Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU? GP refusing my mum a blue badge

231 replies

JollyJunee · 30/04/2022 06:02

I’m so cross with my mum’s GP! Maybe we are in the wrong.
Mum is in her 80s. She has a pacemaker and defib due to a genetic heart condition. She can walk upstairs but slowly and would sometimes need to stop half way up. If we were walking and there was an incline/steep bit, she would have to rest. If it was more than a domestic flight of stairs she wouldn’t even try it.
she walks the dog every day. Slowly, on a totally flat route. She has told me that on the ‘bad’ days she knows the spots where there is a bench/low wall and she can rest.
She also has severe diverticular disease and would occasionally have pretty big bleeds from that which leaves her totally wiped out for a few days. She asked about blue badge last year, and GP refused to fill in the form. Told my mum he wasn’t allowed to lie and she can walk perfectly well. But she struggles a lot at times. He told her if she walks and doesn’t get her heart rate up it’s not worth walking at all.
she saw new cardiologist recently with me. We asked him about it and he was amazed GP refused. Said he would write on the letter to GP about mums issues again. He is arranging a procedure for my mum and it will definitely set her back for a while. She saw GP again today and really fought her case, but GP adamant, my mum can walk and so doesn’t need a blue badge.
Are we being lazy so and so? I would have thought my mum was an ideal person for a blue badge? It’s really knocking her. AIBU?

OP posts:
caecilius1 · 30/04/2022 12:52

@Blossomtoes
You don't know if the obese man with a limp also has heart failure, chronic kidney disease, COPD and an autoimmune disorder which means he's on oral steroids -which have contributed to his weight. All of these things are hidden to the non-clinical member of the public. All you need to know is that a clinical person has assessed his application and evidence, and deemed him as meeting the threshold for a BB.
Don't let it boil your piss, it's none of your business quite frankly.

danni0509 · 30/04/2022 12:50

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 12:39

I’m not in the least judgemental. The reason I needed a blue badge for my mum was because she used a wheelchair - the marking on the disabled spaces is a bit of a clue as to who qualifies for one. Obviously someone who’s blind merits one. The extremely obese man with a limp probably doesn’t.

The first part and the last part contradict each other.

Morph22010 · 30/04/2022 12:45

Limp not lump that should say

Morph22010 · 30/04/2022 12:45

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 12:39

I’m not in the least judgemental. The reason I needed a blue badge for my mum was because she used a wheelchair - the marking on the disabled spaces is a bit of a clue as to who qualifies for one. Obviously someone who’s blind merits one. The extremely obese man with a limp probably doesn’t.

You say you are not in
the least bit judgemental but then say the extremely obese man with a lump probably doesn’t. How do you know he doesn’t? Maybe he’s got another condition meaning he can’t walk far and that’s why he’s become obese as he’s struggled to exercise at all. The point is you just don’t know only the blue badge assessors do and he would have had to supply evidence same as anyone else

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 12:39

I’m not in the least judgemental. The reason I needed a blue badge for my mum was because she used a wheelchair - the marking on the disabled spaces is a bit of a clue as to who qualifies for one. Obviously someone who’s blind merits one. The extremely obese man with a limp probably doesn’t.

EmmatheStageRat · 30/04/2022 12:20

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 12:06

I had the same thing with my mum’s GP. Even after she started using a wheelchair they wouldn’t give in. I started using parent and child spaces. The thing that boiled my piss was the number of people I saw with blue badges who could walk far better than she could.

I’m always shocked by how many posters on here who are affected by disabilities within their nuclear families are so judgmental about the disabilities suffered by others. My teen has a Blue Badge and would probably ‘boil your piss’ because she can walk without any difficulty but she is blind and so is in danger of being knocked down walking across any car park, especially as she has no visible marker to her sight loss such as a Guide Dog or a mobility cane.

Morph22010 · 30/04/2022 12:16

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 12:06

I had the same thing with my mum’s GP. Even after she started using a wheelchair they wouldn’t give in. I started using parent and child spaces. The thing that boiled my piss was the number of people I saw with blue badges who could walk far better than she could.

But it’s not necessarily for not being able to walk, you don’t know why they got the blue badge

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 12:06

I had the same thing with my mum’s GP. Even after she started using a wheelchair they wouldn’t give in. I started using parent and child spaces. The thing that boiled my piss was the number of people I saw with blue badges who could walk far better than she could.

SpindleInTheWind · 30/04/2022 12:04

Doggydarling · 30/04/2022 11:57

Can I pm you? Have some experience, am also in ROI

Sorry @Doggydarling I wasn't shouting at you Grin Far from it.

Glad you can help.

SpindleInTheWind · 30/04/2022 12:02

THE OP IS IN IRELAND not the UK

Doggydarling · 30/04/2022 11:57

Can I pm you? Have some experience, am also in ROI

HealthProbs · 30/04/2022 11:49

GP doesn't get to decide. I have one for MS but I'm arguably more mobile than your mum most days. I just had to provide my diagnosis letter and then I had a phone interview.

caecilius1 · 30/04/2022 11:36

In the UK, it's usually an Occupational Therapist attached to the local council who decides whether to issue a blue badge. Their decision to issue a BB is based on the evidence submitted with the application.
I do agree with @MissLucyEyelesbarrow, of course there's a hierarchy of disability, it's an undeniable fact. However, the BB system isn't tiered.

roarfeckingroarr · 30/04/2022 11:15

It's because you admitted to her walking the dog. I recently applied for one for my 78 year old dad (successfully). He sounds very similar to your mum in terms of mobility; he has a heart condition and kidney problems. I took the approach of "don't lie but talk about the worst days".

Underhisi · 30/04/2022 11:00

"She's borderline for the U.K. criteria. The main advantage of a blue badge is actually the wider space so you can get a wheelchair around the side or if you need to open the door fully and assist them with a seatbelt"

The UK criteria isn't based upon needing space to get out. Needing space ( as the only need) doesn't qualify anyone for a blue badge.

People who can take their dog for a walk can qualify but it depends upon the medical reason they are claiming under.

Morph22010 · 30/04/2022 10:55

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 30/04/2022 09:12

It's such utter bollocks to say that there is no hierarchy of disability. Of course there is. It may feel lovely and affirming to deny that, but the upshot is that the most disabled lose out, because the less disabled use scarce resources that they don't absolutely need. It would be wonderful if there were enough blue badge spaces for everyone with mild mobility restrictions. There aren't. Every blue badge issued to someone who doesn't absolutely need it means less resources for the most disabled.

And the whole point of the GP's refusal is that he feels the OP's DM does not meet the criteria.

The trouble is though how does this actually work in practise as you would have to grade every single person who has a blue badge and even then their needs can be different on different days so it will never be totally fair, constantly changing and be an administrative nightmare. You would like to think that people with a Bluse badge choose not to use if there is an alternative viable option at the time. I’ve been awarded one for my son but he’s not in a wheelchair so if there was plenty of other spaces available even slightly further away id use them as the wheelchair user needs the bigger space. However you then have wheelchair users that need the bigger space but are extremely fit and do marathons so once they are out the car they don’t need to be close- where should they go in the hiararchy? It’s just so variable that a system of you qualify or don’t qualify is all they can do

thereisonlyoneofme · 30/04/2022 10:14

I was given a blue badge because I was diagnosed with terminal cancer. I didnt even see the form, the hospice filled it in and submitted it. I am able to walk but I dont know if it was given because I have been on chemo a lot. I actually only use mine if there is nowhere to park on a road, as I can park on yellow lines.
It is reviewed every 3 years I think.

FredaFox · 30/04/2022 09:37

ilovesooty · 30/04/2022 06:12

If she can walk the dog, even if she needs to take rests, it sounds as though she may not meet the criteria. I understand that the requirements are pretty stiff. She evidently does have limiting health issues but possibly not sufficiently severe to qualify for a badge.

I agree with this. While clearly she has issues she's walking type dog daily so has mobility even if she she stops at benches
I found it quite strict sorting my mums. Even at renewal stage I have to complete multiple pages of forms. My mum can barely walk a few steps or stand for more than 30 seconds unaided

IWantToBeNynaeve · 30/04/2022 09:36

JollyJunee · 30/04/2022 06:54

So many replies! I’m literally scooting out the door to work, so will have a look this evening.
We are RoI, I thought it had to be a GP? Her cardiologist was very surprised GP was refusing, but see the dog walking may be the issue. She always says she makes herself do it no matter how hard, as she adores the wee doggie. Thanks for input.

Here in Ireland it can be your gp or consultant who certifies you meet the criteria, so your mum's cardiologist can do it, no need for the gp at all ;). That's according to the citizens advice page.

TheGoogleMum · 30/04/2022 09:30

I dont know much about these things but I'm surprised the GP doesn't think she is eligible. A friend of mine has one with cystic fibrosis - she can walk its just longer distances are harder. Doesn't sound so dissimilar to be honest. Blue badge often means parking closer to shops which can be a big help when walking is a struggle

StScholastica · 30/04/2022 09:29

She can walk the dog, she can walk from a car to a shop. Stop trying it on OP.
The GP is right to encourage her to stay active.
You are going to damage the relationship and trust between your DM and her GP by complaining about this.

emuloc · 30/04/2022 09:27

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 30/04/2022 09:12

It's such utter bollocks to say that there is no hierarchy of disability. Of course there is. It may feel lovely and affirming to deny that, but the upshot is that the most disabled lose out, because the less disabled use scarce resources that they don't absolutely need. It would be wonderful if there were enough blue badge spaces for everyone with mild mobility restrictions. There aren't. Every blue badge issued to someone who doesn't absolutely need it means less resources for the most disabled.

And the whole point of the GP's refusal is that he feels the OP's DM does not meet the criteria.

There is no hierarchy of disability. Do we start grading people according to what conditions they have, and deciding how disabled a person is compared to the next person with the same condition? If the OP mother is awarding a BB and is able to walk, why do you think it is acceptable to say that she should she be more concerned about someone who can not walk at all, using a BB parking space. If a person is awarded a BB, than they have qualified for one. They are not handed out like sweeties for nothing. So less of the more, or less disabled talk please. It is not helpful at all.

starfishmummy · 30/04/2022 09:25

CatsOperatingInGangs · 30/04/2022 06:12

Have you checked the Blue Badge form on Gov.Uk? The guidance is pretty clear on there. You usually need to qualify for PIP to get one.

That's not true. People over a certain age can't claim PIP anyway. Their route for a Blue Badge is via a Doctors report and assessment by someone in the local blue badge team.

DaphneSprucesPippasClack · 30/04/2022 09:20

Another vote for you just apply to your local council not via your gp. Unless it's different for ROI.

Fuuuuuckit · 30/04/2022 09:18

Hmmmm. OP you say she walks the dog, albeit with planned bench/wall sitting stops. But then she needs a blue badge to get (from the car) to the shops but would be OK walking around them?

With kindness op, I think you are underestimating how much people with disabilities rely on blue badges, and how their everyday life is impacted by mobility issues. Every aspect of their lives, and often with no improvement in sight.

Both my grandparents had blue badges, and when we got to the shoping centre or supermarket we'd plonk them in a cafe and they'd sit awhile whilst we did all their running about. They could no more manage to walk round Sainsburys than I could fly to the moon. Unfortunately old age brings ill health and deteriorating mobility, but if she still has the ability to walk the dog and mooch round the supermarket then I think she could find other ways to manage her expectations at 80years old. Even after a bleed, she should be recovering rather than wanting to be running to the shops. I'm sorry if that sounds harsh.