Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Part 2 -AIBU to wonder why so many people assume Johnny Depp is the good guy and Amber Heard is the villain

1004 replies

StormzyinaTCup · 30/04/2022 19:14

Just thought I would start a follow on thread for anyone interested in the trial. I have kept it in AIBU so that it is easier for previous posters from Part 1 to find.
We are halfway through and have heard JD's testimony so next week we will hear from AH.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
mummyrocks1 · 06/05/2022 18:05

Ooops sorry. Tagged the wrong post. That was for the post where someone said you wouldn't film yourself when being attacked

mummyrocks1 · 06/05/2022 18:04

CooooCoooo · 06/05/2022 10:07

It is very strange that Amber, who seemingly liked to document everything that Johnny Depp did wrong, never took photos or recordings of her own vicious beatings.

There was one instance during her testimony where she said he grabbed her arm and punched her repeatedly in the face and then showed a picture of a round bruise on her arm (which didn't look like the typical bruise from being grabbed which has finger marks but I'm no expert). In the background of this photo, you can see her face which doesn't have a single mark on it. It's impossible not to get a mark after being punched repeatedly in the face.

Also, her testimony about the Australia kidnap incident has a lot of holes in. She said her feet were cut to ribbons, she got cuts on her arms and she felt glass cutting her back when laying on the counter. Where's the bloody footprints? Where's the bloody sheets from when she went to sleep? Where's the medical report? I got one cut from glass on the side of my foot and it bled alot. I had to go to the hospital for treatment, antibiotics and dressings. I couldn't wear normal shoes for a few weeks. Is Amber saying her feet just healed overnight? My cut left a scar, where's her scars? Also, where was security and Ben King when this was going on (she never says). She also said she didn't call the police because there was no evidence but she's just said she's got all these injuries, there's glass everywhere, she's bleeding from her vagina which would indicate that she's cut internally but didn't call the police because there's no evidence? Make is make sense.

Yes agreed. But she said she started to see the signs and the signals he was going to flip out. Surely if it was linked to his drinking or drug taking she could have predicted it and set her phone.

Although if that was me and my husband I would make damn sure I got out of there the minute he started drinking or taking drugs or I saw one of the signs she's talking about before he started on me. But everyone is different and I know victims behave differently. She was not on her own though or isolated. Her friends all lived next door. She could have gone to any of them to get away.

It's odd how no one ever heard anything when he was trashing places and they were screaming at each other.

Why aren't any of her friends giving evidence? Why isn't she friends with them anymore?

ObjectionHearsay · 06/05/2022 16:28

ENoeuf · 06/05/2022 16:05

@Midlifemusings @ObjectionHearsay
this is really difficult to understand - her recounting is appalling and I really feel uncomfortable with its being broadcast (although I’m a hypocrite and have watched it). But as you say surely loyalty/fandom/salary comes beneath safeguarding or reporting abuse - no one leaked it even if they were scared of directly getting involved?

Indeed, we as professionals have safeguarding duty. It's why safeguarding is one of the only reasons to trump GDPR.

It's always best practice to try and get the service user to engage in the report and assist with the safeguarding procedure.

However, many, many service users do not want to get services involved, but we as professionals have a duty above all else to report it to the relevant agency.

We can make independent referrals to police and other statutory agencies regardless.

If AH was on my caseload and she was disclosing this abuse to me, I'd have a duty to notify. Regardless, now it could be it ends at that, the police are aware and a marker is placed as AH would be unwilling to engage but she would still be discussed at MARAC meetings and professionals would still attempt to safeguard her. Same for JD, if he disclosed abuse, I'd have a responsibility to safeguard.

bigjuice01 · 06/05/2022 16:10

Amber Heard didn't have cuts or visible injuries to the medical professionals. For example, the alleged beating that involved the broken glass on her feet? 2 days after that specific incident, where she claimed the bottom of her feet were all cut, she was at a dance studio barefoot, dancing.

The incident in LA where he allegedly pulled out chunks of her hair? She called her nurse right after and the RN notes show that she checked Amber's scalp and didn't see any of the bruises or pus or anything at all.

bigjuice01 · 06/05/2022 16:06

Amber Heard reminds me a lot of my mother. Who was emotionally and physically abusive and now that I'm an adult, I realize she had definite narcissistic tendencies. So I feel bad for Amber's child (however, I'm very biased).

ENoeuf · 06/05/2022 16:05

@Midlifemusings @ObjectionHearsay
this is really difficult to understand - her recounting is appalling and I really feel uncomfortable with its being broadcast (although I’m a hypocrite and have watched it). But as you say surely loyalty/fandom/salary comes beneath safeguarding or reporting abuse - no one leaked it even if they were scared of directly getting involved?

ObjectionHearsay · 06/05/2022 15:57

Midlifemusings · 06/05/2022 15:47

@ENoeuf

I too find the testimony hard to follow as they jump around date wise and sometimes I am unsure if I have just heard 1 even being described 3 times or 3 events being described once. It gets very confusing and I wonder why the lawyers don't create clearer timelines.

The medical practitioners should lose their licenses if she is telling the truth. In the Australia story, her testimony was being slammed against the floor, repeatedly punched in the head, dragged naked by her hair across broken glass, cut up feet from walking barefoot on broken glass, and bleeding from her vagina after a sexual assault. The doctor and nurse were both on site very shortly after that happened and interacted in person with her and their only treatment was to give her medication to help her calm down and get some sleep. That is absolute malpractice if they ignored all her injuries and the clear risk to her life and safety.

Re "the professionals" I'm absolutely appalled by their "lack of safeguarding"

If I had a service user who I knew was going through DA, and I saw any injury, I'd note it I may also directly ask "how did you get that?" and also note the response. Just incase I'm called to court for something!

Makes no difference to note something and then it never see the light of day, than fail to note something and then get called to a witness stand!

During one testimony the notes said "they needed to be kept apart" but no explanation as to why, no clear indication of what had happened to trigger this safeguarding procedure.

If anything this trial has done is made me refresh my team that I manage on "the importance of note taking" 😳

Factual, accurate notes are paramount!

Midlifemusings · 06/05/2022 15:47

@ENoeuf

I too find the testimony hard to follow as they jump around date wise and sometimes I am unsure if I have just heard 1 even being described 3 times or 3 events being described once. It gets very confusing and I wonder why the lawyers don't create clearer timelines.

The medical practitioners should lose their licenses if she is telling the truth. In the Australia story, her testimony was being slammed against the floor, repeatedly punched in the head, dragged naked by her hair across broken glass, cut up feet from walking barefoot on broken glass, and bleeding from her vagina after a sexual assault. The doctor and nurse were both on site very shortly after that happened and interacted in person with her and their only treatment was to give her medication to help her calm down and get some sleep. That is absolute malpractice if they ignored all her injuries and the clear risk to her life and safety.

ENoeuf · 06/05/2022 15:39

It seems to go back and forth a lot, I’m finding it hard to follow any chronology. I hate to raise it but I didn’t follow her bottle testimony at all and the photos of the bottles but it’s not really something I want to pick apart.
i am struggling with the lack of clear photos of injuries, although the ones she has show bruising it doesn’t seem as extensive as her descriptions.
essentially though it is staggering if this is true that she is basically saying his team, anyone who suspected, covered for him and allowed DA to continue. That’s surely career ending not just for Depp.

Midlifemusings · 06/05/2022 15:36

mummyrocks1 · 06/05/2022 15:28

There is more than one incident that she is accusing him of. The photos of her alleged injuries are from other times she says he beat her.

I hope they play that audio link from further down the thread. That shows amber was present and coherent after the finger incident and had no medical help and no one noticed any injuries.

They can't play most of that audio because Jerry Judge who features heavily in it is dead and can't testify.

mummyrocks1 · 06/05/2022 15:28

There is more than one incident that she is accusing him of. The photos of her alleged injuries are from other times she says he beat her.

I hope they play that audio link from further down the thread. That shows amber was present and coherent after the finger incident and had no medical help and no one noticed any injuries.

Midlifemusings · 06/05/2022 15:26

@MarieIVanArkleStinks

Whataboutery doesn't really apply at an individual case level. If a man reports he is being abused - that matters and it isn't mysogyny to bring it up.

There is clear evidence that Amber has lied - so questioning her credibility is also specific to her. I have no problem questioning the crediblity of someone who has lied.

If you listen to the recordings, it would be impossible to say this is one sided. Johnny has clear issues with substances and definitely damages property while in an intoxicated state. He also has called her names. Amber taunts him and mocks him and demeans him and has hit him and thrown things at him. There is no innocent party in this case.

Midlifemusings · 06/05/2022 15:18

mummyrocks1 · 06/05/2022 15:13

There are lots of pictures of her bruises. I wonder how JDs lawyers are going to argue that.

It's strange that no one physically saw these though. Just pictures. Her pictures are weird too if the damage in Australia. If the damage was so bad why has she only taken pictures of a bit of blood, some stuff on the floor and a busted wall. Where's the table, the phone, the glass and bottles? Plus if you had the injuries she is claiming she had why is there no physical evidence of trips to doctors? Are we expected to believe she seeked no treatment for that? Surely you wouldn't go around taking photos of stuff after an attack like that. Surely you would just get out of there. so strange.

Her / JD's concierge doctor and nurse came to the house very soon after the incident and assessed both Johnny and Amber. The only treatment they felt Amber needed was medication to calm her down. They felt Johnny needed a skin graft likely and they were also concerned about infection because blue paint had gotten in the wound. They commented that the bone was smashed. Amber did have scratches on the inside of her arm - there was speculation these were self inflicted marks given how they looked (similar to when someone self harms in that way)

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 06/05/2022 15:14

In response to the last few posts, I think this issue is emotive. It's emotive for me because #MeToo (of which Heard seems to have been elevated to a poster-woman on the back of one article) truly illustrated two things. 1. the absolute prevalence of male on female harassments on practically every level. 2. the fact that, when women try to speak about it, the overwhelming response is to immediately get them to shut up again. They're attention-seeking. They're jumping on the bandwagon. They're lying. Anything but acknowledge the appalling, unassailable statistical evidence that women do have serious problems at the hands of men. (NB, that isn't to say female-on-male abuse doesn't exist too. It does. Are women sometimes awful? Yes. But given the likelihood of significant harm is far greater in reverse, this is whataboutery).

There's bias from the other angle too: that this is a patriarchy, and the reality is that society is far more comfortable with the presumption that women commonly lie than men commonly abuse. There's the powerful Hollywood dream sold to us, the fact that films sell on the back of the actor's face and not as an art form, the idea that we don't want to accept our beloved entertainers are anything other than perfect. The BBC has an image problem like this, too. Then there's the other contingent: that women who speak for other women, or attempt to protect them from this prevailing social wind, are 'man haters'.

I'm mother to a son. I fear toxic masculinity and the horrible pressure it puts on men. I want to see it taken seriously and urgently. As a woman myself, I fear male abuse. I have numerous first-hand experiences of it, some much more serious than others.

It's sometimes hard to look past these biases, which in my own case are wholly conscious on both sides, and see a situation objectively. Part of me wants to see Heard win, because otherwise it will be even harder for female victims of rape and DV to be taken seriously. Part of me sympathises with Depp - I know the pain and destruction of addiction in my own family, and if he, too, is a victim that's one in the eye for toxic masculinity. I just find it hard to accept this situation is completely one-sided and he's a wholly innocent victim. I mean - just look at his behaviour.

I think the interesting social responses to this situation illustrate much more than a belief of whether either or both parties are telling the truth (the only thing which the court is being asked to determine). It's made me explore my own biases, too.

Incidentally, I'm impressed with the Judge. She's balanced, fair, and has a calming and competent, as well as charismatic demeanor. She's also very succinct, clear and to the point on her instructions and to precisely what she will accept. Admirable, and eminently professional.

mummyrocks1 · 06/05/2022 15:13

MargeSimpson79 · 05/05/2022 23:59

she took a lot of photos but doesn’t seem to have any of her injuries? Could these come later? Otherwise it’s a bit strange.

There are lots of pictures of her bruises. I wonder how JDs lawyers are going to argue that.

It's strange that no one physically saw these though. Just pictures. Her pictures are weird too if the damage in Australia. If the damage was so bad why has she only taken pictures of a bit of blood, some stuff on the floor and a busted wall. Where's the table, the phone, the glass and bottles? Plus if you had the injuries she is claiming she had why is there no physical evidence of trips to doctors? Are we expected to believe she seeked no treatment for that? Surely you wouldn't go around taking photos of stuff after an attack like that. Surely you would just get out of there. so strange.

ENoeuf · 06/05/2022 14:48

@Newrunner29 thank you that’s nice of you. I like being on long threads which are chatty, I’ll try to be clearer if I post.

AMegaPint · 06/05/2022 14:28

Diverseopinions · 06/05/2022 08:32

I don't know what is going on, in the sense of whether JD is trying to bring her down with him, because he knows his career is compromised and he doesn't see why she should have stella success- and partly on the back of being a figurehead for women's rights against abusers.

They are clearly both in the wrong. The photographic evidence makes painful viewing. Drugs clearly destroy judgement and the lives of celebrities. But I think, instinctively, people don't blame him for having a go to make himself look better, when she has been bad to him too. Not for the career and money, but just to say "This is who I am, warts and all, but not a Jekyll and Hyde type of monster".

People to whom I've spoken think her facial expressions and mannerisms lack sincerity. I wonder if it would be fair to her to suggest that, if she has had Botox and other treatments which celebrities have, maybe she can't move her facial muscles and this is making her look unnatural.

If she can't move her muscles because she's had botox, her whole face wouldn't move. Her expressions do lack sincerity. It's very over the top, theatrical and over exaggerated.

Newrunner29 · 06/05/2022 14:26

ENoeuf · 06/05/2022 14:21

‘I do find it fascinating ur inability to see the obvious’

you don’t think just generalising about me is rude? You’ve basically reduced me to someone you see as stupid.
of course I can theorise on the ‘why’ of something, doesn’t stop it feeling unfair which is literally all my point was.

I apologise if I came across rude to u that wasn't my intention

ENoeuf · 06/05/2022 14:21

‘I do find it fascinating ur inability to see the obvious’

you don’t think just generalising about me is rude? You’ve basically reduced me to someone you see as stupid.
of course I can theorise on the ‘why’ of something, doesn’t stop it feeling unfair which is literally all my point was.

Newrunner29 · 06/05/2022 14:14

ENoeuf · 06/05/2022 14:02

I’m stunned at your rudeness, despite using MN a lot. Wow. I won’t retaliate, would rather keep the upper hand.

But what's rude about that? U haven't acknowledged anything about the fact all the reasons for the things , u mentioned could be the obvious, mm is a forum to speak and debate and see different sides of things, conversations are expected I don't think it's rude to put it out.

ENoeuf · 06/05/2022 14:02

Newrunner29 · 06/05/2022 10:37

If people r not allowed to testify then there will be good reason they won't be, there will b a proper process, not just not allowed because depps team said no! Maybe also people don't want to testify for her because they don't want to perjure themselves? Think that's right word
I do find it fascinating ur inability to see the obvious

I’m stunned at your rudeness, despite using MN a lot. Wow. I won’t retaliate, would rather keep the upper hand.

AdamRyan · 06/05/2022 14:00

Trixiefirecracker · 06/05/2022 08:01

I think the fact she has repeatedly lied about things and has been shown to be unreliable in her various accounts calls everything else in to question sadly. I’m sure JD was an absolute arsehole but she has admitted to violence towards him on tape so the abuse is definitely both ways.

So he will lose then because the case is about whether she lied about his abuse, not whether she is also abusive

AdamRyan · 06/05/2022 13:59

Boulshired · 06/05/2022 10:44

I think the comment regarding Kate Moss was silly. It added nothing as “I was frightened for my sister” would have been enough. Now she has brought his past relationship into question that before were not relevant. If they can’t prove the photo time stamps then the court of public opinion will be horrific for her. I am hoping that cases will stop being shown live. If recorded maybe only viewed after the verdict. At present everything she says within seconds someone believes they have a contradiction.

In the sun trial she was grilled by the defence for not mentioning the kate moss "thought" when she bought up the alleged attack on her sister.
So not surprising she bought it up straight away this time.

Boulshired · 06/05/2022 13:43

Does anyone know if Depps lawyers will now be able to question amber regarding her ex wife now that she has claimed Depp has previously pushed an ex down the stairs.

Boulshired · 06/05/2022 12:26

As each witness has spoken it became clear that the OP ED was just the vehicle so they could disprove the previous statements of Amber. I was shocked at how respectful they were to Ambers expert witness. Depps lawyer made some good points but didn’t go for the jugular. They let her speak quite often on yes-no questions it was mainly very pleasant. Their aim seems mainly to be to show the world that Amber is exactly the person Dr Curry described.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread