 05/05/2022 18:39

But he can be an arsehole.

The case isn't about if he is a saint or not, or if you'd want (your daughter) to go out with him, or if he is likeable or a misogynistic drug addict.

All he's got to prove is he is not a domestic abuser in as much as he didn't hit her. And that she is. In that she has hit him on multiple occasions, even if he tried to move rooms to avoid her. And that her libellous Op Ed has damaged his ability to earn a living by defaming him, which it did because Disney pulled Pirates immediately after it.

He can be a misogynistic, drug-abusing arsehole and still be entitled to win this libel case.

Rinoachicken · 05/05/2022 18:36

QuotetheLaw · 05/05/2022 18:04

Did AH just say she called the police several times a year? Yet there are no police records for that as far as I'm aware. There are a couple of call-outs but not how she said.

Yep, she did just say that and nope, there’s been no record of those calls to substantiate it.

ENoeuf · 05/05/2022 18:31

I don’t disagree on the following him around stuff but I think his smirking isn’t coming across to me as inappropriate laughing - you’ve tried the he’s happy she’s being exposed, now it’s nervous laughter? Maybe he’s just an arsehole ?

CorsicaDreaming · 05/05/2022 18:06

@ENoeuf - I'm at risk of sounding like a complete apologist for JD, which I'm not because I'd imagine he is pretty much as far from saint as you can get.

But laughing as a defence mechanism in awkward situations where someone is embarrassed but laughter is the absolutely wrong response is definitely something people do - and it seems they can't help themselves doing.

My DH does it sometimes- generally in the most excruciatingly inappropriate moments - and it has angered and upset me at times. And when later I ask him why, that's the reason why he does it.

So I'm not sure his laughter is necessarily him making light of things.

And I do believe JD attempted to move to different rooms to get away from AH (and his sister booked additional rooms to enable this on tours) and she would just follow him and prolong the arguments. Which I can understand if you are infuriated that someone won't deal with something and discuss it, but I cannot understand if you are truly terrified someone is going to be violent towards you. You'd not follow them.

QuotetheLaw · 05/05/2022 18:04

Did AH just say she called the police several times a year? Yet there are no police records for that as far as I'm aware. There are a couple of call-outs but not how she said.

Momicrone · 05/05/2022 18:03

No, but you are correct I would be more worried about my daughter being abused by a man than my son being abused by a woman, although I would rather no-one was abusing anyone.

FrippEnos · 05/05/2022 17:56

Momicrone · 05/05/2022 17:39

Flipping- I didn't say that at all, all dv is bad, but in this case, with two abusive people, he's the one with most power

But you are not taking about this case, you are hypothesizing that your DD would be worse off if she brought JD home than your DS would be if he brought AH home.

Both would be being abused.

Would you support AH over your DS because as a male he has more power?

Momicrone · 05/05/2022 17:39

Flipping- I didn't say that at all, all dv is bad, but in this case, with two abusive people, he's the one with most power

ENoeuf · 05/05/2022 17:38

@CorsicaDreaming i haven’t got involved in the gender discussions, im Well aware abuse can be both ways.
i think people should be respectful of the court process, witnesses, the judge and not play to the gallery, gurning away. Surely if he’s relieved he thinks he will win and she will be exposed he could look content and refrain from acting like a smirking kid? He’s a middle aged bloke whose terrible texts and substance abuse are also being revealed - why that’s funny I don’t know.

FrippEnos · 05/05/2022 17:35

Momicrone · 05/05/2022 17:24

Fripp, I'd be more worried by him as he has more power over all

So you wouldn't be that bothered that the women was physically abusing your DS because "power over all"?

That is really messed up.

You either think that DV/DA is wrong on all counts or don't bother.

CorsicaDreaming · 05/05/2022 17:34

ENoeuf · 04/05/2022 22:56

He, on the other hand, looks as though he's revelling in it, grinning and gesticulating at inappropriate moments, cracking 'funnies' and bending over double with laughter when his witnesses did the same. I sense he's getting a positive pleasure out of making her suffer, so much so that doesn't even care about the potential cost of this to him.

agree with this

@ENoeuf
But although it clearly isn't the most noble behaviour by JD - however you look at it - if (big ifs) you accept his side of the story and that she is lying, manipulative and did hit him on many occasions, and shit in his bed, then ruin his career by a completely untrue Op Ed that made Disney withdraw his contract for Pirates, you would need to be a saint (which JD most definitely is not) to not feel satisfaction if she is finally being shown up for a liar and a bully.

And the gender of either seems totally irrelevant to that for me.

Clearly if you don't believe JD and/or if he is lying, then it does put a whole different slant on it.

ObjectionHearsay · 05/05/2022 17:26

Momicrone · 05/05/2022 17:15

He said she said is why rape convictions are so low. Would you be happy for your daughter to bring this fuck up of a man home?

Thing is in criminal court you need to prove beyond reasonable doubt, and as such cases only have two parties with very different stories, it's very difficult to prove beyond reasonable doubt. It's why we encourage women to go to the SARC immediately, so we can obtain evidence. But again it's not a nice experience and I can 100% see why women don't want to do it.

Women really are damned if they do and damned if they don't in such cases, and I agree it's completely unfair and wrong. But we can't change due process and our courts still need to prove beyond reasonable doubt to avoid false convictions. If all we needed was "woman stated it happened, therefore it must" that would be a dangerous area to go in to.

Oh and if my daughter or son brought a man like JD home, I'd 100% not be happy and I would pray and beg with all my might that my child saw sense! I don't believe either AH or JD are "wonderful" partners for anyone.

Momicrone · 05/05/2022 17:24

Fripp, I'd be more worried by him as he has more power over all

FrippEnos · 05/05/2022 17:23

Momicrone · 05/05/2022 17:15

He said she said is why rape convictions are so low. Would you be happy for your daughter to bring this fuck up of a man home?

I wouldn't be happy with a child of mine bringing either home.

They are both "fucked up".

ENoeuf · 05/05/2022 17:15

Thank you - it’s a lot easier to follow without being in clips on TikTok! I’ll try and find somewhere to watch it.

Momicrone · 05/05/2022 17:15

He said she said is why rape convictions are so low. Would you be happy for your daughter to bring this fuck up of a man home?

StormzyinaTCup · 05/05/2022 17:14

ENoeuf · 05/05/2022 16:43

Im not at home today; does anyone know where I would be able to watch it in full before tomorrow? It would be day 2 of A testimony?

@ENoeuf I don’t think the trial runs on a Friday but you will be able to catch up on today (day 15) via You Tube. I have been watching it on Law & Crime channel via You Tube.

Also, there will be no trial next week as the judge has a prior commitment.

OP posts:
ObjectionHearsay · 05/05/2022 17:11

I think people need to be mindful that DAVRO could be being used by both in this case.

It really does seem a bit tit for tat and toxic.

So each being both the abuser and the victim, can employ DAVRO.

It really is a he said, she said but then she said and he said situation in my opinion.

Zotter · 05/05/2022 17:04

Newrunner29 · 05/05/2022 14:50

I'm saying the specific quote u said from Talented Mr Ripley cannot be found in AH testimony, so the twitter thread mentioned that quote and it cannot be found , there are others that was found and video showing just not that specific one

Thank you. I found the bit I think they are claiming is lifted from Talented Mr Ripley. Amber Heard says ‘when I was around Johnny I felt like the most beautiful person in the world’. This is said at 35.04 mins

The Talented Mr Ripley speech I believe they are referring to is:

“ Marge Sherwood : The thing with Dickie... it's like the sun shines on you, and it's glorious. And then he forgets you and it's very, very cold.

Tom Ripley : So I'm learning.

Marge Sherwood : When you have his attention, you feel like you're the only person in the world, that's why everybody loves him so much.”

In my opinion saying ‘I felt like the only person in the world’ is a fairly generic phrase that people often say when describing how a person makes you feel and it is a stretch to say that short phrase shows she lifted a speech from Talented Mr Ripley.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.