Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remind you that Rainbows, Brownies and Guides are mixed sex?

139 replies

KatieAlcock · 29/04/2022 08:55

I have settled my case with Girlguiding and I may now take my daughter to Brownies, but it's been a long hard slog.
If you have a daughter in Guiding, you do have the right to ask for single sex accommodation for her. In fact, I'd say if you don't, it's a bit worrying.
If you are a leader, you can also say you will only share a room with a female.
Parents and leaders should get decent clear communications about what they are letting themselves in for and their rights, but we shall see if that transpires.

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-10765045/I-outcast-shunned-like-criminal-just-wanting-Girl-Guides-safe.html

OP posts:
PerfectPenquins · 29/04/2022 10:46

On the ground many actual leaders and volunteers think this policy is insane. Luckily it's not come up as an issue for us personally. My daughter won't be going on any overnight trips that include other groups but within our own group she's fine as we don't have any trans kids currently so the mixed sex issue hasn't come up yet. GG have got this so badly wrong it won't age well.

Howeverbut · 29/04/2022 10:44

I'm totally against single sex schools, clubs and organisations but totally in favour of single sex safe spaces: sleeping accommodation, changing rooms, toilets etc.

YayitisfinallySpring · 29/04/2022 10:39

I was pleased that this made the top story on the app today. I was shocked when I read it. My DGD is very shy and immature and the thought of her sharing a tent with an intact male (which she might not realise) is horrifying.

I know this has had a hugely detrimental cost to you emotionally, but thank you so much for not giving in.

FOJN · 29/04/2022 10:29

RainbowRename

Sorry, I should have included the word some. I know many GG leaders are very concerned about mixed sex facilities.

Thank you to Katie for everything you've done to raise awareness.

catandcoffee · 29/04/2022 10:25

Well done Katie 👏

Pumpkinjam · 29/04/2022 10:24

I’m really glad that this has come up in the press as I had no idea this was going on within brownies/guides.

HelloDaisy · 29/04/2022 10:24

MissCrowley · 29/04/2022 09:01

I don't see what the issue is. I'm really sorry but I don't. Scouts have been mixed sex for ages. Obviously asking to have female/ male spaces to change, sleep etc is within our rights.
I'm a girl guiding leader myself. You can't have one rule for Scouts and demand that they allow females in and not reciprocate. It's all or nothing.
Got my flame proofed vest on as I know full well my opinion will not be a popular one.
And before anyone starts throwing around the child sexual abuse card and saying "You have no idea" then please don't bother. I've been there and unfortunately got that t-shirt.
Percentage wise there's more chance of sexual abuse happening within the family members rather than an outside source.

We go through rigorous safe guard training- 4 levels in fact to ensure our young people are kept safe and well during their time with us.

I think you have missed the point, which I’m surprised about as you are a guide leader.

The issue was more about transgender girls being allowed to share sleeping accommodation and showers etc with biological girls even though they still have full male genatalia and that the girls and their parents are not to be told. It was not to be open for discussion.

Even without the possibility of sexual abuse I am not sure I would be happy for my young daughter to be getting changed and sharing showers with physical boys. I am no prude but I would not be happy to be changing and showering near a man, whatever gender they wish to be, so would not want that put onto my daughter without her consent or any discussion beforehand.

ItsSnowJokes · 29/04/2022 10:23

Thank you for standing up for girls, young women and also female leaders.

I will not let my young daughter join rainbows even though she would love it due to these policies as to me this is safeguarding 101. I wish more parents knew that this organisation only acknowledge gender and not sex.

CuddlyCactus · 29/04/2022 10:20

Guides claimed that any male who said they were female was female and did not permit single sex accomodation for guides or leaders (unless the trans person asked for it).

Why could a trans person ask for something and it's granted but others are not allowed to request it? That's not equal treatment

Sunnyshoeshine · 29/04/2022 10:19

There's a lot of misinformation about scouts already on this thread. Scouts may be mixed sex but their trans policy clearly states that use of toilets and facilities etc is according to gender not sex.

www.scouts.org.uk/volunteers/inclusion-and-diversity/including-everyone/lgbtplus/transgender-and-gender-identity/supporting-trans-young-people/

Trans young people should be able to use the toilets or facilities of the gender they identify as.

Spidey66 · 29/04/2022 10:17

The Scouts are transparent though. It's well known they accept boys and girls, but do (I assume) provide single sex facilities as necessary.

Girl Guides say they are a single sex organisation for girls only, but also accept boys who identify as girls, and until now used the same facilities even if inappropriate eg showers, dorms in camps.

MaChienEstUnDick · 29/04/2022 10:13

@KatieAlcock thank you for your courage and your tenacity. I know this has come at great personal cost to you. Flowers

NoToLandfill · 29/04/2022 10:11

Katie THANK YOU for taking the stance you did with GG. Absolutely the right thing to do, at great personal cost to yourself. Thank you so much. GG has been totally captured by gender ideology. Everyone else who understands biology thinks this is ridiculous.

RainbowRename · 29/04/2022 10:00

JOJN I promise you there are a lot of leaders out there who feel very passionately about this issue. My personal stance is that I can do more good for the young girls in my local area by continuing to run my units until the issue arrives physically in my unit. At which point i will leave and I will tell parents why. Please don't think majority of leaders think like the idiots at HQ think. As leaders we spend a lot of time wondering WTF HQ are playing at.

FOJN · 29/04/2022 09:50

Biological male teen can join guides as he 'identifies' as female. leader is not permitted to tell other guides or parents that there is a biological male present. the group goes away on camp and that biological male is permitted to share sleeping, changing and washing space with biological females.

This is the issue MissCrowley as you must know. I can only assume you think anyone remotely concerned about safeguarding or girls privacy is a pearl clutching prude. However it's kind of you to reveal how dismissive GG leaders are about this; parents can now decide for themselves whether they trust you to ensure the safety and privacy of girls is protected.

Moppincraxy · 29/04/2022 09:43

MissCrowley · 29/04/2022 09:01

I don't see what the issue is. I'm really sorry but I don't. Scouts have been mixed sex for ages. Obviously asking to have female/ male spaces to change, sleep etc is within our rights.
I'm a girl guiding leader myself. You can't have one rule for Scouts and demand that they allow females in and not reciprocate. It's all or nothing.
Got my flame proofed vest on as I know full well my opinion will not be a popular one.
And before anyone starts throwing around the child sexual abuse card and saying "You have no idea" then please don't bother. I've been there and unfortunately got that t-shirt.
Percentage wise there's more chance of sexual abuse happening within the family members rather than an outside source.

We go through rigorous safe guard training- 4 levels in fact to ensure our young people are kept safe and well during their time with us.

I find this attitude from a guide leader worrying. It is irrelevant that a higher percentage of sexual abuse occurs within family units, that doesn't mean that child safeguarding should be any less rigorous outside of the family unit.

And saying things like "child sex abuse card" suggests that you do not take safeguarding sufficiently seriously, despite your "four levels of training".

It is not OK for GG to pretend that a male teenager is a girl and can therefore share sleeping etc. facilities with young teenage girls. And even worse for them to go out of their way to hide the fact that male teenagers or male guide leaders are present. I assume they also call anyone who questions this, or is concerned about their daughter's safety, a transphobic bigot.

comealongponds · 29/04/2022 09:41

scouts weren’t forced to go mixed sex by anyone. They chose to because at that time membership was declining and opening up to girls allowed them to remain viable (current waiting lists/membership are irrelevant, this is a decision which was made many years ago).

the issue op is on about is that Guiding claims to be for girls only but allows transgender women and girls to join and insists that they are female and that nobody has a right to know if they or their child was sharing a room/tent with a person with a penis. Admittedly, OP could have made this clearer in their post.

Guiding is still a single gender organisation (not single sex), boys are only able to join if they “identify” as girls. Whereas in Scouts it’s clear that it’s mixed sex and there are usually separate sleeping/bathroom arrangements, trans members in guiding would share bedrooms/bathrooms with girls with nobody being told.

Male volunteers have always been allowed in guiding, but must have separate sleeping/bathroom arrangements and men can’t be leaders. However a man who “identifies” as a woman can be a leader and there’s no requirement for separate sleeping/bathroom arrangements. Which OP and many others, including myself, believe is wrong.

Philisophigal · 29/04/2022 09:36

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

OMG12 · 29/04/2022 09:30

Massive congratulations on this what a triumph for women and common sense!

Mumoftwoinprimary · 29/04/2022 09:28

@MissCrowley You are really mid understanding why Scouts went mix sexed in the 90s. Scouts were not forced to go mix sex. They chose to. Because their membership was collapsing and it was the only way they could carry on.

In the town I grew up at the point of the change there were 11 guide companies - all of which had massive waiting lists. And two scout troops - one of which (that my brother was in and my mum helped with) was on the verge of closing due to lack of numbers. (They had 11 - two of which were technically too old but no one was going to kick them out. They needed 12 to cover the cost of the scout hut never mind any kind of activities and the surplus from previous years was about to run out.)

The weekend after the change was announced all the leaders phone most of the hundreds of girls on the guide waiting list (no GDPR in those days!) and offered them a Scout place. 7 took it up and started the following Thursday.

i’ve just checked and now there are 15 guide companies and 6 scout troops in the town. (Population of the town has more than doubled over the last 30 years.)

donquixotedelamancha · 29/04/2022 09:23

I'm not entirely sure how accurate that information is.

I would say numbers was probably the deciding factor at the time. Not all groups are oversubscribed and numbers had been declining. There was also a feeling amongst members that it was the right thing to do, but a lot disagreed.

OutlookStalking · 29/04/2022 09:21

This is such fantastic news.

I think some posters/voters weren't aware of the previous position (male bodies in female vodied sleeping quarters etc without parents knowledge, and with parents assuming it was girls only.)

Well done!

donquixotedelamancha · 29/04/2022 09:20

I don't see what the issue is. I'm really sorry but I don't. Scouts have been mixed sex for ages. Obviously asking to have female/ male spaces to change, sleep etc is within our rights.

But that wasn't the rule. Scouts openly allow boys and provide single sex accomodation from before puberty. Guides claimed that any male who said they were female was female and did not permit single sex accomodation for guides or leaders (unless the trans person asked for it). I know that seems batshit but I asked this specific question directly about 2 years ago and (after much chasing) got a very clear answer.

I'm a girl guiding leader myself. You can't have one rule for Scouts and demand that they allow females in and not reciprocate.

Its still a completely different rule. Boys are only allowed in guides if they have long hair and say they are a girl.

Hoppinggreen · 29/04/2022 09:18

MissCrowley · 29/04/2022 09:01

I don't see what the issue is. I'm really sorry but I don't. Scouts have been mixed sex for ages. Obviously asking to have female/ male spaces to change, sleep etc is within our rights.
I'm a girl guiding leader myself. You can't have one rule for Scouts and demand that they allow females in and not reciprocate. It's all or nothing.
Got my flame proofed vest on as I know full well my opinion will not be a popular one.
And before anyone starts throwing around the child sexual abuse card and saying "You have no idea" then please don't bother. I've been there and unfortunately got that t-shirt.
Percentage wise there's more chance of sexual abuse happening within the family members rather than an outside source.

We go through rigorous safe guard training- 4 levels in fact to ensure our young people are kept safe and well during their time with us.

For me the issue isnt that Guides may be mixed sex, its the fact that this is hidden. I would want to know if my daughter was going to be sharing a room with a male and be able to make decisions accordingly. Its the lack of transparency that is the issue for me

WallaceinAnderland · 29/04/2022 09:16

For those not aware, Guides do not differentiate between sex and gender. That applies to adults as well as children. This should not be a secret, everyone needs to know this so that parents can make their own decisions as to whether they think safeguarding is robust enough for their child to attend.

Swipe left for the next trending thread