Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my DC is too clever for state secondary school?

481 replies

GeniusCreator · 29/04/2022 22:37

DC is Yr7. Top of year according to what I’ve been told. Read the full series of Harry Potter books by 7 years old. Excels in STEM subjects. Spends ages at home researching science stuff like quantum field theory and nuclear fusion/fission and enjoys it! Designs his own websites and writes his own code for his own games. Primary school were always pretty amazed by him. Secondary school have picked up on him now and have said they’ve never seen anything like him.

He’s already mentioning being a bit bored in class. We live in what could be described as a deprived town and are not well off, no family to help out, so would never be able to get him into a private school. I did check with the private school in the next town but there are no scholarships available.

WIBU to try to crowdfund for private school fees?

He needs a much higher level curriculum than the state school one to continue stretching him. I honestly think he’s destined for amazing things.

<only slightly light hearted>

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
XelaM · 30/04/2022 07:55

I believe you OP.

My dad was like this as a kid. He has a photographic memory and could read grown up books by age of 4 and recite them by heart, recite an encyclopaedia etc. A real wonderkid.

My brother actually went to Cambridge followed by Harvard (in STEM) and he wasn't nearly as smart as my dad at that age, but like your son he also researched quantum mechanics "for fun" in his free time and taught himself coding as a hobby. He could also assemble any Rubiks cube (of all sizes/shapes) in under a minute, which he also taught himself and practiced in his free time. He was also always Mr Popular at school and a class clown, still has a really wide circle of friends (he's in his 20's).

But a kid like that doesn't need a private school to succeed. In fact, they will succeed anywhere. Talk to the school about skipping a year but also enter him in competitions like Maths Olympia and similar (not sure what they're called but speak to the school).

Overthewine · 30/04/2022 07:55

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Everydaydayisaschoolday · 30/04/2022 07:55

Lol. Private schools don't necessarily add value for clever kids.

My DS was reading HP at age 8 so pretty clever too. He went to the local comp and then a Russell group uni. He then got one of a very few graduate jobs at a prestigious London Merchant Bank and has progressed rapidly. He did all this while playing several musical instruments to a high level, coaching his sport as a paying P/T job from age 16 and volunteering at two youth groups. One offering free maths tuition to younger children and the other offering support to the severely disabled. It

if you feel school isn't sufficiently stimulating for him remember there is more to life and learning than the national curriculum . There are extra curricular activities such as drama, sport, music, chess etc that will stretch and develop him and improve his eligibility for a good uni. Outside school there are even more opportunities including scouts, st John’s, Army Cadets and I'm sure that locally and online you will find even more.

At the end of his school career the best he can achieve is 4 or 5 good A Levels. If he is as clever as you say I am sure he doesn't need a private school to get these. Let him develop in non academic ways as well.

IDontLikeMondays88 · 30/04/2022 07:55

😂

liveforsummer · 30/04/2022 07:53

If he wants to go to Cambridge then he gets bonus points for achieving top grades from a poor state school. There will be loads of great grades applying from the private so that's less impressive. It's the ones with the good connections through their high profile parents that get the places from private - can get the work experience etc.

My nephew had unconditional offers from all the competitive units he applied to with a year of his average state school still to go and went on to achieve the highest results the school had ever seen. Moving him up was never considered- he had an established friendship group, as it sounds your son has too which is equally as important throughout high school. There are lots of ways he can expand on his learning within the state system and as the school have already identified him, it sounds like they are on the ball. agree with pp's when saying make sure you look after his mental health. That would be the biggest concern in this case and something my sister was always very aware of with my nephew.

ButtockUp · 30/04/2022 07:53

Maybe approach your son's school about putting him on their 'Gifted and Talented' register .
If they feel that he fits the criteria then the school will have to make special provision for him.

BeachMustHave · 30/04/2022 07:53

Is this a joke?

Sunshine847 · 30/04/2022 07:52

I don't mean to do your son a disservice but all four of our children have read Harry Potter books and started at 6...my 7 year old loves them at the moment. Lots of us have bright kids and not bright kids and we all worry. Actually a lot of people use private schools when they need their children to have extra support as the classes are so small.

You could look for selective private schools and scholarships but you will find at those all the children are bright like your son, and that he's bright enough to get in, but may not get the scholarship...the only worry is if you go down that route, is scholarships and bursaries can be withdrawn. You'd have to also show him the school and he could end up very disappointed. Also remember you need to fund the uniform and trips etc which are expensive. In addition schools put their fees up regularly....its a lot to consider

Good luck

Prettypussy · 30/04/2022 07:52

Harry Pottter is NOT written for 7 year olds!

Louise0701 · 30/04/2022 07:48

You really think 9/10 year olds can’t read Harry Potter?

YABVU and I can’t even be bothered to go into why. You’ve 10 pages of it.

Bobbins36 · 30/04/2022 07:47

amazing 🤣 your child can’t be too smart for secondary school. If they are bright
and self motivated they will
excel. If however they need hand holding and wrapped in cotton wool then by all means investigate private school. Private schools are better at handling nightmare parents though, so there’s always that.

Sweetpea1532 · 30/04/2022 07:46
@GeniusCreator This is a very interesting interview of Maye Musk, Elon Musk's mother about his childhood.. If the link doesn't work, search on YouTube for Maye Musk CBS Los Angeles interview in Aug 2020 or 2021.
ParisNoir · 30/04/2022 07:45

You want to crowd fund for private school? you want people to give you their money in a time of austerity and fuel rises so your kid can attend private school?

hahahahaha! thanks for the giggle this morning OP! 😂

hellcatspanglelalala · 30/04/2022 07:43

TheAbbotOfUnreason · 30/04/2022 00:18

In Scotland you could easily be starting uni at age 17.

Which is pointless, as you end up stuck at home while all your housemates go to the pub.

Fucket · 30/04/2022 07:42

I’ve just had to do an assignment for my teacher training linked to this document from Ofsted.

potentialplusuk.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Ofsted-Reporting-of-Provision-for-the-Most-Able-Pupils.pdf

I wouldn’t think any parent of a child not being challenged enough at school would be unreasonable in approaching the school about it.

I can imagine that post covid the situation has only got worse.

GettinPiggyWithIt · 30/04/2022 07:41

over2021 · 29/04/2022 22:47

Biscuit LOL.

My best friend's son goes to a private school because he's not particularly academic and didn't pass his 11+. When I say not particularly academic I mean lazy, can't be arsed to write, thinks maths is a bore (no learning difficulties). Don't assume private schools are full of clever kids. A lot go to private schools because their parents know they won't get a job off their grades but might off of their connections.

^ That’s total crap.

My kids are at a private school. My husband and I also went, and I can tell you that private school parents want results and yes the teachers don’t actually let you slack off because that’s bad for their reputation. My children are far happier now that they’re being challenged academically.

op my son was like yours which is why we left the state system and he has thrived. Unfortunately, apart from hunting down bursaries and scholarships there’s not much you can do about day to day education.

You can do a lot of educate him in your private time though and there are loads of free resources for gifted children online/ and also summer camps. It depends where his interests lie. What are his interests?

LizzieSiddal · 30/04/2022 07:40

I’m in the minority but think YANBU

However I wouldn’t crowdfund I’d do everything within my power to get him into an excellent private school on a full bursary. Go and speak to these schools, as many are desperate for pupils having lost many Russian and Chinese pupils. My Friend has just moved her extremely bright Dd from state to a very well regarded private school, they gave them a massive discount completely out of the blue(they hadn’t been asked for one, but it is very welcome). She has absolutely flourished since September.

good luck 💐

homeEd2021 · 30/04/2022 07:37

SammyScrounge · 30/04/2022 02:17

I'agree with Puffalicious. I have never seen an academically gifted pupil refuse school. The reasons for refusing are complex but don't include boredom.

Our child was bored rigid by school and well on the way to school refusal and/or depression. An ed psych evaluation showed exceptional ability and recommended acceleration, citing the supporting research. The school refused to implement, insisting on the basis of no evidence other than their personal opinion that he'd be just fine doing the same work as age peers. He asked to be home educated.
It doesn't seem to have occurred to you that:
(a) the reason you are not seeing school refusers in school is because they have already refused school.
(b) if they're refusing school and not fitting in with your pre-conceived expectations of what a gifted child should look like, then they won't be identified in school as an "academically gifted pupil" if or when they turn up, regardless of their underlying potential or cognitive ability.
Frankly, the presence in schools of teachers like you lot (i.e. blinkered, untrained and poorly read on gifted education, full of preconceived fallacious notions of what a gifted child should or shouldn't look like, and therefore unaware of what is in front of your noses) are why we chose in the end to home educate.

WildCoasts · 30/04/2022 07:36

Take him on forest walks, to see movies, to do some volunteer work, expose him to art and maybe do some crafts, teach him too DIY and use tools, encourage a sport if he is interested, teach him to cook. There's so much more to grow a whole rounded person than academics (while nurturing that as well, of course).

Blarting · 30/04/2022 07:32

YABU

RaaRaaOhhhLaaaLaaa · 30/04/2022 07:32

Why are you not responding to people's advice, points and questions?

Someone asked if you were doing anything to stretching him by taking him to debate clubs, music lessons and chess.

Someone asked if he had read any classics like Black Beauty.

But you are just saying how great he is all of the time.

We get it. He needs more than his school is providing.

You are unlikely to get five years of school fees from a crowd fundraiser. So you need to think of something different.

He's your son. What are you doing to enrich him?

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 30/04/2022 07:29

Bright kids (if they have a lot of self motivation, and broadly supportive parents) generally will be fine in state school.
DS2 has clearly been very academic since primary. He had the highest GCSE results his state secondary school had ever seen. As an example of kind of things he does, he heard about the concept of memory palaces (from watching Sherlock 🤣), so did all his GCSE revision using that technique, in a fraction of the time recommended by his teachers.
He is currently having a gap year and will tale a place at Oxford (with an organ scholarship) this autumn.

WildCoasts · 30/04/2022 07:27

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

I went to university in my mid-teens while my friends went back to school. I have more than one highly gifted child. I get it. I relate. I think the voices of those who have been that child are worth listening to. If the child has the interest they will be self-driven. I'm just encouraging the OP to keep things balanced. Academics are just one aspect of her son to value and encourage.

lickenchugget · 30/04/2022 07:27

IncompleteSenten · 30/04/2022 07:14

Light-hearted as in a complete joke and I would never consider for a second asking strangers to pay for my son's education or light-hearted as in let me drop this in and see people's reactions. If I get torn a new one I'll probably leave it but if I get a bit of encouragement my next click will be to go fund me?

This.

It’s the crowdfunding element that has invoked the reaction.

PurpleFlower1983 · 30/04/2022 07:23

@GeniusCreator

What is the sixth form/college like that he will go to? It sounds like secondary will be easy for him but I would make sure he gets into a very good sixth form. No reason why he can’t go onto great things from a state education.