Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remind you that Rainbows, Brownies and Guides are mixed sex?

139 replies

KatieAlcock · 29/04/2022 08:55

I have settled my case with Girlguiding and I may now take my daughter to Brownies, but it's been a long hard slog.
If you have a daughter in Guiding, you do have the right to ask for single sex accommodation for her. In fact, I'd say if you don't, it's a bit worrying.
If you are a leader, you can also say you will only share a room with a female.
Parents and leaders should get decent clear communications about what they are letting themselves in for and their rights, but we shall see if that transpires.

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-10765045/I-outcast-shunned-like-criminal-just-wanting-Girl-Guides-safe.html

OP posts:
5foot5 · 29/04/2022 13:14

KatieAlcock · 29/04/2022 12:59

Is it just my phone or have all replies gone into italic?

Mine has done that too. I thought I must have accidentally done something daft. Wouldn't be the first time

Innocenta · 29/04/2022 13:06

@MissCrowley Both should have stayed single sex. It's important for young people to have sage spaces away from the opposite sex.

movemyshed · 29/04/2022 13:00

I'm shocked to read that other mothers shunned Katie and cancelled playdates.

If this is true, what were they thinking?

KatieAlcock · 29/04/2022 12:59

Is it just my phone or have all replies gone into italic?

OP posts:
Fluffymule · 29/04/2022 12:54

GirlGuiding have behaved appallingly over this issue.

To make major changes to their policy in a stealthy manner, to keep parents and guardians in the dark about the implications, indeed to have a policy of actively withholding information pertaining to issues of safeguarding from parents, is unforgivable in an organisation built around children.

But to then go on the attack when questioned about these changes, to punish, silence and expel members who want to discuss what they believe to be potentially dangerous safeguarding blindspots? Appalling.

I can’t believe their insurers were fully aware or onboard either?

It would seem that fealty to Stonewall and their misinterpretation of the law was far more important than the rights and safety of women and girls within the movement. Their website still links to organisations such as Mermaids, which I would suggest shows terrible judgement on their part.

Who would trust this organisation now? They’ve been forced to concede a little on ‘being open’ with parents. It’s hardly enough. They need need a change of leadership and organisation policy rewrite before I would entrust children into their care.

IstayedForTheFeminism · 29/04/2022 12:50

MissCrowley · 29/04/2022 09:01

I don't see what the issue is. I'm really sorry but I don't. Scouts have been mixed sex for ages. Obviously asking to have female/ male spaces to change, sleep etc is within our rights.
I'm a girl guiding leader myself. You can't have one rule for Scouts and demand that they allow females in and not reciprocate. It's all or nothing.
Got my flame proofed vest on as I know full well my opinion will not be a popular one.
And before anyone starts throwing around the child sexual abuse card and saying "You have no idea" then please don't bother. I've been there and unfortunately got that t-shirt.
Percentage wise there's more chance of sexual abuse happening within the family members rather than an outside source.

We go through rigorous safe guard training- 4 levels in fact to ensure our young people are kept safe and well during their time with us.

ODFOD.

I was sexually abused as a child. The only place I could go as a child that my abuser wasn't allowed/there weren't other males was Brownies and Guides. I'm absolutely fucking horrified that these days he could just ID as a girl and follow me there.

CoffeeWithCheese · 29/04/2022 12:49

We walked away from Guiding when a leader basically really took a dislike to my eldest and took delight in reducing her to tears (at Rainbow age). Was made very clear that in our area if you don't enjoy being really "girlie" and painting your nails and decorating biscuits and colouring in that Guiding wasn't for you. Actually spoke about it with my own old Guide leader (I was in it right up to Young Leader level) and she was horrified about what had gone on and how DD had been treated (and DD is pretty much a mini-me in terms of the "can be a mild little sod" level).

That was just before the Trans agenda really hit Guiding, but we moved them over to Scouting and they have absolutely thrived - the trans gaslighting from GGUK was just confirmation to me that the organisation has really really lost their way now.

ScrollingLeaves · 29/04/2022 12:38

If you have a daughter in Guiding, you do have the right to ask for single sex accommodation for her. In fact, I'd say if you don't, it's a bit worrying.

I read the Daily Mail article OP and it seemed to say Girl Guides and Brownies will allow trans girls to share accommodation and changing rooms with girls. Please would you explain more? I feel muddled.

lassof · 29/04/2022 12:38

Moppincraxy · 29/04/2022 09:43

I find this attitude from a guide leader worrying. It is irrelevant that a higher percentage of sexual abuse occurs within family units, that doesn't mean that child safeguarding should be any less rigorous outside of the family unit.

And saying things like "child sex abuse card" suggests that you do not take safeguarding sufficiently seriously, despite your "four levels of training".

It is not OK for GG to pretend that a male teenager is a girl and can therefore share sleeping etc. facilities with young teenage girls. And even worse for them to go out of their way to hide the fact that male teenagers or male guide leaders are present. I assume they also call anyone who questions this, or is concerned about their daughter's safety, a transphobic bigot.

Scouts have had absolutely huge problems with historic child sex abuse cases.
Paedophiles go where they can access children.
See also football coaches.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 29/04/2022 12:32

Thank you Katie, so much for your bravery in doing this. Let's hope this will mark an end to the lies and coercion of girls to accept male bodies in their overnight accommodation and other spaces they would expect to be single sex.

Girlguiding has been lying to parents and children and denying parents the ability to consent (or not) to mixed sex accommodation etc. They have been denying parents the right to safeguard their children.

It has been deception and lies, lies, lies.

They know most people think 'girl' and 'woman' relates to sex not gender.

They have also been actively discriminating against parents and children with the protected characteristic of religion for whom single SEX (not gender) spaces are required within their religion.

So pretty much more exclusive than inclusive, really.

I loved being a Brownie and Guide but - because of the shoddy safeguarding and the lies - my daughters haven't joined.

I don't think that the organisation lying about something as fundamental and important for safeguarding as biological sex is a very good example.

I'd be delighted to place my girls in Katie Alcock's care of course, and I appreciate many leaders are fighting the good fight, but the overall message has been that the ability of girls (biological females) to say 'no' isn't important and will be denied in favour of the wants of biological males. So, it's a no from me.

334bu · 29/04/2022 12:27

Thank you Katie.

ScruffGin · 29/04/2022 12:21

Thank you for not backing down on this... My daughter won't be joining until they change their stance

Jellycatspyjamas · 29/04/2022 12:15

Many congratulations @KatieAlcock - such an important stand to make.

BlitheRobin · 29/04/2022 12:10

Understand Katie's concern and well done so far!

"It used to be rainbows, brownies and guides for girls.
Beavers, cubs and scouts for boys.
Venture scouts was mixed.

no issues."

We looked at the brownies/guides for my daughter and it was mostly baking, crafts charity work and things along a similar line. It may not be the same everywhere but friends have experienced similar.
Scouts was archery, useful practical skills, hikes, orienteering, kayaking in the summer every week in the holidays. She joined Scouts, and we were grateful she was able to do so..

greyinganddecaying · 29/04/2022 12:01

Well done Katie - I know it's taken a lot of effort and perseverance to get to this point. You should be very proud.

SunshineCake · 29/04/2022 11:50

It used to be rainbows, brownies and guides for girls.
Beavers, cubs and scouts for boys.
Venture scouts was mixed.

no issues.

SockQueen · 29/04/2022 11:42

underneaththeash · 29/04/2022 11:14

And me. But I don't think it will ever be an issue in my unit as I control the waiting list and we only admit girls.

But how would you know, if they registered on GO with a female name? That's my slight concern, as a fellow leader with the exact same stance as you.

underneaththeash · 29/04/2022 11:14

RainbowRename · 29/04/2022 10:00

JOJN I promise you there are a lot of leaders out there who feel very passionately about this issue. My personal stance is that I can do more good for the young girls in my local area by continuing to run my units until the issue arrives physically in my unit. At which point i will leave and I will tell parents why. Please don't think majority of leaders think like the idiots at HQ think. As leaders we spend a lot of time wondering WTF HQ are playing at.

And me. But I don't think it will ever be an issue in my unit as I control the waiting list and we only admit girls.

Clangyleg · 29/04/2022 11:14

So why aren’t they accepting girls and women who might believe they are trans too if they are so inclusive? Personally I would not want my daughter to be influenced by girls and women who believe they are the opposite sex for whatever reason, but the option of her sharing (without our knowledge) sleeping accommodation, changing rooms etc with males infinitely worse.

bluelavender · 29/04/2022 11:10

I think there are many complex issues here

Firstly is the issue of single sex spaces and how they should be used

Reading the article; there is a very important secondary issue- policies on single sex spaces were changed; and when Dr Alcock queried this and discussed it with others she was treated in a negative, detrimental and unfair way

Thirdly; I find some of the comments up post about needing a summary of the article as they would not read the Mail rather concerning. We live in complex times and will not always agree with each other. I think it is actively healthy to read views that you might not agree- I read the Times and the Guardian (though prefer the Observer) and also, occasionally, the Telegraph, and yes, even the Mail. Sometimes I have read something that has actively challenged by thinking- I view this to be a good thing

Stylishkidintheriot · 29/04/2022 11:09

Literally just read an article about your fight. I’m all for genuine trans people being supported. But I do not think that women’s dignity and safety should be compromised.

you were treated terribly by girl guiding. Even if you were wrong: there still needs to be debate and dissent: we can’t just cancel people because they don’t voice the same views as the party line.

well done

Heathyou · 29/04/2022 10:58

I can understand the issues people are worried about (safe sleeping space etc.. ) but I thought it was widely known they accept trans kids? So is your issue that girlguiding is no longer single sex or the safe sleeping / changing facilities.

SushiShopSearch · 29/04/2022 10:54

@KatieAlcock Congratulations on your legal win against The Guides. The safety of girls is paramount and so many parents are still unaware of the failure of protection for them in Girlguiding. Monica Sulley is one prime example.

thecritic.co.uk/misguided-or-misgendered/

TotalRhubarb · 29/04/2022 10:48

i meant to quote Moppin’s post, which I completely agree with.

TotalRhubarb · 29/04/2022 10:46

Completely agree with ALL of this. I find your attitude really worrying MissCrowley.

Thank-you so much, Katie, for forcing Girlguiding to finally take safeguarding seriously and be honest with parents.

Swipe left for the next trending thread