Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my DC is too clever for state secondary school?

481 replies

GeniusCreator · 29/04/2022 22:37

DC is Yr7. Top of year according to what I’ve been told. Read the full series of Harry Potter books by 7 years old. Excels in STEM subjects. Spends ages at home researching science stuff like quantum field theory and nuclear fusion/fission and enjoys it! Designs his own websites and writes his own code for his own games. Primary school were always pretty amazed by him. Secondary school have picked up on him now and have said they’ve never seen anything like him.

He’s already mentioning being a bit bored in class. We live in what could be described as a deprived town and are not well off, no family to help out, so would never be able to get him into a private school. I did check with the private school in the next town but there are no scholarships available.

WIBU to try to crowdfund for private school fees?

He needs a much higher level curriculum than the state school one to continue stretching him. I honestly think he’s destined for amazing things.

<only slightly light hearted>

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Luculentus · 30/04/2022 06:38

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

OhRiRi · 30/04/2022 06:37

I’ve read his WhatsApp messaging where he’ll talk about random science stuff and they’ll be 🤣.

this suggests to me that he's maybe not picking up on social cues and things despite on the surface having a large group of friends? * *

CallipygousElephant · 30/04/2022 06:34

There are many very simple truths that can be applied here.

If he is truly exceptional (ie. a prodigy) he WOULD be flagged for scholarships and you would have been approached. Child prodigies in early high school years are not simply working 'at the top of their classes', but at massively massively advanced levels outwith curriculum that high schools provide (state or private).

Very very clever children (which I think would be a fairer assumption), do fantastically in a range of educational environments, including states schools, if encouraged, enabled and supported.

Very very clever children often burn out in their early adulthood. The pressure (even if you don't intend to put pressure on him, you ARE, by taking this attitude at all) high achieving children are put under often lots of different pressures just by the adults around them valuing their intelligence highly in an open manner. Gifted child burnout in late high school, college/uni or early adulthood is INCREDIBLY common - they can find that without the expectations of others that they are meeting to please people, that they have simply run out of motivation. They rarely learn to study properly unless actively taught, because they take everything in like a sponge and test fantastically with little to no study. They read books like most of us drink water and they become completely used to (and expectant of) the constant praise and pride of being and doing 'better' than peers.

Let him be a child, facilitate any interests he has that you can, listen to him chat about what he's fascinated with and let him excel if he excels. I was your son (though a daughter), 18 years ago. I burned out, became completely riddled with the anxiety of not living up to expectations and didn't pursue further education due to my mental health - despite on paper being, yes, 'remarkable'.

It's not that rare, he is unlikely to be the next Einstein, and if he's going to be - he will find a way regardless.

There is a lot of literature on gifted-child burnout, I'd suggest having a read and calming down a little bit. (Though I've no idea why anyone would suggest you shouldn't burst with pride and other very normal reactions to your own child's achievements!)

WildCoasts · 30/04/2022 06:32

It's great to be a proud parent but it sounds like all is going well with your son. I'd just stay the course and trust that he will continue to learn and explore on his own, as he does now. He's already extending himself and developing interests. You just need to be responsive to providing opportunities that interest him.

As a caution, I offer that I was similarly bright and the academic recognition didn't do me any favours. It became so much how I defined myself, won the approval of my parents, my defense mechanism was that I was smarter and could out academic people. Everyone thought I was cut out for great things. Unfortunately despite the talk up everyone gave me, I was wanting greatly. There were a lot of unmet needs, ambitions and issues that were able to be hidden under the crutch of academic brilliance. My parents would have told you I was fine and doing well too.

Please let your son know his value beyond academics.

PS: I disappointed everyone's academic expectations with my life choices and don't regret it one bit. My heart hadn't really been in the direction I was pushed.

Backtomyoldname · 30/04/2022 06:31

Without wishing to seem unpleasant but the majority of parents think that their DCs are clever and above average.

I know your son is in Y7 but in terms of secondary education its early days. He was seen to be able/top of class in junior school - but big fish in small pond.

Now in secondary - small fish in a big pond and there will, almost certainly be those who are his academic equals.

The majority of pupils will report back that their day has been boring.

I’d put more emphasis on producing a happy well rounded teenager than a clutch of high grades.

There’s more to education than exam passes.

This could be me writing about my son 20 ish years ago. Top of Y6. Went to secondary and came across his equals. ( how do I know this? - he was a pupil at the school I taught at - I saw the figures, test scores etc. We could have hot housed him, gone for private education etc

We decided he would be happier where he was. Looking back we made the right decision.

Ask if he should be considered as gifted and talented. ( that could open further doors at school). Continue to provide opportunities out of school. Take an active interest in what he does both in and out of school.

Please don’t be taken in by the sometimes false promises/idea that paying for education means it will be better. Some private schools are crap. Some are good but have done their pupils no favours - Boris, Jacob I’m thinking of you.

By all means try crowd funding but I’ve more chance of getting vets fees paid for a broken kitten’s leg than you have of school fees.

Hastingsontheup · 30/04/2022 06:31

I have a very bright DS, as you can see from my user name we live in Hastings which has some of the worst performing schools nationally. I absolutely shared your concerns that he would have been bored in our local school (has been in special measures forver) and as a previous poster said in a deprived area I worried about crime and drugs.

Luckily we managed to circumnavigate this by sending him to a SS grammar over the Kent border. But there is no way on this earth his needs would have been met in the local school. He has just turned 18 on track for 4 A*s one of tbe highest achieving in his highly selective school and yes has a place at Oxbridge from October.

user1494050295 · 30/04/2022 06:29

Any local universities. A neighbour had her 13 year old taking access classes. Very bright. See what might be available. Also look at adult colleges and see if you can enroll him in extra classes to keep him engaged.

Quincythequince · 30/04/2022 06:28

Sushi7 · 29/04/2022 22:50

YABU to expect other people to pay for your son’s education. Sorry, but lots of dc are into coding and are encouraged to learn it nowadays. Harry Potter books aren’t difficult to read for a primary school child, but the content in books 3 onwards are not appropriate for a 7 year old. If he’s bored then he needs to join some clubs - learn new skills and make new friends.

This 👆🏻
He doesn’t sound any different to my son’s (two of them) . Whilst very bright, the curriculum is the curriculum and unless he’s already been taught it, he doesn’t know it yet does he!

Plenty of stretch activities to be engaged with there.

Sophie624 · 30/04/2022 06:25

Plenty of bursaries in top private schools for super clever children who can’t afford it. Can you move? Send him boarding? Will he be happy in a private school though?

iloveeverykindofcat · 30/04/2022 06:25

You can get into Cambridge from state schools.😂I did it.

Well OP, I have a genius-level IQ. Yes, it's been tested. Many times. I went to a state comp and I didn't love it, but I do think it made me a more well-rounded person. I mostly educated myself by reading: the Cambridge interview was primarily about my interests and personal ideas, not about what I'd learned at school.

MinnieMountain · 30/04/2022 06:14

Plenty of children go to the top universities from state schools you know OP.

Florrey · 30/04/2022 06:14

I’ve seen people crowdfund 10-20 grand for a course. But I doubt you could crowdfund £150k for seven years of private school. Even scholarships expect you to be as poor as a church mouse, if you have any assets at all they’ll expect you to spend those first, e.g. sell the family home and use that money. I get what you’re saying, the state school system doesn’t really cater for above average children (a few areas have selective grammar schools but most areas don’t). But the government doesn’t care and neither does anyone else, they’re only obliged to offer a basic education not a good education. Your best shot is to pay for extra curricular activities to stretch your child.

Cliftontherocks · 30/04/2022 06:03

My daughter is exceptionally bright.

she was highly academic from the word go and polite and friendly from the word go. She struggled with PE but that is due to a medical problem.
At 11 she had a reading age of 18 and devoured books. Full marks in her KS2 sats.
She applied and got in to an indie girls grammar and loved it and then we relocated in year 8 during lockdown. She started at the local outstanding state school. She was due to do several GCSEs in her 8 but due to lockdown and the new school they were reluctant to enter her for gcse and did not have enough evidence. She did some gcse in year 9 and got level 9s. Alongside her normal GCSEs she is doing a couple of a levels this year in year 10 and is on track to get A*. The rest of her GCSEs are all level 9 and her teachers frequently give her A level work. I had a meeting with the head back in year 9 as he said her teachers had said she was pretty much ready to do all her GCSEs. The issue then is did she do a levels in all those subjects in year 10/11 so maybe 3 a levels then and 4 in sixth form and she’s already got 2! It gets ridiculous. She doesn’t need 9 a levels.
we came up with a different plan. She is doing 2 a levels in stem subjects this year. Interestingly these aren’t her favourite ones but for things like maths to keep accelerating they don’t advise a break between say gcse and a level and a level and university.
Instead the time spent on homework we have invested in things she wants to do socially as that was the main issue polite and friendly but recently discovered high functioning autistic girls mask their autism by learning facial cues etc - she is autistic. Recently confirmed.
so she has some ‘geeky’ outing hobbies - think bonsai tree identification or something, she loves chess, she loves art and creating so we given her everything she needs to follow these hobbies but for example painting can be quite lonely but we wanted to encourage the social part and she hates sports. So instead we found things she wants to do eg horses. She rides and helps out down at a stables and spends the morning there - this gives her a nice group of friends and outside time as well as animals. She does things like navigating which is helping her socially and academically by using her brain. She does music and has joined a band. She is a member of scouts etc lots of team building activities etc
an outstanding state school has been fine but it has taken a lot of discussion as I can assure you no state school wants to enter early due to the what next question? As I said we discussed the option of her doing GCSEs in most subjects in year 9 but what then ? And that’s the same issue as private schools!

I am under no allusions the jump to gcse from primary is large and the jump to a level is huge and then the jump to university. At the moment my daughter has found it easier to do the stem subjects like maths ‘untaught’ using a textbook but subjects like English I believe need discussion with others to get breath and width of perspective and arguing / discussion of ideas so it has been ‘easier’ for her to do maths etc early although her teachers have been amazing she works on her own stuff alongside her peers. Eg they do year 10 work she does year 13. We are lucky as a contact at the local university from one of the teachers said would do some university maths etc with her as part of an outreach program.

my daughters issue is she is level 9 or more across the board so is not sure about what she wants to do - eg maths or medicine or English etc and the school are very aware of this and have been really helpful
eg pointing out that for medicine it is the a level achieved in one sitting that is accepted and for some maths and further maths only count as one subject etc and considering bmat exams

be aware that with great self expectations and ability comes pressure and mistakes can be seen as failures. Eg if you are used to getting full marks on a test paper, you can be judged for getting a level 8 or it not being ‘good enough’. My daughter used to get upset if she ever got a question wrong eg a maths question on the gcse until a kind professor at a local university spoke to her and pointed out the greatest scientists and even he made mistakes and even shared his examples it then twigged that she needs to be able to confront that - and that was a big turning point.

just pressure and expectation are so difficult to manage. My daughter has no idea if and what she will be she just knows she is loved and she is always always good enough and we love her for who she is and not what she achieves.

good luck

Butterfly1066 · 30/04/2022 06:01

The OP just sounds unpleasant though

Her son sounds marvellous

ilovesooty · 30/04/2022 05:59

I see it's going to be another thread where the OP has "privacy concerns".

Snoopsnoggysnog · 30/04/2022 05:36

While the OP sounds a little deluded, there is a lot of jealous and inverse snobbery on this thread.

and a lot of misinformation.

OP it’s bursaries not scholarships you want to be looking for, and you should approach both the private schools in your area you’ve mentioned, and also look further afield.

AlternativePerspective · 30/04/2022 05:20

If he really is that bright he will flourish wherever he is.

A 7 year old proclaiming that “I know that they’re fantasy” sounds like a precocious brat though tbh.

BritWifeInUSA · 30/04/2022 05:17

Harry Potter books? It’s wonderful that he loves to read but it’s hardly remarkable. If you had said he was reading Sartre or Brecht at 7 you might have a gifted child there. But he doesn’t sound any more intelligent than many other high-achievers.

SquirrelG · 30/04/2022 05:12

He sounds happy OP so I would just leave things as they are. A bright kid will do well whatever school they attend, and I don't believe that the education given at a private school is any better.

sashh · 30/04/2022 05:04

Is he happy?

Regardless of how talented a child is they have ONE childhood. If he is happy leave well alone.

MissNothing1991 · 30/04/2022 04:54

GeniusCreator · 29/04/2022 23:02

Re, the Harry Potter books. They’re not exactly ‘kids’ books are they? A lot of 9-10 year olds would struggle to read one a week. There’s a lot of text on each page. I should know, he made me read some out loud as a bedtime story. I only managed a few pages each time! We didn’t want to get him the later books, especially Deathly Hallows, but he told me that he knew it was fantasy not reality and he was fine.

There are no grammar schools in our area at all.

Is that right that I can ask to have him moved up a year? He’s one of the youngest in the his current year though (August birthday).

Yes, they are kids books. I know many children who could read them by 7. I'd be embarrassed admitting that, as an adult, you can only read a few pages of a kids book. I probably read more advanced books by 7, I was a very advanced reader. Funnily enough nobody offered to contribute to put me through private school. Can't imagine why Hmm

Joystir59 · 30/04/2022 04:45

By that age I was reading the classics. I am far from a genius. Calm down OP. If he's bright he will be fine at state school.

ShandaLear · 30/04/2022 04:42

You can also enrich his learning with EdEx - free courses from Harvard, MIT, etc.

www.edx.org/search

Rattles1 · 30/04/2022 04:33

I was moved up a year. And then went to a grammar school for a levels out of town - there were lots of us which took the train, bus or drove there

ShandaLear · 30/04/2022 04:32

You do know an independent school will just teach the same curriculum, don’t you? There isn’t a special extra hard curriculum - it’s just the same one as everywhere else. If he’s already getting top grades independent school isn’t going to improve them. You might want to look at enriching his learning though. Check out your local universities for things public lecture series or hackathons he could attend. Look for online free coding courses, or sign up to something like FutureLearn which have tonnes of courses that can be done for free in anything he wants.