Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Some affairs work out for the better ?

196 replies

Everyoneishappier · 30/04/2022 17:56

NC as super contentious.

Met
My DH when he was unhappily married . (Both would agree on this point)

I was separated but still livng in same house as ex DH.

Move on 15 years and all kids are grown. DH paid CMS and a few extras (with my encouragement) .. Ex wife married the man she was having an affair with...

Both couples are happy.. kids are happy and well blended.

Sometimes you simply marry the wrong person...

(Caveat ) neither couple had kids .. ?

OP posts:
SquirrelG · 01/05/2022 00:42

I don't really think an affair is in the same league as a rape or a murder. I actually think you have to be a fairly awful person to rape or murder someone, I don't think you have to be an awful person to have an affair.

I never said it was in the same league, merely pointing out that it was a flippant comment which, if you wanted to, you could apply to anything. After all you said "that's life" which could cover any scenario at all. You might not think you have to be an awful person to have an affair, but from reading the comments on this thread most people do. Reducing the effects of an affair to "that's life" trivialises what can actually be devastating consequences for some people.

Enko · 01/05/2022 00:32

IDK Xeno

in the ops case who did it destroy? the couple were both looking elsewhere and ended up with their affair partners.

As I said above I don't think the children will be less hurt by their parents break up dye to affrais than simply because ethey outgrew each other

each situation is different and I am not suggesting yours was not painful but in your case there was 1 partner cheating not the same in ops

XenoBitch · 01/05/2022 00:20

Work out better for who?

Affairs always destroy at least one person. It does not really matter if the cheater and OW/OM had a happy ever after. The ends do not justify the means.

I was cheated on, and my ex left for the OW. She knew he was with someone, so I hate her for that. She was also in a relationship herself. My ex berated me after he left, saying that the OW ex had moved on and why hadn't I.
It has been 5 years now, and I still can not trust anyone at all. Have been unhappily single all that time, but I can't risk being hurt like that again. It nearly killed me.

Enko · 01/05/2022 00:11

I understand what you are saying OP. My mother and stepdad had an affair and it broke up my parent's marriage. However, mother and stepdad were together for 36 years after the divorce. Yes, it caused hurt at the time. However, for us children, it would not have caused less hurt if they had split up and then found someone else.

it is not the norm however to accept affairs we are a monogamous society that is the morals most live by.

I don't know I am not fully convinced it is as black and white as saying " he could have got out of it" so could his x if she was fucking someone else within her marriage why is it up to the guy to sort it? I don't always think we as humans behaves in ideal manners however I don't always think that = disaster..

I think my father would have remained in the marriage if my mother had not wanted out. However they were poorly suited and as they grow up wanted very different things in life. so not ideal way to end and begin but not was it a disaster

Finallylostit · 30/04/2022 23:43

Someone always gets hurt and that memory of the hurt, when you first found out, when you realised oyur life was ebing changed by someone else never disappears.

I supported my BF at her fathers funeral. He had an affair and left behind 4 DCS. Set up a new life and was v happy with the OW. At his funeral, one of the second family, stood up at the wake and said how great it was that he had 25 years of happiness after 25 years of hell. His 4 DCS were there from the 25 years of hell - someone always gets hurt and that hurt never goes away.

larkstar · 30/04/2022 23:40

kids are happy and well blended.

That can only be your opinion. I think the impact can take a surprisingly long time to emerge - certainly my dad's affair with a married woman really only started to bother me and affect my view of him late in life - when I married and had kids and by the time my mother died - early-ish IMHO - at 69 - his behaviour over the affair became something I came to despise him for - in fact I and all my siblings stopped all contact with him soon after my mother died - this was 15 years ago. Obviously - that's just my/our singular experience.

Womencanlift · 30/04/2022 23:06

Everyoneishappier · 30/04/2022 17:56

NC as super contentious.

Met
My DH when he was unhappily married . (Both would agree on this point)

I was separated but still livng in same house as ex DH.

Move on 15 years and all kids are grown. DH paid CMS and a few extras (with my encouragement) .. Ex wife married the man she was having an affair with...

Both couples are happy.. kids are happy and well blended.

Sometimes you simply marry the wrong person...

(Caveat ) neither couple had kids .. ?

Unless you are the child of a blended family you will never know for sure that they are happy with how things worked out

If you asked my dad and step mum and even to an extent my mum who knows me better than anyone else, they would say the same as you - that while it was hard at the time my dads affair came out (step mum was the OW) everyone is happy now

When actually for me it has totally messed me up and I didn’t actually realise how badly until I spoke to a therapist a few years ago. I didn’t tell anyone I saw a therapist, never mind what it made me realise about how my dads affair has shaped my life

Hawkins001 · 30/04/2022 22:46

i guess it can vary, depending on how careful the people are in the affair, and also what both parties want from the affair ?

NightAndShiningArmour · 30/04/2022 22:46

YANBU ☺️

howtomoveforwards · 30/04/2022 22:38

I understand the anger directed at people having affairs but I think sometimes this takes on a slightly evangelical tone. Sometimes people are in the wrong marriage

Sure. But you’re focused here on the happily ever after and in my personal experience, the person left behind is the one who has to manage the fall out. They’re the ones who realise every furtive phone call taken in the name of ‘work’ that interrupted birthdays and Christmas was the OW, that the lovely restaurant he took you to on your anniversary was in fact where he and the OW spent their courtship, that he had spent the night you gave birth to your second child with the OW because first child was with the in-laws, and that ultimately, it wasn’t him that had the humiliation of a full sexual health screening. My ex and I conceived a child on his way out - you should be the person trying to reconcile that, the knowledge that you would never have consented to sex with a man sleeping elsewhere. You should have a think about what that does to the innocent party, long term,

There is frequently focus in these threads which quietly suggest the ex wife was awful, and that because some affairs end up with a 20 year marriage, the end truly justified the means. You should be the ex wife who believed her marriage was happy, who was nothing other than a loyal and faithful partner who believed she was was working hard as a team to build a joint future. You should have your life blown out of the water by infidelity and see how it feels before trying to suggest I simply got what I deserved and the longevity of my ex husband’s new relationship makes it all worth it.

HisHX · 30/04/2022 22:37

Everyoneishappier · 30/04/2022 19:24

That's basically what I am trying to convey ...

What you want in your 20/30's mat not what you want in your 40/50s !

In my earlier years I wanted kids .. wanted a decent man who would be kind, and loving and would help me raise them.. as I got older and the children grew I needed something for ME..

I completely understand this. I’m in my mid 30s and so many of my friends who married early 20s are now divorced, and in some cases remarried. YANBU to think that someone who is right for you once, might not be right for you forever. YABU to think affairs are ever OK. Yes, you might end up with someone more suitable, but the collateral damage is horrendous. You don’t need to be a monkey, waiting for the next branch before you let go, most of us have evolved. If it’s not right, let go. Then move on. Affairs always hurt at least one person, but usually, many many more.

silentpool · 30/04/2022 22:37

Everyone has the right to be happy but not at someone else's expense. The decent thing to do is finish one relationship before you start the next one.

LadyShmuck · 30/04/2022 22:32

Also, I obviously don't think affairs are right @SquirrelG, not really sure how I implied that... My life has been made immeasurably harder by the consequences of an affair, but it's just how things have turned out. I can't change the actions of another person any more than I can choose the weather tomorrow.

LadyShmuck · 30/04/2022 22:28

SquirrelG · 30/04/2022 22:08

It'd be lovely if nobody ever had an affair and always honourably ended things before starting a new relationship but life just isn't like that.

Maybe not, but that still doesn't make it right - it's a such flippant comment. We might as well say "it'd be lovely if nobody stole, raped, killed people but life just isn't like that". Of course it's isn't like that, but most people have a sense of right or wrong and don't do those things. Having an affair is a choice - what's so hard about making the right one?

I don't really think an affair is in the same league as a rape or a murder. I actually think you have to be a fairly awful person to rape or murder someone, I don't think you have to be an awful person to have an affair.

I don't really know what's hard about making the right choice, I've never had an affair. However I know lots of people who have, there's probably lots more people I know who have had them and nobody has ever found out.

I know of precisely nobody who has raped or murdered anyone (not to say I don't know somebody who has but has never been caught) which would suggest that there's some different motives going on between those comparisons you've made.

Penguinevere · 30/04/2022 22:14

The ones I’ve seen have been complete car crashes.

SquirrelG · 30/04/2022 22:08

It'd be lovely if nobody ever had an affair and always honourably ended things before starting a new relationship but life just isn't like that.

Maybe not, but that still doesn't make it right - it's a such flippant comment. We might as well say "it'd be lovely if nobody stole, raped, killed people but life just isn't like that". Of course it's isn't like that, but most people have a sense of right or wrong and don't do those things. Having an affair is a choice - what's so hard about making the right one?

SW1amp · 30/04/2022 22:04

Everyoneishappier · 30/04/2022 18:45

Because of the MN trope that affairs never work out ...

It’s not a MN trope, it’s pretty factual

I heard the stats on a podcast with Esther Perez (so?) who said that something ridiculous like 90% of relationships that start as affairs fail within a few years
and those that lead to marriage have a higher divorce rate than those that start normally.

and that’s probably in large part because people who have affairs are damaged in one way or another, and won’t make the most stable of partners so become a self selecting group of no hope relationships with the odd exceptions

but the drop off rate from ‘but this is true love/was meant to be/we are soul mates’ during the affair stage, to over and done with is quite extraordinary given the supposed depth of feelings at the start

LadyShmuck · 30/04/2022 21:45

I don't think there's a place in hell, let alone a special one for cheaters and I have been on the receiving end and ultimately it ended my marriage.

Yeah, it's not great but we're all fallible, I certainly wouldn't hold onto the burning hate and resentment because that only hurts me more.

Some people just cheat, sometimes that ends in a lasting relationship with the OW/OM, sometimes it doesn't. Same as sometimes dating someone leads to marriage and sometimes it doesn't.

It'd be lovely if nobody ever had an affair and always honourably ended things before starting a new relationship but life just isn't like that.

feellikeanalien · 30/04/2022 21:41

Onthedunes · 30/04/2022 20:53

Yeah,

And I presume all the children are as equally happy about everthing as you are.

There is a flippancy in your post, a flippancy that suggests you have never been hurt by the actions of an affair.

You talk of the end outcome, yes you got what you wanted but did everybody else in this scenario get the same ? Were the children's lives as secure, safe, reasoned and ordered as they could have been, were there sacrifices made on behalf of the children and ex's ?

Until you have been betrayed I don't think you could ever imagine the hurt someone goes through and it's not just the big stuff like them having sex with someone else, it's the lies, it's just dreadful.

It almost becomes like a game, where the purpitrator gets off on the deceit, how many times can I fit the other person in, text and call in the shower, toilet, dog walk, local shop visit, taking the kids out to the park and fitting in a facetime.
Day in day out, lie upon lie and all the time the betrayed is out of the loop, looking like a mug, two people laughing at the victim and at the marriage.

And the best thing is, is that you still have no idea of what you have done, pat yourself on the back for your lack of empathy, you did it, you hurt another human being, day in day out for God knows how long.

How much less cruel would it be for people not to do this to another human and tell the truth well before the game of making a wife/husband feel and look like a complete and utter fool.

So in answer to your question, yes it worked out for you but God I would never admit I'd crucified someone by being complicit in inflicting such pain on another person and if you think I'm being overly dramatic then you just have no idea.

There are so many on here who know full well the reality of that pain.

This 100%.

iRun2eatCake · 30/04/2022 21:38

XH met OW and left me for her when l found evidence of his cheating.

Nearly 5 yrs on they are married.

I have never ever regretted marrying him. We loved each other so much. I have also never regretted divorcing him as we were both miserable at the end.

I don't condone affairs... but in our case it saved us both and we are both much happier.

The OW and l get along absolutely fine. XH and l co-parent well. The DC get on well with OW and she has made a huge effort to get to know them.

For us it's all worked out for the best

SquirrelG · 30/04/2022 21:32

Of course the outcome from affairs is sometimes good - but that still doesn't excuse having an affair. If you aren't happy in your relationship then you leave, and after that you can do whatever you like, but not before. Affairs cause untold harm to everyone - and especially to children. It's completely and utterly selfish.

Thinkbiglittleone · 30/04/2022 21:11

But because DH was the sole breadwinner it was harder for him.. despite paying for a cleaner/mothers help-/ cu pair.: for a non working pit the house mother .

I don't like a person who can't put their morals before tough decisions. Yes I'm sure his ex was awful and he was so put up, but he still had a choice to retain his morals. He chose not too.

He lied and he cheated. The people I know who have cheated have always been jealous in future relationships, as they knew how easy it was for them to cheat.

I'm glad you are happy, I'm glad your DH is happy, but there is no reason to cheat, own your own actions, do the right thing, leave before you take up a new relationship. Its the right thing to do.

LetHimHaveIt · 30/04/2022 21:10

myceliumama · 30/04/2022 20:41

My DH and I met while he was still married. He has been with her for 11 years. We became very close friends very quickly after meeting at university as mature students. She wasn't comfortable with it so we stopped being friends. A month later they separated and we had a fling. It was amazing. They decided to get back together and a few weeks later I found out that I was pregnant . They had been trying for years without success. I decided to keep the baby and we got together officially towards the end of my pregnancy. 4 kids later and twenty years down the line and we are still blissfully happy. She has also remarried and has kids too so it all worked out for the best.

I love my husband to bits. He really is my soulmate.

Heartwarming. Truly.

Gynaesaur · 30/04/2022 21:03

I agree that there are some situations where someone is unhappily married- because their spouse is horrible, not just because they're a bit bored or having a midlife crisis- where I wouldn't think too badly of them for having an affair. Or, at least, I'd struggle to feel especially sorry for the cheated on spouse.

But even then, it would be much better for them to have ended one relationship before beginning another. Affairs with all sorts of surrounding circumstances can work out well for the people conducting it. Not necessarily so much for the people who've been cheated on and especially not for any children involved.

It's occasionally an understandable decision but it's never a particularly good one.

Itsbackagain · 30/04/2022 21:00

Cheaters can make all the excuses they want to, they're still cheats and I wouldn't be with one, "unhappily" married or not. Shows their true colours.