Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Six year old just learned to write a sentence.

182 replies

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 11:38

I would like to gauge an idea of whether my six year old needs more work or not. She has been concentrating on sums and learning how to write.

She just turned six and she wrote 'i got a bag' on her own without help.

This is the first sentence she has written all by herself in her book unaided.

I know every child is different, but is this "behind" or not?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CreatingAUsernameThen · 30/04/2022 21:26

cockeyedoptimist · 30/04/2022 19:12

I haven’t read the full thread so apologies if I’m repeating what others have said
As a reception teacher I would say that writing a simple sentence ( using cvc words ) is only just about expected level at end of Reception . Obviously not all
children are at this level but anyone working here should be targeted for catching up in year 1
As an aside I find it unusual as a home Ed parent that you’re asking on mumsnet . Are there not specialist online groups to give support to HE parents for exactly this situation

Yes, but if she posted this there, she'd be vilified for doing 'school at home'. There is unfortunately a large online voice who are very against anything until late primary really. (Despite education being compulsory from 5). She'd get a huge flood of people telling her she's doing it wrong, let her play and it is way beyond expectations.

Home education/ homeschooling is more accepted in America, and Unschooling isn't as common there. I tend to get sensible answers in American groups but it probably hadn't occurred to OP so she came here.

1984Winston · 30/04/2022 19:31

My DD6 is not much beyond this but she has struggled with reading and writing (she's great at maths though) but she is progressing and is miles ahead of where she was at the beginning of the year and that's all that matters, she will catch up and she had a very disruptive first year obviously. I honestly wouldn't worry as long as you can see her progressing

ShopoholicIn · 30/04/2022 19:21

Hi ,
I think your DC is a bit behind. My DC at reception in November- December, so 2-3 months after starting school, was given a project to right about a certain animal. The teacher wasn't very happy that he didn't describe each species in sentences...I was shocked, for me it was a big deal what he had done and I was very pleased, but of course the other kids were writing sentences by then.

cockeyedoptimist · 30/04/2022 19:12

I haven’t read the full thread so apologies if I’m repeating what others have said
As a reception teacher I would say that writing a simple sentence ( using cvc words ) is only just about expected level at end of Reception . Obviously not all
children are at this level but anyone working here should be targeted for catching up in year 1
As an aside I find it unusual as a home Ed parent that you’re asking on mumsnet . Are there not specialist online groups to give support to HE parents for exactly this situation

OfstedOffred · 30/04/2022 19:07

Remember too OP, writing doesnt just mean "handwriting". Lots hate writing at 5 and 6 because they lack the fine motor skills to execute it, not because of their language or comprehension.

Have you tried sometimes letting her type, or dictate to you, so that she is also getting opportunities where she is solely focussing on sentence construction/content and not on letter formation?

How is her reading? Is she reasonable fluid and secure with phonics? Writing tends to lag behind reading so I would focus on the reading initially.

toomuchlaundry · 30/04/2022 18:52

If she wants to do science, will you be able to cover the curriculum as she gets older? Are you going to homeschool though secondary. Is your DD happy about being homeschooled?

OfstedOffred · 30/04/2022 18:52

I would consider that behind for year 1.

In DS reception class, a couple of children were early starters and are reading at green/orange level, a decent chunk have just gone to blue this term, most of the rest are on yellow. There's a small group who are struggling on pink/red.

In writing, around 2/3 of the class would be writing sentences like your daughter has written, or longer. The better half of the class would be independently writing g (eg a caption for a picture) things like "it is a mummy bird/burd with her eggs/egs", or even adding a second sentence.

At our school (Ofsted good) by the last term or y1 they would be expecting several sentences and quite a lot of correct spelling.

cloudcats · 30/04/2022 18:44

Regularsizedrudy · 30/04/2022 18:42

It’s “learnt” in the U.K. mostly

But learned is correct also. Your point? Hmm

Regularsizedrudy · 30/04/2022 18:42

It’s “learnt” in the U.K. mostly

Lunalae · 30/04/2022 18:39

clairemaddox · 30/04/2022 11:47

I am her teacher, she is home educated.

If she is not where she should be I would like to know so I can help her improve.

I have focused on the very basics with a view to her learning how to use "tools" as it were to count, add, subtract, and really hammered the letters in and now she is starting to use that all on her own.

Are you following some sort of curriculum or guide? Children in school write daily, they've got all sorts of lovely sentences coming out of Reception and Year 1. I'm a bit eyebrow-raisy at a 6 year old finally stringing four words together.

It's, er, nice she gets to build models at home but if you've decided you're the best person to be responsible for her entire education, don't neglect literacy and numeracy for letting the kid 'do what she likes', unless she plans to live a life of leisure.

WalkerWalking · 30/04/2022 18:22

I think if you're going to homeschool then you either need to download all the national curriculum standards and expectations (the descriptions of "working towards" and "greater depth" or whatever they call it these days) and monitor progress this way, OR you need to put it out of your mind and do your own thing.

Vague comparisons from unqualified strangers are honestly not helpful. And if you asked the same question 3 times on this same forum, the 3 sets of replies would follow 3 very different paths 🤷‍♀️

Trudij123 · 30/04/2022 18:17

katepilar · 30/04/2022 13:29

Reading further, OP, I have a feeling your reason for home educating is because you want your child to be better /in some areas/ than a school educated child.

I think it would be great if you could let go of your own aspirations and concentrated on what your child is good at and interested in rather then push her in areas she is not ready for yet or not that interested in.

Btw I also found your answer about the reason why you want to homeschool weird, possibly defensive. As if you dont have a reason, or a well articulated reason. Later you mentioned you want to tailor the educations to her needs but to me it seems you are tailoring it to your own needs driven by your anxiety that your child wont be good enough.

I agree with @katepilar and some others - OP, with the best will in the world it honestly sounds to me like you’ve got inferiority issues that you’re trying really hard to not let your daughter develop - but in doing so you’re inadvertently pushing for something that’s just not there right now and if you push too hard too soon you could break her.

you don’t have to try and keep up with the Jones’ let alone better them…

( and calling the HE people “Lax” is very rude I feel !)

ADayInTheLifeOfMe · 30/04/2022 17:32

Part of DD6 Y1 home learning set by her school during lockdown was writing a basic story with a beginning, middle and end.

liveforsummer · 30/04/2022 17:10

The 6 year olds in my class are learning to write simple sentences and started probably after February break. There are in a cohort who are beginning to turn 7 and some can do it relatively easily and many can't. No point in comparing. At this age the range of ability is pretty large and covid has affected things a lot too. If she's keen that's the main thing

2022NameChange · 30/04/2022 16:44

Whilst I don't think I could ever home educate personally, I am definitely not against it, and a family I worked for home educated their little girl, but loosely followed the NC as they always planned to put her back into school for secondary (which they have done now and she's in top sets for everything). The first 3 years she was behind, really behind in literacy, but then somewhere in the 3rd year she just absolutely flourished and everything sort of clicked and then she was ahead of the NC, reading books designed for secondary aged children by 10 and absolutely loved learning. There is no right time, just focus on her love of learning and support as best you can.

Awumminnscotland · 30/04/2022 16:35

Just to add. In case people aren't aware, the Scottish curriculum is completely different to the English system with different expectations at different levels.

Hellospring22 · 30/04/2022 16:32

No problem, I was worried I’d unintentionally offended you. I’d definitely have a look at the curriculum objectives and go from there, it’ll give you an indication of the standard expectations and you can then adapt these depending on how you feel about it. I hope it goes well. The beauty of home education is being able to focus on whatever you want / need to.

katepilar · 30/04/2022 16:31

Imknackeredzzz · 30/04/2022 14:23

Ok I’m ready to get slaughtered - but I just don’t get the home education thing. I appreciate in some situations it’s absolutely the right course, but just to deprive your child of school just because you want to sounds nuts.

I know I’m going to get all sorts of abuse for saying so, but school has so many benefits, peer interaction, learning different boundary’s, structure, coming out of your comfort zone, never mind the learning aspect.

I just don’t get how keeping everything so insular does any sort of service to the child, eventually they’ll have to get out in the real world with a real lack of experience in it!

sorry I hope it goes well but I genuinely don’t get it

If you are genuinly interested there will be lots of info available, both here on MN and internet. The OP didnt come on here for you to tell her you disapprove of homeschooling while you hadnt even made an effort to see why people do it.

Favouritefruits · 30/04/2022 16:28

My eight year old could write a sentence in reception and my youngest is in nursery he could write a simple sentence but I know a lot of his peers couldn’t. Children have fallen behind because of COVID, I think your child sounds a little behind but I bet lots of their class is too.

WhoopItUp · 30/04/2022 16:23

This is my 5 year, two month year old. They are in the top group in reception.

Six year old just learned to write a sentence.
CP2701 · 30/04/2022 16:14

When it comes to writing, I would discuss with her what she's going to write and then create a word bank together. So write some words for her that can't be sounded out.

Then, leave her to write her own sentences using the word bank you've created together. She will still need to add her own common words and words that can be easily sounded out.

Spelling at this stage isn't massively important. It's more about being able to hear the sounds in words, break them down and write them as you hear them. If you get too hung up on spelling every word correctly, children become reluctant to write.

Work on common words recognition and spellings regularly so she can confidently include them in her writing.

CreatingAUsernameThen · 30/04/2022 15:57

My home educated year 1 child can write more than that but is behind her school educated cousin the same age/ year in every regard for English... reading, writing and grammar knowledge/ understanding. But also she can tell you about the collapse of Rome and play keyboard a bit which her cousin can't do! 😉
But I'm not worried, I am pretty certain in my curricum choices for English and she'll be on track or ahead by end of year 6.
I'd say she is behind compared to school, but I bet your little one knows lots of other things!! She'll catch up. Progress and varied education is all that matters really.

Awumminnscotland · 30/04/2022 15:43

I haven't read through the whole thread.
My child is in P1 in Scotland. By this time of year they're all 5 or 6. That level of sentence would be within normal levels for my child's class. Some will be a bit better. Your approach sounds similar to our school where they teach the tools they need and really have deep understanding of all the concepts.
My 6 Yr old is currently, learning how to write a sentence correctly, capital letter, finger space, on the line, full stop.
Comprehension and story writing tools. Correctly writing all common and tricky words learned. Correct formation of letters and acceptable size. They really hammer all these things as well as punctuation and are expected to be accurate in their use of this when attempting it. There'll be other stuff but I won't realise it. The national benchmarks for Scotland go from age 3 to P1. Then P2 3 and 4. The acceptable levels leave room for individual progress.
Your approach sounds great and she'll likely take off quickly from where she is. Like others have said. The fact that she's initiating it herself is perfect.

colouringfoxes · 30/04/2022 15:37

I just double checked curriculum expectations here to make sure she's not horrendously behind, and in her year she should have covered the alphabet (which she has), but not expected to read fluently. Education isn't compulsory here until 6 years old so I think she's doing okay.
My point is that expectations vary massively according to culture and country, so even if your kid isn't in line with her UK peers in everything right now, it's not necessarily a problem if you're not planning on sending her to school in the next couple of years and she can progress more at her own rate until end of primary.

Side note: ofc what she wants to do in future may well change, but even if she wants to be a scientist, remember she'll need more than just science GCSEs to do that, to go to college for A levels (unlikely you can provide A level grade science practicals safely at home) and uni.

colouringfoxes · 30/04/2022 15:23

I'm not in the UK and know an almost 6 year old who can only really reliably write her name, mama, and papa, can just about blend basic consonant-vowel-consonant words, and definitely wouldn't be able to write anything like a sentence. The kids seem to have an equivalent level of education by the time they get to secondary (where I teach), and higher in languages.