Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my DC is too clever for state secondary school?

481 replies

GeniusCreator · 29/04/2022 22:37

DC is Yr7. Top of year according to what I’ve been told. Read the full series of Harry Potter books by 7 years old. Excels in STEM subjects. Spends ages at home researching science stuff like quantum field theory and nuclear fusion/fission and enjoys it! Designs his own websites and writes his own code for his own games. Primary school were always pretty amazed by him. Secondary school have picked up on him now and have said they’ve never seen anything like him.

He’s already mentioning being a bit bored in class. We live in what could be described as a deprived town and are not well off, no family to help out, so would never be able to get him into a private school. I did check with the private school in the next town but there are no scholarships available.

WIBU to try to crowdfund for private school fees?

He needs a much higher level curriculum than the state school one to continue stretching him. I honestly think he’s destined for amazing things.

<only slightly light hearted>

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 30/04/2022 08:15

I tend to think bright children will do well anywhere, so long as they're happy.

My DD is super-bright, and her teachers and the Head of her school have more than once suggested it'd be a "waste" for her not to go to either the grammar or the selective private school. But I'm leaning towards a local comprehensive which has a reputation for being brilliant pastorally and not so great academically, because I'm not in the least bit concerned about her ability to do well academically, but I do worry about her future mental health.

nearlyspringyay · 30/04/2022 08:15

So you want beg to send your normal kid to private school? There's some really white private schools around just are there are some really shit state secondaries, and vice versa.

If he's that much of a genius he'll excel anywhere.

Fucks sake.

LittleMissLego · 30/04/2022 08:14

My very bright dd goes to the local state school. We could afford private fees, but choose not to go down that route. Shes in year 7.

I've just had parents evening and the teachers all had fantastic feedback. Not just about her behaviour and attitude but also on how we could support her. Things like in English getting her to read a wider variety of books as they'll be doing Shakespeare and one 18th century text - so if she reads lots of those books now it will help familiarise her with the language styles. So start reading Frankenstein, Jekyll and Hyde, etc.

Actually my main concerns are that shes happy, that shes well rounded, that she has solid friendships. I don't worry about the academic side of things as shes so self motivated naturally.

Hallyup89 · 30/04/2022 08:13

Haha. I was amazing at state primary. Mediocre at private secondary. It sucked. I never won any prizes or got any commendations and I felt as though my abilities were worthless. State school, I may have had a chance to shine.

TitoMojito · 30/04/2022 08:13

Crowdfund 🤣🤣

Peanutbuttercupisyum · 30/04/2022 08:11

Well if you can’t afford it you can’t afford it. You can’t crowd fund. Most would rather their kids were at private, even more so if their NOT bright, as tbh that’s where private really makes a difference. Just make sure he works hard and goes to oxbridge. He’ll be fine

LivesinLondon2000 · 30/04/2022 08:11

I’m not entirely sure the OP was genuine but assuming it is…
I was one of those children at school, spent my entire time at a (state) school feeling fairly unchallenged by the work but I enjoyed the social aspect and hanging out with my friends.
I did a lot of extra reading on subjects I was interested in at home in my own time. And we only had libraries then, now with the internet there are so many more opportunities to learn and progress.
Unless the private school you’re thinking of is incredibly academically selective, I doubt it will make much difference. Sure the teachers will have a little more time to spend with your DS, but the cohort of children won’t necessarily be much brighter and they’ll still be studying the regular GCSE syllabus.
As other posters have mentioned, I’d be looking at other resources for extra study outside school. Maybe a private tutor for a subject he’s particularly interested in.

SidandAndyssextoy · 30/04/2022 08:11

And one final thing! I think there’s a lot of comparing of apples and oranges on here. State schools vary hugely in their ability to provide stretch for academically able kids. Parents vary hugely in their ability to provide support for extras outside school, or engage in their child’s needs. Private schools vary hugely in their offer, and those who take exceptionally bright kids do offer a very different education to state schools.

whiteroseredrose · 30/04/2022 08:10

Wheelz46 · 30/04/2022 00:02

Seems like a wind up post but it has made me think, can children actually move up a year and if so how would they legally leave school? A summer born kid, moving up a year would mean they are 14 when they finish in year 11.

You can't then have them starting college/university as surely that would be a safeguarding issue! They can't work because of their age, so what on earth would they do or do they stay in year 11 for 2 years?

@Wheelz46 it wouldn't be ideal. However on my DS's Physics Masters course there is a 19 year old Italian. He started Uni at 16 and completed the 3 year course in 2 years. Apparently he is a really nice sociable chap and none the worse for it.

BeachMustHave · 30/04/2022 08:09

Wow! That interview! @Sweetpea1532 Incredible. Very interesting indeed. My mind is blown.

WildCoasts · 30/04/2022 08:08

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

It's not that hard, especially in this day and age with all the information available. If the parents can read, have a computer and the initiative, it can all be found. Even before the internet I found out as a 15 year old by myself that I could get permission to go to university early and organised it with the help of a teacher. If the parents need to they can make an appointment with a developmental psychologist or the school, and ask for that information. It's not that hard.

Lovemusic33 · 30/04/2022 08:07

I haven’t read the whole thread but agree with some of the posts.
many 18 year olds from private schools have been turned down for top unis this year (mainly science and medical courses) despite hitting A*’s in their predicted grades. More places have been offered up to kids from state schools.

My dd has always been top of the class and I toyed with the idea of private school (scholarship as I can’t afford to send her) but decided against it. She’s now 18 and sitting A levels soon, she has got offers for all the uni’s she has applied for including 2 Russell group uni’s. i don’t regret my decision to keep her where she is despite the school not having a great reputation. A bright child will do well wherever they are and the school should provide enough work so they don’t get bored. There’s also so much out of school learning they can do to keep them busy.

And crowdfunding to pay for a school place is a awful idea, no one other than close family are going to give a toss about your brainy child (I know first hand), people just assume you are bragging if you mention how amazingly bright your child is.

AuxArmesCitoyens · 30/04/2022 08:07

If boarding is an option OP send him to Christ's Hospital where fees won't be an issue. Sounds perfect for you.

purplesky18 · 30/04/2022 08:07

Honestly I was similar to your son, I was exceptionally academic, even got a private school scholarship but moved areas and ended up in a deprived state school. I was so bored and a bit naughty however I still left with very good gcses on minimum effort. It did however make me a grounded and well rounded person, it built character and that was most important.

For a while I was so bored of learning and constant pressure I quit and did nothing for a few years, now I’m working my way up in career and finally doing something with myself and I’m nearly 30. Please don’t pressure him and just let him stay in a normal school, he will thank you later for not having to go through the tonnes of pressure of being smart.

SidandAndyssextoy · 30/04/2022 08:07

I forgot to say in my post that I don’t think I personally would have got more from a highly academic private school than my own school. My lack of stretch was only in a couple of areas and there are multiple reasons why neither I nor the school managed that. But if a child was feeling like that across the board it’s worth considering.

Hubblebubble · 30/04/2022 08:06

My point being children can excell at state school and your child may be advanced, but you can just advocate for your state school to stretch him.

SpringLobelia · 30/04/2022 08:06

over2021 · 29/04/2022 22:47

Biscuit LOL.

My best friend's son goes to a private school because he's not particularly academic and didn't pass his 11+. When I say not particularly academic I mean lazy, can't be arsed to write, thinks maths is a bore (no learning difficulties). Don't assume private schools are full of clever kids. A lot go to private schools because their parents know they won't get a job off their grades but might off of their connections.

I find that statement a bit offensive actually. My DS1 has a number of SEN and we chose a private school for him because their pastoral care and SEN provision was excellent. Not because we hope he might profit from connections.

mumsiedarlingrevolta · 30/04/2022 08:05

If this thread is real then please @GeniusCreator don't move him up a year-
the social aspect of maturing etc so impt at that age-especially for boys.

If he is exceptional he will be.

And like PP have said-much more likely these days to get to Cambridge from a State school.

Good luck.

Hubblebubble · 30/04/2022 08:05

Brain fart, The Hobbit at seven, followed by LOTR.

Hubblebubble · 30/04/2022 08:04

I read the hobbit at nine and devoured the entire lord of the rings series at 8. Some children are advanced in literacy. I went through the state school system and am now a professional copywriter. IMO The Harry Potter books have a great plot, but the writing is simplistic and suitable for children.

WildCoasts · 30/04/2022 08:03

Good on you @homeEd2021 Wish you'd been my mother.

lizziesiddal79 · 30/04/2022 08:01

Some people send their children to private school because their child has specific educational needs and prefer the smaller setting. I would say that is becoming more the norm. I don't know why you think private schools necessarily offer more academic rigor. What your child needs is 'stretch and challenge' through extension work in class or homework, or extra curricular clubs. They might benefit from a sixth form mentor also.

Your child is excelling academically, but also needs to excel socially if he is to make the most of his talents. Being in a state secondary will allow him to meet a full range of people. Don't focus solely on the academic. Encourage him to be a rounded person. Get involved in some sports clubs. He's a child. He might also change massively when he hits puberty. I taught in a selective academic school and some of those who burned brightly in Year 7 did not always do so by Year 10. Don't let him burn out. You need to encourage him to be a fully-rounded individual who is allowed to make mistakes and be less than brilliant.

I wish him all the best.

SidandAndyssextoy · 30/04/2022 08:01

I haven’t read the full thread but quite a lot of it.

I was not any sort of child genius but I was pretty bright. I went to a very good comprehensive and then to Cambridge. I am a huge supporter of state schooling in general, and all my kids are in/have been to them.

Because I got the grades I was considered to have done really well, and by all objective standards of course I did. But I was so bored. I disengaged a lot. I hated school. I wasn’t a great performer across all subjects so managed the grades in some of them but in others I would have flown if I’d been stretched. I’m never going to invent anything to change the world, or write the next great novel. I would just have been happier. And this really was a solid school - top of the league tables at the time and often mentioned on here now.

So for your son, and kids like him, I think it is worth exploring scholarships to the very academic private schools, as they can offer a lot more to talented kids than the majority of state schools can.

Ohfgsnotagain · 30/04/2022 08:00

No to crowdfunding. School fees are not a ‘one off” they’re ongoing and will cost ££££.

If he is really gifted then start looking around at scholarships in other areas and move or look at boarding to give him that opportunity.

liveforsummer · 30/04/2022 07:57

GeniusCreator · 29/04/2022 23:39

Haha. I struggled to read the Harry Potter books OUT LOUD not to actually read them! If any of you have actually ever opened one, you’d see there is a lot of small words on the page and it’s bloody hard to read out as a bedtime story. You get dry mouth after a page!

I had absolutely no issues reading Harry Potter out loud - Roald Dahl on the other hand with all the long often nonsensical words was a nightmare and even my dyslectic dd was managing them fine at 7 so I'm not sure finding thing tricky to read out loud is a yard stick 😆