Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you hire a male babysitter?

333 replies

georgarina · 29/04/2022 11:51

Why/why not?

OP posts:
hanginthereagain · 29/04/2022 15:12

BarbaraofSeville · 29/04/2022 15:08

Plus the mental impact on the men who work as primary school teachers, in nurseries or baby sit for friends and family when so many people are looking at them thinking 'paedophile'.

I wonder how any of the people saying 'no way' would feel if their teen DS was unable to get a baby sitting job like his older sister did because people operated a blanket 'no way' policy or assumed they had ulterior motives.

Well said, at least there is some normality out here.

Indicatrice · 29/04/2022 15:10

@BarbaraofSeville but that’s the fault of men. They need to get their house in order if they don’t want to be mistrusted.

Fixyourself · 29/04/2022 15:09

so called ‘checks’ mean nothing. You could be a convicted sex offender and have a valid DBS certificate.

Fishwishy · 29/04/2022 15:09

jewishmum · 29/04/2022 14:33

No. It is a fact that paedophiles are more often male. I do not believe males have a caring mothering instinct.

That's because males make up 50% of the population. If you looked at terrorism and normalised for the small amount of the population they make up you would find a specific religious group that Mumsnet doesn't allow comment on so I'm not naming would be equally disproportionately problematic letting have paid employment in the security services like males and sex offences (it doesn't help that some sex offences cannot be committed by women like rape because they name penis) are problematic in the childcare sector. We do not and should not allow either to be discriminated against unless you allow discrimination against a wide range of things. I would settle to either allow discrimination against women men or religious or racial groups or not but not this stupid mix and match discrimination that seems so prevalent on Mumsnet at the moment.

LivingFastForward · 29/04/2022 15:08

CapMarvel · 29/04/2022 15:03

"The OP used the words ‘hire’ and ‘babysitter’."

Personally if I were to use a babysitting service then I would expect the company/person to be subjet to background checks/have references etc. Assuming all that was in place I would not reject a male sitter out of hand.

That’s your choice. My choice would be to not use a male babysitter to minimise the risk to my children.

BarbaraofSeville · 29/04/2022 15:08

hanginthereagain · 29/04/2022 15:01

Id be more interested in the mental impact all this is on your children, and how they learn to normalise social interactions with males. Living in a environment when their mother constantly claims men are one, some or all of the following Podophile/rapist/lazy/fat/old/bald/lacking in maternal instinct.

I'm just glad my parents and children how a rounded view on the world not the twisted narrative that lives on Mums Net perpetuated by the cacophony of male loathing spiel and story's that "my mate Sonia, told my sister Helen, who's friends with Barbra that some guy on Facebook, tried to talk to cherry's daughter and it turns out from Francis he`s a convicted rapist". 🙄

Plus the mental impact on the men who work as primary school teachers, in nurseries or baby sit for friends and family when so many people are looking at them thinking 'paedophile'.

I wonder how any of the people saying 'no way' would feel if their teen DS was unable to get a baby sitting job like his older sister did because people operated a blanket 'no way' policy or assumed they had ulterior motives.

CapMarvel · 29/04/2022 15:03

"The OP used the words ‘hire’ and ‘babysitter’."

Personally if I were to use a babysitting service then I would expect the company/person to be subjet to background checks/have references etc. Assuming all that was in place I would not reject a male sitter out of hand.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 29/04/2022 15:03

Fishwishy · 29/04/2022 14:55

Indeed all those talking about statistics should probably not let Thier children be looked after by their own family.

That’s about access- most people don’t let just anybody watch their children- if they did I imagine the stats for abuse would be more representative of such

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 29/04/2022 15:02

DS's childminder was male.

It was actually a wife and husband childminding team but on the days we needed it was mainly the husband who did drop off a pick up.

He was wonderful, came very highly recommended by the school and others in the area so had no qualms with him whatsoever.

I hated the fact that it felt weird to me as I am such a believer in the sexes being equal, but I can't deny there is always a worry about men in general.

hanginthereagain · 29/04/2022 15:01

Id be more interested in the mental impact all this is on your children, and how they learn to normalise social interactions with males. Living in a environment when their mother constantly claims men are one, some or all of the following Podophile/rapist/lazy/fat/old/bald/lacking in maternal instinct.

I'm just glad my parents and children how a rounded view on the world not the twisted narrative that lives on Mums Net perpetuated by the cacophony of male loathing spiel and story's that "my mate Sonia, told my sister Helen, who's friends with Barbra that some guy on Facebook, tried to talk to cherry's daughter and it turns out from Francis he`s a convicted rapist". 🙄

FoggySpecs · 29/04/2022 14:57

As a general rule no, but when DS and DD were 8 and 7, they had a male babysitter, he looked after them in day a few times and organised lots of fun games, he also gave them lunch etc. However, I trusted him and he is a great kid.

Another boy offered and I decided against it, he is a bit of a stoner and something just made me uncomfortable, however I do pay him to do dog walking and the dog likes him.

We've had other teenage girls some they loved others they hated, one collected DD from school twice a week for a year, and they had no rapport, I wasn't worried about safety but they did not get along.

Growing up my parents left me and my brother at home with our male housekeeper in the day, it was all fine and but they only did it when we were older.

Fishwishy · 29/04/2022 14:55

Ashleys63 · 29/04/2022 14:42

Yes I probably would.

Children are statistically more at risk from members of their own family.

Indeed all those talking about statistics should probably not let Thier children be looked after by their own family.

LivingFastForward · 29/04/2022 14:54

CapMarvel · 29/04/2022 14:29

I'm not saying just let any old bloke look after your kids, of course not. That would be absurd.

But just as you take precautions with seatbelts etc you can reduce the risk when it comes to leaving your kids in the care of other people. That's literally all I'm saying. If I trust a given male as much as a female to babysit then I see no real reason to say no to one of them simply because they are a bloke because I've assessed the risk to the point I trust each of them equally.

The OP used the words ‘hire’ and ‘babysitter’. These words do not imply that the person is very well known to us. The OP did not ask if we would let close male family look after our children. They’ve probably been deliberately ambiguous and vague to cause conflict.🙄

Whatsnewpussyhat · 29/04/2022 14:48

You can't discriminate on the basis of sex

Of course you can. Why do you think there are exceptions in the equality act that allow us to do precisely this when it comes to protecting women and children?

Should we be able to discriminate against other protected characteristics because of statistics?

If you are hiring a bloody babysitter you can pick who the fuck you want. You would have to actively choose a man or a woman.
Stop trying to falsely compare other categories with sex.

brookstar · 29/04/2022 14:48

I do not believe males have a caring mothering instinct.
What rubbish.
I'm female and I've never had what you refer to as a 'mothering instinct'.
Me and my DH are equally caring individuals and are great parents though. I'm not better because i'm a woman.

brookstar · 29/04/2022 14:46

I'm not saying just let any old bloke look after your kids, of course not. That would be absurd.

But just as you take precautions with seatbelts etc you can reduce the risk when it comes to leaving your kids in the care of other people. That's literally all I'm saying. If I trust a given male as much as a female to babysit then I see no real reason to say no to one of them simply because they are a bloke because I've assessed the risk to the point I trust each of them equally.

Exactly. DH's 18 year old nephew babysits for us regularly and he also babysits for my friends children ( often he has all the kids so we can go out together!) We all know him and trust him.

My DH has looked after our neighbours daughters a couple of times and I've left DS with my friends husband and her brother on a number of separate occasions.

There's a huge difference between a stranger babysitting and leaving your children with people you know and trust - male or female.

ZoeQ90 · 29/04/2022 14:44

jewishmum · 29/04/2022 14:33

No. It is a fact that paedophiles are more often male. I do not believe males have a caring mothering instinct.

Wow, that's harsh.

Ashleys63 · 29/04/2022 14:42

Yes I probably would.

Children are statistically more at risk from members of their own family.

CoalCraft · 29/04/2022 14:42

I wouldn't hire a stranger as a babysitter anyway, only ever family/friends I trust. Otherwise I use a nursery with many members of staff, all of whom are qualified.

The gender of the adults involved makes no difference.

wantmy · 29/04/2022 14:41

Yup. My son and his friends used to babysit for his younger siblings.

Great boys and it was good for my younger girls to have positive male role models in their lives coz their dad is a dick.

MintJulia · 29/04/2022 14:40

Only my brother or one of my nephews.

But then I wasn't keen on leaving ds with his df - who proved to be negligent and lacking in any common sense.

FreedomforWA · 29/04/2022 14:40

Nope. I'm on a local fb page for people seeing babysitters/nannies. There was a man replying to a lot of ads a while back. He is now awaiting trial for multiple counts or sexual abuse.

LocalHobo · 29/04/2022 14:36

I think this thread is an example of one of the many reasons why childcare still primarily falls on women though. Hard to push for equality of childcare if the prevailing opinion in society is that men are too incompetent and / or dangerous to look after children. It feeds into the narrative that childcare by default falls to women, it's a woman's job, and that men are being so good to help out when they do the most basic of tasks once in a blue moon.

This.

Posters on this thread who wouldn't 'hire' a babysitter at all, are not really relevant with their comments imo.

PierresPotato · 29/04/2022 14:36

Hired a babysitter once in a hotel. I kept going back.
Never bothered again!

girlmom21 · 29/04/2022 14:35

What about males in other settings with access to children 1:1? Male teachers, doctors, nursery staff?

As a rule none of those people would be alone with your child. They certainly wouldn't be in your child's home alone with them.