Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU? GP refusing my mum a blue badge

231 replies

JollyJunee · 30/04/2022 06:02

I’m so cross with my mum’s GP! Maybe we are in the wrong.
Mum is in her 80s. She has a pacemaker and defib due to a genetic heart condition. She can walk upstairs but slowly and would sometimes need to stop half way up. If we were walking and there was an incline/steep bit, she would have to rest. If it was more than a domestic flight of stairs she wouldn’t even try it.
she walks the dog every day. Slowly, on a totally flat route. She has told me that on the ‘bad’ days she knows the spots where there is a bench/low wall and she can rest.
She also has severe diverticular disease and would occasionally have pretty big bleeds from that which leaves her totally wiped out for a few days. She asked about blue badge last year, and GP refused to fill in the form. Told my mum he wasn’t allowed to lie and she can walk perfectly well. But she struggles a lot at times. He told her if she walks and doesn’t get her heart rate up it’s not worth walking at all.
she saw new cardiologist recently with me. We asked him about it and he was amazed GP refused. Said he would write on the letter to GP about mums issues again. He is arranging a procedure for my mum and it will definitely set her back for a while. She saw GP again today and really fought her case, but GP adamant, my mum can walk and so doesn’t need a blue badge.
Are we being lazy so and so? I would have thought my mum was an ideal person for a blue badge? It’s really knocking her. AIBU?

OP posts:
Sugarplumfairy65 · 01/05/2022 09:38

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 12:56

So we’re saying the blue badge system in every part of the country is 100% infallible, are we? Just like the assessment for disability benefits? You’re all either incredibly naive or just looking for an argument.

Have you any idea of just how much evidence you have to provide for a pip assessment? It isn't a case of just having a face to face assessment and lying through your teeth. You have to be able to prove your conditions and how they affect you.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 01/05/2022 09:30

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 12:06

I had the same thing with my mum’s GP. Even after she started using a wheelchair they wouldn’t give in. I started using parent and child spaces. The thing that boiled my piss was the number of people I saw with blue badges who could walk far better than she could.

You have no idea what conditions or how the conditions affect them so you shouldn't be judging. As you can see from this thread, blue badges are not handed out like sweeties. There are very strict criteria. It's not all about walking v being in a wheelchair

LookItsMeAgain · 01/05/2022 08:45

JollyJunee · 30/04/2022 22:18

Yes, thanks Earrings, that’s what I think. She may not 100% fit it, but she isn’t far off. As I said earlier, GP tends to be a bit ‘computer says no’ instead of just looking up and seeing the actual person?
When when my dad died recently enough, he saw my mum two weeks later. Midst of a pandemic, in total shock and grief, and she told him proudly she had made herself get out for a walk every day, even though she was just shuffling along…he said if she didn’t get her heart rate up it wasn’t worth doing.
I mean what?! What about mental health, processing grief, routine, fresh air, keeping moving in the elderly in a pandemic. He is an arse in my opinion. If my mum exerts herself she near collapses! But that’s beside the point. If she isn’t entitled she isn’t entitled.

Based on his conduct following your dad passing away and what he said to your mum, can I suggest that you try to find a different GP in her locality that she could be seen by? This guy sounds pathetic to be honest and has a terrible bedside manner!

The opposite of your comment saying that if she isn't entitled, then she isn't entitled could be happening here. If she is entitled but due to the GP not signing off, she is still entitled to a Blue Badge. He might see it as a 'oh she's going to be lazy and be parked closest to the shopping centre doors' or whatever. But if you phrase it as "I'll be seeing that she gets out and about more. We'll have more options of places to go with her etc. etc. etc." so he can see that she is getting her exercise and whatever he thinks is good to get her heartrate up (which by the sounds of it is actually not the best for her heart or her) then that might appease him???

Are there other GP's in the same practice or is there any chance that this one might go on holiday and you could get your mum seen by a locum?

mmmmmmghturep · 30/04/2022 23:26

Blue Badge applications will likely rise sharply because of all the people waiting for hip and knee replacements on the NHS.

mmmmmmghturep · 30/04/2022 23:17

So NOW its good for older more immobile people to get out and about. Pity that didnt occur to the idiot authorities who were taping up benches two years ago.

JollyJunee · 30/04/2022 22:44

Yes, here is hoping. Thanks x

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 30/04/2022 22:39

Yes, I think you're right Jolly. The GP is being bureaucratic rather than seeing the patient before him.

Your mum sounds brilliant, in terms of getting out & yes, what hurtful nonsense from the GP to your poor mum.

Hopefully the cardiologist will have some influence.

JollyJunee · 30/04/2022 22:37

queen as an example, the escalator in a local centre was broken one day a few years ago. It was one of those flat ones that takes you up one level, so an incline rather than steps. Mum said she would be fine to walk up it as it was broken. Got to the top and she said “Help me” to me. Security man heard, ran and got a chair and we sat her down, got her some water, she was ok and we just went home. She just can’t do any exertion. She isn’t able to hit town and shop all day, she doesn’t drink, eats very healthily, she never drives more than 1mile from our house, it’s to the local small supermarket for her few groceries, to mass, hairdresser once a week. She is hardly blocking all the spaces.
perfect example, the car park for the hospital. Badge spaces by door-of which there were loads. She has to park in multi storey across the road. If the lift is out she is buggered.
And why the heck did he give my dad one when he was always able to walk perfectly well??

OP posts:
queenMab99 · 30/04/2022 22:27

Although I have rheumatoid arthritis, which is no longer responding to prescribed medication, I am not applying for a blue badge as I have decided it is less trouble to use a taxi if I need to go somewhere with limited parking. However, I understand about ops mum walking her dog as long as she can sit down occasionally, as I have to do this, and can therefore only walk in areas where there are regular places to sit, as my dog walks are now bench to bench hobbles. This means I can no longer go shopping, as many shops have absolutely nowhere to sit. It doesn't really bother me, I just shop online and have groceries delivered, but if ops mum gets pleasure browsing around shops, but needs a sit down by the time she has walked from her car, at over 80 with heart problems, I think she should have a BB. Posters saying she should walk more and a bit faster to keep healthy, are in need of a compassion transplant!

JollyJunee · 30/04/2022 22:23

Looking at that link briefly Earrings.-must get to sleep will be pooped at work otherwise, it does actually mention cardiac restrictions. My point was yes, she can walk unaided-but only on a flat surface. If it was how far on a hill or steps, the answer would be 2 metres!! I made this point to the GP, she can only walk on flat areas, not at all on incline or steps.

OP posts:
JollyJunee · 30/04/2022 22:18

Yes, thanks Earrings, that’s what I think. She may not 100% fit it, but she isn’t far off. As I said earlier, GP tends to be a bit ‘computer says no’ instead of just looking up and seeing the actual person?
When when my dad died recently enough, he saw my mum two weeks later. Midst of a pandemic, in total shock and grief, and she told him proudly she had made herself get out for a walk every day, even though she was just shuffling along…he said if she didn’t get her heart rate up it wasn’t worth doing.
I mean what?! What about mental health, processing grief, routine, fresh air, keeping moving in the elderly in a pandemic. He is an arse in my opinion. If my mum exerts herself she near collapses! But that’s beside the point. If she isn’t entitled she isn’t entitled.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 30/04/2022 22:11

@JollyJunee

I've read your posts but not all the replies so sorry if I'm repeating anything.

https://www.citizensinformation.ie/en/travelanddrecreation/trafficanddparking/disabledpersonssparkingcard.html#l25a44

We don't have a 'blue badge' as such in Ireland - it's called a disabled person's parking card, but does the same thing.

On the site above you can check with either DDAI or Irish Wheelchair Association for eligibility.

Unfortunately in strict terms your mum probably doesn't qualify - however, one would think a sympathetic GP would be generous re the walking unaided question.

SpindleInTheWind · 30/04/2022 21:53

JollyJunee · 30/04/2022 21:35

So sure there was just a post there that said you don’t need a GP to get a blue badge! Hence my reference to the cheque. It disappeared.

Yes it was ages ago but I'm pretty sure it was about the UK rules. I hope you can sort it out for your mum, @JollyJunee

I thnk @Blossomtoes mum should get one as well (assuming England?) because she's in a wheelchair.

JollyJunee · 30/04/2022 21:35

So sure there was just a post there that said you don’t need a GP to get a blue badge! Hence my reference to the cheque. It disappeared.

OP posts:
Innocenta · 30/04/2022 21:33

There is no hierarchy of disability.
@emuloc Don't be ridiculous. Of course there is in practice; everyone would pick a mild disability over a severe one if given the choice. I know that I would swap if I could. It's actually really trivialising to claim there is no hierarchy, because it conflates such wildly different experiences.

JollyJunee · 30/04/2022 21:33

Should I cancel the cheque as well?😂

OP posts:
Dinoboymama · 30/04/2022 21:32

Some very judgemental comments about who should or shouldn't qualify for a blue badge.

You don't need to be in a wheelchair to qualify for one.
Many people who can walk some distance or even very far may be entitled to them for various reasons.

My son can run, jump, climb on to huts and roofs. He has one for being at risk in traffic. He needs someone holding him always in public and not to be close to other cars as he may kick out at them.

Innocenta · 30/04/2022 21:28

And surely not being able to walk should be pretty high in that hierarchy. Does anyone disagree with that?

@Blossomtoes

Yes, it should, but MN is obsessed with invisible disabilities and doesn't like to acknowledge that mobility impairments can often come alongside severe illness. Hmm

Innocenta · 30/04/2022 21:24

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 30/04/2022 20:45

i would agree some people are more disabled than others and this can also vary from day to day as people can have good days and bad days. However a system that recognised this for parking would be impossible to implement, therefore we can’t judge by looking at people and deciding who is above who in the hierarchy

But that's the whole point of having a fairly high threshold for having a blue badge in the first place. You can't judge, day to day, which blue badge holders need disabled spaces the most. But you can try to ensure that only people who really need them have them in the first place.

I agree. I think the threshold should be higher in general, actually (but in fact I do think OP's mum should get one!).

Teddah · 30/04/2022 21:18

Good luck @JollyJunee your mum is lucky to have a supportive daughter fighting her corner. It sounds like she really struggles with her mobility, I hope she can be re-assessed by a different GP.

Teddah · 30/04/2022 21:16

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2022 12:39

I’m not in the least judgemental. The reason I needed a blue badge for my mum was because she used a wheelchair - the marking on the disabled spaces is a bit of a clue as to who qualifies for one. Obviously someone who’s blind merits one. The extremely obese man with a limp probably doesn’t.

Steroids and immobility made me gain weight. It’s bad enough being young, newly fat and disabled and accepting you need aids like a blue badge without being concerned we are being judged by people like you who don’t have a clue.

JollyJunee · 30/04/2022 21:14

Wow! I had no idea this was such an emotive subject. Thank you all for replying.
My mum is 82, weighs 7st 5lbs, you could put her in your pocket. I think she is fit. I think she is bloody brilliant for her age!! She is completely independent. But any exertion leaves her feeling light headed, unwell, short of breath. So, she could do a washing load, but would have to take it out in bits. She can’t bend over, feels faint. She would have to sit down if she went upstairs. The diverticular disease is severe. She has had 3 episodes of bleeding that were so severe she had to be hospitalised for 1-2 weeks, and they set off her defib. She can only walk the dog late morning, once her tummy has settled. She isn’t able to do anything after that. So her wee bits of shopping would have to be done in am, as she would say she is fit for nothing after walking the dog. She makes herself do that to keep fit.
She said every one of her friends has a blue badge, and they can’t understand how her GP refuses.
reading the replies here I see it may be a case of the form says can they walk x amount and she technically can-therefore he can’t sign it. It has to be the GP. The consultant was surprised and said it was crazy, she would definitely benefit from one, and that they would put it in the letter that her condition had worsened and they felt a badge would be appropriate.
The GP is the type that doesn’t look at the person in front of them, just at what the book says.
I’ll have a look at this properly tomorrow, I’m working again all day. Appreciate the input.

OP posts:
MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 30/04/2022 20:45

i would agree some people are more disabled than others and this can also vary from day to day as people can have good days and bad days. However a system that recognised this for parking would be impossible to implement, therefore we can’t judge by looking at people and deciding who is above who in the hierarchy

But that's the whole point of having a fairly high threshold for having a blue badge in the first place. You can't judge, day to day, which blue badge holders need disabled spaces the most. But you can try to ensure that only people who really need them have them in the first place.

caecilius1 · 30/04/2022 14:24

@Morph22010
Fully agree with you.

Bungalowlady · 30/04/2022 14:23

In the UK. When I applied a GP diagnosis wasn’t acceptable as evidence. Had to be from consultant.