Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feel sick with the shame

140 replies

Pumpupthejammin · 29/04/2022 22:37

I hit/smacked my almost 4 year old Dd today, never have before.
Her behaviour has been so so difficult for the last couple of months. Today she was shouting at me, her grandma, hitting and kicking me, she wouldn’t stop.
She cried afterwards and I held her.
Sitting here crying as I feel so horrendous, wish I could take it back

OP posts:
amylou8 · 30/04/2022 07:36

She will be fine. My parents smacked me, my teachers smacked me, I smacked my children (now in their 20s). None of us are emotionally traumatised by it. I know times have changed and most people now consider it unacceptable. Berating yourself and getting upset, especially infont of your daughter, will achieve nothing.

drpet49 · 30/04/2022 07:23

Sorry but it's not fine - it's not the end of the world and you obviously are distraught, but this comment is ridiculous. It's not fine, and of course you should apologise for hitting a small child.

^This. If a man came on here saying he did this he would be labelled as abusive. Funny that.

Frogslegsbigfeet · 30/04/2022 07:18

I don’t understand d these comments, if a man posted that he found his wife’s behaviour challenging and he lost control so he smacked her one, no one would be saying oh don’t worry about it, the fact it’s a little child doesn’t change that.

and to say oh well it would only be the same if his wife was hitting him is shameful, this is a four year old, not a grown adult.

op, I think you need to understand how you can get further help if you are struggling to cope like this . I understand why you don’t want to tell your husband but this can’t be some secret you both keep, you need to find ways to ensure this situation doesn’t arise again.

Totheweekend · 30/04/2022 07:16

If this was a woman who say their partner had hit them this thread would be LTB-central. I’m a bit shocked at all of the ‘don’t be too hard on yourself’ responses. You hit your child. Feeling shame is a good reaction.
But what’s done is done, what’s matters is what happens next. How are you going to improve your reactions / parenting to ensure this never happens again?

girlmom21 · 30/04/2022 07:14

NrlySp · 29/04/2022 22:46

It’s fine. We are all human. There are a lot lot worse things other parents have done. Forgive yourself, move on. Do no repeatedly apologize to your 4 year old

It's not fine. If OP posted her husband had hit her you wouldn't say "it's fine, it was a one off."

OP maybe consider some parenting classes if you're struggling to manage her behaviour?
Talk to her dad if you're at the end of your tether.

Sweepingeyelashes · 30/04/2022 07:11

@alittlefickle for somebody opposed to causing pain and being a perfect mother and all, why are you trying to make the stressed OP who made a mistake feel so bad? Does it make you feel better about yourself in some way?

PeaceLurking9to5 · 30/04/2022 06:53

yOU'RE being too hard on yourself.

Smacking is not your go-to, it's not your disciplining method.

You lost control. That's what scares you. You're a good person who aims to do things the right way and you lost control of yourself.

The ''antidote'' for shame is self=compassion and according to my therapis (!)t it will also make you less reactionary.

Billandben444 · 30/04/2022 06:16

Maybe you can use it as a jumping point to seek help for yourself so you can manage her behaviour in a better way
Seek help? Wow, just wow!
OP, you know it was wrong, you feel awful and you've apologised to her and you don't deserve to get flamed on here. There would be a huge problem if you didn't feel bad about it but please don't be too hard on yourself. It's important to move on from it though or your daughter will sense that you were the only one behaving badly and that she was totally innocent. I slapped my daughter's leg 30 years ago when she was a similar age, in public outside a department store, and I've never forgotten it and what a terrible thing it was that I'd done. It never ever happened again, she has no recollection of it and we're best friends. Remember what happened and how you feel about it today and then it will never happen again. You're a good mum because you feel so bad about it.

alittlefickle · 30/04/2022 06:14

Sorry, but yes!

My son is 23 and I've NEVER hit him, not even a tap on the hand.... punished yes, taken things away, yes, stuck to the punishment, yes (he always learnt from being punished).

My theory is, when you have a child and they hurt themselves, you want to comfort them, take the pain away, so why would you choose to cause that pain????

mum61 · 30/04/2022 06:06

@Pumpupthejammin I understand how you feel. I did the same once .
I was caring for my daughter alone(her father was working away )I was working and feeling exhausted. My daughter was 4 yrs old and pushing boundaries daily.
The day before she was to be a bridesmaid she sneaked a pair of scissors and cut her fringe off to the roots, I handled this quite well and kept calm.
The next day she painted her bedroom wall with blue nail varnish.I managed that fine.
The third day she got a knitting needle from a high cupboard and ran out to the garden holding the needle pointed at her stomach, she looked a the defiantly ,the grass was overgrown and the ground uneven then she started to run . I had visions of her falling and impaled on the knitting needle ,I was absolutely terrified ,I ran grabbed her by the arm and smacked her 3 times on the back of the legs ,she looked at me we horror . I immediately apologised and hugged her we both cried. I put child locks on draws and cupboards the next day. I felt as you describe about the incident for years .
My daughter is an adult now and we discussed it recently , we both believe smacking is not the best way and I still say im sorry I lost it that day.
My daughter ribs me about it occasionally and laughs.... I don't though it still haunts me.

MintJulia · 30/04/2022 06:02

Don't blame yourself, it can be very difficult and it's a one off.
I slapped my son once. He was a toddler and punched me in the face when I was asleep on the sofa. I lashed out without meaning to.
But he never did that again, neither of us was harmed, he's a perfectly normal teen now and we have a normal healthy relationship.
Put it down to experience and move on. We are all human.

Yellownightmare · 30/04/2022 05:55

I did this once to my younger son who was a real handful, when I was very stressed and getting no support (not an excuse, just for context). I apologised to him the next day and explained I shouldn't have done it. He was fine and never mentioned it afterwards.

Many years later, I don't feel guilty about it now. I understand why it happened and I learnt from it and never did it again.

Cut yourself some slack. I'll ask my son tomorrow if he remembers it and report back!

Oneortwo2022 · 30/04/2022 05:31

Apologise and acknowledge your mistake to your daughter. Explain why it was wrong and that you will work extremely hard to make sure it never happens again.

Remove yourself from the situation in future if it’s starting to get too much.

Onlyrainbows · 30/04/2022 05:24

I had the odd smack when growing up. In fact I remember my mum throwing food at me when I was in my 20s because I came back drunk. They were not the best parents, but the snacking is not here nor there.

Kanaloa · 30/04/2022 04:55

It’s unacceptable and should never ever be repeated but you obviously know that, hence feeling bad about it.

Maybe you can use it as a jumping point to seek help for yourself so you can manage her behaviour in a better way - a way that’s productive and non-violent, to improve both your lives. Lashing out in a temper isn’t going to improve her behaviour, it’s simply reflecting her own behaviour back at her and seeing a trusted adult also lose their temper and hit people isn’t exactly going to help her to stop doing it.

FlappyCats · 30/04/2022 04:51

You over-reacted, you regret it. Please forgive yourself and draw a line. Honestly, we've most of us been in your shoes.

HoppingPavlova · 30/04/2022 04:35

We’ve all been there. I couldn’t risk smacking mine as there could have been considerable ramifications, and recall locking myself in the toilet for a while on several occasions when the little blighters realised they had got me to the edge of the cliff. Seriously, young kids can sniff out weakness and are like animals who know they have cornered wounded prey. It’s not always ‘big feelings’, it’s often sheer cunning and they are experts.

Sweepingeyelashes · 30/04/2022 03:35

People born in the 1960s more likely than not got the odd smack growing up. We got strapped at school if we were naughty and so on. I'm not saying it was a good thing but I don't think generations were scarred by it. So I'd cut yourself some slack and work out some other ways to react in that situation in future.

TheCurrywurstPrion · 30/04/2022 03:27

“She cried afterwards and I held her.”

You’ve already demonstrated to her that in spite of what happened, you love her.

Did it have the desired effect, of stopping what she was doing and considering whether her own behaviour towards you was acceptable?

Probably.

The idea that any parent who ever loses their temper and lashes out is a bad parent is ludicrous. Obviously it’s not ideal, but none of us is perfect. You smacked her once, which stopped the unbearable behaviour in the moment, and while you presumably lost control a little, you only did enough to stop her, you didn’t beat her to a pulp or do any permanent damage.

I’ve seen dogs nip their puppies when the puppies behaviour became too riotous. I’m pretty sure mothers all through nature use limited very small, limited amounts of pain and shock to stop bad behaviour in its tracks. The current obsession with punishing ourselves for such behaviour is unrealistic.

She won’t hate you. She likely won’t remember, though next time she’s being truly horrible, perhaps she’ll think twice because that behaviour resulted in something unpleasant happening last time,

Children whose parents enjoyed hitting them, or did it too often or too hard, and in particular, without reason, or did it to the point where there was permanent mental or physical damage are those who will grow up resenting their parents. The reason all physical punishment is currently frowned upon is because drawing that line in the sand is very difficult, but in my opinion, you are a long way from crossing it and you sound like a good mum.

Superhanz · 30/04/2022 02:40

Pumpupthejammin · 29/04/2022 23:06

I keep thinking what if it’s affected her or she’ll remember it

She'll be absolutely fine OP. My dad hit me once as a child, I remember it only because he was so devastated afterwards (I was fine but did milk it a bit). I definitely wasn't affected by it, I doubt she'll even remember. We all have our limits, the fact that you're in bits about it shows you're a good mum.

RonaldMcDonald · 30/04/2022 02:36

Giving reasons for why you were unable to control your temper is simply asking us to tell you it is okay.
it wasn’t
It is your job to negotiate all of the tiny terrorist times calmly or to leave the child safely until you are able to return and do so.
This is your problem not hers. It is good that you feel shame but not necessarily helpful. Better that you understand your triggers and when you feel emotionally aroused into a state when you might give yourself permission to hit a 4 yr old.
If in honesty you aren’t coping with your temper or response - get help. I wish more parents would do so.
I hope tomorrow is better and I know this must have been hard to read but it is meant to support safer parenting and a happier time for you both

Rikitikitardis · 30/04/2022 01:27

Refrosty · 30/04/2022 00:57

You mean if the husband was smacking his wife who was smacking him? Since that's actually the equivalent situation here.

Um, well it’s not okay for wives to be smacking husbands either is it? Doesn’t matter which one smacks first!

And anyway, adult v adult is in no way comparable to adult v 4 year old child. If up in court for assaulting a toddler, arguing self defence and “they hit me first” would get you laughed out of the dock!

sazza76 · 30/04/2022 01:01

You need to give yourself a break, we’re all human and make mistakes. It’s sometimes really hard being a parent. Have a think about ways you could prevent it happening again if she pushes you that far next time. I’m sure you will get some practical advice on here, I used to sometimes make sure they were safe, walk away and take many deep breaths! This doesn’t make you a bad person or a bad parent, start afresh tommorow.

Refrosty · 30/04/2022 00:57

Refrosty · 30/04/2022 00:57

You mean if the husband was smacking his wife who was smacking him? Since that's actually the equivalent situation here.

That was @Rikitikitardis

Refrosty · 30/04/2022 00:57

You mean if the husband was smacking his wife who was smacking him? Since that's actually the equivalent situation here.