Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Six year old just learned to write a sentence.

182 replies

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 11:38

I would like to gauge an idea of whether my six year old needs more work or not. She has been concentrating on sums and learning how to write.

She just turned six and she wrote 'i got a bag' on her own without help.

This is the first sentence she has written all by herself in her book unaided.

I know every child is different, but is this "behind" or not?

OP posts:
Sceptre86 · 30/04/2022 12:57

My child is 6, turned 6 at the end of March. She can write simple sentences, same as your child. She knows her common words and can spell them. Her teacher is pleased with her progress and has said she is exceeding those set. So I would say your son is doing well and as good as his peers. As you home school is their a curriculum you follow for literacy with benchmarks? For example if you are in the UK and in key stage 1 it tells you what children should be able to do by age 7.

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 12:56

Dinosaursdontgrowontrees · 30/04/2022 12:52

Just to give you an idea op, this was written this morning by my just turned 6year old. He did this alone with no help. He is considered by his teacher to be slightly behind with his writing.
I would echo what others have said though children who are home educated learn at a different pace to those at school. I really wouldn’t worry at this stage, she’s still very little.

That's really good and really helpful. Thank you.

OP posts:
clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 12:53

UnbeatenMum · 30/04/2022 12:50

When my children were in year R most of the class were achieving this by the end of the school year (so age 4y11m to 5y10m). Some were writing writing longer sentences and paragraphs. A few weren't yet and I guess they would have been 'working towards' expectations rather than meeting expectations. I know this because they invited parents to look around the classroom and had lots of work on the walls. Are you planning for her to enter the school system at some point?

No plans, we'll just respond to her needs.

OP posts:
Dinosaursdontgrowontrees · 30/04/2022 12:52

Just to give you an idea op, this was written this morning by my just turned 6year old. He did this alone with no help. He is considered by his teacher to be slightly behind with his writing.
I would echo what others have said though children who are home educated learn at a different pace to those at school. I really wouldn’t worry at this stage, she’s still very little.

Six year old just learned to write a sentence.
TeenyQueen · 30/04/2022 12:52

I used to teach Year 1. By the summer term I'd expect to see the neat letter formation, capital letters, finger spaces, full stops, conjunctions in longer sentences, adjectives and adverbs.

My bag is heavy because it has books in it.

I got a new bag and I love it.

I can carry my bag carefully.

I got a big red bag.

I got a bag.

See the difference?

The two main areas of writing in Yr1 are stories and recount. Could you do a fun activity with her and ask her to write about it? It's fine to model some trickier words and use a word mat, but she should be writing longer sentences now. The key is to be able to plan and say what you're going to write before writing it. Please look at the national curriculum online for some guidance.

MonsteraMother · 30/04/2022 12:52

Look at the early learning goals for the end of reception year. They show what children should be able to do when they are younger than your child.
Compared to an average UK school educated child, your child is behind. Simple sentences like that should be happening around 5 years old. I would be expecting several simple sentences from 6.5 year olds. But, there are lots of countries around the world where kids don't start writing till 7 years old and they end up doing better academically than those that start early.

katepilar · 30/04/2022 12:51

What is the reason you are worried, OP?
In most European countries children start school at the age of six or even seven years old and most of those would not be able to write until that age at all.
Some homeschooled-unschooled children cant write or read until the age of ten or even later.
Why did you pick this example of writing a sentence on her own? I'd say its great for six year old but its not really relevant to what she is going to achieve in life.

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 12:50

pleasegetreadyforbed · 30/04/2022 12:48

I just wanted to add if she's happy to write without being made to then that's amazing. Most children in school hate writing (because we teach too much, too soon).

Also it sounds like her maths is amazing, we've only just started covering sharing equally and most of the children are finding it tricky!!

Honestly she flew through the maths but I'm terrible at maths so she's going to need a tutor pretty soon as I will max out.

Her father was dyslexic and terrible at literacy and I do not want the same for her. I pushed her a bit, then focused on other things, and then she brought me the sentence. So I'm going to go back to English now and see about bringing her up to the levels I've seen here.

OP posts:
MarianosOnHisWay · 30/04/2022 12:50

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 12:41

It's not defensive but it's a huge question and I'm saying the reasons are just the same; it's what I think is going to give her the best education and the best opportunities in life. She can socialise with a peer group who will be interesting and varied.

I think the reasons will be the "same" in that we've chosen something we think will meet their needs.

That was my point and the reason for my question, not to be defensive.

I didn't say I was in difficulty either by the way, just seeking some input, which I've found very useful.

I've seen just from this thread that some would expect more, and a smaller group would expect less.

I'm listening to the ones who would expect more so I can aim the highest.

She wants to be a scientist so I envisage her taking GCSEs in science subjects when she is ready.

As for the English, it's so important to be literate that I want to ensure she remains along with the national average, which I can of course look up, but fancies some raw input from a more personal, perhaps judgemental perspective, so I could ensure she wasn't being sold short.

I don’t think it’s the “same” reasons- when the reason people have chosen school based education is due to the fact that their child will be taught by professionally trained experts, who know the expected outcomes for each stage etc.
That is not to say anything against home ed, by the way. But as PP says, if you choose home ed, you are choosing a particular way of learning and way of progressing where you can’t really compare it to school based. You’re comparing apples and oranges really.

UnbeatenMum · 30/04/2022 12:50

When my children were in year R most of the class were achieving this by the end of the school year (so age 4y11m to 5y10m). Some were writing writing longer sentences and paragraphs. A few weren't yet and I guess they would have been 'working towards' expectations rather than meeting expectations. I know this because they invited parents to look around the classroom and had lots of work on the walls. Are you planning for her to enter the school system at some point?

pleasegetreadyforbed · 30/04/2022 12:48

I just wanted to add if she's happy to write without being made to then that's amazing. Most children in school hate writing (because we teach too much, too soon).

Also it sounds like her maths is amazing, we've only just started covering sharing equally and most of the children are finding it tricky!!

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 12:48

Ihatethenewlook · 30/04/2022 12:45

I’d expect a homeschooled child to be further than this tbh. My youngest ds is 5 and a half and his homework for half term was to write a story that he’d be able to read out loud to the class. He wrote a story about an ant called Sid who went to the beach. He did have my help in coming up with an idea for a story that he’d be capable of writing on his own, but he came up with the sentences and did all the correct spellings and punctuation etc without help. I homeschooled my dd’s through lockdown and they were flying ahead by the time they went back to school due to the 1 on 1 teaching. My dd2 (currently panicking about sats) said only 2 days ago that she wished I could still homeschool her, as her teacher spends 20 minutes explaining things to the class and then constantly repeating it to the children who weren’t listening or don’t understand. She’d spend a full week learning something in school that I could cover and get her to understand in one morning.

That's brilliant. I remember doing stories about ants too. Also, my daughter loves ants. I'm going to formulate a project like this for when she gets back.

OP posts:
CatRatSplat · 30/04/2022 12:48

My year 1 daughter, can write a paragraph with 3 or 4 sentences. Her writing is clear with basic punctuation. The writing itself fits within the line (However she is a reluctant writer, so has to be coaxed).

What you describe is what my child was like in reception. However I know that a few in her class are still at this stage, but it is not the norm.

Ihatethenewlook · 30/04/2022 12:45

I’d expect a homeschooled child to be further than this tbh. My youngest ds is 5 and a half and his homework for half term was to write a story that he’d be able to read out loud to the class. He wrote a story about an ant called Sid who went to the beach. He did have my help in coming up with an idea for a story that he’d be capable of writing on his own, but he came up with the sentences and did all the correct spellings and punctuation etc without help. I homeschooled my dd’s through lockdown and they were flying ahead by the time they went back to school due to the 1 on 1 teaching. My dd2 (currently panicking about sats) said only 2 days ago that she wished I could still homeschool her, as her teacher spends 20 minutes explaining things to the class and then constantly repeating it to the children who weren’t listening or don’t understand. She’d spend a full week learning something in school that I could cover and get her to understand in one morning.

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 12:44

CrashBandicootOnSanityBeach · 30/04/2022 12:42

A 6 y.o. writing such a small sentence as that would suggest that she is a little behind. However, I wouldn't worry about it at the moment, because she will catch up eventually.

She'll catch up quickly yes and my focus in this area will now be some of the projects I've seen above. It really helps me to get this type of input so I can structure our weeks.

OP posts:
CrashBandicootOnSanityBeach · 30/04/2022 12:42

A 6 y.o. writing such a small sentence as that would suggest that she is a little behind. However, I wouldn't worry about it at the moment, because she will catch up eventually.

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 12:41

titchy · 30/04/2022 12:31

I think actually the question of why you have decided to home school is a good one for you to think about, rather than a flippant (defensive?) 'well why do you school educate' response.

The point of home educating I thought was to enable learning at a pace and content decided by the child - which is what the HE community you're involved in seems to embrace. Yet you appear to want her education to be at a pace set by you based on expectations of school learning. They seem diametrically opposed principles hence the difficulty you're now in and needing to seek external input.

Perhaps think about what you want for her a little more?

It's not defensive but it's a huge question and I'm saying the reasons are just the same; it's what I think is going to give her the best education and the best opportunities in life. She can socialise with a peer group who will be interesting and varied.

I think the reasons will be the "same" in that we've chosen something we think will meet their needs.

That was my point and the reason for my question, not to be defensive.

I didn't say I was in difficulty either by the way, just seeking some input, which I've found very useful.

I've seen just from this thread that some would expect more, and a smaller group would expect less.

I'm listening to the ones who would expect more so I can aim the highest.

She wants to be a scientist so I envisage her taking GCSEs in science subjects when she is ready.

As for the English, it's so important to be literate that I want to ensure she remains along with the national average, which I can of course look up, but fancies some raw input from a more personal, perhaps judgemental perspective, so I could ensure she wasn't being sold short.

OP posts:
FairyCakeWings · 30/04/2022 12:40

@cecilthehungryspider I’m guessing the hands mean conjunctions, words like and, so, but.

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 12:37

Mischance · 30/04/2022 12:27

Behind who/what?

Your DD will proceed at her own pace; and part of the joy of home education is to be free of these iniquitous comparisons. Well done for getting stuck into her teaching at home.

Thank you.

OP posts:
ProseccoStorm · 30/04/2022 12:36

I don't think it's hugely helpful to compare, your child will obviously be able to write when they get a little older.

There is also a big difference between between the skills in decoding (reading) and coding (writing) a language.

As you asked, my 5yr old is able to independently writing sentences. She could write a two part sentence with a linking word and an adjective. She might forget to capitalise the first letter, or she might forget the full stop. The spellings would be 80% there but complicated words would be incorrect. Eg she knows all the usual tricky words such as 'was' but beautiful would be 'bootiful'.

cecilthehungryspider · 30/04/2022 12:35

Here's a piece of work (if the photo works) from my child's year 1 book. You can see the prompts at the top showing what they are expected to include: capital letters, punctuation, finger spaces, phonics knowledge, I can't remember what the hands mean, 2A means their sentences should contain 2 adjectives.

Six year old just learned to write a sentence.
titchy · 30/04/2022 12:31

I think actually the question of why you have decided to home school is a good one for you to think about, rather than a flippant (defensive?) 'well why do you school educate' response.

The point of home educating I thought was to enable learning at a pace and content decided by the child - which is what the HE community you're involved in seems to embrace. Yet you appear to want her education to be at a pace set by you based on expectations of school learning. They seem diametrically opposed principles hence the difficulty you're now in and needing to seek external input.

Perhaps think about what you want for her a little more?

cloudcats · 30/04/2022 12:29

I know it's not what you asked, but in case it's useful...

DD's school uses a website called Doodle Learning for maths and English homework and DD loves it.

www.doodlelearning.com

Also, we discovered Outschool during lockdown - live online classes on thousands of different topics for small groups of kids. Some of them have been brilliant. There are one off sessions and regular classes.

outschool.com

Mischance · 30/04/2022 12:27

Behind who/what?

Your DD will proceed at her own pace; and part of the joy of home education is to be free of these iniquitous comparisons. Well done for getting stuck into her teaching at home.

TheSnowyOwl · 30/04/2022 12:26

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 11:47

I am her teacher, she is home educated.

If she is not where she should be I would like to know so I can help her improve.

I have focused on the very basics with a view to her learning how to use "tools" as it were to count, add, subtract, and really hammered the letters in and now she is starting to use that all on her own.

Then on the basis that unlike most six years olds, she won’t have had a disrupted start to her education, I would say she is ok. There are plenty in my six year old’s class who have had a disrupted education who are significantly better and the last term’s homework included writing a short review about a film which is what the age is expected to be able to do. However, there will always be plenty who aren’t at standard and it’s very normal at this age to be behind without it signifying that the child will be behind at a later date.