Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think doctors, specifically GP's need to change their approach to patients

208 replies

GlasswareisOverated · 28/04/2022 22:05

We live in the technological age. We have access to information at our fingertips, that someone fifty years ago, hell even twenty years ago would not have been able to comprehend.
Am I being unreasonable to think that drs need to lose the 'we know best about everything medical' attitude.

Obviously I won't be performing brain surgery any time soon or stripping legs of vascular veins to be used in cardiac surgery but I can read a laboratory report and understand what it means and I can get the gist of most medical studies.

"Half of what you are taught in medical school will be wrong in 10 years’ time. The trouble is, none of your teachers know which half"
Former dean of Harvard medical school, Sydney Burwell.

OP posts:
JetTail · 29/04/2022 19:43

LaMarschallin · 29/04/2022 06:36

JetTail

Incidentally, I had a GP ask me in a rather accusatory tone recently whether I had a medical background! I said that I hadn't. He said it's just that not many patients are familiar or use the term tachy. I'm like, well, honey, unfortunately, overhearing it and asking 'what does that mean?' basically means that it's now a term I'm becoming all too familiar with. I've been 'tachy' all too often.

You may have been mistaking an incredulous tone for an accusatory one.

Doctors are very used to patients dropping in medical terms (often, as a PP said, learned from television programmes).
You only have to read MN to see things like "projectile vomiting" used frequently and incorrectly.

You obviously do know what "tachy" means and I'm sorry that it's been a frequent enough occurrence for you to have learned that.
However, it's usually best not to throw medical terms around because the lay person's understanding and the doctor's understanding of the term may be quite different, whereas everyone can understand "I felt my heart racing" or similar.

I knew what he was asking. I clarified over 100. RESTING PULSE.

Sirzy · 29/04/2022 17:56

Any woman with an endocrine disorder knows how shit GPs can be

to be fair, and not downplaying your experience at all they aren’t much better with Males. Ds has an Endocrine problem and the GP is next to useless. Thankfully his Endo nurse is always on hand to help.

TheCanyon · 29/04/2022 17:27

When I went to my gp about my neurological disorder, he knew right away what it was but asked me to give him a week so that he could go read up on the latest guidelines etc. I was pretty impressed.

phlebasconsidered · 29/04/2022 17:17

Any woman with an endocrine disorder knows how shit GPs can be.

Despite a long family history of autoimmune disorders my gp insisted my symptoms were pnd not thyroid. A second gp agreed. It wasn't until I was hospitalised that I got treated. My tsh was 450 and I had 0 t4. It took 10 years to get to a reasonable level again and even then I had to fight to get them to refer me. I know what my levels should be and EVERY SINGLE blood test I have to explain why I am fine with a repressed tsh (which Addenbrookes agreed with).

And now I'm menopausal i'm not being listened to again. Thankfully I have learned to be a pain in the arse and keep on.

AchatAVendre · 29/04/2022 17:10

lljkk Given men have far worse health outcomes than women, adjusted by age/deprivation/any specific condition, it makes sense to me that men should have more money targetting their health needs. <ducks & runs for cover on that one>

But isn't that due mainly to the loss of genetic material when the chromosomes in the womb divide so as to make a Y chromosome meaning a certain reduction in immune capacity? Thats what I was taught in human biology! And greater risk taking of course but neither can be assisted that much by later health care.

XingMing · 29/04/2022 16:14

@dhaka22 , @Norush4 and @Stabbitystabstab ... skin conditions are one of the particularly tricky areas, I have learned in the last nine months, and among friends of similar age who have had medical issues, there's only a few that haven't experienced skin troubles as a side effect.

And I sympathise on the discoid ezcema... dermatology are still investigating but phototherapy, steroid creams and emollients helped once we got on top of the infection that appears to have kicked it off.

clairemaddox · 29/04/2022 16:04

Half of it is wrong now hence why they don't like you looking.

Are you new here? This is not the place to say what you said. Just do what you need to do to keep your family healthy and let everyone else do what they think is best.

thing47 · 29/04/2022 15:34

Reading blood tests results really isn't rocket science, a patient only has to know what is normal for her to be able to assess whether something has changed. For example, I know what range my potassium levels, creatinine count, A1c, iron levels and white blood cell counts normally fall into. So I can tell at a glance if my latest results are within range. If they aren't I will require an expert to tell why they aren't, and to discuss what, if anything, should be done about it. But I am the best person to spot if the results are abnormal for me.

Like @HmmmNo1 I have a genetic condition, 2 of my 3 (adult) DCs have the same condition so collectively we have about 80 years' experience of living with it. None of us has ever met a GP who knows as much about it as we do, in terms of how it affects us specifically. The specialist clinic we go to, well that's a different matter entirely, they are stunningly good; I will try anything they tell me to, no questions asked, because they have always been right.

Obviously GPs have to cover so much ground, you can't expect them to be experts. But a few of them seem unwilling to accept that sometimes patients do know what they are talking about. A little more listening, and a little less arrogance would not go amiss, on occasion.

Allthe4s · 29/04/2022 14:19

I have non-vascular veins. I call ‘em the prosecco pumps.

lljkk · 29/04/2022 14:11

we know best about everything medical' attitude

I honestly think this has been out of fashion for > 20 years. I can't tell you what individuals will be like, but new doctors & nurses are not trained to think this way -- and don't want to be perceived that way, either. They have sat thru long lectures about patients & clinicians as "co-producers" of good health. That said, most people would like confident advice from their health carers, not a zillion options with no confident endorsement. Like you would want your car mechanic to just make one confident recommendation not give you 16 options of which mechanic doesn't personally like 15 of them.

When you're feeling terrible, you most want a simple recommended treatment to talk about and understand, not to have to do a lot of decision making.

Given men have far worse health outcomes than women, adjusted by age/deprivation/any specific condition, it makes sense to me that men should have more money targetting their health needs. <ducks & runs for cover on that one>

Zilla1 · 29/04/2022 13:02

I understand some other nations have patients able to access specialists directly. I think possibly a majority of patients seen here genuinely don't understand enough about there new symptoms to see the correct specialist without in effect a GP-lite triage, let alone the vast majority of patients for whom diagnosis and treatment is successfully managed in primary care. Putting aside Dunning Kruger, I would support such direct access, if only to allow a primary care system currently being deliberately sabotaged by the English government to better balance demand and capacity. I doubt the specialists in acute would appreciate the increase in direct access for patients mislead by Dr Google and their own ignorance of the limits of their understanding (not to say the patient is not the expert in their own symptoms, just that many have firm and completely incorrect understandings of what is the cause of those symptoms) and the increase from patients currently successfully managed by primary care.

For those talking about obsolete medical school tuition, if only there were CPD and training available or some means of communicating recent research, possibly in the form of online journals and protocols.

Will no one think about the non-vascular veins.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 29/04/2022 12:49

People who think general practice is easy and talk about ‘bog standard’ GPs are exposing their ignorance.

I’m a GP but I also have a sub-specialism within hospital emergency medicine. Not going to say what as it’s rare and quite outing, but there are probably fewer than 10 other doctors in the country with the same level of professional experience in it. That part of my work is interesting and has its challenges, but it’s a million times easier than general practice.

A hospital specialist usually sees patients a long way down the diagnostic line. Often the diagnosis is already made; invariably there have been blood tests, scans etc. Usually the specialist is offering expertise on managing an established diagnosis.

A GP sees completely undifferentiated symptoms, usually at an early stage. Every consultation could be something life threatening or a stubbed toe. Lurking amidst the apparently trivial can be cancers, sepsis and other urgent problems. There is immense skill in differentiating the serious from the minor. I have had cancers present as a blocked nose and a sprained ankle. Mostly the patients have not had any investigations. GPs have to spot what needs further tests, choose the right ones, interpret the results correctly, refer if needed. And that’s just the diagnosis side. They also have to manage literally any physical or mental condition, 90% of the time without any specialist help.

pattish · 29/04/2022 12:44

There IS a huge gap in women’s healthcare, even by female GPs. There is also a lack of research (not their fault).

I know more about the menopause than my GP, and she’s supposed to be the ‘specialist’. So in some cases no, YANBU.

Having said that, obviously some patients will not have a scooby doo about their bodies. But some will. I do wish GPs would listen to people who clearly know their own body and have a hunch about what might be wrong rather than the ‘we know best’ approach.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 29/04/2022 12:31

Finallylostit · 28/04/2022 23:47

OP - I am a doctor, have 5 degrees and am an expert in my field.

When I got sick and I meanly badly sick, struggled on for months, denial was the best medicine, googled treatments etc - I lost my objectivity.

It took one of my colleagues to take me aside and say - stop look ignore google, go back to basics and marched me into the correct person who could sort me out. I had convinced my self via google etc that I could manage this - I could not, I damn near ended up on ITU.

It is not about the diagnosis - it is about all the holistic shit I needed around my illness.

Do not self diagnose do not self treat you are not objective

Agree with this. Doctors often get poor treatment because people assume they don’t need explanations or the same level of enquiry. I am an A&E doctor (as well as a GP) and had to work quite hard to get someone in A&E to do a proper history and examination when I had what turned out to be appendicitis.

Buzzinwithbez · 29/04/2022 12:23

I would compare it with the difference between both experiences of giving birth. Studies have found that even if the outcome is the same, women who were supported on decision making had better mental health outcomes than those not.

After my first birth I was traumatised.
Before my due date - "We'll book your induction for ten days after due date"
"Let's give you another half an hour then start you on the drip" and so on. No discussion just this is what we're going to do to you.

Compared to "This is what the NHS policy is, this is what the options are and this is what I think, what do you think? Do you have any questions?"
I felt like we were partners in decision making and had full trust that they were advising what they felt was in my interests, not coercing me in any way and not just dictated by policy.
It was a whole world of difference and meant I trusted my midwife implicitly, rather than feeling it would be frowned upon to explore my options.

It's the sort of partnership I'd prefer to have with my GP too.. One where the patient is able to assume some responsibility.. Especially one that recognises that I'd prefer to make lifestyle of dietary changes that have a lasting effect, rather than go straight to medication.

AchatAVendre · 29/04/2022 12:18

I think some doctors have taken on board that many patients are more informed now. I've been really impressed by my GP practice, not just the GPs but the nurse practitioners and the reception staff in general. Although from what I've heard from friends, I'm just lucky with that particular practice.

Some consultants and NHS physios though...hmmn. Its rare to meet one who is not patronising and who doesn't talk down to you. I've had to ask them to use specific, clinical terms a couple of times so that I can actually understand what they are trying to say, rather than something like "your painful knee".

Enough studies have been carried out to show that the medical profession, in this country at least, has a bias against women and in favour of writing them off as being "the worried well" without proper investigation. There is enough case law to prove that its really not particularly uncommon. I've had bad advice, and I think, in my (relatively well informed) case at least, its safest to be my own advocate.

Stabbitystabstab · 29/04/2022 11:46

Norush4 · 29/04/2022 00:42

@dhaka22 skin conditions are quite hard to identify if you look closely many look similar. On a dark skin I think it's even harder sorry but it's hard enough getting a decent emollient prescribed from the GP for a dark skin tone your right about that part. Although you could asked to be referred to a dermatologist.

I've had a skin condition diagnosis and treatment without even being seen!
I had to suggest they might like to see pictures. (They've been ignored)
I've been on steroids for months with no visual examinations at all.
I've had to fight for a referral. It's ridiculous.

MargaretThursday · 29/04/2022 11:43

If you wanted to have people relying on the internet, then you need to have a good system of removing sites that give false information.

I remember googling about something I know a little about.
The number of websites there were (especially American "I'm a doctor and I know all about this and will tell you more if you send me some money") giving not just false but directly bad information.
Of course they were filled with testimonies "I never understood what I had until I came across you and now I know everything so I've stopped taking the medicine my doctor prescribed and after nearly 16 hours I feel better than ever..."

And how many people know how to read a medical paper? I'm fairly knowledgeable in both medicine and science and I wouldn't claim that I could do that generally. Some subjects that I know more about, I could have a decent shot at, but I still don't think I would have the capability to do that. I think sometimes it's a case of the more you know, the more you don't know.

Crinklecuts · 29/04/2022 11:35

In general I think it’s great that people can find out about their health on the internet. Education is King and can lead to healthier choices.

That being said, I don’t think just Googling lab results and coming up with a diagnosis is ideal because it’s all about context.

UndertheCedartree · 29/04/2022 11:34

I do get the gist of what you are saying and some drs are quite precious about them knowing it all. I had a particular consultant when I was mentally unwell. She suggested I try a medication. I asked her if she had a BNF (I'm a nurse) that I could look at quickly before agreeing. You would have thought I'd said the worst thing in the world! BNFs are not for patients she said! Then refused to give me any medication!

Another time on an acute psychiatric ward I was given a drug test which came back positive. I knew I had not taken this drug! I did some research and found a false positive was due to a medication I was on. I spoke to a nurse and asked them to pass it on to the consultant. They were very apologetic (leave was stopped immediately on me failing the drug test) and thanked me for finding that out. So, they aren't all the same.

HmmmNo1 · 29/04/2022 11:21

I think like a PP said, patients are able to become 'experts' (for want of a better word!) in specific conditions perhaps but its obviously much more broad for an actual doctor.

For example, I have a genetic condition. I've met GPs and other doctors who don't know what it is or what it affects. I definitely do know more about it then a lot of the doctors I've met, aside from the genetics doctor I eventually for referred to of course. But that's in one very specific and personal subject. I do not know more or as much as doctors in regards to medicine or diagnostics in a broader sense.

Alexandra2001 · 29/04/2022 11:20

The real issue is not enough GP's - 1500 less than in 2015, many more working part time.

Primary care is wrecked, total lack of work force planning.

IsabelHerna · 29/04/2022 11:14

That's a very interesting thread. Personally, I do believe there needs to be a change and/or an adaptation of patient care in general, but I wouldn't hold my breath that people "understand more these days". Unfortunately, we live in a weird time. There are people like the OP has said, that can understand a few things, and there are many people that cannot differentiate between real medical information and wild conspiracy theories and misinformation.

jacks11 · 29/04/2022 11:05

Fairislefandango · 28/04/2022 22:38

YANBU. The surgeon who took out my gallbladder had a mug which said 'Don't confuse your Google search with my medical degree', which was funny and fair enough. However, I doubt my gp knew more about gallstones than I did after I'd done quite a lot of Googling. I wonder how much training the average gp has specifically on gallstones. Isn't it well-known they have one day on the menopause, which affects literally half the population?

People talk dismissively about Googling symptoms as though the only info available is crackpot websites and random people on forums with weird theories about their symptoms- rather than the NHS website and worldwide equivalents, plus umpteen reviewed medical articles. I've had gps just print out a page from the NHS website and hand it to me!

@Fairislefandango
i hope you are being facetious. I’m a dr, not a gp, and this “everyone knows they only get one day on…. ‘ is just nonsense. As with all things there are good and bad in general practice (and every field of medicine), but medicine involves study of first principles of anatomy, physiology, genetics, pharmacology, biochemistry etc which allows you to apply further knowledge to… so if I attend a week long training session or a day conference/course on a technique, procedure or new approach etc, it’s not just that stand alone day session- I am applying that to my existing knowledge. I suspect the majority of gp’s do know more than you do from googling. They give you a print out from NHS website as often patients like to have something to refer to. I doubt that they know little to nothing so just read out the NHS website instead.

I am reminded of the period when I was a junior doctor the number of times patients told me that had pain in their kidneys, but in closer questioning would point to anywhere but where their kidneys were. They weren’t being difficult- they genuinely thought that was where their kidneys were located. I think patients genuinely do think they understand everything they need to from a Google search and reading what they find. Some patients will be a lot more successful than others in the quality of that research, many will not have the background knowledge to apply what they have read even if they do come access high quality, relevant research. Not everyone, but I would estimate a significant proportion. In a similar way that I can Google things about the mechanics of cars or even an aspect of aeroplane engines/how to plumb in something/fit electrics/a technique for cutting hair/cooking a Michelin star dish or any number of skilled tasks- as a reasonably intelligent person I think I would probably get the gist of it. But I certainly wouldn’t be confident that I know better (or could complete the task more efficiently or to a better standard) than most mechanics, plumbers, aeronautical engineers, electrician, hairdressers or chefs, or that I could problem solve/work out a complicated issue in that field, based on my Google research. Same applies to medicine- I don’t even assume I know more than my colleagues in different specialties (including general practice).

As a tertiary specialist, I do find it is not uncommon to find patients think they know more than they do from their own research and often come determined of that and absolutely sure of what they want. It is great that patients have access to information, but many do misinterpret or misunderstand (common issue is confusing correlation with causation, for instance, or not being able to evaluate if a study actually shows what it claims to- especially with some of the smaller/more obscure ones they dig out— they read the conclusion and assume it is right)- not every patient, some are absolutely clued up and capable. But it does remain the case that not everyone is as knowledgeable as they think they are. There are a number of patients- usually those with quite a rare condition- who do become very expert in their condition and how it effects them and who will almost certainly know far more about that specific condition than most `dr’s they come across.

please don’t misunderstand me- I’m happy for patients to have read around the subject, and to discuss what they have read and their conclusions from this, but it’s not unusual to find that even capable, intelligent and thoughtful patients have misunderstood/misinterpreted/given to much weight to a small or poorly designed study/decided they have a certain condition and so on (sometimes because they are clinging in to hope, more than anything). I spend quite a bit of time unpicking this if there is an issue and trying to explain why I don’t agree or don’t think x is the right treatment or approach. Most patients are amenable to this, and happy to listen to the explanation, but I am finding a rising minority do feel “I’ve done my research. I know I have x and I want y because of z research/nice guidelines etc and you must do what I say” and are quite inflexible on that standpoint. Unfortunately, not all of them (I’d say the minority) actually know as much as they believe they do.

In addition, there is the issue that the average reading comprehension of adults in this country is about thought to be about that expected of a 10 year old ( I think, I may be out by a year or so either way). All of our patient information literature has to be accessible and geared to be used by that demographic, which why NHS patient information leaflets can seem insulting or needlessly basic. It also means that perhaps the understanding of what they have read is not always quite as robust as they believe. I am not saying for a minute that all patients are unable to read information and form a reasonable conclusion.

MrsSkylerWhite · 29/04/2022 10:41

A little knowledge is a dangerous thing.

qualified people, whose training never ceases, must be so sick of Dr. Google.