Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you hire a male babysitter?

333 replies

georgarina · 29/04/2022 11:51

Why/why not?

OP posts:
BadNomad · 29/04/2022 18:45

Come on. Lack of opportunity to babysit has zero impact on someone's ability to parent their own child in the future.

Lockheart · 29/04/2022 18:41

Lunar27 · 29/04/2022 18:28

This is the flip side of this thread isn't it.

I wouldn't judge any parent for their choices but don't think it's possible to have it all ways round. You can't have this level of distrust in the opposite sex (justified or otherwise) without the downside of men not doing their fair share of parenting. This naturally leads to men being breadwinners etc etc.

This thread has definitely made for interesting reading and my conclusion is that women can't really trust men at all, either strangers or family. Makes me wonder why women even bother to have kids at all if the male threat is mostly known to them. I mean, how do women sleep at night when their husbands/partners are under the same roof?

Well yeah, you can't raise your sons and daughters in a society which says "males shouldn't babysit, they're dangerous" / "be suspicious of male nursery workers" / "don't leave your children with men" / "don't let your children sleepover if there's not a woman to supervise" and then somehow expect the children you raise to magically turn into parents who play an equal role in rearing their own children. You're conditioning your daughters to think it's solely their job and your sons to be hands off.

BiscuitLover3678 · 29/04/2022 18:36

LilacPoppy · 29/04/2022 12:27

@BanjoKnickers Absolutely never - surely basic safeguarding? no don’t be ridiculous, having a close male friend babysit your child is not a safeguarding risk.

😅it is always a risk!

FabFitFifties · 29/04/2022 18:35

I never had to, but if I had needed to, I would only trust his uncles, and my adult nieces male partners. I spend a lot of my work time in safeguarding meetings.

Lunar27 · 29/04/2022 18:28

Lockheart · 29/04/2022 14:12

I would only refuse a babysitter (male or female) if I didn't know them.

I think this thread is an example of one of the many reasons why childcare still primarily falls on women though. Hard to push for equality of childcare if the prevailing opinion in society is that men are too incompetent and / or dangerous to look after children. It feeds into the narrative that childcare by default falls to women, it's a woman's job, and that men are being so good to help out when they do the most basic of tasks once in a blue moon.

This is the flip side of this thread isn't it.

I wouldn't judge any parent for their choices but don't think it's possible to have it all ways round. You can't have this level of distrust in the opposite sex (justified or otherwise) without the downside of men not doing their fair share of parenting. This naturally leads to men being breadwinners etc etc.

This thread has definitely made for interesting reading and my conclusion is that women can't really trust men at all, either strangers or family. Makes me wonder why women even bother to have kids at all if the male threat is mostly known to them. I mean, how do women sleep at night when their husbands/partners are under the same roof?

youvegottenminuteslynn · 29/04/2022 18:10

@BelperLawnmower

To be fair I would think twice about letting an unknown lady driver ferry my kids around. I'd have more confidence in a man.

Men are statistically far more likely to cause a collision, be injured in a collision or die in a collision than women.

So your preference there isn't based on statistics. Still your personal choice, of course, and you've every right to make it.

But it's rooted in false stereotypes and sexism in rather than data.

Men are statistically more likely to abuse. Not all men, but we can't know which ones so we use data to inform our decisions. For some than means no male babysitters, for others it doesn't.

But the driving example isn't equivalent at all, especially as male and female drivers don't even have accidents at the same level as one another. Men have them more often.

Branleuse · 29/04/2022 18:09

If it was people I didnt know at all then id rather choose a woman or girl. If I knew them fairly well then I might well be ok with a male, depending on how they interact with the children but it makes me anxious. So many people are sexually abused in childhood. Its scary.
Obviously its not all men. Noone said it was, but a babysitter has a long time on their own with a child in private, unlike a teacher for example. Im cautious and make no apologies for that. The stakes are high

itsgettingweird · 29/04/2022 18:07

DarleneSnell · 29/04/2022 17:55

Nope. Nothing personal, just would never leave my small children with a male stranger.

Would you leave them with a female stranger?

I ask because I wouldn't ever leave my ds with a stranger.

But I'd leave them with any member of either sex that I knew and believed I could trust.

DramaAlpaca · 29/04/2022 18:05

As a teenager, my eldest son was highly in demand for babysitting. Always for the children of parents he and I knew, so not a stranger. It was usually to babysit boys, but sometimes girls too. DS was very popular because he's great with kids and happy to play with them.

girlmom21 · 29/04/2022 18:01

roses2 · 29/04/2022 17:09

Last school year I had a male after school nanny for my two boys age 5 and 8. Didn't even cross my mind of any issues. He was a teaching assistant at another school and provided me DBS check, ID etc. My boys loved him and I now use him for tutoring.

From this thread I've gauged that mothers of only boys are more likely to be ok with a male babysitter than mothers of only girls are - which does make sense.

CorvusPurpureus · 29/04/2022 17:55

Both my older two babysat every weekend a few years ago - we're expats, & at the time were living in a compound full of young families.

Ds was nearly always snapped up first, & could've been booked 3 times over every weekend evening. He got very good at prioritising reliable payers, those good for substantial over time because they'd come home hours late & plastered, providers of pizza & a well stocked fridge, best Internet connections & cable subscriptions etc etc!

Dd1 was basically his understudy - still in demand but definitely second choice.

This was because ds is outgoing, funny & loves being the life & soul - happy to organise an hour of games & activities to wear random dc out before bed. He's currently planning a year abroad TEFLing - he's a natural with kids. Dd, OTOH, is sensible but quiet & shy. All our neighbours' dc clamoured to have ds babysit because he was such fun.

Had my ds been inclined to abuse the dc he babysat, he would have been in a perfect situation to do so by age 14 or so. Popular, known for clowning around, in demand with multiple families so any 'new' family could see that he had an established reputation...

I mean, my lad is lovely. I would trust him around any child I know, personally.

But here's the thing: I absolutely wouldn't judge any parent who didn't. He's a bloke & much more likely statistically, sadly, to be an abuser than say, his sister. & as above, IF he had happened to be that way inclined, he'd have had the perfect set up to be an extremely prolific abuser.

I don't think there's easy answers. It makes me sad that anyone would suspect my fabulous ds of nefarious intentions. But it would be entirely reasonable & proportionate to be wary of him/any other male in these circumstances, I think.

DarleneSnell · 29/04/2022 17:55

Nope. Nothing personal, just would never leave my small children with a male stranger.

LivingFastForward · 29/04/2022 17:48

The men abusing children in their care, are presumably the ones that people judged as safe. After all, no one would leave their child with someone they thought would hurt them.

With the the exception of their dad, I would rather leave my children with a woman, the sex that isn’t responsible for the majority of this sort of crime.

weleasewoderick23 · 29/04/2022 17:47

There's always a risk with babysitters, but does no one remember Vanessa George? She worked in a nursery and was DBS checked but still went on to abuse.

And what about teenage girls who use it as an excuse to have their friends round when the parents are out? I understand that it's down to the parents to do due diligence, but I think it's very short sighted to dismiss male childcare.

And then we expect men to be excellent fathers when they haven't been given the chance to experience the reality of childcare.

Iorderedyouapancake · 29/04/2022 17:46

BelperLawnmower · 29/04/2022 17:40

Can you imagine someone asking if a woman should be hired to do valet parking and the answer being "no women are shit drivers and can't be trusted not to crash a Porsche"??! It's just as ridiculous to exclude a man from babysitting purely on the basis of sex.

What's ridiculous is the fact that you'd even make that comparison. We're talking about potential abuse of a child, not a bloody Porsche.

To be fair I would think twice about letting an unknown lady driver ferry my kids around. I'd have more confidence in a man.

Not sure why when male drivers are more likely to be involved in serious accidents

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 29/04/2022 17:43

My dad- yes, my fil- yes; my bil- yes, my Ohs best mate- yes…. Random man no but equally random woman no

SleepingStandingUp · 29/04/2022 17:40

I wouldn't use strangers, so yes.

The risk analysis is hard. The consequences are HIGH but the actual risk is low. Every second man isn't actually a paedophile

BelperLawnmower · 29/04/2022 17:40

Can you imagine someone asking if a woman should be hired to do valet parking and the answer being "no women are shit drivers and can't be trusted not to crash a Porsche"??! It's just as ridiculous to exclude a man from babysitting purely on the basis of sex.

What's ridiculous is the fact that you'd even make that comparison. We're talking about potential abuse of a child, not a bloody Porsche.

To be fair I would think twice about letting an unknown lady driver ferry my kids around. I'd have more confidence in a man.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 29/04/2022 17:36

Can you imagine someone asking if a woman should be hired to do valet parking and the answer being "no women are shit drivers and can't be trusted not to crash a Porsche"??! It's just as ridiculous to exclude a man from babysitting purely on the basis of sex

Yeah, coz lady drivers is the equivalent of men committing the vast majority of sex offences.
Honestly, what a ridiculous comparison.

PumpkinsandKittens · 29/04/2022 17:20

Norush4 · 29/04/2022 17:12

Sorry but isn't it family members and people who are close to you that end up being the abusive ones?

I wouldn't hire a male... but I have a lady as I was in desperate need at the time I had my worries but she was great! Because its your home or theirs I guess it seems a lot more personal than a nursery setting..

Tbh I don’t even leave my kids with family as I don’t have any family help so it’s irrelevant really but no I wouldn’t hire a babysitter male or female as I wouldn’t leave my kids with someone I didn’t know, not just about abuse risks but they wouldn’t like it either so it’s a no from me and I agree with pp that the reason why someone known to you is more likely to abuse is because strangers don’t usually have access to people’s kids I’m sure If they did that would change very quickly. But no I don’t leave my kids with random babysitters, I’m not comfortable with it and if my kids can’t go then I don’t go. I don’t want a stranger in my house or looking after my kids, I don’t need to go anywhere that bad, would rather stay in.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 29/04/2022 17:16

BestDove · 29/04/2022 17:02

This is such a depressing thread!! Surely it's more important to know and have a connection with the babysitter. Their sex shouldn't come into the equation.

Can you imagine someone asking if a woman should be hired to do valet parking and the answer being "no women are shit drivers and can't be trusted not to crash a Porsche"??! It's just as ridiculous to exclude a man from babysitting purely on the basis of sex.

What's ridiculous is the fact that you'd even make that comparison. We're talking about potential abuse of a child, not a bloody Porsche.

Norush4 · 29/04/2022 17:12

PumpkinsandKittens · 29/04/2022 12:01

Nope, not worth the risk imo but then I wouldn’t hire any baby sitter I didn’t know personally that wasn’t a family member or close friend (male or female) so 🤷‍♀️

Sorry but isn't it family members and people who are close to you that end up being the abusive ones?

I wouldn't hire a male... but I have a lady as I was in desperate need at the time I had my worries but she was great! Because its your home or theirs I guess it seems a lot more personal than a nursery setting..

roses2 · 29/04/2022 17:09

Last school year I had a male after school nanny for my two boys age 5 and 8. Didn't even cross my mind of any issues. He was a teaching assistant at another school and provided me DBS check, ID etc. My boys loved him and I now use him for tutoring.

itsgettingweird · 29/04/2022 17:06

I wouldn't use any babysitter I didn't know - through an agency for example.

But using male or female ones known to me I wouldn't choose preference over sex - I'd choose it over whom I thought was best for the job.

BestDove · 29/04/2022 17:02

This is such a depressing thread!! Surely it's more important to know and have a connection with the babysitter. Their sex shouldn't come into the equation.

Can you imagine someone asking if a woman should be hired to do valet parking and the answer being "no women are shit drivers and can't be trusted not to crash a Porsche"??! It's just as ridiculous to exclude a man from babysitting purely on the basis of sex.