Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Six year old just learned to write a sentence.

182 replies

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 11:38

I would like to gauge an idea of whether my six year old needs more work or not. She has been concentrating on sums and learning how to write.

She just turned six and she wrote 'i got a bag' on her own without help.

This is the first sentence she has written all by herself in her book unaided.

I know every child is different, but is this "behind" or not?

OP posts:
clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 13:16

Chooksnroses · 30/04/2022 13:13

My Grandson was nine when he really started reading...home educated following the Scandinavian principle of learning through play, and not starting any formal teaching until age 7. He now powers his way through books like Harry Potter, or text books about his many interests. I fully expect him to go to University when he's older, like his cousin who was also home educated.
Your little girl seems to be doing fine, and I think you should relax and let her follow her interests , then provide materials to enable her to extend her knowledge. The advantage of what you're doing is that you can have a much more holistic approach to her education.

Thanks. It's very holistic yes. She likes physical stuff so does clubs for that. We do meet ups and days out.

She's definitely advanced in some areas.

I appreciate what you've said. I just want to reiterate I'm not "worried", I'm just looking for some input from a specific group of people.

Thank you again. I agree with you.

OP posts:
Aroundtheworldin80moves · 30/04/2022 13:16

You say her father is dyslexic... it runs in families. So she may need a different approach to learn.

How is her reading and comprehension?

With her science kits, do you record the results, guess whats going to happen before doing it, compare things? Writing doesn't just happen in English.

YvanEhtNiojYvanEhtNioj · 30/04/2022 13:14

Sorry, didn't read all your posts. I didn't see you were home-schooling DC.

watcherintherye · 30/04/2022 13:14

I'm not sure what you are suggesting I don't realise, sorry?

It just sounded like you thought taking GCSE Sciences would be enough to pursue a career, which I’m sure you don’t! A friend of mine home educated her ds, until it became clear that his ambition (to go to Oxbridge) would probably be better served by a more conventional route. But that’s many years down the line for your dd, of course, should that be the case.

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 13:14

JS87 · 30/04/2022 13:09

DS in year 6 would never have created anything like that in year 1. His writing was basically illegible. Even now he forgets capital letters and his writing is pretty messy. However is he working between expected and at greater depth for his English sats so I think what they can do in year 1 varies a lot.

So, can I ask you; do you and his teachers consider him to be "behind"?

I ask because that's been suggested a few times on this thread.

OP posts:
ApolloandDaphne · 30/04/2022 13:13

At 6 my DD2 could read and write nothing. She was not interested. She now has a first class degree and a good job. Age 6 is far too young to be worrying. My Finnish nieces and nephews hadn't even a begun school by that age! Children all develop at different times.

Chooksnroses · 30/04/2022 13:13

My Grandson was nine when he really started reading...home educated following the Scandinavian principle of learning through play, and not starting any formal teaching until age 7. He now powers his way through books like Harry Potter, or text books about his many interests. I fully expect him to go to University when he's older, like his cousin who was also home educated.
Your little girl seems to be doing fine, and I think you should relax and let her follow her interests , then provide materials to enable her to extend her knowledge. The advantage of what you're doing is that you can have a much more holistic approach to her education.

YvanEhtNiojYvanEhtNioj · 30/04/2022 13:11

My sister teaches 6-7 year olds. Most of them can't even read letters yet. They just run feral "learn through play" all day long.
You should be asking your DC's teacher about their progress not a bunch of strangers on the internet.

JS87 · 30/04/2022 13:09

DS in year 6 would never have created anything like that in year 1. His writing was basically illegible. Even now he forgets capital letters and his writing is pretty messy. However is he working between expected and at greater depth for his English sats so I think what they can do in year 1 varies a lot.

Foldinthecheese · 30/04/2022 13:08

I have 6yo twin boys and they do a writing workshop every Monday at school. They write about something they did over the weekend and draw a picture to illustrate it. I think it’s a lovely way to let them write about something of their own choosing, and they often chat about their chosen subject in advance.

Saying that, one of them has always been enthusiastic about writing independently, creating his own books. They wrote a book about colours together over Christmas. Just try to give her lots of opportunities to write independently about subjects she enjoys. One of mine has terrible handwriting and the other has awful spelling, but their teachers and I just gently continue to work on that stuff while being enthusiastic about what they have created.

Onesundaymorning · 30/04/2022 13:08

Have a look at the CLPE writing scales. This will give you a good idea of progression in writing.

Hesma · 30/04/2022 13:07

My dyslexic 9 year wouldn’t manage that alone. Don’t compare, just support and encourage. Celebrate every effort even if not perfect

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 13:06

Hellospring22 · 30/04/2022 12:59

I home educated my now year 2 child for a year after the initial covid lockdown. She remained on roll during this time and she returned to school a year ago at exactly the point your child is currently at the expectation by this period was that she could write about half a page of text. They’d been working up to this since before Christmas. So I’d say she’s behind where and average school educated child would be expected to be. Home education is very different, though and as others have said education is different across the world. I think it depend on what your long term plans are re education. We always intended for my daughter to return to school but if you’re wanting to know the curriculum objectives these can be found online. I used Twinkl PlanIt a lot to ensure my daughter remained on track and she returned to school perfectly on track. This was with only 1 to 1.5 hours of education a day so was easily achieved. Your child is an individual though.

I was looking for an idea of where to bring her up to, which I've got. I was looking for harsh criticism and harsh judgement, which I got.

OP posts:
ShandaLear · 30/04/2022 13:05

I think if you’re teaching her you really need to start reading more about child development and milestones. Coming on to a forum like this to ask such a question when it’s easily googleable suggests you’re not quite sure what you’re doing.

MarianosOnHisWay · 30/04/2022 13:05

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 12:59

It's funny you know. Just in this microcosm here where I've sought input I've seen people say that yes, she is behind and that school is best because professionals deliver the education.

Then a couple of things like this where it seems perhaps the teachers weren't best.

Well, why leave it up to chance when I can deliver the education myself, basically.

Sorry to hear about your son. I hope he's doing much better now.

I didn’t say school is best because it is delivered by professionals. You said that the reasons you chose home ed were the same reasons that other people chose school ed- i.e. because they want the best for their children. I agreed, but I said that part of the reason people choose school ed is that it is taught by professionals, which is the exact opposite of the reason some choose to home ed. Home ed and school ed are so different, you really can’t compare them and you really can’t compare where a home ed child would be educationally with where a school ed child would be, in many ways both positive and negative. As I said, apples and oranges.

IvorCutler · 30/04/2022 13:04

It’s absolutely fine.

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 13:04

FeetupTvon · 30/04/2022 13:03

I work with 6/7 year old.
This is perfectly normal and certainly not a cause for concern.

Others here have said different.

Why do you think this discrepancy exists?

OP posts:
clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 13:03

watcherintherye · 30/04/2022 12:57

She wants to be a scientist so I envisage her taking GCSEs in science subjects when she is ready.

It’s just the way this was written, I’m sure, and I know you will be aware that the interface between home schooling and conventional education becomes most difficult at the point where a child wishes to pursue a particular academic route. To become a scientist will involve going to university. To access the very best Universities, she will need more than Science GCSEs. I’m assuming that’s not what you meant, and maybe you anticipate her taking GCSEs in science earlier than her other GCSEs?

I'm not sure what you are suggesting I don't realise, sorry?

OP posts:
FeetupTvon · 30/04/2022 13:03

I work with 6/7 year old.
This is perfectly normal and certainly not a cause for concern.

Kennykenkencat · 30/04/2022 13:00

TeenyQueen · 30/04/2022 12:52

I used to teach Year 1. By the summer term I'd expect to see the neat letter formation, capital letters, finger spaces, full stops, conjunctions in longer sentences, adjectives and adverbs.

My bag is heavy because it has books in it.

I got a new bag and I love it.

I can carry my bag carefully.

I got a big red bag.

I got a bag.

See the difference?

The two main areas of writing in Yr1 are stories and recount. Could you do a fun activity with her and ask her to write about it? It's fine to model some trickier words and use a word mat, but she should be writing longer sentences now. The key is to be able to plan and say what you're going to write before writing it. Please look at the national curriculum online for some guidance.

What happens if you don’t see that

What do you do with children who don’t get to that standard

Hellospring22 · 30/04/2022 12:59

I home educated my now year 2 child for a year after the initial covid lockdown. She remained on roll during this time and she returned to school a year ago at exactly the point your child is currently at the expectation by this period was that she could write about half a page of text. They’d been working up to this since before Christmas. So I’d say she’s behind where and average school educated child would be expected to be. Home education is very different, though and as others have said education is different across the world. I think it depend on what your long term plans are re education. We always intended for my daughter to return to school but if you’re wanting to know the curriculum objectives these can be found online. I used Twinkl PlanIt a lot to ensure my daughter remained on track and she returned to school perfectly on track. This was with only 1 to 1.5 hours of education a day so was easily achieved. Your child is an individual though.

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 12:59

Kennykenkencat · 30/04/2022 12:57

Ds went to school and by year 3 couldn’t read or write.

I ended up taking him out of school because he wasn’t being taught anything and having to do homework which involved him copying my writing in pencil was just torture.

School broke him and he has never really recovered

It's funny you know. Just in this microcosm here where I've sought input I've seen people say that yes, she is behind and that school is best because professionals deliver the education.

Then a couple of things like this where it seems perhaps the teachers weren't best.

Well, why leave it up to chance when I can deliver the education myself, basically.

Sorry to hear about your son. I hope he's doing much better now.

OP posts:
clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 12:58

katepilar · 30/04/2022 12:51

What is the reason you are worried, OP?
In most European countries children start school at the age of six or even seven years old and most of those would not be able to write until that age at all.
Some homeschooled-unschooled children cant write or read until the age of ten or even later.
Why did you pick this example of writing a sentence on her own? I'd say its great for six year old but its not really relevant to what she is going to achieve in life.

I'm not worried, I'm just looking to hold myself to a high standard in what I get her to do.

I agree learning through play is good but we are just beginning to be much more structured now that I've lessened my work commitments.

OP posts:
Kennykenkencat · 30/04/2022 12:57

FairyCakeWings · 30/04/2022 11:47

If she’s just turned six, then I assume she’s in Y1?

Honestly, we would expect much more than that for a child to be at the expected standard at this stage in Y1. You can Google the expected standards to see what the government expects children to be able to do by this stage, but the most important thing you can do is talk to your child’s teacher. The progress that your child is making is more important than what they’re capable of.

Ds went to school and by year 3 couldn’t read or write.

I ended up taking him out of school because he wasn’t being taught anything and having to do homework which involved him copying my writing in pencil was just torture.

School broke him and he has never really recovered

watcherintherye · 30/04/2022 12:57

She wants to be a scientist so I envisage her taking GCSEs in science subjects when she is ready.

It’s just the way this was written, I’m sure, and I know you will be aware that the interface between home schooling and conventional education becomes most difficult at the point where a child wishes to pursue a particular academic route. To become a scientist will involve going to university. To access the very best Universities, she will need more than Science GCSEs. I’m assuming that’s not what you meant, and maybe you anticipate her taking GCSEs in science earlier than her other GCSEs?