Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remind you that Rainbows, Brownies and Guides are mixed sex?

139 replies

KatieAlcock · 29/04/2022 08:55

I have settled my case with Girlguiding and I may now take my daughter to Brownies, but it's been a long hard slog.
If you have a daughter in Guiding, you do have the right to ask for single sex accommodation for her. In fact, I'd say if you don't, it's a bit worrying.
If you are a leader, you can also say you will only share a room with a female.
Parents and leaders should get decent clear communications about what they are letting themselves in for and their rights, but we shall see if that transpires.

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-10765045/I-outcast-shunned-like-criminal-just-wanting-Girl-Guides-safe.html

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
StageRage · 06/05/2022 17:44

MissCrowley · 29/04/2022 09:01

I don't see what the issue is. I'm really sorry but I don't. Scouts have been mixed sex for ages. Obviously asking to have female/ male spaces to change, sleep etc is within our rights.
I'm a girl guiding leader myself. You can't have one rule for Scouts and demand that they allow females in and not reciprocate. It's all or nothing.
Got my flame proofed vest on as I know full well my opinion will not be a popular one.
And before anyone starts throwing around the child sexual abuse card and saying "You have no idea" then please don't bother. I've been there and unfortunately got that t-shirt.
Percentage wise there's more chance of sexual abuse happening within the family members rather than an outside source.

We go through rigorous safe guard training- 4 levels in fact to ensure our young people are kept safe and well during their time with us.

You have missed the point.

The issue is that the Guiding association was following Trans Girls are Girls and not safeguarding between biological sexes.

My Dc were in a fantastic mixed scouts group and went on many expeditions, and never ever did different sexes share a tent or dorm.

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 06/05/2022 17:40

MissCrowley · 29/04/2022 09:01

I don't see what the issue is. I'm really sorry but I don't. Scouts have been mixed sex for ages. Obviously asking to have female/ male spaces to change, sleep etc is within our rights.
I'm a girl guiding leader myself. You can't have one rule for Scouts and demand that they allow females in and not reciprocate. It's all or nothing.
Got my flame proofed vest on as I know full well my opinion will not be a popular one.
And before anyone starts throwing around the child sexual abuse card and saying "You have no idea" then please don't bother. I've been there and unfortunately got that t-shirt.
Percentage wise there's more chance of sexual abuse happening within the family members rather than an outside source.

We go through rigorous safe guard training- 4 levels in fact to ensure our young people are kept safe and well during their time with us.

I quite agree with you.

WifeMotherWorkRepeat · 06/05/2022 15:27

Congratulations Katie and thank you so much for pursuing this for the safety of our daughters. Sending you my huge thanks, respect and appreciation 💐

jeaux90 · 06/05/2022 14:46

@KatieAlcock totally agree. I pulled my DD out of the organisation after your case hit the news. Absolutely appalling.

She started at Scouts then (dropped during the pandemic) but I don't think the safeguarding policy is any better.

KatieAlcock · 06/05/2022 14:34

@jeaux90 unfortunately many areas don't have single sex secondary schools, making Guiding even more important.
I am heartened by organisations such as the Girls' Day School Trust coming out in favour of single sex status but as far as I can see there has been no clarification so far from Girlguiding.

OP posts:
jeaux90 · 06/05/2022 10:56

@Howeverbut

Why? Single sex schools are statistically proven to achieve better results for girls. And whilst sexual assault cases are high in mixed secondary schools (including 500 reported rapes over that specific persons of reporting) I will not have my DD in one.

Single sex spaces, services and sports are really important especially for female children.

Beamur · 06/05/2022 10:48

Feel free to comment, it's a public forum. But if you have a question, ask it, don't just take a position mocking people who do want to discuss issues that are important to them.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 06/05/2022 10:46

I think it was you that was 'outraged', wasn't it? what I want to know is why the poster felt the need to come here and post. Thats just looking for comments

Unless of course 'outraged' wasn't the word you were looking for?

And I still don't understand the "spontaneous app etc" with or without the comma. What app?

Beamur · 06/05/2022 10:46

If people weren't commenting you wouldn't have anything to laugh at...

siestaingsnake · 06/05/2022 10:34

Beamur · 05/05/2022 21:15

what I want to know is why the poster felt the need to come here and post. Thats just looking for comments

Is this aimed at me siestaingsnake or the OP?

Don't you approve of discussion on a public forum?

silly me I forgot I usually come on here to laugh at the outraged and commented an opinion

siestaingsnake · 06/05/2022 10:30

DockOTheBay · 05/05/2022 22:00

What is "spontanious app"?

oops missed a comma spontanious, app et

I'm as entitled to my opinion as everyone else.

DockOTheBay · 05/05/2022 22:00

siestaingsnake · 05/05/2022 20:46

I think we need Scouting to come towards Guiding in terms of some paperwork etc and Guiding needs to go towards Scouting in terms of being spontanious app etc. they can learn much from each other

What is "spontanious app"?

Beamur · 05/05/2022 21:15

what I want to know is why the poster felt the need to come here and post. Thats just looking for comments

Is this aimed at me siestaingsnake or the OP?

Don't you approve of discussion on a public forum?

siestaingsnake · 05/05/2022 20:46

I think we need Scouting to come towards Guiding in terms of some paperwork etc and Guiding needs to go towards Scouting in terms of being spontanious app etc. they can learn much from each other

siestaingsnake · 05/05/2022 20:43

beavers cubs scouts the kids can sleep mixed sex or same sex.

What I want to know is why the poster felt the need to come here and post. Thats just looking for comments.

Trans gender are just that I'm sure the poster hates Peer Educators too. If and when it crops up in a unit then it would be dealt with. Scouting becoming mixed sex also meant it was eligable for funding that single sex organisations cannot get. Guiding has always been supported by husbands brothers fathers etc and good leadership teams have always had the protocols in place

Beamur · 05/05/2022 20:36

Justkeeppedaling · 05/05/2022 19:08

Still doesn't call out that girls and boys and women and men will be sharing sleeping/dressing/washing spaces on residential events though, nor that if you have a rainbow or Brownie who has a toilet related incident (it happens), or even starts her period in a meeting or during a residential, it could be a man who helps her out.

There are sections on this which again, I think may have been updated - lots of advice around seeking venues with certain facilities and a lot about all members feeling safe etc..so less of the attitude of girls having just to put up and shut up, but still putting a very large amount of responsibility on Leaders to make this work.

Justkeeppedaling · 05/05/2022 19:14

OutlookStalking · 05/05/2022 19:09

It would be a lot simpler to have it single sex wouldn't it...

Wouldn't it just.

OutlookStalking · 05/05/2022 19:09

It would be a lot simpler to have it single sex wouldn't it...

Justkeeppedaling · 05/05/2022 19:08

Still doesn't call out that girls and boys and women and men will be sharing sleeping/dressing/washing spaces on residential events though, nor that if you have a rainbow or Brownie who has a toilet related incident (it happens), or even starts her period in a meeting or during a residential, it could be a man who helps her out.

Beamur · 05/05/2022 18:57

I think these might have been updated? Section about new trans members. Basically girl-only means sex and gender and GG state that unequivocally.
It seems much clearer, but I think some people are not going to be happy.
Basically girls and trans girls are welcome. NB girls are sort of welcome. NB boys are not. Trans boys, well this is what they say
we don’t expect there to be many trans boys interested in joining Girlguiding as we are explicitly a girl-only organisation but they can join. Or remain.

This is copied from their section about NB members.

As a girl-only charity we accept female members, under the protected characteristic of sex, and those whose gender is girl or woman, under the protected characteristic of gender reassignment.

A young person who is non-binary (someone who does not exclusively identify as girl or boy) and was recorded female at birth would be welcome to join. They are likely to have friends and peers in their unit and a clear desire to be part of our girl-only charity because they see the benefit and support that will come from a girl-only space for them. When registering on GO a young person is not asked about their gender identity.

Girlguiding is open to non-binary young members who were recorded female at birth. They will need to identify strongly enough with our girl-only space to feel comfortable and confident in wanting to benefit from, and contribute to, a movement of girls and young women who share and explore issues and experiences relating to growing up as a girl in today’s world.

Young people who are boys or are non-binary and were recorded as male at birth are not able to join Girlguiding because Girlguiding is a girl-only space.

For new non-binary young members, who were recorded female at birth, it's important to have an open and honest conversation with them and their parents or carers if suitable. Discuss with them what it means to be a Girlguiding member, what they want to get out of a guiding experience, and explore whether Girlguiding is the right choice for them.

I'd like to know what happens when a transgirl Guide decides that maybe she's not a girl after all, or is NB. As boys and NB boys are not permitted to be members, presumably their membership would be terminated?

ChristinaXYZ · 30/04/2022 17:16

@KatieAlcock do you think anything will change as a result of your brave stand? Now there is more light shone on the issue will GG make some adjustments especially for overnight stays, or be more open about what parents and their daughters can expect do you think?

BogRollBOGOF · 30/04/2022 00:10

This policy has come up around the time that my DSs have been around the same age as my unit. We always followed the policies on segregating them by sex and there were many pack holidays that I couldn't go on because we couldn't reasonably accommodate male leaders' children according to the policy.

It is galling and concerning that that policy which exists for good reason can be negated by the magic words "I am a girl". We've been transparent about leaders' children, and as they've got older it's become easier to manage to not mix them with my Guiding life.

Having sons, I've also become entangled in Scouting and at least it is transparent that it is an organisation where both sexes can participate frequently.

It's my friendships that keep me in Girl Guiding. I hate the wet, naval gazing, pescriptive new programme. The scouting programme is more practical. Girl Guiding has been reduced to "lets talk about going for a walk. How would we feel about it?" Scouts get on with actually going for a walk.

Roadblock6 · 29/04/2022 22:54

Well done Katie. I’m so tired of their miserable and sly HQ literally destroying Girlguiding as a whole. They are a continuous fuck up.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 29/04/2022 22:42

As a Scouting leader... I think most are like me, crossing their fingers and hoping the issue doesn't come up locally as whatever you do, it will be wrong.
Strangely, Scouts does allow for troops to be single sex under certain conditions (mainly parallel groups, so that things such as the Muslim groups can operate.

Also points above about the disparity where Scouts allows girls but Guides doesn't allow girls... these are International movements. In some countries, Guides can only exist because it is Single Sex.

Thank you Katie for standing up for openess and honesty. I've just renewed my Safeguarding training. The main theme through it was no secrets and communication. Lying completely goes against this.

KatieAlcock · 29/04/2022 22:26

It should also be on medical details.
It's not recorded by GG so you will have to trust parents to tell you.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread