Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think doctors, specifically GP's need to change their approach to patients

208 replies

GlasswareisOverated · 28/04/2022 22:05

We live in the technological age. We have access to information at our fingertips, that someone fifty years ago, hell even twenty years ago would not have been able to comprehend.
Am I being unreasonable to think that drs need to lose the 'we know best about everything medical' attitude.

Obviously I won't be performing brain surgery any time soon or stripping legs of vascular veins to be used in cardiac surgery but I can read a laboratory report and understand what it means and I can get the gist of most medical studies.

"Half of what you are taught in medical school will be wrong in 10 years’ time. The trouble is, none of your teachers know which half"
Former dean of Harvard medical school, Sydney Burwell.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GlasswareisOverated · 03/05/2022 09:35

@nat6999 that's horrifying. I am so guttted for you, being let down like that.
Have you looked into suing for medical negligence?
You've had permanent harm done and now have a life that is severely impacted by lack of care.

OP posts:
Nat6999 · 03/05/2022 05:25

I started with neurological symptoms of numbness in my feet, I went to see my GP who spent the entire appointment talking about something totally unconnected with my feet. When she finally drew breath I tried to tell her about my feet & got told to make another appointment, my time was up. I couldn't get another appointment until February, this was November, by then the numbness had traveled up my legs & I was struggling to walk, the doctor at that appointment told me I would have to live with it. I finally got to see a neurologist in July by which time I couldn't walk any further than a couple of steps, I had scans & nerve conduction studies & got told if I had seen them when the numbness started they could have done something but the damage was too extensive now. I'm in a wheelchair now, housebound & unable to care for myself. I know we should be greatful for the NHS but I have lost faith in it now

GlasswareisOverated · 02/05/2022 21:34

We have automatic data retrieval form GP surgeries. They put a coding on a patient's file and our system receives that coding .
It can also lead to people ending up on our system who have been miscoded,, which is a giant headache in itself.

OP posts:
ApplesAndChalk · 02/05/2022 19:01

GlasswareisOverated · 02/05/2022 18:17

I work in a role with people who are at risk of complications due to diagnoses that on many occasions have not even been explained to the person I am talking to.
This happens two to three times a week, since being in the role I am currently in.
So it's not just my personal experiences I am basing my criticisms on.
It is a wide spread problem that I encounter every single week.
I should not be in position where I am having to explain how the diagnosis happened, the possible consequences of the diagnosis and the remedies that are available to ease the burden of the diagnosis.
Every single week, I am encountering people who have not even been contacted by their GP, who have a life altering condition that they have not even been told they have.
For some reason I am quite angry about this, it is not my place to offer the kind of support these people need.
I am encountering people who have not been given the information they need fromtheir doctors, the places they can reach out to, to get further support.

I don't see how someone would know that someone has a condition when the person concerned doesn't know? How do you find out?

GlasswareisOverated · 02/05/2022 18:20

Furthermore I have recently been highlighted as a shining example of how the role I am in, should be performed, so I will continue to offer the support I do, but it is really not my place to be doing so, but if I don't, who will?

OP posts:
GlasswareisOverated · 02/05/2022 18:17

I work in a role with people who are at risk of complications due to diagnoses that on many occasions have not even been explained to the person I am talking to.
This happens two to three times a week, since being in the role I am currently in.
So it's not just my personal experiences I am basing my criticisms on.
It is a wide spread problem that I encounter every single week.
I should not be in position where I am having to explain how the diagnosis happened, the possible consequences of the diagnosis and the remedies that are available to ease the burden of the diagnosis.
Every single week, I am encountering people who have not even been contacted by their GP, who have a life altering condition that they have not even been told they have.
For some reason I am quite angry about this, it is not my place to offer the kind of support these people need.
I am encountering people who have not been given the information they need fromtheir doctors, the places they can reach out to, to get further support.

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 02/05/2022 14:49

I have a similar problem, my Free T4 (with TSH in normal range)has been suboptimal on four occasions, that combined with the diagnoses of Fibromyalgia, PCOS and Bi-polar has led me to the conclusion that there is something out of whack with my HPA axis, but no one will listen (plus the chronic insomnia...)

If no one will listen to you, what does that tell you? i take it you mean several medical professionals aren't listening....not just the same GP.

Fwiw i have found every single GP or Consultant very willing to listen to me and how i feel/ideas about a particular issue & very often, having listened, they then proceed to tell me how and why i'm wrong... because though i know a lot about IT, i know jack about orthopedics or Meniere disease.

LeFeu · 02/05/2022 14:22

Remember Andrew Wakefield? Remember all the people who swallowed that they shouldn’t vaccinate their children despite the vast majority of the medical profession telling them otherwise? Or a million coronavirus conspiracy theories? The general public is not able to critically evaluate “a few internet articles” and in fact I think expecting them to do so would be actively damaging to public health interests.

GlasswareisOverated · 02/05/2022 14:11

@JetTail exactly what I was about to do to @Badbadbunny so I laughed instead, thank you.

@Iheartmysmart I have a similar problem, my Free T4 (with TSH in normal range)has been suboptimal on four occasions, that combined with the diagnoses of Fibromyalgia, PCOS and Bi-polar has led me to the conclusion that there is something out of whack with my HPA axis, but no one will listen (plus the chronic insomnia...)

And just to repeat can anyone on this thread name six types of Diabetes without googling?

Because I can with NO medical training.

OP posts:
Iheartmysmart · 02/05/2022 12:57

Have to say that I do agree with you in some circumstances. My dad’s new GP could have made him very ill by not reading his notes properly and prescribing a drug which was contraindicated with others he was taking.

My mum visited her GP on several occasions and was told her issue was just part of the natural ageing process. Nope, she was in heart failure.

I’ve been to my GP with hypothyroid symptoms for the last 6 years only to be told nothing was wrong with me. Had private tests done and I have central hypothyroidism. My GP was basing her diagnosis on my TSH level and had never taken my FT4 into account. Fortunately there are some very knowledgeable people out there on Google who knew straight away what it was!

JetTail · 02/05/2022 12:36

luckylavender · 02/05/2022 12:31

Nope. I think you're being ridiculous

Well QED then.

JetTail · 02/05/2022 12:36

The other thing which baffles me about some doctor referrals or notes is the shortened version of things they write. 'Pt c/o upper left quadrant pain post C2H5OH' for example. Hx is another one that I now recognise. I thought that they were sending me 'care of' pain and that C2H5OH was perhaps a ward number they were fast-tracking me to. No, I'm not that thick, but I think they deliberately abbreviate some things so as not to annoy a patient perhaps.

luckylavender · 02/05/2022 12:31

Nope. I think you're being ridiculous

JetTail · 02/05/2022 12:22

Mind you, one consultant described me as an "excellent historian" once and I replied to a thread on here which was asking why consultants start their letters with things like 'I met this lovely lady at clinic today' or something! I was most flattered at the time of receiving the letter (to my GP) that a doctor had made this astute observation of my obviously superior intelligence lol as I hadn't really discussed any historical events that I could recall but I was confident that I must have said something for him to realise just how brilliant I was! My ego was rapidly deflated by doctors here telling me that it simply meant that I had given a detailed history of my illness. Chapter and verse I suspect! 😆

notanothertakeaway · 02/05/2022 12:15

Brainwave89 · 29/04/2022 09:20

My son is a doctor and I discussed your message with him. Whilst the profession is keen to use technology to its maximum (online consultations where appropriate, use of telephone consultations etc) It takes a massive amount of training to be a doctor and it would be extremely unwise to rely on anything you read online. Please be very careful.

Sorry @Brainwave89 I had to laugh at the idea that having a phone call is classed as "using technology to its maximum". I was making phone calls at work in the late 1980's. It didn't seem particularly cutting edge at the time

But I agree with your point that a little info online is a dangerous thing

KitKat1985 · 02/05/2022 12:14

Speaking as a nurse, you have a point for some people. However everyone who has worked in the medical profession will also be able to tell you god knows how many examples of human stupidity which is why unfortunately not all members of the public can be trusted with this.

JetTail · 02/05/2022 12:10

This is another thing that I would advise doing whenever you meet a doctor be they your GP or a consultant. Firstly, advise them of any new symptoms and/or illnesses you've had since last consultation - even if apparently unrelated. The other thing that I would advise is to let them know if you're taking any supplements (such as vitamins or herbal therapies or whatever) or indeed whether you're taking for example ibuprofen as well as prescribed pain relief for example as then they know that the pain management they have you on isn't sufficient.

In the case of the electrolyte that is always low for me, I take a supplement of that and it's still constantly low which makes it doubly unusual.

JetTail · 02/05/2022 12:04

God help any poor doctor who has to try to get a simple answer out of me! 😔

JetTail · 02/05/2022 12:02

Here's another example of ambiguity.
I'm under an Endocrinologist. At the first consultation, he asked whether I ever felt palpitations. Now that is one that I didn't even know was a medical 'symptom'. My interpretation of it was that it was an old-fashioned way of describing feeling nervous. He clarified what he meant i.e. could I feel my heart fluttering (I'm pretty sure that "fluttering" was not the word he used 😆, but you get the gist). I replied that I occasionally did. He then asked, is it when you feel anxious about something or does it just happen? That was a difficult one to answer because I explained that I couldn't really answer as anytime I felt these flutterings lol, I attributed them to something going on in my life, but that I wasn't sure which came first haha i.e. stress causing the flutterings or the flutterings causing a feeling of anxiety. I'm pretty sure that I confused him lol.

JetTail · 02/05/2022 11:40

Has either consultant written to the GP suggesting prescribing Vit D? Or have they just told you? A lot of it can be that the consultants do not have the authority to prescribe for unrelated conditions. That has to go through the GP (rightly) as they are supposed to be the ones who know about all your conditions. Like for example, whether your OH has ever had a blood clot or something, where Vit K might not be advised. It's a fucking pain the ass, I give you that! I'm so frustrated with the medical profession (or the NHS shit procedures more specifically) sometimes.

Badbadbunny · 02/05/2022 11:36

@JetTail
Also, a GP should be able to treat the ingrown toenail. A consultant shouldn't be required.

But they didn't. That was the problem. They suggested salt baths, various creams, etc., but it just got worse. It took a referral to podiatry (not a consultant), and partial removal of the nail to solve it. GP kept saying the referral would take months, citing that as the reason for trying to "self treat". In the event, he got a podiatry appointment within a couple of weeks and they booked him in for the partial removal the week later, so no delay/wait at all, once the GP had finally done the referral. Months of pain for no reason at all. If there'd have been a way to go straight to podiatry, it would have saved several GP appointments and months of pain.

JetTail · 02/05/2022 11:36

Badbadbunny · 02/05/2022 11:33

@JetTail

If you can get a Vit D & K supplement, it works better. I bought some online from Amazon the year before last when covid was raging as I was told that the K works to aid absorption. Vit K though can be a dangerous one sometimes though as it can increase the clotting mechanism, so not really to be taken by a cancer patient unless you consult with at the very least, the GP.

But that's exactly the problem. The GPs havn't a clue. It's why neither the oncologist nor ortho consultant will issue a VitD prescription - they say it's the GP's job to do it, but the GPs havn't a clue, hence six months since asking and still no resolution. My OH would happily make his own arrangements if he could!

That has to be frustrating as I certainly wouldn't gamble with self-prescribing while receiving treatment for cancer. I would contact the GP somehow and state 'DH is going to buy the following item online and take it, UNLESS you state otherwise'. That sort of pins them to the wall a bit as they then literally have to say either yay or nay. Well, maybe. Worth a shot!

Badbadbunny · 02/05/2022 11:33

@JetTail

If you can get a Vit D & K supplement, it works better. I bought some online from Amazon the year before last when covid was raging as I was told that the K works to aid absorption. Vit K though can be a dangerous one sometimes though as it can increase the clotting mechanism, so not really to be taken by a cancer patient unless you consult with at the very least, the GP.

But that's exactly the problem. The GPs havn't a clue. It's why neither the oncologist nor ortho consultant will issue a VitD prescription - they say it's the GP's job to do it, but the GPs havn't a clue, hence six months since asking and still no resolution. My OH would happily make his own arrangements if he could!

JetTail · 02/05/2022 11:30

Also, just to warn you - you will be bombarded now with about 50 posts saying 'cancel the cheque!' i.e. to state that thrush isn't bacterial, it's fungal. Brace yourself @Badbadbunny 😂

JetTail · 02/05/2022 11:29

Badbadbunny · 02/05/2022 11:18

So what's the difference between having toothache and going to the dentist against having an ingrown toe nail and going to the podiatry dept, or not being able to hear and going to audiology? Some things are obvious enough that patients can "sign post" themselves. As I said, dentists already check for other things during check ups etc, so if the dentist has suspicions of something more sinister (i.e. mouth cancer), then s/he will refer elsewhere, just as an audiologist will refer if their observations/tests throw up something suspicious. An awful lot of the "obvious" stuff could be taken away from the GP control and passed to self-referral.

I can see your point, but sometimes it's not actually simple. Like the cases I referred to in the last few posts this morning. Also, there would be a lot of idiotic self-referrals for consultants to have to sift through. Also, a GP should be able to treat the ingrown toenail. A consultant shouldn't be required.