Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not put money in work collection?

108 replies

Plantpot45 · 28/04/2022 14:16

Honestly there are about 2 or 3 per month with people leaving going on maternity leave retiring etc. The going rate is a tenner. If it is someone I know well and work closely with I always put money in but this current person I’ve never even met face to face. Only via messaging and on virtual meetings. I wouldn’t know her if I saw her in the street! So why everyone is putting the pressure on to contribute? Problem is most of my other colleagues do know her, and so it’s more what they will think if I don’t contribute? I’ll be honest, I also really can’t afford it at the moment so find it hard to justify to my husband who puts in the lions share of the money in our house. So Aibu?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Plantpot45 · 01/05/2022 18:49

C8H10N4O2 · 29/04/2022 12:22

Obviously you should be giving if you don't know the person well enough or don't have the money.

However why do you have to justify your expenditure to your husband? Does he similarly explain his own smaller items of spending to you?

It’s more out of respect and if I wanted to put it in he would be fine with me donating. It’s just because it’s hard to justify chucking money at people I don’t know and don’t want to give it to. I’ve bought presents for many of my own friends who I love and he’s happy for me to do that with our joint funds and literally never questions anything I spend.

OP posts:
Murdoch1949 · 30/04/2022 19:55

I would never contribute to colleagues I didn't know, nor write a platitude in a card for a colleague I didn't get on with.

Dinoteeth · 29/04/2022 19:30

I think that's part of the issue there are no HR rules, it's a unwritten etiquette, much off it can be driven by individuals in a department.
Sometimes one department will be doing stuff while another isn't.

tttigress · 29/04/2022 15:54

I no longer work in the UK, however when I did, people that I barely knew would walk up to my desk and ask for a contribution to their sponsored whatever on a regular basis.

Really annoying, though to be honest I usually contributed just for a quiet life.

Surely there should be some HR rules on this?

Obviously charity and work collections are great, but I am not sure you should be asking your work colleagues for money directly?

Antarcticant · 29/04/2022 15:38

When I retired there were messages on my card from people I had never met

A colleague of mine who was going on maternity leave once discovered she had signed her own 'good luck' card! It was a big office and there were cards going round all the time, clearly it had been passed to her without a second thought and she'd signed her name on auto-pilot.

Dinoteeth · 29/04/2022 14:45

When I retired there were messages on my card from people I had never met, so their heartfelt messages meant nothing.

While I've never had a gift from a company or colleagues I was given a leaving card from one of the worse places I've ever worked.
My boss hated me, absolutely hated me, and he had the fucking cheeky to put a message on the card. If it wasn't for other colleagues the card would have gone in the office bin. I binned it when I got home!

Sub1required · 29/04/2022 14:10

It's such a relief working somewhere that doesn't do collections very much, usually in the smaller teams. We do have charity days and bake sales but they don't pressure for contributions.

A previous work place was rife with collections plus charity days. Every birthday, leaver, wedding, baby or death. What's worse is on more than one occasion they would collect for a leaver, they left, came back months later, leave again and attempt a 2nd collection.

MajorCarolDanvers · 29/04/2022 13:51

YANBU to not contribute. It should always be voluntary.

However YABU to find it hard to justify to my husband who puts in the lions share of the money in our house why the hell are you having to justify your spending to your DH. He is your partner not your parent.

Ratched · 29/04/2022 13:50

Retired now, but my last mantra was ' I'm sorting it out directly, but thanks.'

People I knew got a nice card, people I knew and liked got a nice card and a small, personal gift.

The rest were ignored

When I retired there were messages on my card from people I had never met, so their heartfelt messages meant nothing.

I did get a wonderful gift, but the best one came direct from my P.A. and cost somewhere around a fiver - but it was personal, and meant something to me.

OP - resist. Just say no😁

RealBecca · 29/04/2022 13:45

@FooFighter99 Is the colleagues wifes baby not his? Otherwise isnt it a collection for his baby?

RedWreck · 29/04/2022 13:40

I've literally saved over £100 since I stopped putting into other people's collections. If it's someone I'm close to then I'll buy my own gift if not then I wish you well but I'm not paying.

Giveitall · 29/04/2022 13:33

I told everyone I would no longer be donating unless I have met & have had personal interactions with that person. I also said I would not sign their card as I hadn’t donated so didn’t “deserve” to be included for that either.
Worked for me and no one minded. It had gotten ridiculous!
Stand your ground. Pick & choose who you donate for.
I also stopped going to the office Christmas party. I had no desire to sit with colleagues getting drunk & be polite and false-friendly with colleagues I didn’t like. You only have to do it once & colleagues soon get used to it.

PurpleRainbowSun · 29/04/2022 13:27

I agree - although luckily my work are very clear these things are voluntary and wouldn't chase you.

But it's still a bit of pressure. I didn't mind so much when it was envelopes handed around and you could slip some coins in and no one would know how much you gave - but now it's online so if you just donate one pound the organiser will be able to see. I have donated recently when its been someone I knew well but most of the time I haven't (although I think I forgot last time I meant to). I suppose I could afford it but am also not rolling in money.

I did feel especially put out when an email came round asking for collection for someone who earns at least 5 times more than me. I thought it was off/tone deaf to even ask junior staff. Was happy to sign the card but sure the former colleague didn't need my money.

balalake · 29/04/2022 13:25

As long as you are consistent in when you contribute and when not, then just say no. So if it's only for maternity leave but nothing else, fair enough.

FooFighter99 · 29/04/2022 13:18

We've got one going round at the moment, for a male colleague whose WIFE is having a baby. She doesn't work here, non of us know her. Needless to say I won't be putting any money in

WheekestLink · 29/04/2022 13:14

Of course not! If it's someone you're fond of and you have spare cash, put in a collection, if not, don't.

I was badgered (I only recall this because it annoyed me so much) with over five emails last year for a collection for someone I'd never met, communicated with or even heard of. I ended up sending an email to the collector saying I didn't know the person so no need to continue to send me emails.

SwanBuster · 29/04/2022 13:10

On this note I always remember my previous workplace only did collections for executives who were leaving, never for the ‘ground floor’ workers.

One time we were asked to contribute something for a director leaving in the London office, who we had no real relationship with - whilst nothing was being arranged for an engineer in our own office who was leaving at the same time!

greenbirdsong · 29/04/2022 13:10

You're not being unreasonable.

This has always happened in my office too.

I don't mind when it's a friend/close colleague but I'm not putting in for every Tom, Dick and Harry in the offices's wedding/birthday/maternity/retirement etc.

SwanBuster · 29/04/2022 13:07

I approach this with my usual bizarre economically judgmental attitude.

  • if the person leaving/getting married/having a baby is young, I usually give a money. They can likely do with a little boost.

if the person can actually afford to retire*, I don’t bother 😂

I myself wouldn’t want vouchers or something partially funded by younger people on top of knowing I’m nicking their future income through the state pension Ponzi scheme.

TheLightSideOfTheMoon · 29/04/2022 12:46

The fundraising is for other stuff.

Shit like wear your pyjamas to work for a day and give £2 to x charity.

The charities are always bullshit. Last time is was to raise funds for a local couple to buy a new sofa. On our local FB people give them away free constantly.

Also, my work has no dress code. Very casual jeans and trainers job. Wearing pyjamas isn’t much of a change.

Stuff like this annoys me.

nearlyspringyay · 29/04/2022 12:31

TheLightSideOfTheMoon · 29/04/2022 12:26

I’m starting to feel like this.

£10 here and there adds up.

I got paid yesterday and after I’ve taken out bills, food and other essentials I’m left with about £50.

Now my work want money to send a colleague flowers after an injury (she fell down whilst walking around on a moving bus) and other staff keep saying we need to do more fundraising.

I CANNOT AFFORD IT.

My money NEEDS to stay in my household right now. I’m all for helping people but right now I really can’t.

Fundraising? It's not fundraising is it. Just don't do it @TheLightSideOfTheMoon you don't have to divulge financial situation. I have a bit of a blanket rule that I don't get involved, and I certainly don't expect anything. Like tipping, just dont do it.

My firm arranges for cakes for birthdays / flowers for birthdays / weddings etc and usually a voucher for mat leave.

TheLightSideOfTheMoon · 29/04/2022 12:26

I’m starting to feel like this.

£10 here and there adds up.

I got paid yesterday and after I’ve taken out bills, food and other essentials I’m left with about £50.

Now my work want money to send a colleague flowers after an injury (she fell down whilst walking around on a moving bus) and other staff keep saying we need to do more fundraising.

I CANNOT AFFORD IT.

My money NEEDS to stay in my household right now. I’m all for helping people but right now I really can’t.

C8H10N4O2 · 29/04/2022 12:22

Obviously you should be giving if you don't know the person well enough or don't have the money.

However why do you have to justify your expenditure to your husband? Does he similarly explain his own smaller items of spending to you?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/04/2022 12:20

I think you should just say I can't afford it... they can't argue with that

The problem is that they often will, though. A lot of people who don't appreciate their privilege equate 'can't afford it' with 'would rather keep my money to spend on nice treats for me' - as (ironically) that's exactly what they use it to mean when it suits them.

"Don't be mean, it's only a tenner!" Just plain tone-deaf, some people.

Antarcticant · 29/04/2022 12:13

Ignore the emails.

If you are chased directly, reply "Thank you for the reminder, but I won't be contributing".

Don't explain or apologise.