Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my DC is too clever for state secondary school?

481 replies

GeniusCreator · 29/04/2022 22:37

DC is Yr7. Top of year according to what I’ve been told. Read the full series of Harry Potter books by 7 years old. Excels in STEM subjects. Spends ages at home researching science stuff like quantum field theory and nuclear fusion/fission and enjoys it! Designs his own websites and writes his own code for his own games. Primary school were always pretty amazed by him. Secondary school have picked up on him now and have said they’ve never seen anything like him.

He’s already mentioning being a bit bored in class. We live in what could be described as a deprived town and are not well off, no family to help out, so would never be able to get him into a private school. I did check with the private school in the next town but there are no scholarships available.

WIBU to try to crowdfund for private school fees?

He needs a much higher level curriculum than the state school one to continue stretching him. I honestly think he’s destined for amazing things.

<only slightly light hearted>

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Sidisawetlettuce · 30/04/2022 09:10

SpindleInTheWind · 29/04/2022 22:50

Read the full series of Harry Potter books by 7 years old

Did he, aye?

We'll this is interesting because some people are sayig that reading all Harry Potter books by age 7 is nothing out of the ordinary and this comment seems to think it's a massive brag. Another person commented that HP were aimed at ages 4-7 which shows how stupid they are.

Getoutofbed25 · 30/04/2022 09:10

You sound like a great parent wanting the best for their child.

I would speak to private schools as see what they suggest.

Did you read a recent post from a parent who’s child wanted to go to Oxford/Cambridge and she was feeling she had done her child a disservice by putting them in private school due to the classes run for state educated kids.

Speaking yo his current school may give you a better idea how they can push him.

FreetheKhalo · 30/04/2022 09:10

Top of year according to what I’ve been told

Told by who? I’m a teacher and we’ve never ranked kids as being the top and bottom. We compare them to themselves and their own targets.
I also wouldn’t personally judge anything on how many points he has for achievement either as different teachers record things better than others so they aren’t always representative.
School should be stretching him but he needs to know the curriculum as well as the advanced information. I’ve had students before that come across as mini Einstein’s but then score poorly on tests because they know advanced content but not basic skills.

Xtraincome · 30/04/2022 09:09

Hi, OP

Your boy sounds super intelligent. But don't assume that being top of y7 is criteria for moving up a year. He fits into education well, can learn easily and has friends- this is the situation most parents dream of.

If he is in fact a genius there are many ways to find out. But, to me, he sounds like he is very clever with an interest in science. Does he just relay information well or is he undertaking experiments at home and engaging in heavily scientific discussion with likeminded people on forums etc?

Depending on where you are in the country, you could explore some extra curricular things. Chess is known to be a great way to encourage gifted children. Our DDs are not geniuses, but chess is something we play a lot with them and it is beneficial in some ways and a good way to bond.

Sorry you're getting flack on here. But, we do, as parents, have a tendency to assume our very smart children should be leapt ahead of their peers- very rarely do children benefit in the long run from this setup.

gunnersgold · 30/04/2022 09:09

If he is so clever then visit the private schools and get a scholarship!

Begging for school is very crass and frankly embarrassing!

Pinkyxx · 30/04/2022 09:08

Independent schools have scholar programs and the resources to stretch able students. Look at selective boarding schools and consider 13+ entry. They test aptitude for entry and almost all of the very selective boarding schools offer 100% means tested bursaries (i.e. it's free for you). If your son is as able as you suggest he will be a very attractive student. While I don't consider her a genius or gifted by any stretch of the imagination, she is bright and able with aspirations. She attends a girls selective school for secondary. The curriculum they follow is far broader that state schools and the expectations on students pitched much higher. Extension work is available from every lesson along with super-curricular projects, essays etc. In addition to this are a broad array of sports, activities, trips, events, competitions and pastoral opportunities. She loves it, has made wonderful friends and thrived since joining in year 7. She was bored and coasted through primary school in her state school, always at the top of the class making next to no effort.. that isn't much to go by though since it all depends on the class.

StScholastica · 30/04/2022 09:07

I really don't get the "He's clever, therefore we need to push him even more" theory.
At the end of his school career he will be measured against the same academic yardstick as every one of his peers, which is his GCSE and A Level results.
And believe me, a lot of children (from state and private schools) apply to uni with the absolute top grades in every subject, what makes him stand out will be his extra curricular stuff.
If he is as clever as you feel he is, he can afford to relax and follow his interests. Don't "other" him or let him believe he is the special one.
I'd be encouraging him to do something that is a real challenge for him, like maybe football or dance and something he can excel in like the cyber first courses ŕun by GCHQ.

Doubleraspberry · 30/04/2022 09:07

PurassicJark · 30/04/2022 09:06

You actually struggled to read Harry Potter books yourself? 😕I really wouldn't admit that anymore op..

Pay for tutors. Please don't try to help him yourself.

Really no need for that, is there?

cecilthehungryspider · 30/04/2022 09:07

SpindleInTheWind · 29/04/2022 22:50

Read the full series of Harry Potter books by 7 years old

Did he, aye?

2 of my 3 children did that too. They are bright kids but not genius level. I don't think that's a particularly wild claim.

dizzydizzydizzy · 30/04/2022 09:07

Blimeyherewegoagain · 29/04/2022 23:04

If your son is exceptional AND self motivated he’ll do well at any school because he’ll be filling in the gaps himself through home study.

This.

DD "inhales" books (quoting English teacher), has always been on various sports teams and has always loved any kind of museum or lecture or extra curricular opportunity.

She went to normal comp, got 4 x A* in her A-Levels and is now studying for a Masters in a STEM subject at a top uni.

PurassicJark · 30/04/2022 09:06

You actually struggled to read Harry Potter books yourself? 😕I really wouldn't admit that anymore op..

Pay for tutors. Please don't try to help him yourself.

lljkk · 30/04/2022 09:06

Kids at private schools do lots of drugs. They can afford it.

DD attended state until yr12. She loved her public school 6th form, but often came home with stories about the drug use, and "rich people" stories. The things they would blithely spend money on. DD started smoking while at 6th form: nobody else in her life except her indie school peers smoked.

I could say more about DD's high achievements, but agree thread will go poof so why bother. I would prioritise social life over academic concerns, anyway.

ChocBloc · 30/04/2022 09:05

No the more kids that don't go private the better the state system will get. their results only seem worse because of people who take their kids out to go private. And no you can't crowd fund your geniuses school education that's just weird.

Giraffesandbottom · 30/04/2022 09:04

@Barbadossunset

King’s, St Paul’s, Westminster, Godolphin and Latymer etc.

Eton I think is always used as an example because of how many well known people have attended there so it’s well-known but I think its a bit of a meme school at this point, and I have no idea how it consistently gets into the top school lists. I know a few people who’ve attended and they, like people who attended Harrow, are not particularly bright. Unlike people who attended the schools I listed (and similar london day schools).

WalkerWalking · 30/04/2022 09:04

I've never known a school that tells parents their kids' "placing" within the year group academically or behaviourally?

You could think of this two ways. Your son might be better off in an academically selective school with more children of a similar ability. But on the flip side, from what you've written, he would not be considered at all exceptional at my highly selective school, which could be quite a dent to his confidence.

HeatherShiver · 30/04/2022 09:03

@neverbeenskiing ha we could start a support group.

ibelieveinmirrorballs · 30/04/2022 09:03

I think you are a tiny bit deluded and in awe of your son. I mean, that's normal, we're supposed to be a bit in awe of our kids but... I don't think what you describe is as extraordinary as you think.

Like your son, my daughter (also now in Y7) had also read all HP books by age 7, at the same age was going around telling everyone she wanted to go to the best university in the country to study physics or chemistry to PhD level and is consistently at the top of her year.

Unlike your son, she was at a prep boarding school from 7-11 and has now gone into the state grammar system and tells me every single week how much happier she is there.

There are plenty of private schools who do excellent scholarships and bursaries (we got a 70% discount to the one we went to) and if you're prepared to send him boarding you won't struggle to get him one if he's as exceptional as you believe.

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 30/04/2022 09:01

"As someone who went to Cambridge from a Northern comprehensive, the pressure can also be v high from a school that doesn’t normally do this sort of thing. My friend and I were there one big hope, and we got tons of pressure"

Yes, I can understand that, having gone to a northern comp in a deprived area myself, but this school isn't like that, it's in an affluent commuter town for one thing, and they have a G&T programme and have sent students to some good universities. It's just that their focus is on the "whole child", and on making sure that every child meets their full potential, not just the very bright ones.

I haven't completely made my mind up which school to make our first choice (DD is in Y5), but I was very impressed when I went to their open evening, and have heard so much good stuff from parents and pupils already there.

And of course there isn't really a choice with LA schools anyway! It's our technically nearest school (that's not single sex or religious) but if there's a lot of applications/siblings that year we still might not get it.

Anyway, don't mean to distract from the OP. I doubt you'd get very far with crowdfunding OP, but there's no reason you shouldn't investigate scholarships for private schools.

Cheesepleeze · 30/04/2022 09:00

Crowdfunding sounds very selfish/entitled. Have you considered home educating if you don’t feel that state school is a good fit for him, but you can’t afford private school?

Barbadossunset · 30/04/2022 08:59

if people really think Eton is an Academic school they have lost the plot

giraffesandbottom which schools do you think are academic?

HeatherShiver · 30/04/2022 08:56

I was moved up two years for some subjects (in the early 80s).
It was awful and I still feel bad about it now. I was a total oddity to my actual year group and the older kids.
It impacted me socially hugely.
I ended up more or less dropping out of education by 14.
I put myself through university in my 30s and ended up (at one point in my career) lecturing at a top five university.
I'd leave him where he is, let him make friends and concentrate on bringing up a happy boy who's doing well at his state school.
Like others said, look at sport, music or other activities for him.

neverbeenskiing · 30/04/2022 08:56

As a child of working class parents who was sent to private school and moved up a year, I wish the adults around me had thought more about the consequences of those decisions. It might have been good for me academically but socially and emotionally it was disastrous and I would never wish the same for my DC. I now choose to work at a state secondary, where I am 100% certain the children are receiving a much better educational experience (both academically and pastorally) than I did.

DomesticatedZombie · 30/04/2022 08:54

Your son sounds great; it's lovely that you're proud of him.

Children do better at private school for various reasons - lots of it is confidence, associating with lots of other comfortable, well-off children, higher expectations, making connections and learning how to get along with various social situations. Some of it smaller class sizes, etc.

Emotional and social development is also important, though - your son will probably have to negotiate that with his peers, even if he is 'advanced' academically. It can be hard to be gifted, wherever you are in the school system. (from observation of a gifted child in my son's year).

I think looking for tutors, courses, challenges and opportunities within and outwith school is going to be your best bet. Sounds like your son will do well - the most important thing is that he is well supported and encouraged, imo. Keep finding opportunities for him, let him test himself, and keep asking questions. All the best.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 30/04/2022 08:53

Seriously?! Wow.

Yabu.

If he is all that then he will have no issue getting a scholarship.

hiredandsqueak · 30/04/2022 08:52

My son was very gifted, won the whole school maths challenge within weeks of starting year seven. Has an eidetic memory, passed GCSEs, A levels, got a degree and masters with minimal effort. His degree and masters lecture notes consist of one or two words and the occasional don't remember. He'd write his dissertation taking a day off work the day before the deadline.
He said secondary school was the best time of his life, not because they taught him much but because of friendships, sports teams, extra curricular activities, residentials and all the stuff outside the lessons. Encourage your child to make the most of every opportunity. FWIW ds hasn't read any of the Harry Potter series not sure that it has much bearing on intelligence.