Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think doctors, specifically GP's need to change their approach to patients

208 replies

GlasswareisOverated · 28/04/2022 22:05

We live in the technological age. We have access to information at our fingertips, that someone fifty years ago, hell even twenty years ago would not have been able to comprehend.
Am I being unreasonable to think that drs need to lose the 'we know best about everything medical' attitude.

Obviously I won't be performing brain surgery any time soon or stripping legs of vascular veins to be used in cardiac surgery but I can read a laboratory report and understand what it means and I can get the gist of most medical studies.

"Half of what you are taught in medical school will be wrong in 10 years’ time. The trouble is, none of your teachers know which half"
Former dean of Harvard medical school, Sydney Burwell.

OP posts:
Poppins2016 · 29/04/2022 00:07

A couple of years ago I saw a GP who openly said 'I can't quite decide what it might be, let me quickly Google something", flipped the computer screen round to show me what they were looking at and asked me what I thought about a couple of things before diagnosing me (correctly, with something quite unusual, confirmed by a consultant following referral). I found it really refreshing and actively sought that GP out in future as I'd far rather see someone who acknowledged their lack of expertise in a certain area versus someone who fobs people off due to not wanting to admit it.

MintJulia · 29/04/2022 00:02

Most members of the public cannot do this.

You only have to Look at how many people do crackpot diets each year to know that people need clear instructions from doctors.
Look at some of the absurd rumours about vaccines we have seen recently.

If you are capable of understanding more, then ask your gp pertinent, relevant questions and I'm sure he or she will respond.

jamimmi · 29/04/2022 00:01

I'd agree with PP above. I work in an out patient clinic with long term conditions. Some of my patients especially those with years of issues are experts, treating them is a discussion about what's next and their aims and goals. New patients I always say tell what you know and how much do you want to know. Some have great info and good understanding others would harm themselves based on their knowledge and Dr Google, this includes patients who are educated to PhD level in one case in a related field. YABU that reading lab results could be done by a Non Medic or AHP! Lab results are a tiny part of managing a health issue.

JetTail · 29/04/2022 00:01

Well, I passed by a doctor in A&E recently who was googling 'how to treat a wound sealed by glue plaster' or similar. I just noticed it as I had ordered some online! Lol. He was then talking to another colleague and said that it was a child and that it had become infected underneath the seal. So google is king sometimes.

I have noticed that GPs do not meet patients anymore. Everything is econsults. And then the 8am fastest finger first. And then the infuriating text which reads 'please make an appointment with the doctor to discuss your recent tests'. Well I would, if I could get through! And if you can text, why not just give an appointment while you're texting?

I have been a little let down by GPs recently. Let down is sort of an understatement actually. Apart from referring you, on the basis of a phone call, they don't seem to actually do anything anymore apart from to drop balls.

MrOllivander · 28/04/2022 23:57

I admit I question stuff but my diagnosis was missed for 7/8 years

It's infuriating conversations like
I have AIN
Ok but your bloods are fine so you aren't neutropenic
Yes, because I injected GCSF yesterday so my neutrophils are high today but I still have AIN that's why I am on GCSF
So why do you have it?
It's autoimmune
Why do you have that?

Well if I knew what caused autoimmune diseases I would be a rich woman Confused

Add to that the doctor that told me I must have misunderstood that I had that because it was a children's disease that they grow out of.. he ended up ringing my consultant who wasn't very happy

And being told my bloods are "normal". I need the actual results so I can alter medication and vitamin D. If my vitamin D is on the lower end of normal I'll up my dose a bit as I've been severely deficient before. Normal is no help!

pigsDOfly · 28/04/2022 23:47

But surely doctors do know best about medical matters.

I bloody hope so anyway, isn't that what they train for?

I'm an intelligent adult but I'm not medically trained. I want someone who is and who knows what they're doing when it comes to dealing with my medical conditions and who can advise me accordingly.

I've had dealing with many doctors in my fairly long life and yes, years ago a lot of doctors had an 'I know best' attitude but it's been many years since I've come across a doctor like that. In my experience things have greatly improved in that regard and everything is always fully discussed.

Yes, I suppose I could read a medical report but, as with the majority of people, most of it would mean very little to me. And anyway, what would be the point and how would it help my treatment. Even doctors need other doctors to treat them when they're unwell.

But alternatively, of course, I could always go on Google and make my own decision as to whether I need to go with option A, or chose option B and just cut my own leg off. If that's what Doctor Google advises.

Finallylostit · 28/04/2022 23:47

OP - I am a doctor, have 5 degrees and am an expert in my field.

When I got sick and I meanly badly sick, struggled on for months, denial was the best medicine, googled treatments etc - I lost my objectivity.

It took one of my colleagues to take me aside and say - stop look ignore google, go back to basics and marched me into the correct person who could sort me out. I had convinced my self via google etc that I could manage this - I could not, I damn near ended up on ITU.

It is not about the diagnosis - it is about all the holistic shit I needed around my illness.

Do not self diagnose do not self treat you are not objective

AlexaShutUp · 28/04/2022 23:46

Personally, I feel that my GP does treat me with respect, but equally, I respect the many years of study and experience that she has in her field, and I wouldn't for a moment suppose that I could match that - or even come close to that, frankly - from a bit of googling and a layperson's reading of a few lab reports.

Doctors are human, so they are not perfect. There will be things that they don't know, and there will be things that they get wrong. However, I think you're being incredibly dismissive of the expertise and experience that it has taken them years to acquire.

Lentil63 · 28/04/2022 23:45

Your arrogance is truly breathtaking!

Kite22 · 28/04/2022 23:44

Yup. YABU

MojoMoon · 28/04/2022 23:42

Have you met the public?

in 2015, the OECD conducted its Survey of Adult Skills, known as PIAAC (Programme for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies). This survey found that 16.4% (or 1 in 6) of adults in England, and 17.9% (or 1 in 5) adults in Northern Ireland, have literacy levels at or below Level 1, which is considered to be 'very poor literacy.

Not convinced encouraging the public to not listen to their GPs and that their own research is as valid as a medical degree is a great idea.

Half the public are stupider than average.

OuchitHurtstoomuch · 28/04/2022 23:39

Am I being unreasonable to think that drs need to lose the 'we know best about everything medical' attitude

I've never met a dr with that attitude.🤷🏻‍♀️. I'm sure they exist but I've not come across any. Drs training goes on forever. 5 years at uni, 2 years as F1 and F2 then years more training and lots more exams before they get to be consultants. Humans are complex systems and understanding how it all works together isn't something you can have a quick google about.
I can't believe people believe that drs only spend one day learning about the menopause. It sounds like some people haven't a clue about the training Drs go through.

SarahAndQuack · 28/04/2022 23:17

I agree with others saying that being able to access medical information is not the same as being able to interpret it, so technology doesn't make as much difference as all that.

I do think doctors sometimes get it very wrong, and the old-fashioned 'doctor's word is law and cannot be questioned' is a bad thing. We only need the Ockenden report to show that. But ... I really do think that's also about bad doctors. A good doctor will listen anyway. It's always been like that. The examples where a doctor or a group of medical practitioners haven't listened, are examples of the system not working as it should.

I don't think we ought to move towards patients getting more of a say, or more authority. While many people could read a lab report etc., many of those people would not know the limits of their knowledge - they would have a false sense of awareness. And medics might have a false sense of their awareness too. This can be extremely dangerous, as I know first hand. I won't tell the details as they're outing, but when my DD was born and was sick, the nurse had a quick conversation with my DP and established she worked in biomedical science, so presumed she would understand something that was obvious to her as a nurse. DP had no idea, neither did I, and as a result we were given responsibility to repeatedly do something that could have killed DD. We had no idea of the limits of our knowledge. We should not have been put in that position.

veronicagoldberg · 28/04/2022 23:03

I read so much that most doctors I see ask me if I'm a medic. This doesn't mean I can diagnose myself or recommend treatment. I just have above-average comprehension skills.

AndSoFinally · 28/04/2022 22:59

Yes, a patient may well know an awful lot about their one condition and how it affects them, and which treatments they'd like to try.

I'm not sure what point you're making though? As doctors, we need to know quite a lot about every condition, and an awful lot about whatever our specialty is. I'm not sure how you think it compares?

BlueIvy11 · 28/04/2022 22:51

Fairislefandango · 28/04/2022 22:38

YANBU. The surgeon who took out my gallbladder had a mug which said 'Don't confuse your Google search with my medical degree', which was funny and fair enough. However, I doubt my gp knew more about gallstones than I did after I'd done quite a lot of Googling. I wonder how much training the average gp has specifically on gallstones. Isn't it well-known they have one day on the menopause, which affects literally half the population?

People talk dismissively about Googling symptoms as though the only info available is crackpot websites and random people on forums with weird theories about their symptoms- rather than the NHS website and worldwide equivalents, plus umpteen reviewed medical articles. I've had gps just print out a page from the NHS website and hand it to me!

When I had my gallbladder removed, it took 8 months for them to diagnose. I went through screenings for hepatitis and all sorts. They never would look at gallstones because I'm less then 8st and slim. I kept asking them to just check as I looked up my symptoms. Then one day, I had a trainee and he just said, sounds like gallstones. He scanned me then next day and he was correct. The symptoms I had where bizarre. I couldn't drive as I was so tired and dizzy. Couldn't eat anything and couldn't even speak properly. My legs and arms where covered in bruises from my itchy skin and I was jaundice really badly. I lost so much weight and it's affected my liver too, so now I'm on medication possibly life long if it doesn't improve. Totally agree that there is not enough information on it.

Onlyforcake · 28/04/2022 22:41

I know what you mean. Common ailments are a lot easier to diagnose because of the Internet BUT so many human errors, miscommunication come up and so many skim to the rare outcomes, that wouldn't have before i can understandwhy doctors aee wary.

It can work against you too. I had gallstones, a nurse said I had that, it came up very frequently when I googled imy symptoms (16 years ago). But the doctor was adamant that the nurse was wrong. It was 9 months later before that doctor said he'd try an ultrasound to look at my gallbladder but not to hold out any hope.

Fairislefandango · 28/04/2022 22:38

YANBU. The surgeon who took out my gallbladder had a mug which said 'Don't confuse your Google search with my medical degree', which was funny and fair enough. However, I doubt my gp knew more about gallstones than I did after I'd done quite a lot of Googling. I wonder how much training the average gp has specifically on gallstones. Isn't it well-known they have one day on the menopause, which affects literally half the population?

People talk dismissively about Googling symptoms as though the only info available is crackpot websites and random people on forums with weird theories about their symptoms- rather than the NHS website and worldwide equivalents, plus umpteen reviewed medical articles. I've had gps just print out a page from the NHS website and hand it to me!

TheDogsMother · 28/04/2022 22:31

My GP is great, speaks to me like I am capable of understanding things and talks through all the options when it comes to prescribing. That said I was given some blood test results by email recently, had no clue what the readings actually meant and couldn't seem to access an explanation.

thing47 · 28/04/2022 22:28

dollymuchymuchness · 28/04/2022 22:22

The best doctors listen to their patients. These doctors know that a parent knows their own child better than anyone else. They also know that patients know about their own bodies. Anyone with a chronic illness soon becomes an “expert patient”. If your GP doesn’t listen, then it’s prudent to change doctors.

I agree with @dollymuchymuchness . In fact, I'd go one step further and suggest that patients with a long-term chronic illness almost certainly know as much as most GPs about their condition in terms of how it affects them. Maybe not the exact science, but definitely what does and does not work for them.

Specialist consultants might well be able to offer greater insights, and will know more about current thinking and up-to-date research in the field, but common-or-garden GPs? Nah.

Discovereads · 28/04/2022 22:28

PlasticineMeg · 28/04/2022 22:20

Im on the fence.

I think it must be so annoying to be a GP and have patients come in clutching pages from Google thinking they can diagnose themselves.

but in particular women are never listened to in the way they should be, there’s a huge gap in womens healthcare and it needs to stop

Well 56% of U.K. GPs ARE women, so really not seeing how there could be a huge gap in womens healthcare by GPs.

Thatswhyimacat · 28/04/2022 22:23

I have a medical background and I find my GP is very respectful of this and never speaks to me like I wouldn't understand something. That said, she's the GP and while she will listen to what I think, I'm not always right nor do I know the nitty gritty of NHS related things and how medicine works 'in practice' as opposed to theory.

dollymuchymuchness · 28/04/2022 22:22

The best doctors listen to their patients. These doctors know that a parent knows their own child better than anyone else. They also know that patients know about their own bodies. Anyone with a chronic illness soon becomes an “expert patient”. If your GP doesn’t listen, then it’s prudent to change doctors.

Theredjellybean · 28/04/2022 22:21

Marvellous the OP has solved the workforce crisis for the NHS... We will just leave a load of ipads in the waiting room and the patients can get on with it themselves.. Meanwhile us pesky up ourselves doctors can go and have a cup of tea

catsonahottinroof · 28/04/2022 22:21

I think GPs do this more now though, if you've done research they seem to listen and do what you want eg prescribe specific medications, refer for tests. The tricky thing nowadays is getting an appointment in the first place. Also I've requested copies of my blood test results, not sure why patients don't automatically get a copy (I suppose it could lead to a lot of time wasting with queries).