Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feel sick with the shame

140 replies

Pumpupthejammin · 29/04/2022 22:37

I hit/smacked my almost 4 year old Dd today, never have before.
Her behaviour has been so so difficult for the last couple of months. Today she was shouting at me, her grandma, hitting and kicking me, she wouldn’t stop.
She cried afterwards and I held her.
Sitting here crying as I feel so horrendous, wish I could take it back

OP posts:
Rikitikitardis · 30/04/2022 12:27

Goldijobsandthe3bears · 30/04/2022 12:11

I think that’s a huge stretch of imagination, and every time you put ‘true abusers’ in quotes you are suggesting the OP is an abuser of sorts so stop being coy and own it. I don’t smack my children but now I’ve read some people trying to help the OP get some perspective I think next time they annoy me why not bash them up…

I’ve clarified my point, you still disagree with me - that’s fine. I suggest we move on, and let this thread do likewise. Have a lovely day.

Goldijobsandthe3bears · 30/04/2022 12:11

Rikitikitardis · 30/04/2022 11:48

@Goldijobsandthe3bears None of this is personal. I’m making the point precisely because we don’t know who is reading these posts and because I think it’s really important to challenge the narrative of “we all make mistakes” “kids push us all to our limits sometimes” “it never did me any harm” “feeling bad about it means you’re a good parent”.

Who knows how many others (“true abusers” - intentional or otherwise) could be reading this thread and using people’s well-meaning replies to the OP to justify goodness knows what.
.

I think that’s a huge stretch of imagination, and every time you put ‘true abusers’ in quotes you are suggesting the OP is an abuser of sorts so stop being coy and own it. I don’t smack my children but now I’ve read some people trying to help the OP get some perspective I think next time they annoy me why not bash them up…

Rikitikitardis · 30/04/2022 11:48

@Goldijobsandthe3bears None of this is personal. I’m making the point precisely because we don’t know who is reading these posts and because I think it’s really important to challenge the narrative of “we all make mistakes” “kids push us all to our limits sometimes” “it never did me any harm” “feeling bad about it means you’re a good parent”.

Who knows how many others (“true abusers” - intentional or otherwise) could be reading this thread and using people’s well-meaning replies to the OP to justify goodness knows what.
.

SexyLittleNosferatu · 30/04/2022 11:48

Refrosty · 30/04/2022 00:57

You mean if the husband was smacking his wife who was smacking him? Since that's actually the equivalent situation here.

Except it isn't the same. Children are children and parents are there to bring them up properly and that involves discipline. The behaviour of kids now is a result of this ridiculous parenting that asks children to behave nicely and involves no actual parenting or discipline.

Goldijobsandthe3bears · 30/04/2022 11:36

Rikitikitardis · 30/04/2022 11:28

I don’t think you read my post properly. I made it clear that I was speaking generally and not specifically to the OP.
And I did not call her an abuser. I said that this style of parenting can make children vulnerable to future abuse. Which is different.

As an aside though, I’m interested to know what you mean by “true abusers”?
There are deliberate abusers- the cruel and sadistic, and then there are those who are coerced, damaged and who act out of rage and deperation. I’m sure we can all think of news stories about parents in both categories, but the impact on the child is just the same.

Ahh thanks for the dose of patronising, it’s good to get one daily. You are going way over the top and it’s unnecessary and unhelpful in this particular situation. If you aren’t speaking to the OP then your input is moot surely 🤦🏼‍♀️It just feels like you are trying to kick someone when they are down but maybe you just like pontificating.

tootiredtoocare · 30/04/2022 11:30

You do NOT need help for one event. No judgement here, the exact reason I decided not to smack back when it wasn't really considered wrong the way it is now (20 years ago), was because I knew I had a temper and I worried I might smack too hard or more than once. I have walked away and closed the door to get hold of my temper before going back to address poor behaviour. And, yes, I once lost it and smacked, and felt terrible afterwards. He doesn't remember. Swallow your guilt, and move on. Her behaviour does seem a little extreme for a 4 year old though, if it's a regular thing you might get advice from your HV about coping techniques for you both, even at 4 she can learn exercises for coping with her temper. My DD has learning difficulties and we use techniques for her sensory overload reactions to try to prevent meltdowns, such as walking away and counting her steps, taking deep breaths and counting to ten, pressing her thumb and each finger tightly together one by one, or making slow circles on her palm (like 'round and round the garden') and counting those. It helps us both.

Rikitikitardis · 30/04/2022 11:28

Goldijobsandthe3bears · 30/04/2022 11:14

Have you heard yourself, she knows it wasn’t good ffs, she is a parent who has made a mistake! True abusers would give a shite and certainly wouldn’t post on here and now you are talking about her child being set up to accept abuse for life 😱

I don’t think you read my post properly. I made it clear that I was speaking generally and not specifically to the OP.
And I did not call her an abuser. I said that this style of parenting can make children vulnerable to future abuse. Which is different.

As an aside though, I’m interested to know what you mean by “true abusers”?
There are deliberate abusers- the cruel and sadistic, and then there are those who are coerced, damaged and who act out of rage and deperation. I’m sure we can all think of news stories about parents in both categories, but the impact on the child is just the same.

Goldijobsandthe3bears · 30/04/2022 11:18

Seriously OP, no you shouldn’t have done it and your reaction suggests you’ll never do it again, I agree with other posters not to over apologise as that will be upsetting for her to deal with. My parents smacked me and whilst it wasn’t great and we have learned from their mistakes I’m also not traumatised or seeking out abuse.

woodhill · 30/04/2022 11:15

Anyway hope you are ok OP

What does your dm think?

Goldijobsandthe3bears · 30/04/2022 11:14

Rikitikitardis · 30/04/2022 11:09

Also though, and I’m saying this for the benefit of others reading, not just you OP, smacking a child and then hugging them to show you still love them, does not ‘put it right’. It is potentially setting them up for unhealthy future relationships. Done repeatedly it will teach them that smacking is okay if you love somebody. That it’s okay if you say sorry afterwards.

What is the answer- don’t hug them after? No, the answer is to never smack them.

And to those saying “they won’t remember”, maybe not, but their brain will be learning it and making the connections. The early years of childhood are crucial development wise.

For every poster here saying “it never did me any harm” there will be another asking about how to make her abusive partner love her and ignoring all the pleas to LTB.

OP, a one-off and out of character incident won’t do any harm, but it is not good parenting.

Have you heard yourself, she knows it wasn’t good ffs, she is a parent who has made a mistake! True abusers would give a shite and certainly wouldn’t post on here and now you are talking about her child being set up to accept abuse for life 😱

woodhill · 30/04/2022 11:12

amylou8 · 30/04/2022 07:36

She will be fine. My parents smacked me, my teachers smacked me, I smacked my children (now in their 20s). None of us are emotionally traumatised by it. I know times have changed and most people now consider it unacceptable. Berating yourself and getting upset, especially infont of your daughter, will achieve nothing.

Have to agree

It's seems ok on here for the dc to continue to hit their dps. I wouldn't put up with that in the first place

carrotcruncher81 · 30/04/2022 11:09

Don't be so hard on yourself. The fact that you feel so awful is punishment enough. I wouldn't keep apologising to your DD. What's done is done and she will soon forget about it! Just maybe now look at ways to understand why she is behaving so badly and explore how to perhaps solve it in a different way. Children can test the patience of a SAINT!

Goldijobsandthe3bears · 30/04/2022 11:09

alittlefickle · 30/04/2022 06:14

Sorry, but yes!

My son is 23 and I've NEVER hit him, not even a tap on the hand.... punished yes, taken things away, yes, stuck to the punishment, yes (he always learnt from being punished).

My theory is, when you have a child and they hurt themselves, you want to comfort them, take the pain away, so why would you choose to cause that pain????

Oh dear..

Rikitikitardis · 30/04/2022 11:09

Also though, and I’m saying this for the benefit of others reading, not just you OP, smacking a child and then hugging them to show you still love them, does not ‘put it right’. It is potentially setting them up for unhealthy future relationships. Done repeatedly it will teach them that smacking is okay if you love somebody. That it’s okay if you say sorry afterwards.

What is the answer- don’t hug them after? No, the answer is to never smack them.

And to those saying “they won’t remember”, maybe not, but their brain will be learning it and making the connections. The early years of childhood are crucial development wise.

For every poster here saying “it never did me any harm” there will be another asking about how to make her abusive partner love her and ignoring all the pleas to LTB.

OP, a one-off and out of character incident won’t do any harm, but it is not good parenting.

Goldijobsandthe3bears · 30/04/2022 11:07

Rikitikitardis · 30/04/2022 01:27

Um, well it’s not okay for wives to be smacking husbands either is it? Doesn’t matter which one smacks first!

And anyway, adult v adult is in no way comparable to adult v 4 year old child. If up in court for assaulting a toddler, arguing self defence and “they hit me first” would get you laughed out of the dock!

It was you trying to make the comparison 🤨

Goldijobsandthe3bears · 30/04/2022 11:05

Refrosty · 30/04/2022 00:57

You mean if the husband was smacking his wife who was smacking him? Since that's actually the equivalent situation here.

Exactly

Babyvenusplant · 30/04/2022 11:00

Next time you feel yourself getting to breaking point, if possible, leave her somewhere safe where she can't hurt herself, step out of the room and take some big deep breaths, calm yourself down, count to ten, twenty etc.. and then go back into the situation calmer. It really does help

PumpkinsandKittens · 30/04/2022 11:00

What I find interesting is that on MN any time there is a thread on smacking everyone says it’s totally unacceptable and should be illegal yet anytime someone admits to smacking their child on here they get nothing but sympathy and told it’s fine? 🥴 MN logic

Heliotropium · 30/04/2022 10:59

Heliotropium · 30/04/2022 10:53

Shouting, removing treats, controlling screen time, banishing to room, sitting on naughty step. They would all be abusive to do to an adult you supposedly care about, so why are they better
For the same reason we do punish adults in a lot of those ways when we incarcerate then but we don't hit them.
Although I too don't think op should beat herself up for a one off mistake that she regrets.

Also for the same reason schools punish using the equivalent of those ways but not hitting. Presumably no one would be in favour of schools or prisons using physical punishment

Rikitikitardis · 30/04/2022 10:58

Pumpupthejammin · 30/04/2022 09:47

Do people really think I need help for this? Where from?

I think OP that you have not been helped by the people who jumped to your defence trotting out the “we all do it” “it never did me any harm” line. Obviously this line of thinking has to be challenged.

I think that only you know whether you really need help.

If you have never smacked anyone before, did this as an automatic response, perhaps having been smacked yourself as a child and maybe didn’t realise until it happened how bad it is? If so - lesson learned.

If you really feel you lost your rag and all control and lashed out as a consequence of that (maybe you have felt this way with other people or in other situations too?) then it doesn't matter how sorry you are, you have anger problems and it could happen again, so you need to seek help.

Heliotropium · 30/04/2022 10:53

Shouting, removing treats, controlling screen time, banishing to room, sitting on naughty step. They would all be abusive to do to an adult you supposedly care about, so why are they better
For the same reason we do punish adults in a lot of those ways when we incarcerate then but we don't hit them.
Although I too don't think op should beat herself up for a one off mistake that she regrets.

Mariposista · 30/04/2022 10:17

Pumpupthejammin · 30/04/2022 09:47

Do people really think I need help for this? Where from?

No OP you don't. People are just getting on their high horse, likening your smack to full on abuse. You were pushed to the limit by her bratty behaviour and the fact that you feel bad means that you are not a bad person. However, if her behaviour continues to be bad, you can ask for help managing her - but from people like her nursery teachers, etc to put a behaviour management plan in place. Please don't overcompensate today because you feel bad. Obviously praise any good behaviour, but she does not deserve extra treats/cuddles for what happened yesterday. At the end of the day it happened because she was naughty.

twilightcustard · 30/04/2022 10:09

@thedancingbear the aggressive response suggests otherwise darling🙄

ManyATime · 30/04/2022 09:49

A child lashing out in a temper is not the same and it's still not ok
No two situations are exactly the same and the message that it’s ok to hit back to defend yourself if you’re getting hurt doesn’t seem so bad to me.

Pumpupthejammin · 30/04/2022 09:47

Do people really think I need help for this? Where from?

OP posts: