Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remind you that Rainbows, Brownies and Guides are mixed sex?

139 replies

KatieAlcock · 29/04/2022 08:55

I have settled my case with Girlguiding and I may now take my daughter to Brownies, but it's been a long hard slog.
If you have a daughter in Guiding, you do have the right to ask for single sex accommodation for her. In fact, I'd say if you don't, it's a bit worrying.
If you are a leader, you can also say you will only share a room with a female.
Parents and leaders should get decent clear communications about what they are letting themselves in for and their rights, but we shall see if that transpires.

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-10765045/I-outcast-shunned-like-criminal-just-wanting-Girl-Guides-safe.html

OP posts:
SpindleInTheWind · 29/04/2022 21:28

I find it hard to fathom how people like @MissCrowley have safeguarding responsibilities that they are able to discharge safely and legally.

underneaththeash · 29/04/2022 21:28

SockQueen · 29/04/2022 11:42

But how would you know, if they registered on GO with a female name? That's my slight concern, as a fellow leader with the exact same stance as you.

i only take from our village and the neighbouring one. It should also be on medical details.

ChristinaXYZ · 29/04/2022 21:15

Incredibly dismissive - especially your 'got the t-shirt' comment @MissCrowley - what's that supposed to mean? Being sexually assaulted is akin to going to a festival or something?

And the 'more likely' thing is a ridiculous stance. You are more likely to be killed by a family member than out and about - does that mean you don't think good street lighting, night buses, and other things that help keep people safe are not worth bothering with either? Did you have no feelings about the women who have been killed this last year (any year??) by strangers when vigils were held both in memory and because women had had enough? Should no-one have bothered over that because women are more likely to be killed by a family member?

No, you cannot prevent every risk, but by God you should take every precaution, and keeping biological men and boys out of girls' dorms is a major one.

Justkeeppedaling · 29/04/2022 20:58

YnysMonCrone · 29/04/2022 20:46

Katie, you are a hero and a loss to the true spirit of Guiding.
The day the issue rises in my unit will be my last day in Guiding. I wish I had your courage to speak out.

It happened to me, and I did.

YnysMonCrone · 29/04/2022 20:46

Katie, you are a hero and a loss to the true spirit of Guiding.
The day the issue rises in my unit will be my last day in Guiding. I wish I had your courage to speak out.

Annabelle69 · 29/04/2022 19:58

@KatieAlcock You are a heroine.

I cannot thank and admire enough people like you who put themselves on the line to protect the rights and safety of women and girls.

Having any man/boy masquerading as a woman/girl in order to share, tents, hospital wards, toilets, changing rooms, rape crisis centres, prison cells, train sleeper carriages (the list goes on) is insanity.

modgepodge · 29/04/2022 19:50

DockOTheBay · 29/04/2022 18:57

Yep
I think the issue is unlikely to arise at my unit as I run Brownies. If it does I will not allow biological male child to share with female children, and i will make it clear why.

But how would you know they were a biological male? If they haven’t hit puberty, give you a girls name, parents say they’re a girl….how could you tell?

I wonder how schools are handling trans issues on residentials? I’m a teacher (primary) and I’m dreading this issue ever coming up for me.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 29/04/2022 19:43

Surely the girls get to choose if they're happy sharing sleeping quarters and showers with someone with a penis though?
The trans persons rights do not trump every else's.
It's about equality, everyone should be consulted and go with the wishes of the majority

This is the issue.

The lies and deception are because they know parents would not accept mixed sex.

But it's worse than that. They're implementing a policy that is telling girls their needs must be subverted for males. That their desire for safety, privacy, dignity or any other bloody reason they want a single sex space DON'T matter. And indeed the trans person (who in every example is male) should be allowed to do as they want to the detriment of every single biological girl there.

By their lies, deception and lack of clarity they are making it VERY clear they don't think girls should have the right to say 'no' to Trans identifying males.

No-one is saying trans identified females shouldn't be allowed in the guides - it's pretty much always been a haven for girls that don't conform to sex based stereotypes, however they identify.

The guiding policy is essentially excluding trans identified females.

And the rest of the biological girls are being told 'trans' trumps everything else - so it's not surprising so many girls are then claiming to be trans.

Unfortunately they won't be able to identify out of the utter sexism of all of this because it's only the males that count.

Turtles4543 · 29/04/2022 19:25

Thank you Katie

Georgeskitchen · 29/04/2022 19:16

Well done Katie for standing by your principles. I wish there were more people as brave as you x

DockOTheBay · 29/04/2022 18:57

RainbowRename · 29/04/2022 10:00

JOJN I promise you there are a lot of leaders out there who feel very passionately about this issue. My personal stance is that I can do more good for the young girls in my local area by continuing to run my units until the issue arrives physically in my unit. At which point i will leave and I will tell parents why. Please don't think majority of leaders think like the idiots at HQ think. As leaders we spend a lot of time wondering WTF HQ are playing at.

Yep
I think the issue is unlikely to arise at my unit as I run Brownies. If it does I will not allow biological male child to share with female children, and i will make it clear why.

IstayedForTheFeminism · 29/04/2022 18:54

It's always so lovely that so many people think that because some groups are mixed sex they all should be. (Please read this in the most sarcastic tone tone you can because it's far from lovely. )

Brownies/Guides was the only group where I lived that didn't have boys in. It was the only place I ever truly relaxed and didn't have to worry about whether the boy/man next to me was actually a rapist. It was my only safe space. I needed it. I deserved it.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 29/04/2022 18:51

Bloody well done Katie.

duskyspringfield · 29/04/2022 18:40

i saw the way this was going and was really relieved when my DD didn’t want to go to Guides…

I just wouldn’t want to put her in a shit situation that GG would have been happy to do. Very poor safeguarding in my view.

Beamur · 29/04/2022 18:37

The boys they go to school with are probably ones they'd most like time away from if my DD is anything to go by!

Autienotnaughtie · 29/04/2022 18:35

RainbowRename · 29/04/2022 09:01

Congratulations Katie.

The whole situation is insane. I have promised myself if the situation presents itself at my unit I will walk away and take my daughters (if they are still there at the time) with me.

I refuse to willingly endanger the young girls in my care in this way. Well done you for being brave enough to fight this.

From the boys they probably go to school with?

Autienotnaughtie · 29/04/2022 18:34

MissCrowley · 29/04/2022 09:01

I don't see what the issue is. I'm really sorry but I don't. Scouts have been mixed sex for ages. Obviously asking to have female/ male spaces to change, sleep etc is within our rights.
I'm a girl guiding leader myself. You can't have one rule for Scouts and demand that they allow females in and not reciprocate. It's all or nothing.
Got my flame proofed vest on as I know full well my opinion will not be a popular one.
And before anyone starts throwing around the child sexual abuse card and saying "You have no idea" then please don't bother. I've been there and unfortunately got that t-shirt.
Percentage wise there's more chance of sexual abuse happening within the family members rather than an outside source.

We go through rigorous safe guard training- 4 levels in fact to ensure our young people are kept safe and well during their time with us.

Agree completely we are talking about mixed children events no different to any other activity

Beamur · 29/04/2022 18:32

Cliftontherocks · 29/04/2022 18:08

My daughter goes to a scouts. She is going to help out at a scout camp on the weekend. Biological girls - her and her friend have a tent. Biological boys have tents. Trans boy (going from boy to girl) has their own tent. That makes perfect sense.

Someone’s rights to gender reassignment characteristics does not trump anyones right to have single biological sex spaces.

This seems perfectly reasonable.
In my opinion, the fact that Guides is/was girls only is actually really valuable. Girls having a space simply to do activities and have fun without men/boys around. I wasn't sure it was a good thing until my DD joined Brownies and for her, and girls like her, single sex has been a welcome respite from the relentless presence of boys in childhood and adolescence.
I think that the option to have a club single sex is fine and mixed sex, also fine, but parents do need to know. Scouts policies on trans members isn't brilliant either, but everyone knows that both sexes attend. Guides has been less than clear about this and continuing with the same rules as if only females (sexed) were attending. This is the safeguarding blind spot.
Whilst I appreciate that everyone is entitled to privacy and dignity, that needs to apply for everyone.
I also wonder what Guides rules would say about a detransitioned transgirl/woman? If Guides is a fudge of single sex and/or single gender, presumably a male no longer identifying as female would have to leave.

Americano75 · 29/04/2022 18:17

Thank you Katie, you're an absolute shero. ❤️

Cliftontherocks · 29/04/2022 18:08

My daughter goes to a scouts. She is going to help out at a scout camp on the weekend. Biological girls - her and her friend have a tent. Biological boys have tents. Trans boy (going from boy to girl) has their own tent. That makes perfect sense.

Someone’s rights to gender reassignment characteristics does not trump anyones right to have single biological sex spaces.

CuddlyCactus · 29/04/2022 18:02

I'm talking about children, I said trans girls not women. I don't believe that trans under 10s pose a risk to girls.

I agree but Surely the girls get to choose if they're happy sharing sleeping quarters and showers with someone with a penis though?
The trans persons rights do not trump every else's.
It's about equality, everyone should be consulted and go with the wishes of the majority

AgathaAllAlong · 29/04/2022 17:51

Mybestyear · 29/04/2022 17:07

FFS seriously! So it’s ok to have biological males in with the brownies but not the guides! Because paedophiles like older girls 🤦‍♀️

And boys /girls sneaking into each other’s tents is a world away from a biological male self-identifying as a woman sleeping in a tent with girls.

Who said anything about peadophiles? I said very clearly that adult leaders is a different point entirely. I'm talking about children, I said trans girls not women. I don't believe that trans under 10s pose a risk to girls.

itsgettingweird · 29/04/2022 17:15

WallaceinAnderland · 29/04/2022 09:16

For those not aware, Guides do not differentiate between sex and gender. That applies to adults as well as children. This should not be a secret, everyone needs to know this so that parents can make their own decisions as to whether they think safeguarding is robust enough for their child to attend.

Thankyou.

I use to help at a boys brigade and we has female leaders. When we went on camp we had separate sleeping arrangements, the boys shared and the male leaders shared.

In scouting I always understood it was mixed sex and separate sleeping arrangements.

O absolutely had no idea the guiding facially didn't differentiate between sex and gender. That's really bad as a starting point but horrendously negligent in safeguarding for a group aimed at girls and woman.

If a male wants to identify as a female in gender (whatever the definition of gendered female means?!) then they still should have the separate sleeping arrangements based on sex that we have had as a society for as long as time can remember.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 29/04/2022 17:11

So the Scouts say that? I admit I haven't looked recently.

But at least everyone know they are mixed sex. It's a slightly better set up.

Next stop then, get both organisations to wake up to the reality of what they are doing.

Recent EHRC guidance and their next steps should start to make a difference.

Mybestyear · 29/04/2022 17:07

AgathaAllAlong · 29/04/2022 17:01

No, I mean gender. But it's neither sex nor gender segregated.

Of course I can see the difference. And I agree with you if what you are saying is that safeguarding measures need to account for possibly trans girls - but what would those measures look like? At brownies in particular, I don't see what harm it does to have trans girls there too. At guides when they're teen-agers I agree it's different, but not to a huge extent. Scouts might not share a tent but you can get there's loads of sneaking into tents they should not be in!

The trans leaders is another matter entirely.

FFS seriously! So it’s ok to have biological males in with the brownies but not the guides! Because paedophiles like older girls 🤦‍♀️

And boys /girls sneaking into each other’s tents is a world away from a biological male self-identifying as a woman sleeping in a tent with girls.

Swipe left for the next trending thread