Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think doctors, specifically GP's need to change their approach to patients

208 replies

GlasswareisOverated · 28/04/2022 22:05

We live in the technological age. We have access to information at our fingertips, that someone fifty years ago, hell even twenty years ago would not have been able to comprehend.
Am I being unreasonable to think that drs need to lose the 'we know best about everything medical' attitude.

Obviously I won't be performing brain surgery any time soon or stripping legs of vascular veins to be used in cardiac surgery but I can read a laboratory report and understand what it means and I can get the gist of most medical studies.

"Half of what you are taught in medical school will be wrong in 10 years’ time. The trouble is, none of your teachers know which half"
Former dean of Harvard medical school, Sydney Burwell.

OP posts:
Peoniesandpeaches · 29/04/2022 02:40

I’ve generally had good experience with doctors and felt respected but going through IVF I’ve never encountered more patronizing and arrogant doctors. While I know that nobody is ever going to care about your treatment outcome as much as you for the money I’m paying I’d hope they could at least fake some empathy instead of their ‘computer says no attitude.’

romdowa · 29/04/2022 02:40

I think the inability of drs in general to listen to patients is a huge issue. It's very evident in patients with chronic illnesses. I've chronic and rare illnesses , most of which drs have never heard of yet they known best 🙄🙄 my father is a diabetic though , one of the most common chronic illnesses and the amount of drs which haven't a clue is staggering , most of their info is out dated and they become highly insulted when told they are wrong. My father has an brain injury and he's received some dangerous advice over the years from clueless drs but I've now instructed him to only follow the advice of his diabetic specialist.

knitnerd90 · 29/04/2022 02:36

A bit of both really. On the one hand you've got patients who either are ignorant or have the wrong end of the stick because they've been reading garbage websites. On the other there's quite a lot of arrogant doctors who ignore veery basic things their patients are saying and resort to "Well I'm the doctor!" if you point it out. Especially if you are from many ethnic minorities, a woman, disabled, and/or fat--doctors' biases are well demonstrated in research.

NaturalScone · 29/04/2022 02:31

u sound like u been to da skool of farrage.

Ponderingwindow · 29/04/2022 02:02

I have encountered some very stubborn doctors, but I have found that most will work with you cooperatively once they understand that you really understand the subject matter. To be clear, that doesn’t mean spending time on webmd. That means reading and understanding original research and truly understanding the science of your own conditions.

Libertybear80 · 29/04/2022 02:00

Well that's fine until you get it wrong mrs know it all!

Incapacitated · 29/04/2022 01:43

some people believe that because they’ve read some articles online they can argue against a virologist or infectious disease consultant.

To be fair there's a huge difference between arguing with a consultant who has specialised for many years, and a GP who knows a little about a lot. A number of consultants I've spoken to are deeply disillusioned with GPs because patients arrive too late with misinformation imparted by GPs which then has to be corrected.

My child has asthma. In despair I asked a medic friend who specialises for advice, explaining what the GP had advised. She advised a treatment path that has been effective and added 'GPs don't understand childhood asthma'. Her advice was the opposite of what I'd heard from the GP.

I went to the doctor with reduced fetal movements. No referral to maternity unit. No listening to baby's heart. He prodded my stomach while out of the blue asking if my father in law was who he thought he was. Then sent me home. I called the maternity unit myself who said they were "very surprised" in a weary, unsurprised manner.

Let's draw a veil over how most of them year endometriosis and the length of time it takes to be referred for treatment.

One wonders what they are good at. Weighing everyone? Inserting the mirena coil? They've got to be on commission for those because they are keen.

GlasswareisOverated · 29/04/2022 01:31

My experiences on a personal level have led me to conclude it's not sometimes wrong, it's often wrong, will elaborate in the morning, as Mumsnet developed an issue with something during the typing of the post and I do not have the energy to retype currently.

OP posts:
GlasswareisOverated · 29/04/2022 01:29

Can't be dealing with retyping right now and the screenshots are not clear. Will log onto laptop and retype using the screenshots in the morning.

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 29/04/2022 01:28

YABU. Yes, doctors can be very arrogant. They’re sometimes wrong. Yes, we can get a lot of information from the internet. But there’s also an awful lot of misinformation and downright rubbish too. A lot of people aren’t able to interpret some of the info out there correctly either.
Covid has been a great example of this. The amount of complete baloney that a lot of people have believed is astonishing. And some people believe that because they’ve read some articles online they can argue against a virologist or infectious disease consultant.

GlasswareisOverated · 29/04/2022 01:27

Typed a really long post, have managed to screen shot it so I will be adding the hugely long post as screenshots.

To think doctors, specifically GP's need to change their approach to patients
To think doctors, specifically GP's need to change their approach to patients
To think doctors, specifically GP's need to change their approach to patients
OP posts:
Incapacitated · 29/04/2022 01:27

Yes I agree. Many patients have come across research that a gp wouldn't have time to read in much depth as their scope is so wide. They should start taking that on board.

I had an acute pulmonary response to a specific antibiotic recently. It's vital that I never have it again. My GP has written on my notes that I'm 'anxious' about taking it. Why? Because they haven't heard of the pulmonary response (easily found in two minutes) and I didn't have swelling.

Another gp told my friend she didn't need contraception because it was impossible for her to get pregnant while she was breast feeding. She had an unexpected extra child and spent a year hospitalised because she couldn't cope with another child so soon after the first. The GP should have listened when she ventured to say doubtfully that she didn't think the advice was right.

I developed serotonin syndrome recently and needed to change meds. A. GP who looked about 17 didn't take her eyes off the screen and offered an alternative. I'd read that the alternative would make my symptoms worse (later confirmed by a consultant). She shrugged her shoulders and said she didn't know anything about serotonin syndrome and did I want the prescription.

Another friend went to the GP about her awful PMT. He said he'd never heard of it and googled it as she waited. Then he offered her diazapam. She said she didn't think those drugs should be handed out for an ongoing condition. She knew that. He didn't.

I went to a GP with a serious eye infection (was hospitalised two days later and it should have been caught earlier as there were many ulcers by that time). The GP was actually wearing slippers. She handed me something that was almost identical to what I had been using.

None of these excuses for doctors will ever receive feedback on how awful they are.

I'm sure there are many lovely GPs but I'm personally tired of pretending the rest are actually doing something. The least they could do is accept the patient might know something, if they're going to be so pathetic.

Interestingly the service is completely different when I access medical care on the NHS via family members who are medics. I think doctors can be useless if they want to be because they can enjoy NHS Premium if they get ill. And they'd probably bother to read the reference books if it came to that.

PollyDarton2 · 29/04/2022 00:58

I’ve watched all 18 seasons of Greys Anatomy so I’m 99% sure I could actually be a doctor if I wanted to be.

I think my thoughts on this topic are different for diagnosis than they are for treatment. Where treatment is concerned, anyone can read the NICE guidelines. For diagnosis, patients are always going to be closer to their symptoms but doctors should (in theory!) be better at objectively interpreting them.

JetTail · 29/04/2022 00:44

Mainly I feel like screaming - read my file!!!

I'm pretty sure that would not help me though.

Norush4 · 29/04/2022 00:42

@dhaka22 skin conditions are quite hard to identify if you look closely many look similar. On a dark skin I think it's even harder sorry but it's hard enough getting a decent emollient prescribed from the GP for a dark skin tone your right about that part. Although you could asked to be referred to a dermatologist.

Norush4 · 29/04/2022 00:38

veronicagoldberg · 28/04/2022 23:03

I read so much that most doctors I see ask me if I'm a medic. This doesn't mean I can diagnose myself or recommend treatment. I just have above-average comprehension skills.

I don't think it's about reading tbh. Even nurses rely upon the doctors in the hospitals and the GP surgeries. I do not understand what OP is asking from her post.

How technical do you want your GP to get because there's a lotnof people that may not understand I don't think it matters about the fancy terms as long as my GP was kind and caring Inwould be happy tbh.

dhaka22 · 29/04/2022 00:35

Yanbu but I also understand why people disagree as the reality is the average person probably can’t interpret medical literature or laboratory reports well.

I’m autistic and one of my niche interests is obsessively keeping up to date with medical literature for my skin condition and similar skin conditions. (I don’t tell other people as I know it sounds like a ’sad’ interest haha).

I’ve been asked a few times during consulations with private dermatologists whether I have a medical background.

My experience with NHS gps hasn’t always been great. Once a qualified NHS GP told me to ‘drink more water’ and ‘eat more fruit’ for my severe discoid eczema. 🙃 I wasn’t even there for treatment/advice, I had just gone for insurance referral letter so I could see a derm.
Most GP’s aren’t well informed on skin issues even ‘common’ inflammatory skin conditions - I don’t expect them to be specialists but I was disappointed the doctor was so ignorant, and gave such patronising advice.

Quite a few times when I’ve suspected I had something, been misdiagnosed, only to later finally get the diagnosis of what I originally suspected. I’m a woman of colour so that probably doesn’t help. 🤷‍♀️

JetTail · 29/04/2022 00:34

OuchitHurtstoomuch · 29/04/2022 00:30

Anyone who watches any of the dozens of 999 medical fly-on-the-wall type shows knows what the term tachy means. You hear it all the time 😅😅.

I'll keep that in mind next time I'm accused of being some undercover medic lol

Namenic · 29/04/2022 00:32

No 1 person is going to get it right all the time.

Google can be helpful, but it can lead down a rabbit hole - over-investigation can be actively harmful (eg unnecessary radiation exposure) as well as wasting resources.

JetTail · 29/04/2022 00:32

It's like, back in the day, stress occupied our lives too! Whether it was from war, or infidelity, or multiple children, or poverty, or whatever the fuck. These things have always existed! Back even to the day when man brought food to cave. What has changed, is our exercise level and our diet. Pretty sure that imbibing is from 2000 years ago at least and hell knows when smoking arrived. But nothing has massively changed apart from our activity levels. Physically. And our diets in the West to accommodate ever more demanding pressures on our time. We don't have community. We don't have a lot of support sometimes. Isolation, despite being surrounded by people is also common. We can't just talk about our niggly knee anymore. Who would listen? So it all builds. And medicine hasn't caught up.

OuchitHurtstoomuch · 29/04/2022 00:30

JetTail · 29/04/2022 00:22

Incidentally, I had a GP ask me in a rather accusatory tone recently whether I had a medical background! I said that I hadn't. He said it's just that not many patients are familiar or use the term tachy. I'm like, well, honey, unfortunately, overhearing it and asking 'what does that mean?' basically means that it's now a term I'm becoming all too familiar with. I've been 'tachy' all too often.

Anyone who watches any of the dozens of 999 medical fly-on-the-wall type shows knows what the term tachy means. You hear it all the time 😅😅.

JetTail · 29/04/2022 00:25

Tachy is the short version of tachycardic which medical professionals use to refer to a resting pulse over 100 bpm.

JetTail · 29/04/2022 00:22

Incidentally, I had a GP ask me in a rather accusatory tone recently whether I had a medical background! I said that I hadn't. He said it's just that not many patients are familiar or use the term tachy. I'm like, well, honey, unfortunately, overhearing it and asking 'what does that mean?' basically means that it's now a term I'm becoming all too familiar with. I've been 'tachy' all too often.

Poppins2016 · 29/04/2022 00:19

Discovereads · 28/04/2022 22:28

Well 56% of U.K. GPs ARE women, so really not seeing how there could be a huge gap in womens healthcare by GPs.

I've had a few female GPs dismiss my symptoms as 'anxiety' (a common theme in women's healthcare) when I've actually gone on to be diagnosed with something physically wrong with me after persisting for a diagnosis and treatment.

JetTail · 29/04/2022 00:13

And an interesting point actually about holistic! There is no such thing in Western medicine. Various bits of me are under various specialities yet nobody but myself has thought to question why I was getting a lot of complaints which were inflammation in nature and also autoimmune in nature. And now that I know that, while I will wait for 'modern' medicine to treat my various respective bits lol, I'm going old-school. Ayurvedic and Chinese. And crackpots! I'm that fucking desperate. Necessity is the mother of invention. Western medicine hasn't evolved at the pace of dietary and lifestyle changes in the past 100 years. It's like we are so fucking past any textbook theory now that it's the old reliables that they trot out. Stress, diet, smoking, alcohol. Without having a clue, or even an iota of a suggestion of a clue as to what the hell to do!