Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remind you that Rainbows, Brownies and Guides are mixed sex?

139 replies

KatieAlcock · 29/04/2022 08:55

I have settled my case with Girlguiding and I may now take my daughter to Brownies, but it's been a long hard slog.
If you have a daughter in Guiding, you do have the right to ask for single sex accommodation for her. In fact, I'd say if you don't, it's a bit worrying.
If you are a leader, you can also say you will only share a room with a female.
Parents and leaders should get decent clear communications about what they are letting themselves in for and their rights, but we shall see if that transpires.

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-10765045/I-outcast-shunned-like-criminal-just-wanting-Girl-Guides-safe.html

OP posts:
MissCrowley · 29/04/2022 17:05
  1. I'm a volunteer so doesn't cost me anything but also I don't get paid to do it either
  2. For your other comment I'm leaving the conversation because that's very below the belt. I was sexually abused as a child which I stipulated in my original comment if you'd actually bothered to read it.

I was interested in hearing others views and have enjoyed reading them and taking them on board, but I will not tolerate those kinds of comments as I find them upsetting and offensive.

Mybestyear · 29/04/2022 17:02

@MissCrowley you sound like the type of person who says things like “but why didn’t she speak up” when girls/young woman are abused. Given the amount of women and girls abused and killed on a daily basis compared to men, we absolutely can demand single sex spaces for girls.

Sadly your “4 tiers of training” appears to be a waste of money.

AgathaAllAlong · 29/04/2022 17:01

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 29/04/2022 14:30

In other countries there is no gender segregated Scouts, it's weird that there are in this country.

Do you mean sex segregated?

And that would be absolutely fine as everybody knows they are mixed sex and all the usual safeguarding precautions are taken.

Can you not see the difference?

No, I mean gender. But it's neither sex nor gender segregated.

Of course I can see the difference. And I agree with you if what you are saying is that safeguarding measures need to account for possibly trans girls - but what would those measures look like? At brownies in particular, I don't see what harm it does to have trans girls there too. At guides when they're teen-agers I agree it's different, but not to a huge extent. Scouts might not share a tent but you can get there's loads of sneaking into tents they should not be in!

The trans leaders is another matter entirely.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 29/04/2022 17:00

It is worrying that the Scouts are taking the same view, that gender trumps sex, but at least parents are aware that there are both boys and girls in the Scouts, and that leaders could be either female or male. In GG many parents will have been assuming until now that they could be quite sure their girls were in a single-sex organisation, with male helpers/leaders' sons in separate accommodation on residential trips. Now they know this can't be assumed and they won't be told if in fact another Guide is a teenage male or a Leader is an adult male.

I wonder if there's a possibility of a sex discrimination claim there. As a general rule, the Guides could lawfully turn a male away, but now it seems if a male says 'I identify as trans' they'll be welcomed in. This is surely discriminating against the males who might like to join but who acknowledge that they are male. And thus it is that single sex exemptions all over the place are placed under threat.

SpindleInTheWind · 29/04/2022 16:55

nothingcomestonothing · 29/04/2022 14:47

Thank you KatieAlcock for your courage and perseverance. You should never have been put in this position. GG have cheerfully thrown girls under the bus to appear 'inclusive'. Religious girls, sexually abused girls, or just girls who want or need a girls-only space, all unimportant in this definition of inclusive but as long as Stonewall are happy eh?

Quite.

What an absolute shit show Girlguiding has made of this.

AnotherNC22 · 29/04/2022 16:42

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist just because scouts is mixed sex doesnt mean they have dealt with the trans issue as several of us have pointed out upthread. The scout trans policy still allows young people to use the toilets, showers, facilities etc of the gender they identify with, not according to sex.

I cant believe the number of posters who see scouts as a viable alternative when their policy is exactly the same?!

nothingcomestonothing · 29/04/2022 14:47

Thank you KatieAlcock for your courage and perseverance. You should never have been put in this position. GG have cheerfully thrown girls under the bus to appear 'inclusive'. Religious girls, sexually abused girls, or just girls who want or need a girls-only space, all unimportant in this definition of inclusive but as long as Stonewall are happy eh?

RinklyRomaine · 29/04/2022 14:44

AgathaAllAlong · 29/04/2022 14:11

I don't understand what the problem is. They're all children, why can't they share the same spaces? Really don't see how learning to tie a knot or make a pasta frame is put in jeopardy because the girl next to you is really a boy. Are you all freaked out by primary school too?

In other countries there is no gender segregated Scouts, it's weird that there are in this country .

Actually, it's not just about sleeping and washing spaces. There's plenty of evidence to suggest girls thrive with access to single sex spaces. That they self censor, take second place and generally don't have the same confidence in some mixed sex spaces. For some girls, orgs like GG are invaluable.

Safeguarding when male leaders like Monica Sulley can publicly pose in fetish gear and silently be sharing sleeping quarters with tween and teen girls WITHOUT their parents knowing is a another matter entirely. Thank you Katie.

Noisyprat · 29/04/2022 14:33

I think the issue here is that many parents just assume that safeguarding means their children will be in single sex accommodation and use facilities for their sex. The word 'gender' has long been used and been accepted as meaning 'sex' however unfortunately this is definitely not the case because as we know they are very different.

Anyway my DD was a Brownie, never made it to Guides. It's such a shame that these organisations feel the need to effectively lie to parents. They do it because they know it is a safeguarding issue. Unfortunately unless there are more people like Katie it will take something terrible to happen for it all to be exposed.

Lastly, there are many people quoting scouts on here, I thought they had the same view regarding gender/sex. They seem to believe that gender is a protected characteristic under the EA, if they can't even get this right then there's no hope.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 29/04/2022 14:31

And so many adults - women a lot of them (some on this thread with their ‘what’s the big deal?’ bollocks) - don’t understand the bigger safeguarding picture… if I were being kind I’d put it down to them being utterly and pitifully thick but alas I think it’s pure, vile, good old fashioned misogyny.

Unhappily for people like them people like me are absolute terriers on this and won't let their shoulder shrugging go unchallenged.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 29/04/2022 14:30

In other countries there is no gender segregated Scouts, it's weird that there are in this country.

Do you mean sex segregated?

And that would be absolutely fine as everybody knows they are mixed sex and all the usual safeguarding precautions are taken.

Can you not see the difference?

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 29/04/2022 14:29

Its not about sitting next to them. Its about sleeping in the same tent/sharing the same changing, washing etc spaces.

Without parents being aware that these spaces will be mixed sex and with nobody knowing what, if any, risk assessment had been done (none apparently as all the girl guides were 'girls' even if not all female - according to GG themselves).

Had they done, as Scouts etc did, then there would be no need for asking the questions Katie did!

Notaneffingcockerspaniel · 29/04/2022 14:26

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

LouLou198 · 29/04/2022 14:17

I have followed your case from the beginning. Well done and thank you Katie for persevering with this as long as you have Flowers

Giveaschitt · 29/04/2022 14:17

AgathaAllAlong · 29/04/2022 14:11

I don't understand what the problem is. They're all children, why can't they share the same spaces? Really don't see how learning to tie a knot or make a pasta frame is put in jeopardy because the girl next to you is really a boy. Are you all freaked out by primary school too?

In other countries there is no gender segregated Scouts, it's weird that there are in this country .

Its not about sitting next to them. Its about sleeping in the same tent/sharing the same changing, washing etc spaces.

AgathaAllAlong · 29/04/2022 14:16

To clarify Katie, I do not agree with how you have been treated by Guides, your friends, and the media. I think their rules on this issue are fine, but also, it's fine for you to have asked questions, and their response to your doing so is very bad.

AgathaAllAlong · 29/04/2022 14:11

I don't understand what the problem is. They're all children, why can't they share the same spaces? Really don't see how learning to tie a knot or make a pasta frame is put in jeopardy because the girl next to you is really a boy. Are you all freaked out by primary school too?

In other countries there is no gender segregated Scouts, it's weird that there are in this country .

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 29/04/2022 14:08

MissCrowley · 29/04/2022 09:01

I don't see what the issue is. I'm really sorry but I don't. Scouts have been mixed sex for ages. Obviously asking to have female/ male spaces to change, sleep etc is within our rights.
I'm a girl guiding leader myself. You can't have one rule for Scouts and demand that they allow females in and not reciprocate. It's all or nothing.
Got my flame proofed vest on as I know full well my opinion will not be a popular one.
And before anyone starts throwing around the child sexual abuse card and saying "You have no idea" then please don't bother. I've been there and unfortunately got that t-shirt.
Percentage wise there's more chance of sexual abuse happening within the family members rather than an outside source.

We go through rigorous safe guard training- 4 levels in fact to ensure our young people are kept safe and well during their time with us.

The issue is/was the fact that GG chose to go mixed sex WITHOUT telling anyone, They simply redefined girl to include some boys. and even excludes transboys as they were no longer girls!

If GG had done as Scouts did there would have been far, far less of an issue.

And before you tell me I am wrong, read what they wrote after settling with Katie - it was ALL about clarity of communication. NOTHING about reviewing their policy of being a mixed sex organisation now, simply "Ooops, we'll promise to get better at telling parents something about the fact that some of our girls may be male bodied!"

So you see, you are coming at this from a direction nobody here took, least of all Katie!

JuneFromBethesda · 29/04/2022 14:01

I want to add my thanks to @KatieAlcock for your tremendous bravery and tenacity in taking this on. It should never have been necessary but thank goodness you won.

I hope now @MissCrowley understands what the issue is.

SlipperyLizard · 29/04/2022 13:58

My DD went from Brownies to Guides pre-pandemic. I wondered why other girls the same age (10) had switched to a different night (most go up to the guides on the same night as brownies was). A few weeks later I noticed a boy entering, but he had a coat on so assumed older brother/son of leader. At the end I saw him come out, coat off, in Guide top/necker.

I asked DD “is there a boy in your guides?”. She said she wasn’t sure - told me the name used (a girls name) but that she thought it was a boy. Next week I watched again - absolutely no mistake it was a teenage boy (mid puberty). We switched to an alternative night - perhaps the other girls who’d gone up at the same time had known about it (they are from big scouting families).

If Guides wants to be mixed sex it should be honest about it - it shouldn’t gaslight girls & their families by pretending they are single sex while allowing some males to join.

Gowithme · 29/04/2022 13:49

SushiShopSearch · 29/04/2022 10:54

@KatieAlcock Congratulations on your legal win against The Guides. The safety of girls is paramount and so many parents are still unaware of the failure of protection for them in Girlguiding. Monica Sulley is one prime example.

thecritic.co.uk/misguided-or-misgendered/

Jesus Christ that is worrying.

MajorCarolDanvers · 29/04/2022 13:46

@Mumoftwoinprimary

You are really mid understanding why Scouts went mix sexed in the 90s. Scouts were not forced to go mix sex. They chose to. Because their membership was collapsing and it was the only way they could carry on

Sorry but that is completely wrong.

Firstly girls could join venture scouts from 1976
It became fully mixed from 1991
It became compulsory for all groups to accept girls from 2007

Scout membership was not collapsing at all. It has grown steadily since WWII (with a pandemic dip that it has nearly recovered from).

The full inclusion of girls and the introduction of Beavers (1982) were boosts to growth but its just incorrect to say it was the only way the could carry on.

MajorCarolDanvers · 29/04/2022 13:37

Agree with every word of this.

Nancydrawn · 29/04/2022 13:35

If you have a daughter in Guiding, you do have the right to ask for single sex accommodation for her. In fact, I'd say if you don't, it's a bit worrying.

Do you mean if you don't have the right to ask, it's a bit worrying?

Or do you mean if you don't ask, it's a bit worrying.

EvilPea · 29/04/2022 13:25

Innocenta · 29/04/2022 13:06

@MissCrowley Both should have stayed single sex. It's important for young people to have sage spaces away from the opposite sex.

I don’t agree.
dd is in scouts. Its got slightly more girls than boys and it’s great. Each bring something to the mix. They are all friends and have each other’s backs. It’s really nice, they just see each other as another scout.

Swipe left for the next trending thread