Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

... to think a lot of middle aged couples stay married for convenience

78 replies

HofstadtersLaw · 29/04/2022 13:43

That's certainly my own case. We've drifted apart over many years and live very different lives. I've met someone else, a good friend, but that is all for now. I'd like to change that so have some big decisions in the coming weeks for me.

DSis is in an unhappy marriage too. Feeling unloved, not appreciated, no sex, etc. She's decided to wait things out until youngest starts work or goes to college.

My best friend has no kids, and happy staying in her marriage for financial and a few other reasons.

Is it just me and people I know?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FarFarFarAndAway · 02/05/2022 12:00

I have two friends who are open that the reason they have stayed (and both left or separated for short times) is financial and functional- they don't fancy being poorer single parents doing everything for three kids all the time without the money and physical support of another parent to drive them around, do the dinner and so forth. One hasn't worked for many years, she would be on benefits, she doesn't fancy that and has a lovely life, so the fact her husband is emotionally dysfunctional is the price to be paid. The other likes her husband but nearly left him. I think it's fine to decide that life would be harder separated and act accordingly, not everyone conforms to the endless love match of Disney.

I also think some marriages come around again to be better when you are older, especially after menopause, I've seen that in my own family.

I don't think you should stay for the kids, my parents are much better apart but I think it's ok to make decisions about how you want to live and if you aren't unhappy and it's better for you financially and support-wise to stay in a marriage, then that's fine too, and not always a bad decision.

nokidshere · 02/05/2022 11:48

I'm sure plenty of couples should probably split but I doubt they are together just for convenience. As others have said, it's more likely because of financial consequences or constraints, children, fear of the unknown.

We celebrated our 35th anniversary yesterday and have been together almost 40yrs. We were together 20yrs before having children and our boys are now getting ready to spread their wings. Without doubt, the hardest times in our marriage were when the boys were small. Working full time, skint, huge mortgage, children, they all put a strain on a relationship.

Now we are retired and are very happily 'plodding along'. Life is calm and chilled. We both have hobbies which give us plenty of alone time, but behind closed doors we are still feisty, have massive discussions/debates/arguments about everything under the sun and a great sex life.

The point is that only the people in the relationship know why they are still there and, for some, convenience might be what they need or want.

UseOfWeapons · 02/05/2022 11:36

I divorced at 36, and again at 41. Never again. But I wasn’t financially supported by my exes.
Two of my friends no longer want to be with their husbands, but don’t want to go through dividing things up, and working full time to survive. Nor do they want to be alone.
To each their own, wouldn’t suit me, but it’s their choice.

HelpMeGetThrough · 02/05/2022 11:09

I do wonder about my parents to be honest. My father did bugger all day to day at home really when we were kids. If he shut a cupboard door he was helping out. Father had his hobby that he did at least two evenings a week, usually more (cycling wasn't a thing back then and it wasn't golf), so we never saw him some days at all.

They are 79 and 84 now and they bicker like hell, it's very draining. He has another expensive hobby now, which they can afford, but it does wind my mother up, but she did say to me a while ago, that she gets evenings to herself.

I do wonder if they had us a children now whether the marriage would survive.

Loopytiles · 02/05/2022 10:53

So you’re having an emotional affair and considering ending your marriage.

Would have been much better to decide what to do about your marriage before embarking on an EA.

Doubt many people stay in marriages due to ‘convenience’. For money issues, fear of other options, and/or upsetting DC, sure.

akitamiss · 02/05/2022 10:48

I know a few couples that split up in 40s/50s/60s for a variety of reasons. This probably would not have happen in my parents time. Things do change in relationships over long periods time, it is normal and expected, nothing stays the same. That can result in the relationship growing and evolving, or becoming more distant (and perhaps failing).

For example, in my case, over the years, DH has grown an interest in a time consuming, somewhat expensive hobby, sometimes with travel involved. While I don't have an overlapping interest in that hobby, I'm actually very happy for him to have something he enjoys like this. It's good for him!

DH also has some health issues that sometimes results in ED (viagra not a help). That was a big issue for him to deal with on a personal level, and of course it had an impact on me too and impacted my confidence. However, we've worked something out that works for us as a couple, even now is still keeping me very happy Blush

So looking from the outside it might look like a challenged relationship (DH's hobby/time/money + his ED and a partner that still wants a sexual relationship), but I think we're both happy together.

peaceanddove · 01/05/2022 21:06

Cameleongirl · 29/04/2022 15:16

I think it all boils down to love and friendship, Tbh. I still love DH and find him interesting to be with. We disagree on a lot of subjects, and he really annoys me at times - and I certainly annoy him! - but we still find each other interesting. I recognize the same spark among other couple friends. If you don't feel that way about your long-termpartner, it's probably just convenience.

This is very much how DH and I still are after 30 years together. He makes me laugh every day and can still make me blush. There's still a lot of passion (ahem) and we still argue - but that's because we could never be indifferent to each other. I always say that the opposite of love isn't hate, it's indifference.

But, this is exactly the type of marriage I wanted. I never wanted to be with a DH who was essentially just a friendly house-mate. Tepid domesticity has always left me cold. I don't need DH to ever clean the bathroom or cook dinner - I need him to make me giggle like a teenager, and make me feel like I'm always the most beautiful woman in the room (to him).

But, lots of people are very content to share their life with a friendly house-mate. Not everyone wants or needs to be Romeo & Juliet or Clare & Jamie.

Cameleongirl · 01/05/2022 19:05

@Penguinsaregreat I agree that subsequent relationships can work out, but from what I've observed, it's more likely to work out if the unhappy partner leaves, has some time alone, and then meets someone new - or perhaps kindles a romance with someone they already knew, but weren't involved with at all.

I suppose it's because they have time to process the end of one relationship and figure out what they really want from a new one.

Penguinsaregreat · 30/04/2022 20:28

Thinking about my friends I believe those who are married are happy. I have single friends who are divorced and they seem happy too, not one of them regrets ending their marriage.
I don't doubt there are women who stay for the lifestyle and because it is easier than having to get a full time job and work yourself to the bone.
As for leaving for another man/woman I disagree that it rarely works out. People like to think there is such a think as karma but I haven't seen much evidence of it. I read once that second marriages have a higher failure rate than first marriages, this doesn't bare out in my experience.
I have quite a few friends who are on their second marriages and I can't think of any one who is unhappy in their marriage. If course they might be giving a good performance. I only have one friend who is going through problems and she isn't married they just live together.

Anonymous48 · 30/04/2022 18:31

Cameleongirl · 30/04/2022 01:07

It’s interesting the comments about people not wanting to be alone. I’d be fine being on my own, I love it! As long as I still had my friends (who are mainly women), it wouldn’t bother me.

Not that I don’t enjoy DH’s company.😂

I agree with you. I'm happily married and love sharing my life and my home with my husband. But if that were to end, the being on my own part I'd be fine with!

sweeneytoddsrazor · 30/04/2022 17:53

I think lots of people are like this initially when the dc grow up and move out, but gradually grow closer together again. Relationships change often, sometimes you are close other times further apart. And all relationships have to be worked at.

xmaspost · 30/04/2022 16:13

I know of a few couples that are still married, but clearly far from happy and satisfied (I've been told). I also know many are very happy (again based on what I've been told by them).

I was lucky in that I exited a wrong relationship for me when I was younger. I think as people get older they're less likely to make such a change, even if they are unhappy?

Having been in both positions, I'm always delighted to read about other happy couples. It's not for everyone ... but those of us lucky enough to be in such a situation should cherish and nurture it.

Monty27 · 30/04/2022 01:16

There's plenty of middle aged couples I know that are still together sans DC's or even didn't have DC's that still adore each other despite the troubles they may have been through. They simply love each other.
Others I know didn't make it. Including myself.
It's your life OP. Do what you feel is right.

Cameleongirl · 30/04/2022 01:07

It’s interesting the comments about people not wanting to be alone. I’d be fine being on my own, I love it! As long as I still had my friends (who are mainly women), it wouldn’t bother me.

Not that I don’t enjoy DH’s company.😂

TokyoTen · 30/04/2022 01:02

Maybe some people feel this way. But surely the minority. Personally we don't- mid fifties, together 25+ years and still love each other and enjoy spending time with each other.

VivienneDelacroix · 30/04/2022 00:15

I think it's common tbh. I feel very sad for my friend in a sexless marriage with an utter dullard, but having already been through one divorce I don't think she can face another. It's all very polite until she's had a few to drink and then she'll tell us how depressing it all is.
Unfortunately she thinks she just has to stay in the marriage now, despite the fact her husband is a complete cocklodger who has spent years working in low-stress jobs and sitting on his arse watching TV, while she has run herself into the ground in a highly stressful job and runs around after him like he's the Queen of Sheba. He's now convinced her to sell the house she bought and use the equity to pay off debts he had before they were married and move to a cheaper property in his home country, away from her family and friends. But she's scared of being on her own, has no children, and thinks if they divorced she'll grow old alone.
It's so sad.

Sunnytwobridges · 29/04/2022 23:59

Of course there are tons of them. I know quite a few who stay married because of the kids, financial reasons, don’t want to be alone.

LakeIsle48 · 29/04/2022 23:57

When I was in my first longterm relationship when I was in my 20's I ended the relationship because I wanted to do and see different things. He was so great and he was devastated when it ended. I know now why he took it so hard. Having your heart broken is horrific! I know I'm exaggerating but it is so effing painful. I'm going to join a nunnery!

artisanbread · 29/04/2022 23:54

I think it's a spectrum, as with most things. There are a lot of relationships in between deliriously happy and completely miserable. I'm not sure at which point people decide to pull the plug. My relationship with DH is unexciting, probably even dull most of the time because we are busy with demanding full-time jobs and raising kids. I still much prefer it to being on my own. I enjoy the companionship,shared humour and the family time. We don't spend very much time at all doing things just the two of us but when we do it is enjoyable. I like being able to share the responsibilities of life.

It's certainly very different from the early years and we can be distant at times but I wouldn't trade it in to go off seeking passion, romance and excitement that I might never find.

LowlandLucky · 29/04/2022 23:54

Don't tar us all with the same brush. Middle aged and loving life and my DH, not bored, not coasting, not making do but having a great time together ta very much.

LakeIsle48 · 29/04/2022 23:45

I know my heart is broken now but I would love to be with someone who I love and who loved me. I used to be in some really loving relationships and I miss that

gogohm · 29/04/2022 23:37

We split when youngest was 18. Life is amazing now

LakeIsle48 · 29/04/2022 23:35

I stayed single when my kids were young and I'd have to say I had a great time. I had 2 amazing lovers. We ended it because one of them had to move because of his work in different countries and my recent longterm partner ended things completely out of the blue, no warning, nothing. Up til then I loved being in a relationship

Westfacing · 29/04/2022 23:35

There are lots of unhappy older women (60 plus) on Gransnet who are now stuck with demanding and miserable old buggers. They should have got out years ago but now fear old age on their own or can't afford to split. They fetch and carry for husbands who sit and watch TV all day.

LakeIsle48 · 29/04/2022 23:23

I'm 56 and see a good few friends who are very happy. They laugh a lot together. I would give my right arm to be in a loving relationship. My 9 year old relationship ended very recently. I feel bereft, lonely and very upset