Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To regret offering to visit an elderly neighbour in hospital when the daughter seems emotionally and physically distant

57 replies

Seenoevil1 · 29/04/2022 16:29

AIBU to now regret offering to help and getting involved?

My elderly neighbour is in hospital with dementia and unlikely to go back home after several falls. Her daughter lives a 7 hour drive away. Her son in law came to my door with an update and I felt sorry for them living further away so I said I'd pop in and see her at the hospital, take juice etc. I distinctly said I'd do this 'when I could' - however they then sent me details of friends of hers who live in the area asking me to co-ordinate my hospital visits with them.

Her daughter said the other couple would visit on a Mon or a Tues and asked me to tell them when I was going. I explained I couldn't do weekly or a set day but will go when I can. I had thought fortnightly but didn't want to tie myself down...

I feel my casual offer has been misinterpreted and I don't know or want to liase with the other couple as I don't have the time. The hospital ward is agreeable to me and the friends visiting.

Am I being unreasonable to now feel put upon and wanting to back away?

I've handed some juice in as the woman tested positive for covid so no-one was allowed in. The nurse handed the juice to her and told me my neighbour was confused and angry that the juice wasn't from her daughter. While I was standing at the nurses station the noises made me think back to my Dads final weeks in the sane hospital (diff ward) 2 years ago at the start of the pandemic. I stood there and thought: 'What am I doing here?' Then I felt bad for my neighbour..

It has been 3 weeks since she was admitted to hospital and feel I should visit...in the meantime the family had a pre-planned trip abroad. I don't really know this family well though I chatted in the street to my elderly neighbour quite often during the lockdown as I was worried about her. I moved into the street a few months before lockdown and gave her soup and scones a few times. She is now free from the 10-day isolation the hospital imposed and will be able to see visitors. I've not had any recent communication from her daughter other than that her mum would have to isolate for 10 days.
A previous text message was quite business-like, thanking me for handing things in and saying she had phoned and got an update from nursing staff.

Any advice? I feel as though I'm being contrary but also feel put upon. I don't know when the daughter is coming to visit next and I was a carer for many years for my late father who lived near me.

OP posts:
justfiveminutes · 02/05/2022 03:24

I can understand how you feel, and am pleased that you have settled on a course of action - of course you should not feel obligated to visit.

However, I do think that you have misinterpreted her daughter's text. To me, it just sounds as if she doesn't want two visitors turning up at the same time, possibly due to covid restrictions, or just so that she maximises the number of days on which her mum sees a friendly face. Personally, I would not have interpreted it as an expectation for regular visits. I would have stuck to my plan of irregular, as-and-when visits but just avoided Mon/Tues and text the other visitors on the day I planned to visit so that they didn't turn up too.

Anyway, I'm glad it's sorted out.

milkyaqua · 02/05/2022 03:09

SonicWomb · 02/05/2022 02:06

As the daughter of someone with dementia I’m so sad to read these comments.

To me it sounds like all the daughter has done is not sound grateful enough in her message to you. I personally don’t think asking you to coordinate if you’re going is unreasonable at all.

People with dementia know much more about what’s going on than you realise but everyone is so quick to write them off because they don’t feel comfortable. I saw many friends abandon my loved one, who knew she was being abandoned. A friendly face made such a difference to her even if she was having a bad day, it was something she’d have done (and did) for anyone.

Please don’t write off this lady, it’s not for you to put yourself out but an occasional visit can mean the world.

She has made two visits, and felt uncomfortable being in the same hospital where her dad spent his final weeks, and has also felt put upon by the daughter and expected to visit more, and to co-ordinate her visits with others as if she is a family member - the same daughter who could of course cancel her trip abroad if she feels so strongly about her mother getting more visits from random, kind neighbours.

Fraaahnces · 02/05/2022 02:35

I thought I’d pop in also to say that although she was probably pleasant enough with you because she was your neighbour, you admit yourself that you didn’t really know this woman. The daughter lives 7hrs away and wasn’t in touch all that often. There may be a very good reason for that also. You don’t know THEIR history. That’s also between them.
My mum was known as the generous soul who would go out of her way for anyone. And she was. She had an army of lame ducks around her to whom she would give money, time, valuables, etc… She would basically keep these people under her thumb until they realised that her toxic personality and controlling behaviour wasn’t worth the payoff. She was the exact opposite with me. She was physically, emotionally and psychologically abusive. She withheld food (she was anorexic and determined that I would be too) and so screwed up I left early. Like a lot of terrorist mothers, she was very clever about it all and was never caught out. At the end of her life, her filters slipped and everyone saw the “real” her - especially her treatment of me. Kind of gratifying, but a bit late. Her behaviour had led to me raising my kids on the other side of the world, without her input. At her funeral, I sat there listening to tales of her generosity, etc, thinking that I never knew that person at all.

SonicWomb · 02/05/2022 02:06

As the daughter of someone with dementia I’m so sad to read these comments.

To me it sounds like all the daughter has done is not sound grateful enough in her message to you. I personally don’t think asking you to coordinate if you’re going is unreasonable at all.

People with dementia know much more about what’s going on than you realise but everyone is so quick to write them off because they don’t feel comfortable. I saw many friends abandon my loved one, who knew she was being abandoned. A friendly face made such a difference to her even if she was having a bad day, it was something she’d have done (and did) for anyone.

Please don’t write off this lady, it’s not for you to put yourself out but an occasional visit can mean the world.

milkyaqua · 02/05/2022 01:29

Good on you, OP.

Seenoevil1 · 01/05/2022 23:10

Hi everyone

To update - I visited my neighbour in hospital today and took more juice. I decided it would be my only visit due to feelings discussed.

She was very confused and afterwards I messaged her daughter saying I had popped in but was going to leave it at that as I didn't know her that well really.

I appreciate everyone's advice. I realised as soon as I saw my neighbour that I felt it was too much for me as she was talking about being 'like a prisoner' in the hospital, had piles of clothes lying neatly beside her case as though she was anxious to leave.

It was sad and she and looking for reassurance, however I could see clearly that was something only her family could provide.
Thanks again. x

OP posts:
milkyaqua · 30/04/2022 00:10

saraclara · 29/04/2022 18:21

I'm not sure what the daughter has done wrong here. Asking you to let them know when you'd be going didn't necessarily mean that she expected you to go on that day every week, surely? And she was presumably just making sure that you didn't turn up on the same day as the others and get turned away.

You can't judge people by perceived tone in their messages. What you read as bunsiness-like might have been typed in an entirely different tone. Not every appreciative person types oozing warmth and gratitude. Text is notiriously difficult to interpret, lacking tone of voice, facial expression and body language.

Seven hours away is one heck of a journey. Taking advantage would be expecting something of you that they could easily do for themselves. They simply can't visit her often, and you offered. I'd see how this visit goes, and then decide what you want to do or not do in the future. But don't assume that the daughter is unappreciative. Her popping in to see her mum for an hour would take three days. If she works, that simply isn't going to be something she can do more than very occasionally.

Did you miss this bit in the OP?

I distinctly said I'd do this 'when I could' - however they then sent me details of friends of hers who live in the area asking me to co-ordinate my hospital visits with them.

Her daughter said the other couple would visit on a Mon or a Tues and asked me to tell them when I was going. I explained I couldn't do weekly or a set day but will go when I can. I had thought fortnightly but didn't want to tie myself down...

I feel my casual offer has been misinterpreted and I don't know or want to liase with the other couple as I don't have the time.

The OP is not the elderly neighbour's daughter, carer, close friend, or relative. She made a kindly offer and is now being told to organise a visiting roster. That is the job of a family member. Meanwhile, the daughter is off as I understand it on an overseas holiday, prearranged or not!

ittakes2 · 29/04/2022 19:52

I don't think you should mention the juice as that just complicates things. You sound like someone who doesn't want to hurt people's feelings. Just say
"I am sorry but I think I have given you the wrong impression how close I was to your mother. I only met her before the lockdowns and we occasionally chatted in the street. Unfortunately, I do not have the time to co-ordinate visits for her, but I am happy to see her occasionally if you think that would help and I will let the other person know when I intend to go so our visits don't clash.

caecilius1 · 29/04/2022 19:46

@saraclara
The OP hasn't done anything wrong either, however, it might not have been the daughter's intention but her texts have upset the OP.

Seenoevil1 · 29/04/2022 19:30

Thanks - well put xx

OP posts:
crosstalk · 29/04/2022 19:09

I would just tell her that you can only do this irregularly but that her mum was distressed the juice came from you and not her and that she doesn't recognise you. That you do not want to be coordinating with anyone but will let her know if you are going. Presumably she is trying to sort care from 7 hours away and it's difficult enough on your doorstep. She and her husband and family will need to step up. It's a shame they have left it so late but so many of us do.

Seenoevil1 · 29/04/2022 18:49

The request was to co-ordinate generally and I felt they were assuming regular visits from me. I suppose alarm bells were ringing.

True - as someone said - not everyone sends gushy texts.

Mrs Drudge, I think you're right and it is out of my hands as I may end up worsening her mood as I'm unfamiliar.

Thanks all for helping me to de-tangle my thoughts. I'll update next week.

OP posts:
Toddlerteaplease · 29/04/2022 18:30

Was the request to coordinate solely due to covid restrictions. So people didn't have a wasted journey as someone else had already visited that day.

saraclara · 29/04/2022 18:21

I'm not sure what the daughter has done wrong here. Asking you to let them know when you'd be going didn't necessarily mean that she expected you to go on that day every week, surely? And she was presumably just making sure that you didn't turn up on the same day as the others and get turned away.

You can't judge people by perceived tone in their messages. What you read as bunsiness-like might have been typed in an entirely different tone. Not every appreciative person types oozing warmth and gratitude. Text is notiriously difficult to interpret, lacking tone of voice, facial expression and body language.

Seven hours away is one heck of a journey. Taking advantage would be expecting something of you that they could easily do for themselves. They simply can't visit her often, and you offered. I'd see how this visit goes, and then decide what you want to do or not do in the future. But don't assume that the daughter is unappreciative. Her popping in to see her mum for an hour would take three days. If she works, that simply isn't going to be something she can do more than very occasionally.

MrsDrudge · 29/04/2022 18:10

I read in your post that the nurse told you the woman was confused and angry when you so kindly took in juice for her, as the juice wasn’t from her daughter.
it may be that however good your intentions , and you do sound very thoughtful and concerned, an unfamiliar person visiting may cause more agitation for this poor lady.
Perhaps letting the daughter know this would be a good way to step back.

Heliotropium · 29/04/2022 18:10

You're under no obligation. Just do what you feel comfortable with and no more. The daughter could probably make more of an effort but it depends really what her childhood was like. Some people are abused or scapegoated and struggle mentally to see their parent as an adult. There's no way of knowing who that applies to as people can be different behind closed doors.

Seenoevil1 · 29/04/2022 18:08

Thanks - wise words. Good warning there!
Sorry your kindness was taken advantage of. I often agree to things right away then regret later...
All the best x

OP posts:
Nelliephant1 · 29/04/2022 18:07

You sound like me! You hear the words coming out of your mouth while your brain is saying please stop talking!!

You're under no obligation at all, your neighbour is not visitorless so pop in if and when you want to, but don't feel bad if you don't visit. With the best will in the world, it's not your responsibility to visit or coordinate your availability. I've got a funny feeling that you won't be the only one who has been put in a difficult position by the daughter so don't feel bad about it.

Goldengoosey · 29/04/2022 18:02

Hi I would drop a short note/text to the daughter saying you won’t be visiting again as her mum was quite distressed when you dropped off the juice as it was her daughter she wanted to see, not you. And a hope your mum is feeling better soon ending.

I got caught up in a similar scenario a few years ago with an elderly neighbour. Like this lady the daughter took advantage of my kindness and started messaging me with shopping lists and hospital/doctor appointments she had decided was now my responsibility! I worked f/t. I had to be quite blunt with the daughter and say I’m not a carer. I was just being a good and helpful neighbour. They were all quite well off so could have easily paid for carers and grocery deliveries. The daughter never spoke to me after that!

You need to take care of yourself especially if this is all bringing your dad’s death back to you. Step back 💐

Seenoevil1 · 29/04/2022 18:02

Thanks everyone for your lovely replies and sound advice. It is interesting hearing some experiences too. I've decided - since I'm getting so tied up in knots with the pressure of expectations - that I will make one visit in person, then step away.

I agree, best not communicating with the family.

Much appreciated, all. xx

OP posts:
FinallyHere · 29/04/2022 17:50

after initially offering to visit

From your description you have 'visited' once already. I don't see that you have committed to doing anything else.

Reply to the message asking you to coordinate with other visitors with 'sorry, that won't be possible' leaving the responsibility firmly on their shoulders.

Any time it is convenient to you to visit, and you want to, visit. Don't offer any further communications to the family.

Visit only as suits you, or not at all & don't engage with the family.

ButtockUp · 29/04/2022 17:39

How lovely you are.

It's not your responsibility to visit at certain times, on certain days and to take certain items in for her.
It's not up to you to 'co-ordinate' visits.

That her family are 7 hours away is not your problem.

That the family, 7 hours away, want you and others to co-ordinate visits, smacks of trying to absolve themselves from visits and duties.

It sounds like she probably doesn't even know if it's you that has been visiting.

If you want to visit, then visit when you can.

If visiting her causes her to be confused then step back. Her world is diminishing by the day.

There are times, in life, when stepping back is the best thing to do.

Please do not feel any guilt or onus.

I've been there with two very dear neighbours who I'd known for a very long time and whose family seemed to want to take a back seat for as long as possible.

PattyMelt · 29/04/2022 17:33

Only do what you want to do. If you aren't comfortable going back to the hospital where your Dad was then don't go.
You don't don't know what kind of relationship she has with her daughter they don't sound very close and it could be for good reason.
If she comes home and you still want to visit, do it then.

TheHatinaCat · 29/04/2022 17:32

How kind of you.

If you like going to see her then just go as and when it suits you. No need to co-ordinate or get it agreed with anyone. If the daughter wants that level of control she can do it herself!

Just think of yourself as a friendly face for the old lady. Nothing more.

Seenoevil1 · 29/04/2022 17:27

Hi
I appreciate what you're saying. That was very kind of you, what you did for your neighbour but, yes, it was pretty poor that the daughter stepped back completely. Thanks for the warning.

OP posts: