Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my DC is too clever for state secondary school?

481 replies

GeniusCreator · 29/04/2022 22:37

DC is Yr7. Top of year according to what I’ve been told. Read the full series of Harry Potter books by 7 years old. Excels in STEM subjects. Spends ages at home researching science stuff like quantum field theory and nuclear fusion/fission and enjoys it! Designs his own websites and writes his own code for his own games. Primary school were always pretty amazed by him. Secondary school have picked up on him now and have said they’ve never seen anything like him.

He’s already mentioning being a bit bored in class. We live in what could be described as a deprived town and are not well off, no family to help out, so would never be able to get him into a private school. I did check with the private school in the next town but there are no scholarships available.

WIBU to try to crowdfund for private school fees?

He needs a much higher level curriculum than the state school one to continue stretching him. I honestly think he’s destined for amazing things.

<only slightly light hearted>

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
PinkiOcelot · 01/05/2022 10:01

🤢not envy

edwinbear · 01/05/2022 09:56

OP was/is he on the Gifted & Talented scheme at school? DH is very bright, (IQ 150), he was put on G&T for maths at school which gave him access to extra lessons on a Sat morning to stretch him, which worked well for him. He didn't go to private school but still managed to do perfectly well for himself - although chose to head into the City at 18 rather than go to University.

exceptionalson · 01/05/2022 09:54

Had to name change, sorry. @GeniusCreator my son actually is exceptional. I suspected he might be age 8 when he was so far ahead of everyone in his class at Maths that his state primary got a secondary maths teacher to come and do some sessions 'for fun'. The age 11 when he started doing A level Maths problems again 'for fun'. I could go on with more examples, Maths Olympiad etc.

He went to a perfectly ordinary state school, and I have to say the school were extremely supportive of him even though they could not do much outside the curriculum. He was happy.

He is now at Oxford and still fairly exceptional (top 10% of his year group) and a scholar.

Anyway, if he goes to private school he will probably be disadvantaged in Oxbridge admissions if MN were to be believed. Send him to private school if you want, but most importantly, send him somewhere he will be happy.

Saracen · 01/05/2022 09:28

We home educate, and I know a few kids like your son, including the former best friend of one of my DCs. Such children often thrive out of school. They have time to do their own thing. You can get them together with people who know about the stuff which interests them. You don't necessarily have to "teach" them as such. You can instead just help them find the resources they need, and stand back while they learn under their own steam. They go at their own speed and can learn about a wide range of subjects in as much depth as they want.

Qualifications can be done at whatever age they are ready. They can mix and match GCSEs, A levels, and university courses. Open University will accept under-16s if it is clear they are ready, though funding can be a challenge since they aren't old enough to consent to student loans.

It's also good for sociable kids. They they can mix with many different people (kids and adults) in various settings, and don't have to spend most of their time with a fixed "peer group" at school.

That might be an option to consider.

Winter2020 · 01/05/2022 08:06

Hi OP,
I just wanted to say think very carefully before moving your son up a year. I wouldn't.
Your son is very clever but importantly he is happy and has friends. That might not be the case if you change his year. Being clever doesn't stop him from wanting a peer group/friends.
...and where does it end? Will he go to uni early and not be able to go out with the others as he is only 17? Or do you plan for him to take a year out? Why not just let him enjoy his schooling. The social side is just as important as academic. A genius child with anxiety/depression will struggle to thrive. Keep things in perspective.

Luculentus · 01/05/2022 07:51

Willyoujustbequiet · 01/05/2022 02:15

Has he been assessed for autism? The earlier the diagnosis the better, especially seeing you have another dc with SEN.

Why would he be?

MountainDewer · 01/05/2022 02:58

Private school doesn’t necessarily teach a ‘higher curriculum’. They have more extra curricular activities like science clubs etc.
which your can easily do with your DC. Hackathons, maths Olympiad… etc.

Willyoujustbequiet · 01/05/2022 02:15

Has he been assessed for autism? The earlier the diagnosis the better, especially seeing you have another dc with SEN.

WildCoasts · 01/05/2022 00:30

I give no weight to IQ tests. Some people can be exceptional in one area and weaker in another, which will affect the score. It also depends what type of IQ test and whether it plays to your strengths. Some are more language oriented and others more maths oriented. I've done both types. Intelligence does not always reflect in the ability to perform in the school system either. I support multiple intelligences and value all of them. I also support people with an IQ of 1000 choosing to take on a trade or art rather than more academic path if that is what makes them happy.

Minimalme · 30/04/2022 17:49

He will be fine, honestly op, especially as he is good socially.

Lots of kids are bored at school for lots of reasons.

I have one dc who is looking forward for year 10 because he's hoping the work gets harder and another who is bored because everything is still an unfathomable mystery in year 3.

The eldest goes to an under performing comp. The main thing school has taught him is how to throw a punch in self-defence. The rest he seems to teach himself at weekends Grin

ADifferentUser · 30/04/2022 17:35

I wouldn't push the year change thing: I don't think it will increase his chance of getting into a top university (although also won't necessarily prevent it, although I'd be more on the fence if he was older in his year).

I would look into the full-ride scholarships at the big independent schools that others have suggested to see if they're attainable and would work for him and you as a family.

Anything but the most high flying schools state or independent will struggle to stretch a really top end student. You may find a great and dedicated teacher, or a well resourced school, or a group of children at the same level, but from experience I'd say many grammars (say) would struggle to stretch what you're describing.

Theoretical Physics is part of the maths faculty at Cambridge. Where ever he goes to school, think ahead to ensure you will will have access to good further maths teaching. (Could be tutoring / external / online if the school doesn't offer it.)

Look for things to keep him engaged and stretched in the meantime: junior mensa has been suggested, as has chess (if that's his thing and you have a good club for juniors locally). Look for access to county(?) level gifted and talented initiatives. I'd also suggest at nrich (.maths.org) and the RI Maths Masterclasses -- will need a teacher nomination, and the UK Maths Challenge / UK Maths Trust. There are plenty of good books out there too: The Pleasures of Counting (expensive, so borrow?) may be somewhere to start, although it's aimed at slightly older children.

HRTQueen · 30/04/2022 17:21

they are tutored to take the 11+ many prep school children are taking the 11+ early

the tutoring for schools where the competition is high will be weekly text exams in prep schools plus many will have home tutors. They are taught how best to pass a test (if you can’t answer move on to the next question)

it’s not down to intelligence it’s down to the extra work put in to these children

I really dislike this idea that private school children are smarter/better read or more intelligent it’s not the case it’s that these children are privileged abs that privilege impacts how they are educated (smaller classes, extra support on tap is needed)

PaperTyger · 30/04/2022 16:44

Op o have not read the thread but scholarship?

Diverseopinions · 30/04/2022 16:41

Kids in private schools may not all be more intelligent, but the entrance exams ensure they are just below 11+ standard, which is a hard exam to take, so many are academic and well-read.

In private schools, the conversation will revolve at break- time around more intellectual subjects, by and by. I used to come back from Tonbridge to London at 4pm, every day, and I eavesdropped the excited chatter of the uniformed elite talking about transference of particles, when an object is dropped and on the ground for two seconds, etc. And the parents will have intellectual discussions at the dinner table and take an interest in building models, travel, history, etc.

I know it's not the whole picture, and I personally prefer the mix of inclusive education, but I feel that being that brainy, as OP's kid might be, is almost like a special need, and it's almost cruel to expect him to dumb down and tone down his flights of fancy to fit in with a culture which is like a river fed into by some streams of very unacademic influences, as well as bright kids too. But sometimes very brainy people are different, and their social skills are different and geeky because of their enormous brains. He might be teased.
For a rounded just bright kid, I'd say state is fine, but not for a genius. I just don't think the system can create the number of opportunities he needs....not with new-style GCSEs, funding cuts, pressures etc. ....This worst case scenario could happen, only OP can be in a place to predict and judge what is best. I think, by the way, that posters on Mumsnet are very competitive. I see it in these threads and ones about what it's like to be very attractive.

Sweetpea1532 · 30/04/2022 16:35

@BeachMustHave

Ignore the Title of this one about Elon's father...it's just click bait...It shows Elon's true genius...he, of all people could choose to be uppity with his great intellectual ability and wealth but he shows vulnerability and his desire to improve the World.

@Theo1756 that would be Penny singing "Soft Kitty" nowWink

OrangeBalloony · 30/04/2022 16:17

Just no OP.

There are people seriously struggling in this world and you want other people to pay for your DC to go to private school as he's "too smart for state school"

No. You should be ashamed of yourself.

Joystir59 · 30/04/2022 16:16

FrankLeeSpeaking · 30/04/2022 14:45

@Joystir59 I could have read HP at 7 too. Sadly my child prodigy tendencies didn't really carry through, and I got decidedly normal GCSE and A Level results and now have a boring, mundane job instead of a glittering high flying career!

I didn't reach glittering academic heights either, I got a degree, and have always read extensively, and have done some creative writing, but certainly was never usually clever or gifted.

GeniusCreator · 30/04/2022 16:13

@extrastrongmints There is a world of difference between "stumbled through, because they thought it would please the adult in the room" and "devoured independently with full comprehension and immense enjoyment"

He actually asked for the books after watching the the first two films one Christmas. He would have been 6 then. Got through them one by one in about around a week each. He later watched the rest of the films with DH and me knowing what was coming in each one as he’d read the books. Absolutely loved them all and wanted to be Harry for a bit, had costume, wand, bag, lunch box, did the HP studio tour etc. His class started reading the first one a few years later. I know he was the only one in his class who’d read them all as he teacher asked me about it.

As for me not being able to read, hilarious that poster (can’t be bothered to scroll back) obviously hasn’t got the reading comprehension themselves to understand that I said quite clearly that I struggled to read the books out loud, not actually read them, as his part of bedtime story as he wanted to carry on with them. They’re not read aloud books really and there was a lot to read on each page.

OP posts:
HRTQueen · 30/04/2022 15:42

Children at private school are not more intelligent, smarter than other groups of children just they have more focus on them individually and they have been tutored to be able to pass the exams and those schools that have many applicants like a child that will fit in with the school ethos 🙄

better him being moved up a year private or state

Plumbear2 · 30/04/2022 15:39

GeniusCreator · 30/04/2022 00:45

There are two private schools near us. A very good one I should have applied for in Yr6 for but didn’t think about it. The other has scholarships for age 13 in sport and arts only. Those are the two areas he’s not interested in. At Primary, the other DC would ask him to help him with work and school always said he was amazing and a delight. Due to Covid, he missed out on it being picked up on in Yr5/6 probably.

I always knew he was above average. He says he wants to go to Cambridge to be a theoretical physicist (absolutely no prompting from us) but hadn’t really considered how extraordinary he was until he started at secondary and started getting feedback.

I didn’t want to put it in the OP but he currently has the highest points for behaviour, work ethic/effort etc by a big gap out of the whole school (1000 + students) and I have had calls from them marvelling about him. He’s given a presentation at a science event alongside Y10s and 11s taking over a large part of it!

I’m not delusional honestly. Out of my other 3 DC, only one is similar but no where near his level still.

I do not put pressure on him. He needs no prompting with homework. I have to encourage him to actually do some gaming!

I’m going to get this thread deleted as it’s outing now. It was lighthearted with the crowd funding and username. I wouldn’t seriously try to do that!

The fact people can’t comprehend that you can have a super intelligent kid and want to do what’s best for them so they stay motivated and achieve what they’re capable of, say I’m making it up, is boggling really. We are not well off, DH and I didn’t go to Uni and are not particularly knowledgeable about this stuff ourselves, so not sure how to deal with it.

Just to point out that behaviour points for behaviour, work ethic etc do not mean he is the brightest etc. It is possible for children to earn these points regardless of which sets they are in because they know how to behave,have good ethic etc. In fact at the prize giving in our school those in lower sets received the highest number of points because they achieved their very best every single day. Of course they praise your child in his acheivemts, they do this for every child. There will be many children in the school who acheive as highly as him, he is now a small fish in a very big pond.

BrieAndChilli · 30/04/2022 15:36

I think at this age, if you can’t comfortably afford private school then you should look at extra curricular things- chess club, coding club, scouts, sports, tutor, local astronomy club etc etc. Just encourage interests and help develop social skills and other soft skills that will stand him in good stead.
I know lots of very intelligent people who have awful time management/social skills etc.

I have also found (myself included - joining Mensa at 12) that often labelling a child at a young age as extremely gifted puts too much pressure on them and they often crash and burn once that hit adulthood. I rebelled and went travelling for a few years and worked abroad. I then had kids before I developed a career. It’s only now in my 40s I am using my brain.

extrastrongmints · 30/04/2022 15:31

There is a world of difference between "stumbled through, because they thought it would please the adult in the room" and "devoured independently with full comprehension and immense enjoyment". I suspect a lot of those claimed to be reading HP at young ages on MN are the former.
There is also a difference between can and should. The first 3 HP books are fine for mid-primary kids, and reading them at 6 or 7 is not that uncommon (my kids did it, so also did a couple of their bright classmates. However from the 4th book on, there are some teenage/pubescent themes that would really be better left till much older. I do wonder about the judgement of people who let their kids read "all" the HP books at that age - it shows something of a lack of awareness.

goodbyestranger · 30/04/2022 14:59

in top private schools where all the kids are exorcised to get 8s and 9s at gcse etc

Grin
Giraffesandbottom · 30/04/2022 14:57

His IQ came out at 155. Not on a MENSA test granted as you have to send off for them but on an online test that his friends challenged him to do

you don’t “send off” for a Mensa test for a child. They are tested by somebody from Mensa.

tuliplover · 30/04/2022 14:50

If he's that bright perhaps a full scholarship to a boarding school. A friend's son got one at Winchester, and I'm sure others offer it too. But be quick off the mark - bright in your school would be average in top private schools (where all the kids are exorcised to get 8s and 9s at gcse etc) and there's techniques for taking the entrance exams.