Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask Christians about dinosaurs...

557 replies

EastYorksLass · 29/04/2022 17:46

This is a serious question - so I have been thinking a lot lately about whether God exists, the meaning of life and why is the world in such a terrible state... been thinking about going to church but still feel I am on the fence. One question which has really got me thinking (after watching dear old David Attenborough... ) is where do dinosaurs fit into all this. Sorry if this sounds very weird but I would love to hear an explanation!

OP posts:
gogohm · 30/04/2022 20:19

Well they lived 60m+ years ago. I've never met a Christian in the U.K. that believes in the literal truth of the bible including 3 bishops who are Facebook friends!

Topgub · 30/04/2022 20:17

Why not?

Because we evolved by chance?

If God is love, why didn't he love the neanderthals too?

is it ok to answer your question with “I don’t know?”

yes! Of course.

Without Vimto.

awwwww. Thats a shame 😏

Pumperthepumper · 30/04/2022 20:14

That’s such a lovely, thoughtful answer @UpdateStoleMyProfile - I really enjoyed reading it.

UpdateStoleMyProfile · 30/04/2022 20:11

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:17

I cant remember what I asked now?

Why would god design the universe via the big bang and evolution so a wee human could evolve and worship them.

Something like that. How does ID relate to the bible without backwards shoehorning?

The theological answer is god isn't human and doesn't have to live by human rules (god moves in mysterious ways etc etc)

I dont need help with theology. I like discussing beliefs. Questioning them. Challenging them.

For the first question, my understanding (which I fully accept may be wrong), is simply God is Love. God Loves. And so he wants us to Love him.

why do it via Big Bang and evolution? Why not? Why not set the universe in motion with one almighty explosion - done might see that as one big breath - Ruach, the breath of God. maybe the pleasure he gets from a relationship with a human is all the richer and more valuable to him simply because it took so long to come to fruition?

I believe we are here in order to love God. And each other. That that is the primary purpose of each of us. And I believe if we can get that right then the world would be a fundamentally better place for everyone and everything.

how does ID relate to the bible without backwards shoehorning? I don’t entirely understand the question, sorry. The Bible is a collection of 66 books with multiple different authors. Some of the places and stories within it are corroborated by archaeology and contemporaneous accounts. Others aren’t. Some of it is allegory, and it is my belief that the creation story in genesis falls within that. And some of it is historical record - take a look at Numbers or Chronicles (if you are awake and can’t sleep. It’s incredibly tedious in places). A record of how many men were a part of each tribe of Israel. How many pounds of gold were brought to the temple. How many slaves were captured, etc. I’m not sure why anyone would record it all if it weren’t true.

I don’t think stating that some parts are allegory and some are history is shoehorning anything. Song of Songs is a long love poem; some say to God but personally I think it’s more like erotica. Psalms is a collection of poems and songs, some marking events others guides for worship. And then you have the books of prophecy. Prophets warning of dire things if Israel doesn’t turn back to God. Israel turning back, God relenting, Israel forgetting, turning away, Prophets warning, disaster striking, Israel repenting, God relenting.

kind of like how people warn about climate change now really. We all know it’s happening, the prophets keep telling us and we are mostly sticking fingers in ears and continuing to burn fossil fuels and create emissions, and gradually or rapidly destroying the balance of the earth. God gives us a plan for life, we ignore it at our peril.

and then the New Testament. 400 years or so after the last voice in the Old Testament, along comes a new prophet John, and starts warning people to get ready for his cousin Jesus. Do we get the gospels who tell us about the things Jesus did, then Acts tells us about what the early Christians did. A bunch of letters from Early church leaders to different churches and to all believers, and then another book of prophecy at the end.

is it ok to answer your question with “I don’t know?” I don’t have the answers. I’m not God. What I do know is that as science reveals ever more about the complexities of the universe I find myself more in awe of the one I believe created it to be this way. We sing about hands that flung stars into space, hung the moon and the sun and set the planets dancing. And that’s beautiful. But it’s incredibly simplistic. Now we know more about the universe. And the more we know the more we realise we don’t know. So that God of the gaps grows ever bigger for me. Lots of scientists at our church. Some of whom became Christians through their scientific research. and lots of scientists within my circle of friends. Some of whom are atheist due to their own research. We seem to coexist happily enough. Without Vimto.

Hawkins001 · 30/04/2022 20:00

This is just a question, but why have and do, humans give so much credibility and time and effort to various texts that have been written by humans regardless for which deity it's for ?

and why do some humans offer their souls at the mercy of these beings ?

overall main question why does human societies need religions ?I

lastly what happens to religions when human society realises (Assuming it's is) that the galaxies are full of various lifeforms ?

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:58

Yup, it just doesn't bear much relation to your summary.

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:57

I honestly wasn't aware I had asked you.

I do not like the formatting of this website and cannot get to grips with the replies or how to tell who you are replying to.

Or who is replying to you.

Excpet for the big grey wall of text reply which I also don't like.

But if you're going to get so offended by an oversight, maybe its for the best not to reply.

Princetopple · 30/04/2022 19:55

Depends on the kind of Christian, really. My family are pretty... Literal. I avoid the topic. They don't ever say anything about it. My cousin converted to Christianity after completing his geology degree. I overheard him talking to my dad and he said that he knows the fossils are definitely real as he's seen and studied them, but equally 'knows' that God is real. So god put them there as a joke to play a little trick on everyone, because he's a fun god like that. I had to leave the area because I think my facial expression would have offended them.

My science teacher was also a Christian who taught us evolution by telling us "it's just a theory". He never felt the need to point out every other "theory". I think that is shocking.

Pumperthepumper · 30/04/2022 19:53

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:52

Those are your beliefs, not mine

No, they’re not - remember your post about football strips and Christmas?

girlmom21 · 30/04/2022 19:52

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:50

Are you not religious then?

You've asked that same question repeatedly and I've answered that same question repeatedly. If you're not prepared to pay attention to peoples responses stop pretending you're interested in any form of discussion.

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:52

Pumperthepumper · 30/04/2022 19:49

It’s an odd stance then - you don’t want a discussion, you don’t want answers, you do want answers, you want justification and not to respect religion, you celebrate Christmas but don’t want the religious calendar, you want one specific belief to stumble on this thread and state their rationalisations - all while claiming you have no chip on your shoulder.

Those are your beliefs, not mine

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:50

Are you not religious then?

Pumperthepumper · 30/04/2022 19:49

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:39

I dont have a chip.

Its called responding in kind.

No one has to justify anything 🤷‍♀️

It’s an odd stance then - you don’t want a discussion, you don’t want answers, you do want answers, you want justification and not to respect religion, you celebrate Christmas but don’t want the religious calendar, you want one specific belief to stumble on this thread and state their rationalisations - all while claiming you have no chip on your shoulder.

girlmom21 · 30/04/2022 19:48

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:43

The Christian God def wants to be worshipped.

The Jewish and Islamic one too (same being or not depending on your belief, but all want worshipped)

The religions are all based on the relationship god has with humans. How he wants humans to act and behave.

Did he just chance upon us after we'd evolved and thought, great!! I can tell this lot who to shag and what they can eat!

What are you making those assumptions based on? The bible? I don't think He had anything to do with the bible or the religious teachings, personally.

I think they were created by people taking a moral high ground in His name.

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:43

The Christian God def wants to be worshipped.

The Jewish and Islamic one too (same being or not depending on your belief, but all want worshipped)

The religions are all based on the relationship god has with humans. How he wants humans to act and behave.

Did he just chance upon us after we'd evolved and thought, great!! I can tell this lot who to shag and what they can eat!

girlmom21 · 30/04/2022 19:40

Why would god design the universe via the big bang and evolution so a wee human could evolve and worship them.

I don't think, if there is a God, that he created Earth to be worshipped.
Look at all of the other planets in our solar system - maybe they were all just experiments and he hit the jackpot with Earth because we had sustainable life.

Maybe God had no clue what conditions would create life. In my head, if He exists, he's an overseer. He gave the planet what it needed to sustain life. He never had any intention of dictating how or what that life looked like or became.

I don't think a God could perform the little miracles that people talk about like giving us a cure for cancer. He didn't give us all the rubbish that creates many cancers. We made those ourselves. They're our responsibility.

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:39

I dont have a chip.

Its called responding in kind.

No one has to justify anything 🤷‍♀️

Pumperthepumper · 30/04/2022 19:37

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:36

Weirdly enough I could think of those explanations myself.

As a non believer its not that hard.

How does a Christian who believes in ID and evolution and specifically that God loves and wants a relationship with homosapiens rationalise it?

I think you might have to take that chip off your shoulder if you want someone to justify their beliefs to you 🤣

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:37

I did

On the thread.

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:37

What do you believe?

GoldenOmber · 30/04/2022 19:36

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:36

Weirdly enough I could think of those explanations myself.

As a non believer its not that hard.

How does a Christian who believes in ID and evolution and specifically that God loves and wants a relationship with homosapiens rationalise it?

You’d probably have to find one and ask.

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:36

Weirdly enough I could think of those explanations myself.

As a non believer its not that hard.

How does a Christian who believes in ID and evolution and specifically that God loves and wants a relationship with homosapiens rationalise it?

GoldenOmber · 30/04/2022 19:33

Why would god design the universe via the big bang and evolution so a wee human could evolve and worship them.

I don’t think God would. “God created the universe so humans would worship him” isn’t a standard Christian belief really. Can’t speak for all the denominations obviously, but if you’re genuinely interested in the history of Christian thought on why God created the universe you might want to start with Aquinas and go from there?

How does ID relate to the bible without backwards shoehorning?

Intelligent design is a specific belief, like a sort of watered-down creationism. It’s not a belief I hold so 🤷‍♀️ on how its proponents fit it in.

Pumperthepumper · 30/04/2022 19:32

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:30

Up to you?

I dont control how people answer.

Thanks, discussion then, since nobody can know a literal answer.

Maybe he hated the dinosaurs and thought he could do better. Maybe he needed them to die to enrich the earth. Maybe he wanted to give humans a billion year old treasure hunt.

Topgub · 30/04/2022 19:30

Up to you?

I dont control how people answer.

Swipe left for the next trending thread