Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feel sick with the shame

140 replies

Pumpupthejammin · 29/04/2022 22:37

I hit/smacked my almost 4 year old Dd today, never have before.
Her behaviour has been so so difficult for the last couple of months. Today she was shouting at me, her grandma, hitting and kicking me, she wouldn’t stop.
She cried afterwards and I held her.
Sitting here crying as I feel so horrendous, wish I could take it back

OP posts:
Ferntastical · 30/04/2022 09:31

Beating yourself up afterwards is still using a form of punishment, just on yourself. I don't think you can stop using punishment when pushed, until you learn to stop punishing yourself.

You've acknoweledged what you've done so now focus on WHY you did it. What clues were there that you were reaching breaking point and how can you avoid getting into that spot again? This will be much more productive as well as better for you all.

I got the odd smack as a child. I don't agree with it, it left me with less skills to handle upset and I don't think the woman my Mum is today would do it now. But we do still have a close relationship and friendship, so little has truly been harmed.

thedancingbear · 30/04/2022 09:05

Onwards22 · 30/04/2022 09:02

I too smacked my DD and still feel guilty about it 10 years later.

I don’t agree with smacking as it just teaches them that that’s an ok thing to do. However many parents do smack their children and don’t see anything wrong with it. So your once is nothing.

Whats done is done and now you know you won’t do it again.

Don’t over compensate.
Think about how you are going to manage her behaviour in the future instead.

If she’s being physically aggressive and you’re going to lose your temper then putting her in a room with a baby gate so you can still see each other but you can ignore the bad behaviour until she calms down is a good idea.

I think the main problem here is the OP’s behaviour, not her child’s. perhaps she should focus on how she is going to manage that as well.

domestic violence often escalates.

Onwards22 · 30/04/2022 09:02

I too smacked my DD and still feel guilty about it 10 years later.

I don’t agree with smacking as it just teaches them that that’s an ok thing to do. However many parents do smack their children and don’t see anything wrong with it. So your once is nothing.

Whats done is done and now you know you won’t do it again.

Don’t over compensate.
Think about how you are going to manage her behaviour in the future instead.

If she’s being physically aggressive and you’re going to lose your temper then putting her in a room with a baby gate so you can still see each other but you can ignore the bad behaviour until she calms down is a good idea.

vdbfamily · 30/04/2022 09:00

Genuinely interested here in why people think that if you smack a child it teaches them that violence is okay but all other forms of disciine do not teach that that is okay.
Pretty much all forms of behavioural control in children would be considered abusive in an adult relationship.
Shouting, removing treats, controlling screen time, banishing to room, sitting on naughty step. They would all be abusive to do to an adult you supposedly care about, so why are they better.
Many people have come on previous threads like this saying they would have found a snack less traumatic than having to go to their room or other forms of control.

thedancingbear · 30/04/2022 08:58

twilightcustard · 30/04/2022 08:55

I was smacked (rarely) as a kid and I hold no anger towards my parents. It did not damage my life. This website tends to get responses from puritans in the scope of particular things, smacking being one of them. So just resolve to try it differently next time and don't feel shame

For fuck’s sake. There’s nothing puritanical about thinking that assaulting children out of anger is wrong.

IvorCutler · 30/04/2022 08:55

I don’t think it’s fine and while I can certainly empathise with being pushed to the limit (my son is autistic and can have catastrophic meltdowns) I really feel strongly against it. What’s done is done though op, I hope you can stop yourself in the future. Accept that it was a lapse and move on.

twilightcustard · 30/04/2022 08:55

I was smacked (rarely) as a kid and I hold no anger towards my parents. It did not damage my life. This website tends to get responses from puritans in the scope of particular things, smacking being one of them. So just resolve to try it differently next time and don't feel shame

girlmom21 · 30/04/2022 08:44

thedancingbear · 30/04/2022 08:42

Another poster horrified at the apologism here.

hitting children for chastisement is morally dubious. Losing your rag and assaulting a child out of anger is domestic violence, plain and simple. It is abusive behaviour.

adults should never be violent towards children. Never.

The most bizarre part is the people who suggest that hitting a child will teach them that hitting isn't ok Hmm

thedancingbear · 30/04/2022 08:42

Another poster horrified at the apologism here.

hitting children for chastisement is morally dubious. Losing your rag and assaulting a child out of anger is domestic violence, plain and simple. It is abusive behaviour.

adults should never be violent towards children. Never.

SuziSecondLaw · 30/04/2022 08:37

Ahh I still remember the one time I lost my temper with my eldest and smacked her, 11 years ago. It never happened again. Don't best yourself up. You're obviously a good mum or you wouldn't care that you'd done it. Constant difficult behaviour at that age is extremely stressful. Take care of yourself.

girlmom21 · 30/04/2022 08:35

ManyATime · 30/04/2022 08:13

It's not fine. If OP posted her husband had hit her you wouldn't say "it's fine, it was a one off."

except that if the husband had been hitting and kicking his wife, I don’t think many of us would blame the wife for retaliating.

A child lashing out in a temper is not the same and it's still not ok

Kanaloa · 30/04/2022 08:34

And I don’t see the relevance of it not being as bad as ‘an alcoholic parent lashing out.’ Well an alcoholic parent lashing out isn’t as bad as a sober parent punching a child. And a sober parent punching a child isn’t as bad as a sober parent kicking a child down the stairs. And that’s not as bad as locking a child in the cupboard for 6 months. And that’s not as bad as blah blah blah. It’s not a sliding scale of rubbish parenting where you justify your bad parenting moments by saying it’s not as bad as someone else’s awful and abusive parenting.

Kanaloa · 30/04/2022 08:32

short sharp shock can stop it immediately and yes

If kid-hitters had a pull string on their back ‘short sharp shock’ would be their top phrase. Along with ‘never did me any harm’ and ‘kids need to know.’

vdbfamily · 30/04/2022 08:28

I think you are massively over reacting and people's connects are not helping. Your child was behaving really badly and your job is to teach them right from wrong and that behaviour is not acceptable.
FWIW I don't think snacking is the best way but I think sometimes in in situations where they are repeating a behaviour that puts then in danger or doing something that is hurting others, then a short sharp shock can stop it immediately and yes.... you can then give them a cuddle and say you love them but explain why what they were doing was wrong/ dangerous/ harmful and that they must not do it again.
I don't know why people use the argument that it is the same as domestic violence.
Nobody says that when you send a child to their room, remove their treats, take away screen time or send them to their room. Would you do that to an adult and get away with it or would u be considered to be a controlling bully.
My grown up children are absolutely clear that we abhor violence. They have never even heard their dad raise his voice more than a handful of times in 20 years other than to say their meal is ready!
I asked them the other day off being snacks had made them think violence was okay. One could not remember ever being smacked, all 3 were clear that violence was not answer to anything.
I gather from your OP that the quick snack immediately stopped the bad behaviour, you immediately showed them how upset you were that you had had to do that and showed them you loved them and hopefully explained why it had happened with them being so naughty.
This is such a different scenario to a malicious beating, an alcoholic parent lashing out at whoever gets in the way for no reason, a controlling parent who takes pleasure in making the child wait hours for a proper smacking.
Can people really not see the difference in those scenarios?

alittlefickle · 30/04/2022 08:20

Sweepingeyelashes · 30/04/2022 07:11

@alittlefickle for somebody opposed to causing pain and being a perfect mother and all, why are you trying to make the stressed OP who made a mistake feel so bad? Does it make you feel better about yourself in some way?

It's my opinion! Hitting children is bad.

Kanaloa · 30/04/2022 08:16

ParsleyRosemarySage · 30/04/2022 08:12

Hitting children isn’t an effective way to ‘explain’ that hitting isn’t acceptable.

Neither is a 5-page article in some fancy journal by a professor of child development. What do you think a 4 yr old is going to do while in the middle of a ‘violent’ (highlighted because I don’t have another word for the violence level of a 4 yr old) tantrum? Stop immediately to listen to a lecture and respond with “ Why yes mama, I see the error of my ways now and I shall immediately cease and desist from here on after”?

I work with older kids and teens who haven’t had any discipline and you can tell.

Who has suggested reading a 5-page article from a fancy journal to a misbehaving child? If you think that’s the only alternative to hitting children I’m disturbed that you claim to work with kids.

And by the way all that ‘oh what are you supposed to do, read a fancy journal to the child or give them a fancy pants lecture’ is just defensive nonsense from parents too lazy to consider that hitting kids is bad parenting.

I also work with kids by the way - somehow we manage behaviour without hitting them or reading them articles from ‘best childcare practices of the 21st century.’ Funny that.

ManyATime · 30/04/2022 08:13

It's not fine. If OP posted her husband had hit her you wouldn't say "it's fine, it was a one off."

except that if the husband had been hitting and kicking his wife, I don’t think many of us would blame the wife for retaliating.

Phobiaphobic · 30/04/2022 08:12

My kids can remember various occasions when I lost my temper, but the extremely rare time I smacked them (once, maybe?), they don't recall that at all.

ParsleyRosemarySage · 30/04/2022 08:12

Hitting children isn’t an effective way to ‘explain’ that hitting isn’t acceptable.

Neither is a 5-page article in some fancy journal by a professor of child development. What do you think a 4 yr old is going to do while in the middle of a ‘violent’ (highlighted because I don’t have another word for the violence level of a 4 yr old) tantrum? Stop immediately to listen to a lecture and respond with “ Why yes mama, I see the error of my ways now and I shall immediately cease and desist from here on after”?

I work with older kids and teens who haven’t had any discipline and you can tell.

Pootle40 · 30/04/2022 08:02

Sweepingeyelashes · 30/04/2022 03:35

People born in the 1960s more likely than not got the odd smack growing up. We got strapped at school if we were naughty and so on. I'm not saying it was a good thing but I don't think generations were scarred by it. So I'd cut yourself some slack and work out some other ways to react in that situation in future.

I was born in 1975 and was smacked occasionally. I also was smacked by a head teacher for writing on the chalk board during lunch break. Nothing bad just writing on a chalk board.....beggars belief really. Only the headteacher one has stayed with me.

Kanaloa · 30/04/2022 08:00

ParsleyRosemarySage · 30/04/2022 07:57

If this is real then you need to get a grip op. This is why so many were against an outright ban on smacking. If your dd was as being as bad as she sounds then an age-appropriate light smack now may well have been the quickest and most effective way to “explain” that it is not appropriate or tolerable behaviour. Young children need inducting into society by effective parenting, and they do not have the communication abilities of university professors yet.

If smacks - and I mean smacks - are saved for extremes then you are fine. Relax.

Hitting children isn’t an effective way to ‘explain’ that hitting isn’t acceptable.

ParsleyRosemarySage · 30/04/2022 07:57

If this is real then you need to get a grip op. This is why so many were against an outright ban on smacking. If your dd was as being as bad as she sounds then an age-appropriate light smack now may well have been the quickest and most effective way to “explain” that it is not appropriate or tolerable behaviour. Young children need inducting into society by effective parenting, and they do not have the communication abilities of university professors yet.

If smacks - and I mean smacks - are saved for extremes then you are fine. Relax.

thecatsarecrazy · 30/04/2022 07:52

Don't beat yourself up op. It happens. My son pushed me to my limits once and I smacked him on the leg. He went into school and told his teacher who took me to one side and informed me it was a safe guarding problem. And he would have to inform someone. I felt absolutely awful and ashamed. I had recently had a baby and was terrified he would be taken off me and all sorts. Nobody ever contacted me. I never raised a hand to him again. He can still be a very difficult boy to deal with. Its hard work being a parent.

girlmom21 · 30/04/2022 07:43

amylou8 · 30/04/2022 07:36

She will be fine. My parents smacked me, my teachers smacked me, I smacked my children (now in their 20s). None of us are emotionally traumatised by it. I know times have changed and most people now consider it unacceptable. Berating yourself and getting upset, especially infont of your daughter, will achieve nothing.

I never understand this "it never did any harm" attitude. You think hitting children is ok. That's clearly done you some harm because that's not a healthy attitude.

Kanaloa · 30/04/2022 07:39

Billandben444 · 30/04/2022 06:16

Maybe you can use it as a jumping point to seek help for yourself so you can manage her behaviour in a better way
Seek help? Wow, just wow!
OP, you know it was wrong, you feel awful and you've apologised to her and you don't deserve to get flamed on here. There would be a huge problem if you didn't feel bad about it but please don't be too hard on yourself. It's important to move on from it though or your daughter will sense that you were the only one behaving badly and that she was totally innocent. I slapped my daughter's leg 30 years ago when she was a similar age, in public outside a department store, and I've never forgotten it and what a terrible thing it was that I'd done. It never ever happened again, she has no recollection of it and we're best friends. Remember what happened and how you feel about it today and then it will never happen again. You're a good mum because you feel so bad about it.

Erm, yes? There’s no shame in seeking help if you find your child’s behaviour unmanageable. Whether that he help in the form of books/behavioural resources, or parenting courses etc. And if it gets to the point that you’re driven to hitting your child I’d say the behaviour has become unmanageable for you.