Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU? GP refusing my mum a blue badge

231 replies

JollyJunee · 30/04/2022 06:02

I’m so cross with my mum’s GP! Maybe we are in the wrong.
Mum is in her 80s. She has a pacemaker and defib due to a genetic heart condition. She can walk upstairs but slowly and would sometimes need to stop half way up. If we were walking and there was an incline/steep bit, she would have to rest. If it was more than a domestic flight of stairs she wouldn’t even try it.
she walks the dog every day. Slowly, on a totally flat route. She has told me that on the ‘bad’ days she knows the spots where there is a bench/low wall and she can rest.
She also has severe diverticular disease and would occasionally have pretty big bleeds from that which leaves her totally wiped out for a few days. She asked about blue badge last year, and GP refused to fill in the form. Told my mum he wasn’t allowed to lie and she can walk perfectly well. But she struggles a lot at times. He told her if she walks and doesn’t get her heart rate up it’s not worth walking at all.
she saw new cardiologist recently with me. We asked him about it and he was amazed GP refused. Said he would write on the letter to GP about mums issues again. He is arranging a procedure for my mum and it will definitely set her back for a while. She saw GP again today and really fought her case, but GP adamant, my mum can walk and so doesn’t need a blue badge.
Are we being lazy so and so? I would have thought my mum was an ideal person for a blue badge? It’s really knocking her. AIBU?

OP posts:
Morph22010 · 30/04/2022 14:12

caecilius1 · 30/04/2022 13:52

Obviously there are loads of PIP /DLA appeals too. That's often wrong too but the point is there are undeniable hierarchies of disabilities.

i would agree some people are more disabled than others and this can also vary from day to day as people can have good days and bad days. However a system that recognised this for parking would be impossible to implement, therefore we can’t judge by looking at people and deciding who is above who in the hierarchy. My child is autistic and we’ve just been awarded a blue badge and some days we won’t need so if that’s the case I won’t use a disabled space but on other ocassions it will be a godsend. Not related to parking but I remember at one point in the past I was on my own really struggling with him having a meltdown and trying to run off and a lady in a wheelchair let me go ahead of her and said “your need is greater than mine” which really stuck with me. Ultimately it just comes down to being considerate for others and not judging

Kennykenkencat · 30/04/2022 14:11

Why do you need to go through a doctor

Dd has ADHD and is going through Pip

I think she got hers through our local council
Or the .gov website
I don’t think it says anything about a GP filling out a form.
it says you have to have something where it shows your diagnosis

Does your mum have access to her medical notes where it shows she has a medical diagnosis.
Or any letters that say she has a certain diagnosis. Or could she get copies from the hospital if she has lost them.

Underhisi · 30/04/2022 14:06

"The thing that boiled my piss was the number of people I saw with blue badges who could walk far better than she could."

Blue badges are awarded for restricted mobility which is not the same thing as ( although can include) physical inability to walk. My son can walk. He also, due to his disabilities behaves in extremely unsafe ways and puts himself and others at severe risk of harm.

5zeds · 30/04/2022 14:04

Blue badges aren't rationed. They are available to anybody who needs one, there is no issue of 'priority'. not my experience at all. (And to be very clear NOBODY would think my child doesn’t need one).

EmmatheStageRat · 30/04/2022 14:02

People who automatically get a Blue Badge

You automatically qualify for a Blue Badge if you are aged 3 or over and at least one of the following applies:

you receive the higher rate of the mobility component of the Disability Living Allowance (DLA)

you receive a Personal Independence Payment (PIP) because you can’t walk more than 50 metres (a score of 8 points or more under the ‘moving around’ activity of the mobility component)

you are registered blind (severely sight impaired)

you receive a War Pensioners’ Mobility Supplement
you have received a lump sum benefit within tariff levels 1 to 8 of the Armed Forces and Reserve Forces (Compensation) Scheme and have been certified as having a permanent and substantial disability that causes inability to walk or very considerable difficulty in walking

you receive the mobility component of PIP and have obtained 10 points specifically for descriptor E under the ‘planning and following journeys’ activity, on the grounds that you are unable to undertake any journey because it would cause you overwhelming psychological distress

If you have any score other than 10 points under descriptor E, in the ‘planning and following journeys’ activity of PIP you may still be eligible for a Blue Badge, but you do not automatically qualify. This includes if you have a higher score of 12. You will have to provide evidence to demonstrate your eligibility which will be assessed as part of your application.

People who may get a Blue Badge

You may be eligible for a badge if one or more of the following applies:

you cannot walk at all

you cannot walk without help from someone else or using mobility aids

you find walking very difficult due to pain, breathlessness or the time it takes

walking is dangerous to your health and safety
you have a terminal illness, which means you cannot walk or find walking very difficult and have a DS1500 form

you have a severe disability in both arms and drive regularly, but cannot operate pay-and-display parking machines

you have a child under the age of 3 with a medical condition that means the child always needs to be accompanied by bulky medical equipment

you have a child under the age of 3 with a medical condition that means the child must always be kept near a vehicle in case they need emergency medical treatment

you are constantly a significant risk to yourself or others near vehicles, in traffic or car parks

you struggle severely to plan or follow a journey
you find it difficult or impossible to control your actions and lack awareness of the impact you could have on others

you regularly have intense and overwhelming responses to situations causing temporary loss of behavioural control

you frequently become extremely anxious or fearful of public/open spaces

Your local council will decide if you are eligible for a badge. They cannot start the assessment process until they have all the necessary evidence. It may take 12 weeks or longer to assess your application. If they decide that you are not eligible and you think that they did not take account of all the facts, you can ask them to consider your application again.

So sorry, OP, for derailing your thread as I’m aware that you’re in the ROI and the information posted above is for the UK and from the Gov.UK website to explain the ‘hierarchy’ of who automatically qualifies for a Blue Badge versus those who may get a Blue Badge.

As she is blind, my teen automatically qualifies for a Blue Badge, but we have occasionally been challenged by other Blue Badge holders about our right to park in access spaces and often run the gauntlet of those who ostentatiously check my windscreen for a valid Badge in car parks.

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 14:02

caecilius1 · 30/04/2022 13:52

Obviously there are loads of PIP /DLA appeals too. That's often wrong too but the point is there are undeniable hierarchies of disabilities.

And surely not being able to walk should be pretty high in that hierarchy. Does anyone disagree with that?

chisanunian · 30/04/2022 14:02

MintJulia · 30/04/2022 06:10

Maybe it's a case of priority. There are lots of people in wheel chairs or using frames etc who need more help with access than your mum. She can walk the dog so as long as she takes it slowly, she manages ok.

Or perhaps the gp wants to encourage your mum to walk because it will help with her health.

Blue badges aren't rationed. They are available to anybody who needs one, there is no issue of 'priority'.

OP, is there more than one GP at the practice?

5zeds · 30/04/2022 13:53

My GP wrote saying she felt we needed one for dc (England) as we haven ‘t seen his paediatrician due to lockdown and the council refused to follow her advice as they don’t have to.

caecilius1 · 30/04/2022 13:52

Obviously there are loads of PIP /DLA appeals too. That's often wrong too but the point is there are undeniable hierarchies of disabilities.

caecilius1 · 30/04/2022 13:50

PIP is obviously awarded on a hierarchy of disability too, also by a clinically appropriate person. There are all combinations of monies awarded based on the evidenced disabilities.
So let's not be disingenuous about hierarchies of disabilities.

caecilius1 · 30/04/2022 13:48

It's defined clinically @x2boys and In your own example, both of your family members have a BB.
This poster's GP has clinically decided that the lady in question doesn't meet the clinical threshold.
OP can appeal this or approach another GP.

Morph22010 · 30/04/2022 13:47

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 13:32

So how is this process fair if you have a GP who refuses to complete the documentation so you can’t even apply?

That’s the system in the Republic of Ireland where the op lives and I don’t think it is fair but I live in England so applied under the English system

x2boys · 30/04/2022 13:44

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 30/04/2022 09:12

It's such utter bollocks to say that there is no hierarchy of disability. Of course there is. It may feel lovely and affirming to deny that, but the upshot is that the most disabled lose out, because the less disabled use scarce resources that they don't absolutely need. It would be wonderful if there were enough blue badge spaces for everyone with mild mobility restrictions. There aren't. Every blue badge issued to someone who doesn't absolutely need it means less resources for the most disabled.

And the whole point of the GP's refusal is that he feels the OP's DM does not meet the criteria.

How do you define the most disabled?
My son has a blue badge,he's twelve and extremely mobile ,he can run ,jump ,etc however he also has severe autism and learning disabilities and has zero danger awareness we need to be near to where we are going for his safety
My mum also has a blue badge she can barely walk and and exertion leaves her in pain ,the point being once she's in her wheelchair she's far safer than my son
It's not disability top trumps

caecilius1 · 30/04/2022 13:39

@Blossomtoes
We're talking about the ROI, which is a civilised country and therefore will have an appeal process.
Either ask the GP to reconsider, try another GP in the practice, complain to the practice manager or ROI's equivalent of the CCG ie use your democratic rights.

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 13:38

RuthW · 30/04/2022 13:36

You apply for a blue badge yourself. Doesn't have anything to do with gp.

The GP has to supply supporting documentation where I live.

RuthW · 30/04/2022 13:36

You apply for a blue badge yourself. Doesn't have anything to do with gp.

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 13:32

So how is this process fair if you have a GP who refuses to complete the documentation so you can’t even apply?

SpindleInTheWind · 30/04/2022 13:26

The PIP system in England now acknowledges that activities should be judged on whether the claimant can carry them out reliably (safely), repeatedly and in a reasonable time.

So a person who could walk slowly, once in a day, to a shop door from a car, but would as a result be in a great deal of pain, would gain points.

Morph22010 · 30/04/2022 13:18

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 13:05

No we’re not and we all know there are people that lie

OK. You’ve just contradicted yourself but I’ll leave you to it.

How have a contradicted myself I’ve said you can’t judge as you don’t know peoples disabilities that is true. I’ve also said they’d will be people that will lie that is true. I was replying to your comment about the obese man with a limp probably not needing, you don’t know what other conditions he had, he could be an out and out liar and fraudster but you don’t know so can’t judge. Someone using a wheelchair could also be a liar and fraudster and not really need it you just don’t know.

thecurtainsofdestiny · 30/04/2022 13:17

I have seen the blue badge application form for the area I live in. The questions were factual & included how far the person could walk ( it was a certain number of metres). It wasn't up to the GP to grant a blue badge but only to give the evidence.

Haven't seen the forms for ROI but it sounds as if the GP was saying that they couldn't in good conscience say yes to at least one of the questions, like "can the person only walk less than 200 metres". (or whatever, I don't know what the actual question was that the GP felt they couldn't lie about).

It would be unreasonable to ask the GP to lie about a factual thing.

But I wonder if they might feel able to agree to it if the question was seen as what your mum could manage on her worst days? She might meet the criteria on those days, even if she can occasionally walk further.

caecilius1 · 30/04/2022 13:08

I'm not looking for an argument at all, I think that's somewhat ironic.
Your difficult experience has coloured your view clearly.
Blue Badges applications and their evidence are assessed by a clinically-appropriate person. You feel you can do a better job, based on your arbitrary observations, so what's stopping you from training as an OT?
There are obviously hierarchies of disabilities, as I've stated upthread. Again, that's for a clinician to judge.

There's a misconception on this thread that the wider bays are for wheelchair users only. Nothing whatsoever to do with that, the yellow lines are to provide enough space for the disabled person to exit /enter near to the entrance of the building.

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 13:05

No we’re not and we all know there are people that lie

OK. You’ve just contradicted yourself but I’ll leave you to it.

Morph22010 · 30/04/2022 12:59

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 12:56

So we’re saying the blue badge system in every part of the country is 100% infallible, are we? Just like the assessment for disability benefits? You’re all either incredibly naive or just looking for an argument.

No we’re not and we all know there are people that lie but if you know of anyone where that is definately the case then report them through the appropriate channels for fraud.

Horcruxe · 30/04/2022 12:58

You dont need your GP the Cardiologist can fill out the form

Also in most cases you dont need anything from the GP just to fill out the form and they can arrange their own assessment

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 12:56

So we’re saying the blue badge system in every part of the country is 100% infallible, are we? Just like the assessment for disability benefits? You’re all either incredibly naive or just looking for an argument.