Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think doctors, specifically GP's need to change their approach to patients

208 replies

GlasswareisOverated · 28/04/2022 22:05

We live in the technological age. We have access to information at our fingertips, that someone fifty years ago, hell even twenty years ago would not have been able to comprehend.
Am I being unreasonable to think that drs need to lose the 'we know best about everything medical' attitude.

Obviously I won't be performing brain surgery any time soon or stripping legs of vascular veins to be used in cardiac surgery but I can read a laboratory report and understand what it means and I can get the gist of most medical studies.

"Half of what you are taught in medical school will be wrong in 10 years’ time. The trouble is, none of your teachers know which half"
Former dean of Harvard medical school, Sydney Burwell.

OP posts:
Zonder · 29/04/2022 07:37

Thank goodness for Google, Holby and Grey's anatomy.

To think doctors, specifically GP's need to change their approach to patients
AProperStinging · 29/04/2022 07:34

thewhatsit · 29/04/2022 07:12

No of course not, but in my case I always - over many years - have a high-ish white blood cell count. I don’t pretend to know what that could be a sign of and have never ever suggested it to a doctor. BUT it is helpful when I can provide printed sheets of old blood work going back many years (that I’ve had privately) and they can see that my readings are always a little high. They can do with that information as they wish and I’ve never argued that they should or should not be concerned (because again, I don’t really know what the concern is and what further tests would be) but it’s nice to be involved in the discussion. No NHS midwife or doctor has ever actually let me know what my number is (whereas I could tell you what the number has been over about 5 private blood tests) or given me the sheet to keep.
Every time I’ve shown them old readings the doctor has decided it’s not an issue but these are now really old documents and should this come up again in another pregnancy (hypothetically were I to have another it WOULD come up because it’s always come up and resulted in a referral to a consultant) it would feel better to know that I can be provided with my own medical data, even if as a lay person I can’t understand it fully.

Are you not in England? All of my blood test results are on the NHS app. Going back years

CorsicaDreaming · 29/04/2022 07:21

@PollyDarton2

"I’ve watched all 18 seasons of Greys Anatomy so I’m 99% sure I could actually be a doctor if I wanted to be. "

LOL 😆

StScholastica · 29/04/2022 07:15

If the govt have their way, I'm sure they will use artificial intelligence programmes to replace GPs as a cheaper model of healthcare.
No arrogance with computers, but unfortunately, no compassion, no empathy or understanding either.

thewhatsit · 29/04/2022 07:12

HistoricMoment · 29/04/2022 06:51

Interpreting a lab report really isn't as easy as googling "high potassium". This is why as a GP, you will get questions like "OMG my potassium is high I've got kidney failure!!" when actually the cause is something else entirely. There's a reason medical training takes so long.

No of course not, but in my case I always - over many years - have a high-ish white blood cell count. I don’t pretend to know what that could be a sign of and have never ever suggested it to a doctor. BUT it is helpful when I can provide printed sheets of old blood work going back many years (that I’ve had privately) and they can see that my readings are always a little high. They can do with that information as they wish and I’ve never argued that they should or should not be concerned (because again, I don’t really know what the concern is and what further tests would be) but it’s nice to be involved in the discussion. No NHS midwife or doctor has ever actually let me know what my number is (whereas I could tell you what the number has been over about 5 private blood tests) or given me the sheet to keep.
Every time I’ve shown them old readings the doctor has decided it’s not an issue but these are now really old documents and should this come up again in another pregnancy (hypothetically were I to have another it WOULD come up because it’s always come up and resulted in a referral to a consultant) it would feel better to know that I can be provided with my own medical data, even if as a lay person I can’t understand it fully.

Luculentus · 29/04/2022 07:04

Lockheart · 28/04/2022 22:10

Have you met the average member of the public?

Have you seen the inane and obvious questions which get posted on this forum alone?

"What's the weather like in X?"

"My leg is falling off, should I see a doctor?"

"I have a burn, should I put toothpaste on it?"

Do you think these people are capable of medical diagnostics?

The thing is, though, that doctors can't assume all their patients are within that category - just as all doctors aren't the same either. They don't necessarily have to assume everyone is capable of medical diagnostics, but they shouldn't assume they're stupid, either.

Generally speaking my experience of GPs in our local surgery has been good, but on a recent phone appointment with a hospital doctor I found she was really patronising: she asked if I knew anything about the condition I had, I said I had googled it, she instantly jumped into docsplaining to me that I couldn't trust everything I read on the internet. I struggled to get a word in edgeways to say that what I had read was on the NHS website so I hoped it was pretty reliable. She then went on to say that my results had all been absolutely normal and everything was fine, till I queried something that had been in the copy letter I received - whereupon she actually looked at the notes and went gently into panic mode and did a total reverse. I ended up thinking it was lucky for both her and me that at least one of us had their brain in gear.

HistoricMoment · 29/04/2022 06:51

Interpreting a lab report really isn't as easy as googling "high potassium". This is why as a GP, you will get questions like "OMG my potassium is high I've got kidney failure!!" when actually the cause is something else entirely. There's a reason medical training takes so long.

thewhatsit · 29/04/2022 06:50

Oh I’ve got one that Google is really helpful with actually but as long as you end up on the right sites (which perhaps is always the challenge?!). Which drugs you can take while breastfeeding.
Most drugs aren’t tested on breastfeeding mothers so won’t say they can be taken even though they can. There are resources online which collate all the information out there and give fact sheets on each drug and how compatible or not it is with breastfeeding - these are extremely helpful and have helped many mothers successfully challenge decisions not to put them on antidepressants or painkillers.
There is a pharmacist who collated all the U.K. information out there on drugs and breastfeeding and actually just got an MBE for her services because she has helped so many women keep breastfeeding when their GP has said no. It’s not an NHS service but you’ve always been able to contact her online free of charge.

NewGardenProject · 29/04/2022 06:49

I get what you mean OP, it’s annoying to feel patronised like having basic scientific language like urine explained to you 🙄

FrankLeeSpeaking · 29/04/2022 06:49

However, I doubt my gp knew more about gallstones than I did after I'd done quite a lot of Googling

Ah yes. Those wasted years in medical school learning advanced anatomy, physiology, treatment, contraindications, colleague and self experience in a clinical setting etc of a very common condition could have been saved if they just did "quite a lot of googling" instead.

FruityPolos · 29/04/2022 06:47

Librarian here.

Do you think the majority of the population can tell the difference between a trustworthy website with valid medical information and peer reviewed journal articles vs a opinion based website edited by someone with no medical knowledge at all? Most first year degree students struggle with this and often site Wikipedia as a valid source of information.

olympicsrock · 29/04/2022 06:42

@Sirzy has it right. A patient particularly with a chronic condition is the expert in them. GPs / doctors are the expert in medicine. You work together as a team to explore the right treatment for the individual patient.

There is more to medicine than just reading an article/ NICE guidelines. You study how to interpret the evidence , take nothing on face value.
conditions and medications interact. Part of medicine is knowing your limits and asking for specialist advice . Doctors ask each other for expert advice all the time as no one knows everything- part of medicine is about accessing and communicating with the right expert.

You cannot however replace 20 - 30 years of professional experience with a bit of Googling!

FrankLeeSpeaking · 29/04/2022 06:40

YABU.
There is a difference between reading results and interpreting them in a clinical context.

Some patients with complex issues do know an awful lot about their condition and treatments etc. Maybe more so than a doctor who hasn't come across that particular issue before. But that doesn't mean they know as much about medicine as a doctor does, in general.

thewhatsit · 29/04/2022 06:38

I think I know what you mean a bit.

I’ve had lots of routine blood tests done privately and the full results have always been sent to me in a detailed report. I liked getting it. When something would come up that a doctor questioned I / we could refer to previous blood work and see if it was within the normal range for me.

When I was pregnant and the NHS did blood work I was always surprised that you don’t get to see the results. I even remember a midwife saying something on my blood work was a bit high so they’d arrange a consultant to check it out.. I asked “is it X? Because my X score is always on the high end of average?” But I wasn’t allowed to know (my own medical data?) and I saw a consultant, at huge expense to the NHS presumably, just for them to say “your X is on the high end of normal” and me to say “yes I thought as much. Here are 5 different blood test reports I’ve had privately that I’ve printed out for you. You can see that a high reading seems to be my normal”. They review my documents, say yes all seems to be fine .. no concerns and I go. I still don’t actually find out the score that was concerning them though. Exact same thing happens in second pregnancy. Owning my own medical data is important to me.

After my NHS scans I have always felt the need to book private ones too. Not because the NHS didn’t do anything right because they’d mention things like “Hm that’s a bit odd, let me check with a colleague..” - they’d consult, decided whatever was fine and that would be that. I wasn’t allowed to know the details. So then at a private scan the consultant (a lot are consultant performed) actually explains to you what they are seeing - what it would mean in a worst case but why they are happy. At my second birth something happened which had been mentioned at my scans could happen - I would only have known that because it had been explained to me privately.

LaMarschallin · 29/04/2022 06:36

JetTail

Incidentally, I had a GP ask me in a rather accusatory tone recently whether I had a medical background! I said that I hadn't. He said it's just that not many patients are familiar or use the term tachy. I'm like, well, honey, unfortunately, overhearing it and asking 'what does that mean?' basically means that it's now a term I'm becoming all too familiar with. I've been 'tachy' all too often.

You may have been mistaking an incredulous tone for an accusatory one.

Doctors are very used to patients dropping in medical terms (often, as a PP said, learned from television programmes).
You only have to read MN to see things like "projectile vomiting" used frequently and incorrectly.

You obviously do know what "tachy" means and I'm sorry that it's been a frequent enough occurrence for you to have learned that.
However, it's usually best not to throw medical terms around because the lay person's understanding and the doctor's understanding of the term may be quite different, whereas everyone can understand "I felt my heart racing" or similar.

SquirrelG · 29/04/2022 06:27

Wow, you have rather a high opinion of yourself OP. I have been interested in medical things since I was a child, but I don't for one moment think I know more than any GP. Surely you don't think doctors walk out the door from medical school and never study anything again?

CorsicaDreaming · 29/04/2022 06:20

AndSoFinally · 28/04/2022 22:59

Yes, a patient may well know an awful lot about their one condition and how it affects them, and which treatments they'd like to try.

I'm not sure what point you're making though? As doctors, we need to know quite a lot about every condition, and an awful lot about whatever our specialty is. I'm not sure how you think it compares?

Isn't the point the OP is making just that - that because a patient is solely interested in their own symptoms and condition but a doctor (esp a gp) needs to know about a complete range of illnesses that may affect any of their hugely diverse patients, some people with good research skills may end up being more of an expert on their own body and conditions that they live with everyday and have researched comprehensively / discussed with other sufferers.

I agree it has clear dangers and limitations but I can also see the logic of it.

cookiemonster2468 · 29/04/2022 06:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

To be honest though, this actually is the case quite often, so you can see why it happens.

Doctors have a difficult balance to strike, because whilst they obviously need to treat those who need it, they shouldn't be wasting time and resources on people who can manage and improve their conditions with small lifestyle changes.

LaMarschallin · 29/04/2022 06:15

Isn't it well-known they have one day on the menopause, which affects literally half the population?

As in: "Today, class, we're covering the menopause"?
No, that's not how it works.

There are years of learning subjects that interconnect.
So, during anatomy the structure of female reproductive organs will be studied in detail; during endocrinology, relevant hormones will learnt about; pharmacology deals in detail with drugs etc.

It's not like you'll rock up with, eg, gallstones and the GP will say, "Bugger! I was away the afternoon we did that".

cookiemonster2468 · 29/04/2022 06:14

Fairislefandango · 28/04/2022 22:38

YANBU. The surgeon who took out my gallbladder had a mug which said 'Don't confuse your Google search with my medical degree', which was funny and fair enough. However, I doubt my gp knew more about gallstones than I did after I'd done quite a lot of Googling. I wonder how much training the average gp has specifically on gallstones. Isn't it well-known they have one day on the menopause, which affects literally half the population?

People talk dismissively about Googling symptoms as though the only info available is crackpot websites and random people on forums with weird theories about their symptoms- rather than the NHS website and worldwide equivalents, plus umpteen reviewed medical articles. I've had gps just print out a page from the NHS website and hand it to me!

I think the issue is that the average member of the public doesn't necessarily know which information is correct when they go to Google. You don't have the filter provided by years of medical study.

CorsicaDreaming · 29/04/2022 06:11

That sounds really tough @BlueIvy11
I hope you do make a full recovery. It must be very frustrating you weren't listened to sooner.

TroysMammy · 29/04/2022 06:07

I've been a GP Receptionist for 12 years so I am of course qualified in all things medical. I can spell diarrhoea, tonsillitis, gall stones and prostate which is more than my colleagues can.

There is no way I can read a medical report confidently even though there may be some words that I do understand and I would never interpret blood results for myself or anyone else. I really don't know why people come on Mumsnet to ask randoms about their blood results either.

FixTheBone · 29/04/2022 06:01

In my experience, a lot of 'expert' patients miss the point entirely. I've had people come into my clinic with a couple of printouts from pubmed demanding which type of suture they want for their surgery, looking very confused, or even angry when the conversation goes down the line of whether an operation is actually indicated or not.

Philisophigal · 29/04/2022 05:20

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

Sirzy · 29/04/2022 02:51

Ds is medically complex, so I am the expert in him and the doctors and others in his team are the experts in the individual conditions. We work together to come up with the best plan for him.

I phoned the GP yesterday, I had a plan of action in mind before, she explained why one part was probably not quite right and we agreed what to try.

its about teamwork and respecting others areas of expertise.