Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feel sick with the shame

140 replies

Pumpupthejammin · 29/04/2022 22:37

I hit/smacked my almost 4 year old Dd today, never have before.
Her behaviour has been so so difficult for the last couple of months. Today she was shouting at me, her grandma, hitting and kicking me, she wouldn’t stop.
She cried afterwards and I held her.
Sitting here crying as I feel so horrendous, wish I could take it back

OP posts:
Refrosty · 30/04/2022 00:54

Move on. This won't break her. Giving her a complex about it, or making this into something bigger, due to your guilt might make things ten times worse.

MyCatIsAJerk · 30/04/2022 00:50

My mum smacked me, more than once and I must say every time I was truly misbehaving — and yes I remembered it and never repeated the very, very naughty behavior.

It didn’t scar me at all, but it did teach me that certain behaviour is unacceptable and that when Mum said “Stop it, that’s enough,” she meant it.

Rikitikitardis · 30/04/2022 00:47

I’m sure this experience will help make sure that you never do it again. I don’t expect there will be any long term harm from a single smack. So no need to panic.

On the other hand I am surprised how relaxed some posters are being with the “everyone makes mistakes” attitude.
Since March smacking is physical assault in Wales. And I have to say I agree. If it’s not okay for an adult to be smacked, then it’s not okay for a child.
I’m not sure that many would take the “we all make mistakes” attitude if it was a husband who smacked his wife.

mycatisannoying · 30/04/2022 00:38

Tomorrow's another day OP Flowers

oakleaffy · 30/04/2022 00:32

Pumpupthejammin · 29/04/2022 22:56

I can’t stop thinking about it, can’t believe I did it, feel so shit 😪

We have all done things we regret.
Don't worry about it too much.
The perfect parent doesn't yet exist.

SammyScrounge · 30/04/2022 00:17

GreenLunchBox · 29/04/2022 22:41

I wouldn't beat myself up about it

You've never hit her before but she figured out how to do it.

Maybe now she will realise hitting is not very nice

<Steps back to be flamed>

Quite right.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 30/04/2022 00:13

ladydimitrescu · 29/04/2022 23:42

Sorry but it's not fine - it's not the end of the world and you obviously are distraught, but this comment is ridiculous. It's not fine, and of course you should apologise for hitting a small child.

“do not repeatedly apologise to your 4 year old”. I agree with that. There’s no need to distress a small child further by making a big deal of it.

Mamanyt · 30/04/2022 00:10

If this is the worst mistake you make between now and when she turns 18, you'll have done a stellar job. Smacking a child, while NOT what you want to be your go-to response, is not the end of the world if it only happens once.

CorsicaDreaming · 30/04/2022 00:10

PS - sorry OP i was sure that book went up to 4 years but I now realise it's more aimed at the baby years.

CorsicaDreaming · 30/04/2022 00:06

The Wonder Weeks

The Wonder Weeks - A Stress-Free Guide to Your Baby`s Behaviour: A Stress-Free Guide to Your Baby's Behavior https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/168268427X/ref=cmswwrcppapiii_BY4T019M7A03173KNSM0

malificent7 · 30/04/2022 00:06

I rekon that more parents do it than admit. At least you feel sad about it.

CorsicaDreaming · 30/04/2022 00:04

I think 4 years is a very difficult age -

They really know their own mind and want their own way.
But are too young to reason with and see anyone else's point of view.

They a beginning to have fewer naps, so you have even less time and space,
but they still need complete care and attention as they have no common sense.

It is exhausting mentally and physically

Don't be too hard on yourself OP.

But do read some useful books on coping strategies. Just walk off if you really think you may do it again. Shut the bedroom door. Count to ten. Breathe. Give yourself a few seconds to get calmer. It will also signal to your DD that such behaviour means they LOSE your attention and get no reaction. So it can help to defuse it both ways round.

I found The Wonder Years a helpful read. It suggests children go through particularly challenging behaviour just as they are moving on to a new stage of development. And then they will develop the next set of skills. It's a very interesting idea and I found it helped to think "it must be a wonder week!" When DS was being especially difficult...

Sunnytwobridges · 29/04/2022 23:57

She was hitting and kicking you, And you hit your limit. As long as it’s a one off it’s no big deal. She will be okay. Just walk away next time.

Monty27 · 29/04/2022 23:53

It's done it's over. You know how bad it is and tomorrow is a new day.
It's a lesson to you both.

sausageandbeansx · 29/04/2022 23:51

My parents smacked me all the time as a child. It was 100% a rubbish way to punish us. I remember saying ‘ner ner that didn’t even hurt’ and being a little s* after they did it. But she wont be traumatised, I have a very good relationship with my parents

trainnane · 29/04/2022 23:49

Truth is that we all break at times and do things we regret. Whilst I don't agree with hitting kids as they learn that behaviour, I've done the same when pushed the the limits

LowlandLucky · 29/04/2022 23:47

Very few parents are "perfect" and very few have "perfect" children, you live a real life and you have reacted out stress and exasperation. I was smacked twice as a child, i remember it but it hasn't traumatised me, i don't hate my parents for it, in fact i really don't think anything of it.

Happymum12345 · 29/04/2022 23:45

I really doubt she’ll remember. You’ve said sorry & you’re genuinely remorseful. Everyone makes mistakes but not everyone is sorry. All will be well. I personally wouldn’t talk about it again unless she brings it up. E gentle with yourself.

ladydimitrescu · 29/04/2022 23:42

NrlySp · 29/04/2022 22:46

It’s fine. We are all human. There are a lot lot worse things other parents have done. Forgive yourself, move on. Do no repeatedly apologize to your 4 year old

Sorry but it's not fine - it's not the end of the world and you obviously are distraught, but this comment is ridiculous. It's not fine, and of course you should apologise for hitting a small child.

babbi · 29/04/2022 23:38

You need to give yourself a break and be kind to yourself.
Youre finding things a bit challenging at the moment which is so typical when you have children that age .
Stop beating yourself up.. your DD will be fine . Take care

NewYorkCityDreamer · 29/04/2022 23:38

i was smacked as a child by both of my parents. My mam did it maybe 15-20 times when I was being ‘naughty’ (since diagnosed with autism and ADHD) when at the end of her tether.

My dad did it in a calculated way when my mam wasn’t home. I hate my dad and avoid him as much as possible, especially now I’m 23 and realise how much I was struggling with big feelings.

I forgive my mam and realise how hard it was for her. I know she was trying.

don’t beat yourself up too much but don’t do it again

PJsAndRainyDays · 29/04/2022 23:31

I think you would find, that if people were truly honest, a lot of us have done exactly the same in a moment of desperation.

You are a good parent, a bad parent wouldn't even care or feel bad. You know now how it's made you and her feel and hopefully it will never happen again Flowers

Mariposista · 29/04/2022 23:24

Ok, it wasn’t the best way to handle things but you were pushed to the limit by her bad, bratty behaviour. Give yourself a break. Next time you will know the triggers. Tomorrow is another day. Guaranteed you have not messed things up for good - but don’t now overcompensate and spoil her -she needs to learn that kicking and hurting are not ok.

RoseLunarPink · 29/04/2022 23:23

Op you know it wasn’t good and you feel terrible - that shows you are not an awful parent. You were stressed and being hit and kicked, having your buttons pushed and you reacted, it happens. Now you know what can lead to that and work on ways to head it off, stay calm etc. - and though I’m opposed to smacking I also don’t think it’s the end of the world for your child to realise you are human and have your limits.

if it helps at all, both my DC were at their absolute worst for tantrums and hitting etc at nearly 4, and got better after that. And while I haven’t hit, I have pushed them away roughly, or pulled them too hard by the arm, in situations like this and felt really ashamed too.

I agree with saying sorry and explaining you were cross and should have handled it differently, but briefly and don’t keep talking about it or make it into a big thing. And work together on ways to calm down, read books about angry feelings etc - it helped my DD when she learned to describe it as a volcano exploding, so she could sense when she felt it building up and talk about it.

hope you’re feeling a bit better.

Whybot · 29/04/2022 23:19

I told my kids , when teenagers, that I lost my temper and smacked them a few times, but that it didn’t work to reduce the poor behaviour and we talked about why not. I also told them sorry at the time and when talked about it . One day they’ll be parents and like many parents may struggle with tiredness and anger. Is there anyone in real life you can confess this too? Your remorse suggests to me you’re a good mum. .