Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think doctors, specifically GP's need to change their approach to patients

208 replies

GlasswareisOverated · 28/04/2022 22:05

We live in the technological age. We have access to information at our fingertips, that someone fifty years ago, hell even twenty years ago would not have been able to comprehend.
Am I being unreasonable to think that drs need to lose the 'we know best about everything medical' attitude.

Obviously I won't be performing brain surgery any time soon or stripping legs of vascular veins to be used in cardiac surgery but I can read a laboratory report and understand what it means and I can get the gist of most medical studies.

"Half of what you are taught in medical school will be wrong in 10 years’ time. The trouble is, none of your teachers know which half"
Former dean of Harvard medical school, Sydney Burwell.

OP posts:
fUNNYfACE36 · 29/04/2022 10:38

I often think must be so hard to be a GP constantly making high stakes decisions based on the incomplete and unreliable data given by your patients. I mean, sure you can run tests, but that takes time, which in some cases may be too late

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 29/04/2022 10:26

I have very little faith in GPs following some very bad experiences, including being patronised and fobbed off when politely pointing out that my late husband was showing obvious neurological symptoms after the GP diagnosed him with a virus when in fact he was developing a spinal cord compression and subsequently died from a tumour on his spine.

I have also found them very lacking when it comes to palliative care - through a professional capacity.

I can't remember the last time I was properly diagnosed by a doctor and I usually manage to identify and manage my own health problems.

Some of them are extraordinarily dim and lacking in imagination as well. One told me my recent course of metronidazole for a dental problem couldn't have led to an improvement in my gallbladder problem - which I had observed to be the case - whereas the next GP I saw explained that antibiotics are often prescribed to help gallbladder inflammation and that the metronidazole will certainly have helped.

Dealing with health problems should always be a collaborative partnership between a doctor and patient - providing the patient is able to do that - and old fashioned patronising attitudes of 'doctor knows best' need binning. Arrogance is the sign of a very poor practitioner who probably has a string of misdiagnosed, unhappy and sometimes dead patients behind them.

Brainwave89 · 29/04/2022 09:20

My son is a doctor and I discussed your message with him. Whilst the profession is keen to use technology to its maximum (online consultations where appropriate, use of telephone consultations etc) It takes a massive amount of training to be a doctor and it would be extremely unwise to rely on anything you read online. Please be very careful.

Iwonder08 · 29/04/2022 09:19

GP experience is a complete gamble. Sometimes they are reasonable, sometimes not. I met about 15 in different surgeries. Also they all have a dramatic personality transplant if you mention a private medical insurance or they work privately. I totally appreciate lack of resources, but I would expect similar degree of empathy either private or NHS. I also believe they are generally more Dismissive towards women vs men. Both male and female GPS.

Nocaloriesinchocolate · 29/04/2022 09:12

Actually my GP is the other way round! Because both DH and I spent many professional years reading masses of medical reports, letters, notes etc, he thinks we know more about medicine than actually we do!!

On another note I’ll never forget the wonderful GP I had when DS was a toddler. I took him to the surgery once and said to the GP that I was worried about him. The only symptom was that he was quiet which was exceedingly unusual for DS (still is! He can, in my grandmother’s phrase, talk the hind leg off a donkey). The GP took that very seriously and dx him with something or other (nothing major) - I can’t remember what now

CorsicaDreaming · 29/04/2022 08:54

Ariela · 29/04/2022 08:26

@CorsicaDreaming I'm actually just going to go stuff a note through their door on the way to work, sadly no time to spend an hour+ on the phone today.
He won't phone 111 because he's 'not that bad' (but would ring 999 if it was - I don't think he thinks 111 is different from 999)

That is so difficult isn't it, re his view of 111

It is an excellent service and well worth calling.

CorsicaDreaming · 29/04/2022 08:52

@ElizabethBennetismybestfriend - that is terrible, do hope you start recovering soon 💐

CorsicaDreaming · 29/04/2022 08:51

@Discovereads
@SkoolShoes

"Well 56% of U.K. GPs ARE women, so really not seeing how there could be a huge gap in womens healthcare by GPs."

I think the other problem with this is you can't assume that just because somebody is a woman they are going to make an excellent GP with complete empathy and understanding for women's health issues.

A female GP who has just qualified is unlikely to herself have ever been pregnant or have gone through the menopause and so it doesn't necessarily mean just because they're a woman they are going to have a full grasp of all key issues that affect women any more than a male GP. And a male GP with 20 years experience who is empathetic about infertility issues, for example, may be significantly better informed and more experienced than the newly qualified female GP.

Although having said that my GP is female and has a particular interest in women's health issues and is absolutely excellent.

Zilla1 · 29/04/2022 08:48

Will no one think of the non-vascular veins?

CorsicaDreaming · 29/04/2022 08:46

That is really terrible, @Ariela - could your father actually go to the gp surgery and explain and ask to book an appointment (for a future time) directly? Or phone 111 and get access via that service?

That's terrible if no one has got back to him all week and it's now a BH weekend coming up.

felulageller · 29/04/2022 08:43

We need to get away from GPs as gatekeepers of the NHS.

Children should have paediatricians.

Women should have gynecologists.

Nurses and pharmacists should be able to issue more drugs and sick lines without a GPs signature.

One size fits all just doesn't work anymore.

Ariela · 29/04/2022 08:26

@CorsicaDreaming I'm actually just going to go stuff a note through their door on the way to work, sadly no time to spend an hour+ on the phone today.
He won't phone 111 because he's 'not that bad' (but would ring 999 if it was - I don't think he thinks 111 is different from 999)

LaMarschallin · 29/04/2022 08:25

Obviously I won't be performing brain surgery any time soon or stripping legs of vascular veins to be used in cardiac surgery

I wonder if the OP was thinking of "varicose veins"?

Be a brilliant BOGOF scheme if you could remove varicose veins and use them up in heart surgery. Less waste too.

CorsicaDreaming · 29/04/2022 08:20

That is really terrible, @Ariela - could your father actually go to the gp surgery and explain and ask to book an appointment (for a future time) directly? Or phone 111 and get access via that service?

That's terrible if no one has got back to him all week and it's now a BH weekend coming up.

PintOfBovril · 29/04/2022 08:18

Just came to say, all veins are vascular.

CorsicaDreaming · 29/04/2022 08:06

@Lockheart - your examples made me laugh.

Ironically my mother is a (retired) doctor, and it really did feel like your leg had to be falling off before she'd accept I had something wrong...

a rather spectacularly broken leg that she initially just gave a couple of paracetamol for comes to mind (and she admitted years later she felt a bit guilty that when we did finally go to the hospital, I was immediately put in a wheelchair and whisked off).

I think doctor's children can get it the toughest...

ElizabethBennetismybestfriend · 29/04/2022 08:06

I didn’t need Google. I turned up at my GP surgery twice with an infection that I had had before. Ignored both times. On my second visit I was told it couldn’t be a strep B infection and it wasn’t worth looking at a sore throat as it would go away on its own. Three weeks later I am in critical care trying not to die from sepsis caused by an untreated strep b throat infection. Not trying to be an expert but would wish the GP I saw actually listened, sometimes we do know what is wrong.

SkoolShoes · 29/04/2022 08:04

Discovereads · 28/04/2022 22:28

Well 56% of U.K. GPs ARE women, so really not seeing how there could be a huge gap in womens healthcare by GPs.

Really? You do not think there has been huge underfunding in women's heatlh? Research done on men (easier - less hormonal fluctuations). Try this as a starter lordslibrary.parliament.uk/womens-health-outcomes-is-there-a-gender-gap/ I am astounded you can even begin to think that female GPs will outweigh the decades and decades of male-focussed healthcare/research/pharm bias. Fucking hell.

CorsicaDreaming · 29/04/2022 07:59

FruityPolos · 29/04/2022 06:47

Librarian here.

Do you think the majority of the population can tell the difference between a trustworthy website with valid medical information and peer reviewed journal articles vs a opinion based website edited by someone with no medical knowledge at all? Most first year degree students struggle with this and often site Wikipedia as a valid source of information.

Yes - academic here and I'd totally agree with you @FruityPolos - understanding about what is and isn't a reliable source, especially on the internet, is really poor amongst many students. Sadly not always confined to their first year!

Ariela · 29/04/2022 07:52

I haven't seen a doctor myself in 12-15 years, so no idea what my practise does.

I do think GP surgeries seem to assume that everyone lives with and is competent with technological advances of the past 10-20 years.

My FIL has various issues one of which was causing him pain and he has been told top phone if he gets pain - but cannot get in touch with his GP via the phone - the recorded message says to go online to book, which he tries to, then he has to be sent an access code to a mobile phone - but he has no mobile phone.

So I sorted on his behalf, got through and passed on the message that he was in pain and had been told if in pain he had to phone the GP back. I explained he couldn't book an appointment online as no mobile phone, and was told someone would call him. This was Monday, as of last night NOBODY has called him - he's carried the house phone round with him all week. I rang yesterday afternoon to try and get him this |GP callback - but sadly the offices were shut due to staff training!
I worry how on earth someone without technology, and nobody to call can manage to contact their GP?

Allthe4s · 29/04/2022 07:50

@PollyDarton2

I’ve watched all 18 seasons of Greys Anatomy so I’m 99% sure I could actually be a doctor if I wanted to be.

I’ve also watched all of House so wanna open a surgery together? 😀Anything not diagnosed you send to me and we’ll run a series of invasive life threatening tests until we kill either the patient or their pesky symptoms.

Nsky62 · 29/04/2022 07:47

Mine are fine, tho one got meds wrong, which was very annoying, had to put in complaint, all sorted tho

Fossiltop · 29/04/2022 07:45

Presumably a GP would know that all veins are "vascular" though, OP?

Angrymum22 · 29/04/2022 07:43

Dr Google is a great source of information, if you have studied medical sciences at degree level. 99% of the population haven’t. Even then diagnostics is a whole speciality in itself. Why do you think it takes GPS so long to train, they don’t leave medical school and set up shop the next day.
Because of Dr Google, health professionals now have to super cautious with patients who present with a diagnosis from Dr Google, or indeed mumsnet. Patients will know what symptoms they should have and often muddy the waters resulting in over medication and incorrect diagnosis.
I had Covid in Feb 2020 and had months of fatigue afterwards that I put down to post viral fatigue, I didn’t think it merited a visit to the GP. Turned out to be cancer fatigue, I was diagnosed with breast cancer 18mnths later. Now had I seen my GP the subtle difference in this symptom was that it was getting worse rather than gradually improving, a good GP would have picked this up and asked further questions.
Giving your GP a list of symptoms copied from the internet isn’t how diagnostics works. Subtle questioning gives a much better picture.
You can often diagnose a problem within 30 seconds of a consultation or as the patient starts to leave. Patients who suspect bowel cancer will often leave it to the last minute to mention blood in their poo, having gone through all the other symptoms. Possibly it is embarrassment and they are hoping the HP will bring it up first. Sometimes it’s cancer fear, they know things aren’t right and the fear of cancer is still very high.

Itwasntmeright · 29/04/2022 07:40

Whilst I share your frustration with doctors who seem dismissive, sadly a large proportion of the general public are a bit thick.