Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think doctors, specifically GP's need to change their approach to patients

208 replies

GlasswareisOverated · 28/04/2022 22:05

We live in the technological age. We have access to information at our fingertips, that someone fifty years ago, hell even twenty years ago would not have been able to comprehend.
Am I being unreasonable to think that drs need to lose the 'we know best about everything medical' attitude.

Obviously I won't be performing brain surgery any time soon or stripping legs of vascular veins to be used in cardiac surgery but I can read a laboratory report and understand what it means and I can get the gist of most medical studies.

"Half of what you are taught in medical school will be wrong in 10 years’ time. The trouble is, none of your teachers know which half"
Former dean of Harvard medical school, Sydney Burwell.

OP posts:
JetTail · 02/05/2022 11:23

Badbadbunny · 02/05/2022 11:04

@JetTail

And that is why patients could never simply refer themselves to consultants.

But that doesn't apply for simpler things. People "refer themselves" for NHS dental and optician appointments, but can't do that for NHS hearing aids, nor podiatry, nor physiotherapy for example. I knew I needed hearing aids, but it took 3 months to get the GP to do the referral to audiology. My son had an ingrown toe nail which the GP surgery kept fobbing him off for, until they finally did a referral to podiatry, after a few months of severe pain, being unable to do sports, etc., completely unnecessarily.

Referrals for the "big things", then yes, of course, but so much of what they do really is simple and obvious enough for self-referral. I really don't see any difference between self referral NHS dentistry as opposed to hearing aids. In both cases, an initial consultation would flag up if the patient was in the wrong place or if there were signs of something more serious needing referral elsewhere.

If you can get a Vit D & K supplement, it works better. I bought some online from Amazon the year before last when covid was raging as I was told that the K works to aid absorption. Vit K though can be a dangerous one sometimes though as it can increase the clotting mechanism, so not really to be taken by a cancer patient unless you consult with at the very least, the GP.

This is the one I buy www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B07D3B4Q2P/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_image?ie=UTF8&psc=1

Also, there is another way to get Vitamin D which is one I'm not even going to write, in case some idiot takes the advice without a very large dollop of caution!!

And this article (do not take this as Gospel) states the following:
“For better absorption of vitamin D, you must include vitamin K, magnesium, and zinc in your diet. They speed up the absorption procedure and reduce your likelihood of being vitamin D deficient,” she suggests www.healthshots.com/preventive-care/self-care/6-ways-to-increase-absorption-of-vitamin-d-in-the-body/#:~:text=%E2%80%9CFor%20better%20absorption%20of%20vitamin,D%20deficient%2C%E2%80%9D%20she%20suggests.
NOTE: I HAVE NO IDEA WHAT SORT OF WEBSITE THAT IS OR INDEED WHETHER IT'S QUACKERY but it certainly does mention the Vit K.

Badbadbunny · 02/05/2022 11:18

JetTail · 02/05/2022 11:11

That's not comparable! Dentists and opticians are not consultants! You know you need one but you don't know what treatment you might need. It's like doctors. You know you need a doctor, but you might not know which speciality within the 'doctor' sphere. You're comparing apples and oranges. You might as well have said that referring yourself to a consultant doctor was comparable to realising that your car needed some assistance and you 'self refer' to a mechanic!

So what's the difference between having toothache and going to the dentist against having an ingrown toe nail and going to the podiatry dept, or not being able to hear and going to audiology? Some things are obvious enough that patients can "sign post" themselves. As I said, dentists already check for other things during check ups etc, so if the dentist has suspicions of something more sinister (i.e. mouth cancer), then s/he will refer elsewhere, just as an audiologist will refer if their observations/tests throw up something suspicious. An awful lot of the "obvious" stuff could be taken away from the GP control and passed to self-referral.

Badbadbunny · 02/05/2022 11:15

TheUndoingProject · 02/05/2022 10:53

I think if you go to a doctor with this kind of antagonistic attitude you’re setting yourself up for an unproductive relationship.

Trouble is that when you've already experienced multiple instances of mistakes and fobbing off, you become conditioned to expect the worst.

It took me multiple appointments to get put onto HRT. I saw many GPs of both sexes re different conditions all pertaining to the menopause, but no one cared - just basically told "it's how it is". Ironically, it was an appointment with an "old" male GP where there was a breakthrough who actually listened properly to what I was saying and set me up on HRT patches which have worked a treat.

As for general GP competence, I once had a severe case of thrush in my mouth which wasn't cleared up by the antibacterial mouth/tongue creams etc. The GP prescribed a strong antibacterial tablet which he said would clear it up within a week. The prescription was for one week's worth, i.e. 7 tablets. When I handed it to the chemist, there was a fair bit of whispering between the dispensing staff and one came over to tell me they were just going to phone the surgery to check something. After about half an hour, she came back and told me there'd been a mistake and that the tablet was a "one off" and it would have been dangerous to take it 7 times as it was so strong, the GP had made an error prescribing too much and they were waiting for a replacement prescription for just a single tablet!

So, I don't apologise for having an "attitude" with GPs as they aren't always right and patients really do need to do their own research/checking etc rather than relying on the GP being right.

JetTail · 02/05/2022 11:11

Badbadbunny · 02/05/2022 11:04

@JetTail

And that is why patients could never simply refer themselves to consultants.

But that doesn't apply for simpler things. People "refer themselves" for NHS dental and optician appointments, but can't do that for NHS hearing aids, nor podiatry, nor physiotherapy for example. I knew I needed hearing aids, but it took 3 months to get the GP to do the referral to audiology. My son had an ingrown toe nail which the GP surgery kept fobbing him off for, until they finally did a referral to podiatry, after a few months of severe pain, being unable to do sports, etc., completely unnecessarily.

Referrals for the "big things", then yes, of course, but so much of what they do really is simple and obvious enough for self-referral. I really don't see any difference between self referral NHS dentistry as opposed to hearing aids. In both cases, an initial consultation would flag up if the patient was in the wrong place or if there were signs of something more serious needing referral elsewhere.

That's not comparable! Dentists and opticians are not consultants! You know you need one but you don't know what treatment you might need. It's like doctors. You know you need a doctor, but you might not know which speciality within the 'doctor' sphere. You're comparing apples and oranges. You might as well have said that referring yourself to a consultant doctor was comparable to realising that your car needed some assistance and you 'self refer' to a mechanic!

Sirzy · 02/05/2022 11:09

The oncologist will only deal with the cancer itself and keeps referring everything else back to the GP surgery,

and this is part of the problem. Consultants and their teams should be able to deal with things which are issues related to a condition that they understand better.

Ds has a number of chronic conditions and the ones which are best to manage are the ones where the team at the hospital are contactable and act quickly. I contacted the endocrine team last week and got back to me in hours suggesting a change to make

Badbadbunny · 02/05/2022 11:04

@JetTail

And that is why patients could never simply refer themselves to consultants.

But that doesn't apply for simpler things. People "refer themselves" for NHS dental and optician appointments, but can't do that for NHS hearing aids, nor podiatry, nor physiotherapy for example. I knew I needed hearing aids, but it took 3 months to get the GP to do the referral to audiology. My son had an ingrown toe nail which the GP surgery kept fobbing him off for, until they finally did a referral to podiatry, after a few months of severe pain, being unable to do sports, etc., completely unnecessarily.

Referrals for the "big things", then yes, of course, but so much of what they do really is simple and obvious enough for self-referral. I really don't see any difference between self referral NHS dentistry as opposed to hearing aids. In both cases, an initial consultation would flag up if the patient was in the wrong place or if there were signs of something more serious needing referral elsewhere.

JetTail · 02/05/2022 11:03

TheUndoingProject · 02/05/2022 10:53

I think if you go to a doctor with this kind of antagonistic attitude you’re setting yourself up for an unproductive relationship.

I'm pretty sure that no-one goes to a GP with an "antagonistic" attitude. You go when you're absolutely desperate and in pain or feeling otherwise unwell and you're hoping that they'll help. However, if you're constantly being fobbed off and your extensive googling has suggested something to you which hasn't even been considered, you'd be forgiven for feeling frustrated!

Badbadbunny · 02/05/2022 10:58

thing47 · 30/04/2022 12:12

Then there is all of the routine chronic disease monitoring that GPs carry out day to day

Anyone who think GPs are good at 'routine' chronic disease monitoring doesn't have a chronic disease. In my experience, most of them don't actually have a scooby.

I agree. The idea that GPs are good at managing chronic diseases is a joke.

My OH has cancer and will need to be on a sackful of prescription drugs for the rest of his life.

The GPs havn't a sodding clue about how to deal with all the complications and side effects that come with that.

The oncologist will only deal with the cancer itself and keeps referring everything else back to the GP surgery, such as vitamin deficiencies, high blood pressure, heart palpitations, general pains, etc. When OH goes to the GP to get treatment/meds for these things, they're hopeless. The GP surgery won't even agree to doing his blood tests, and just send him to the hospital for them. Latest saga is a Vit D deficiency, highlighted by both the oncologist and an orthopeadic consultant over a year ago. OH got himself the strongest possible OTT Vit D from the pharmacy, but levels are still falling. Oncologist and Ortho consultant both told DH to get stronger Vit D on prescription from his GP. Six months later, after several phone consultations and 2 more blood tests (GP wanted his own doing instead of relying on the oncology ones!), still no bloody prescription and the latest was a message from the GP telling OH to get the strongest OTT vit D from the pharmacist - clearly hasn't listened to a word OH has said nor read the notes of previous consultations.

Some GPs are absolutely hopeless. It's no wonder they think they're busy when they can't do the simple things at first attempt and patients need multiple subsequent consultations for the same thing because the GP won't bloody listen!

JetTail · 02/05/2022 10:57

I have one illness (well a few actually but this one in particular is apparently the culprit for all manner of things 🙄) and honestly, if I had a pain in my arse, it would be attributed to that condition. It's infuriating! As my friend (a consultant) said to me recently while I was having a rant that as per usual this condition was the one blamed for whatever symptoms I was having (upper abdo pain), "they're like grasshoppers - jumping to conclusions!"

TheUndoingProject · 02/05/2022 10:53

I think if you go to a doctor with this kind of antagonistic attitude you’re setting yourself up for an unproductive relationship.

Oblomov22 · 02/05/2022 10:47

I agree with OP. Obviously not all people are intelligent enough, so need help. The people skills now required that many GP's (and others) don't have, is to know the difference.

I often know more about my health than they do : my diabetes, my frozen shoulder that type 1's are more prone to and should have had surgery 3 years ago instead of being fobbed off with physio, says surgeon; or HRT, than a GP. because they are generalists.

I read up on HRT. Extensively, after being fobbed off and denied for years. One GP gave me wrong info, I corrected her re the NICE guidelines from 2015, so 7 years ago. She admitted that she now realised most of her female patients, 100's could be on the higher dosage. The ignorance, nigh on negligence is shocking. I only got where I got, the correct disagree, through politely fighting.

Some patients know nothing, and need a GP's help. Many of us have already investigated and need kindness and a referral.

JetTail · 02/05/2022 10:46

@Bramshott My GP practice now works mainly with e-consults. One of the questions you're asked is 'Is there any particular treatment you would like'. Lol! Yes, I'd like a foot massage please! Like what the fuck?!

Well that is when the stupid e-consult doesn't stop you proceeding with big red font 'CALL 999 IMMEDIATELY!'. So you either have to do that, or go back and change your answers. I spent a week to and fro to A&E with a combination of symptoms. GP kept telling me to go to A&E and A&E doctors kept sending me home and telling me to go to the GP. In the heel of the hunt I ended up with sepsis.

Bramshott · 02/05/2022 10:39

I haven't read every post, so apologies if someone has already made this point, but actually I find the new tendency to consult patients on their care can be less than helpful at times. When DH broke his collarbone a couple of years ago we both found it really difficult that the doctors kept saying "what treatment would you like?" We would much rather they had made a clear recommendation for their position of much greater knowledge!

MrOllivander · 02/05/2022 10:39

thing47 · 30/04/2022 12:12

Then there is all of the routine chronic disease monitoring that GPs carry out day to day

Anyone who think GPs are good at 'routine' chronic disease monitoring doesn't have a chronic disease. In my experience, most of them don't actually have a scooby.

That ^^
I manage my own mostly, and through my consultants. I'm lucky if my doctors remember I have one chronic disease let alone the rest
I've had a letter from 2 consultants asking for me to be referred as I have hashimotos, they've refused twice

My consultant saw what I had been prescribed for a UTI, said "that won't work" and couriered me antibiotics and told me in future to ask him

JetTail · 02/05/2022 10:38

And they still can't figure out (going on for years now) why that electrolyte is almost always low. 🤔

JetTail · 02/05/2022 10:35

Sorry, website is crashing so posted before I lost it. Ye, so I just happened to ask the doc who was sending me home what that electrolyte value was. He then must have asked for that to be tested and 20 minutes later a nurse came with an IV bag of said electrolyte. The value was 0.2. Normal range is 0.7 (ish) to 1.0. Had I done what he had told me to do and gone home, I would very likely have died.

I'll let ye guess what the conditions were. And that is why patients could never simply refer themselves to consultants. Not even trained doctors know what the hell is wrong half the time, let alone my good self!

JetTail · 02/05/2022 10:29

I have had one exceptional experience with a GP (however, it was not here). I went in to the GP thinking that I was going insane and not having a clue how to describe what was happening i.e. the symptoms I was experiencing. I tried to explain it by saying something like "I can't sit still without feeling an overwhelming urge to move." 🤔 I was full sure that she was going to get the men in white coats! I was aware that it made me sound like I was a lazy arse and that my mind was telling me to get up off said lazy arse (like the current Smart watches sometimes rudely prompt you to MOVE AROUND!!). I was astounded to discover that what I was experiencing had a name!!

A&E doctors can be awful though also. Well, so can GPs but mainly if you manage to actually meet one in person, they have a vague notion of what speciality to refer you to. One such occasion was when I was brought to Resus by ambulance and even though the journey was probably 5 minutes, it was the longest 5 minutes of my life. My hands were spasming so to speak, and folding inwards to my elbows if you get me. My neck and jaw were also clenching and I couldn't talk as couldn't move mouth/jaw etc. I was so fucking panicked as I felt like the clenching/spasming was spreading to my chest and that I very soon wouldn't be able to breathe. I actually don't recall why I had called 111 or 999 but the spasming thing only happened after I had to walk downstairs to ambulance which was maybe parked 20 metres up a slight hill. In any case I was given something (no idea what) and after of hours I was brought to Majors from Resus. A doctor came a little while later and told me that I could go home. I was like 'are you kidding me? I can't even get off this trolley, let alone make my way home! I have a history of one electrolyte being low (they still don't know why) but it's not one that is routinely tested for in the full blood count they do in A&E. I the

Icelandicsox · 02/05/2022 10:09

The problem, OP, is that everytime you have an interaction with a registered healthcare professional that as well as trying to help you and not harm youperson puts their registration on the line. Not just the job they are in now but the ability to work at all in the career they've studied and worked for from their school days.

There is no way of knowing when a patient says 'I've done my research' how good that person is in evaluating the evidence (its not as easy as just reading peer reviewed material - see Andrew Wakefield and the Lancet), do they understand grades of interaction and that some resources provide better information than others around this for various classes of drugs and have they consulted the right one, do they understand risk/benefit profiles, do they understand the side effects and what these mean for their life if they get them, are they at risk of pregnancy? Get any of this wrong and that's the patient harmed and the registration out the window.

GlasswareisOverated · 02/05/2022 10:07

Also everyone who is taking the piss out of my use of vascular (I was drunk when I wrote the original post), can you name six types of diabetes without googling?
Because I can and I am not medically trained in anyway.

OP posts:
awaynboilyurheid · 02/05/2022 09:38

Womans health issues are generally ignored or under treated by GP’s and hospital consultants too. On average it takes 5 years to be diagnosed with endometriosis a common but very painful condition, woman have to put up with being told here take a pain killer, have you tried exercising? etc before they are “allowed” to be referred for scans or get suitable treatment.

Another condition, an autoimmune condition, Hashimoto’s thyroiditis affects more woman than men, 1 man for every 10 woman is affected. Yet Levothyroxine is the ONLY drug prescribed by the NHS, if it doesn’t cure the wide range of life altering symptoms then according to the mainly male medical profession, it’s all in your head.
Woman are then put on anti depressants and told to go away. I cannot imagine this being the treatment pathway for cardiac conditions where a huge variety of medication is available but that’s because it affects mainly men.
Woman seeking help on health forums all share the terrible way they are treated takes years to be diagnosed then under medicated and dismissed.
Many have to resort to buying medication from abroad and self treating to cure symptoms because of this one drug one, dosage, approach of the NHS.

There is huge mysogeny in medicine, which needs addressed and GP’s definitely play their part in this , agree some without realising it, even if it’s a female GP as just two examples of conditions that affect mainly woman are shown not to be treated with the same variety of medication or resources given to conditions which affect mainly men.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 02/05/2022 08:44

@Discovereads

PlasticineMeg
Im on the fence.

I think it must be so annoying to be a GP and have patients come in clutching pages from Google thinking they can diagnose themselves. but in particular women are never listened to in the way they should be, there’s a huge gap in womens healthcare and it needs to stop

Well 56% of U.K. GPs ARE women, so really not seeing how there could be a huge gap in womens healthcare by GPs

Erm…just because a GP or any other doctor IS a woman, does not make them an expert on women’s healthcare-you do realise that right? That a female GP may have led their studying and therefore their expertise in the direction that interests them-such as children/skin/heart disease etc etc.

Alexandra2001 · 02/05/2022 08:34

Nat6999 · 30/04/2022 23:04

I've lost faith in doctors. My GP surgery used to be great, but over the last 5 years it has gone downhill. The lovely helpful GP's have all either left or retired & we are left with new doctors who aren't caring & just want you in & out as fast as they can, that is if you can get past the pit bull receptionist & avoid the nurse practitioner who if you see you have more chance of winning the Lottery than getting a prescription. I'm under a neurologist who was great when I was paying £200 an appointment but since transferring to the NHS just doesn't seem interested.

.... because you are not the only patient they have got to look after.

Patient numbers per GP have rocketed, as have numbers per consultant.

Ask yourself why so many have left/retired/emigrated?

My DD was 10minutes late for a home visit (after dealing with a particular complex patient) she got a mouthful ... dealt with her and drove away thinking "why do i bother"
She is getting this more and more, less staff means more work, harder to keep appointment times, dickhead patients (my phrase not hers)

Nat6999 · 30/04/2022 23:04

I've lost faith in doctors. My GP surgery used to be great, but over the last 5 years it has gone downhill. The lovely helpful GP's have all either left or retired & we are left with new doctors who aren't caring & just want you in & out as fast as they can, that is if you can get past the pit bull receptionist & avoid the nurse practitioner who if you see you have more chance of winning the Lottery than getting a prescription. I'm under a neurologist who was great when I was paying £200 an appointment but since transferring to the NHS just doesn't seem interested.

TheSummerPalace · 30/04/2022 22:33

I was working for an NHS trust and had a meeting, where my head of division was present. She heard my voice and got me seen by their top ENT specialist within three days, who diagnosed me with Vocal Dystonia (vocal muscles not functioning as they should, specifically the one on the left hand side).
I got referred on to another ENT specialist, to have botox injected into the vocal chord.
I then saw a neurologist privately for a separate issue, a tingling sensation in my scalp, related to neck problems I have suffered with since the age of sixteen. The neurologist pointed out that the vocal dystonia was a side effect of the medication I was on treat my bi-polar disorder, the medication was acting as dopamine antagonist, effecting my brains ability to communicate with my left vocal chord. I stopped taking the medication (having considered the pros and cons of staying on the medication and continuing with the botox injections) my voice is over ninety percent recovered now.
I did not figure out the problem on my own but at the same time, it should have not taken six GP appointments and four different consultants (three ENT and one neurologist) to figure out a)what the issue was and b)how it could be resolved effectively.

Almost exactly the same thing happened to me - I’d been seen by an ENT consultant, a consultant neurologist, a voice consultant (who was injecting botox in the muscles, controlling my vocal chords to relieve the symptoms of the vocal dystonia) and a psychiatrist. Not one of them considered that the SSRI, I had been told to take, was causing the vocal dystonia! I’d suffered for three years! I found it out on Google, and stopped taking the SSRI - I got 90% of my voice back, and the voice consultant agreed I no longer met the criteria for botox.

It’s in the BNF, that the SSRI could cause movement disorders! Why is that 3 consultants (and one of them had a whole team of speech and language therapists and junior doctors in attendance - at least 6 of them) and a Mental Health Trust didn’t know that, with all that medical training, the peer reviewed articles, CPD, etc and presumably their own copy of the BNF?

FrankLeeSpeaking · 30/04/2022 20:41

People are all blaming GPs and calling them incompetent... they have x amount of time with patients. (I believe 10 minutes, but may be wrong). A lot of surgeries have a "one problem per appt" policy.

Someone with complex systems can't possibly be diagnosed etc in 10 minutes. Patients with multiple symptoms may not even be allowed to go through them all.

The system is shit.